Court Rules

Limits & Logistics

Document Limits

AttachmentsCourt-wide
5 pgs

Courtesy Copies

Exhibit List

  • 1 copy • Email
  • Email

Exhibits

  • First Day of Trial

Joint Statement of Case

  • Email

Trial Brief

  • 1 copy • Email
  • Email

Adjournments

Court-wide
3Court Daysnotice

Communication

Email
twinn@sbcourts.org
Phone

Chambers

(805) 614-6515
Scheduling
Phone
Court-wide

Chambers

(805) 882-4570
Scheduling
Phone
Court-wide

Chambers

(805) 882-4590
Scheduling
Phone
Court-wide

Chambers

(805) 614-6500
Scheduling
Email
Court-wide

Chambers

SchedulingEmergencies
Filters:

Document Format Requirements7 rules

FormattingMandatory

You must file your documents without a hearing date inserted.

department-sm-4-policies-and-procedures · p. 2
|SectionEx Parte Matters (Family)
FormattingImportant

When there are no more than five exhibits and no more than 25 total exhibit pages, place a divider sheet before each exhibit; it must be blank except for the exhibit number at the bottom.

Court's wording

For five (5) or less exhibits, and where the total number of pages of all exhibits combined does not exceed 25 pages: (If the number of pages exceeds 25, follow the instructions under c - e below) • Each exhibit shall have a divider sheet in front of the actual exhibit. • The divider sheet shall be blank except for the exhibit number displayed at the bottom.

FormattingImportant

Exhibits must be organized in the order they are listed on the Exhibit List.

FormattingImportant

Plaintiff/Petitioner is assigned Exhibits 1 through 200 and Defendant/Respondent is assigned Exhibits 201 through 400.

FormattingImportant

For more than five (5) exhibits, exhibit packets shall be assembled in an exhibit binder, using numbered tab pages before each exhibit.

FormattingImportant

Original deposition transcripts to be used at trial must be available to the court in hard copy.

File type
Paper
Applies to
  • Deposition transcript
FormattingImportant

If the CA State Bar license number is not noted on the card, it must be handwritten.

Document Filing Requirements16 rules

Filing RequirementsMandatory

A person seeking a remote appearance based on extenuating circumstances must file local Form SC-2073.

Court's wording

If extenuating circumstances exist that require a remote appearance, the court requires the filing of local Form SC-2073, Request to Appear by Zoom Videoconference/Order, at least 10 calendar days prior to the hearing date for the court’s review and consideration.

Filing RequirementsMandatory

Case Management Statements are required to be filed for every CMC, unless otherwise specifically ordered.

Filing RequirementsMandatory

Each party must submit and serve a mandatory settlement conference statement as required by the cited rules.

Court's wording

No later than five court days before the initial date set for the settlement conference, each party must submit to the court and serve on each party a mandatory settlement conference statement as required by CRC 3.1380(c) and Local Rule 1423.

department-sm-4-policies-and-procedures · p. 3
|SectionMandatory Settlement Conferences (MSCs)
Filing RequirementsMandatory

The first page of the exhibit packet shall be the Exhibit List. The Exhibit List shall list (in numerical order) the number of the exhibit, the type of exhibit, and a brief description of the exhibit.

Document
Exhibit packet

Must include

  • Exhibit list
Filing RequirementsMandatory

To file a non-confidential brief, select eFiling code “Brief” and include “MSC” with the hearing date in the filing description field.

department-sm-4-policies-and-procedures · p. 3
|SectionMandatory Settlement Conferences (MSCs)
Filing RequirementsMandatory

If you wish an MSC Brief to be submitted confidentially, please select “Settlement Conference Statement,” as your eFiling code to ensure it is lodged confidentially. Include the hearing date in the filing description field.

department-sm-4-policies-and-procedures · p. 3
|SectionMandatory Settlement Conferences (MSCs)
Filing RequirementsMandatory

Use eFiling code “Trial Brief”. Add the trial date in the Filing Description field.

Filing RequirementsMandatory

File a joint exhibit list if possible, or separate lists otherwise; use eFiling code “Exhibit List” and enter the trial date in the Filing Description field.

Court's wording

A joint exhibit list, to the extent possible, and separate exhibit lists otherwise, is to be e-filed at least three (3) court days before the trial date, with a courtesy copy e-mailed to SM4Continue@sbcourts.org. Use eFiling code “Exhibit List”. Add the trial date in the Filing Description field.

Filing RequirementsMandatory

Witness lists must be e-filed at least three (3) court days before the trial date, to show to the jury at the outset of voir dire, with a courtesy copy e-mailed to SM4Continue@sbcourts.org. Use eFiling code “Witness List”. Add the trial date in the Filing Description field.

Filing RequirementsMandatory

A list of proposed jury instructions by CACI numbers and any pinpoint instructions are to be e-filed three (3) court days before the trial date. Use eFiling code “Jury Instructions, Proposed, Filed”. Add the trial date in the Filing Description field.

Filing RequirementsMandatory

A set of business cards from each attorney shall be presented to the courtroom clerk at the time in limine motions are heard or, at the very latest, on the first day of voir dire.

Filing RequirementsMandatory

Trial briefs must use the “Trial Brief” eFiling code and include the trial date in the Filing Description field.

Court's wording

Trial briefs are to be e-filed at least three (3) court days before the trial date, with a courtesy copy e- mailed to SM4Continue@sbcourts.org. Use eFiling code “Trial Brief”. Add the trial date in the Filing Description field.

Filing RequirementsMandatory

The joint statement must be for the jury to read during voir dire and its Filing Description must include the trial date followed by “Joint”.

Court's wording

A joint statement of the case for the benefit of the jury to be read during voir dire, is to be e-filed three (3) court days before the trial date, with a courtesy copy e-mailed to SM4Continue@sbcourts.org. Use eFiling code “Statement”. Add the trial date in the Filing Description field followed by “Joint”.

Filing RequirementsMandatory

If exigent circumstances require a Zoom appearance, the specified request form must be e-filed at least 10 days before trial and served on the other side.

Court's wording

In-person appearances of all parties, witnesses, and counsel is required. If exigent circumstances necessitate a Zoom appearance, local form SC-2073, Request to Appear by Zoom Videoconference/Order, must be e-filed for the court’s consideration at least 10-days prior to trial with service to the other side.

Filing RequirementsNote

The court appreciates the listing of specific completion dates on the discovery portion of the CMC Statement as opposed to “per code”.

Filing RequirementsNote

Parties may print or download the Exhibit List local form (SC-1043) from the court’s website at https://www.santabarbara.courts.ca.gov.

Filing & Service rules

Electronic Filing Rules

Witness lists must be filed electronically using eFiling code “Witness List.”

Witness lists must be e-filed at least three (3) court days before the trial date, to show to the jury at the outset of voir dire, with a courtesy copy e-mailed to SM4Continue@sbcourts.org. Use eFiling code “Witness List”. Add the trial date in the Filing Description field.

Page 4 | Non-Jury Trials

Exhibit lists must be filed electronically using eFiling code “Exhibit List.”

A joint exhibit list, to the extent possible, and separate exhibit lists otherwise, is to be e-filed at least three (3) court days before the trial date, with a courtesy copy e-mailed to SM4Continue@sbcourts.org. Use eFiling code “Exhibit List”. Add the trial date in the Filing Description field.

Page 4 | Non-Jury Trials

Trial briefs must be filed electronically using eFiling code “Trial Brief.”

Trial briefs are to be e-filed at least three (3) court days before the trial date, with a courtesy copy e- mailed to SM4Continue@sbcourts.org. Use eFiling code “Trial Brief”. Add the trial date in the Filing Description field.

Page 4 | Non-Jury Trials

The Zoom appearance request must be e-filed.

In-person appearances of all parties, witnesses, and counsel is required. If exigent circumstances necessitate a Zoom appearance, local form SC-2073, Request to Appear by Zoom Videoconference/Order, must be e-filed for the court’s consideration at least 10-days prior to trial with service to the other side.

Page 5 | Non-Jury Trials

The joint statement of the case must be e-filed using the specified eFiling code.

A joint statement of the case for the benefit of the jury to be read during voir dire, is to be e-filed three (3) court days before the trial date, with a courtesy copy e-mailed to SM4Continue@sbcourts.org. Use eFiling code “Statement”. Add the trial date in the Filing Description field followed by “Joint”.

Page 5 | Jury Trials

The proposed jury instructions must be e-filed using the specified code.

A list of proposed jury instructions by CACI numbers and any pinpoint instructions are to be e-filed three (3) court days before the trial date. Use eFiling code “Jury Instructions, Proposed, Filed”. Add the trial date in the Filing Description field.

Page 5 | Jury Trials

Motions in limine and opposition papers must be e-filed.

Motions in limine are to be e-filed at least three (3) court days before the trial date; Opposition papers shall be e-filed one (1) court day before the trial date.

Page 5 | Jury Trials

Filing Timing and Cure Windows

The Zoom appearance request form must be filed at least 10 calendar days before the hearing.

If extenuating circumstances exist that require a remote appearance, the court requires the filing of local Form SC-2073, Request to Appear by Zoom Videoconference/Order, at least 10 calendar days prior to the hearing date for the court’s review and consideration.

Page 2 | Zoom Appearances

Each party must submit and serve its mandatory settlement conference statement no later than five court days before the initial settlement conference date.

No later than five court days before the initial date set for the settlement conference, each party must submit to the court and serve on each party a mandatory settlement conference statement as required by CRC 3.1380(c) and Local Rule 1423.

Page 3 | Mandatory Settlement Conferences (MSCs)

E-file a joint exhibit list when possible, or separate exhibit lists otherwise, at least three court days before trial; also email a courtesy copy and use the required code and filing-description date.

A joint exhibit list, to the extent possible, and separate exhibit lists otherwise, is to be e-filed at least three (3) court days before the trial date, with a courtesy copy e-mailed to SM4Continue@sbcourts.org. Use eFiling code “Exhibit List”. Add the trial date in the Filing Description field.

Page 4 | Non-Jury Trials

E-file trial briefs at least three court days before trial, email a courtesy copy to the specified address, use eFiling code “Trial Brief,” and add the trial date in the Filing Description field.

Trial briefs are to be e-filed at least three (3) court days before the trial date, with a courtesy copy e- mailed to SM4Continue@sbcourts.org. Use eFiling code “Trial Brief”. Add the trial date in the Filing Description field.

Page 4 | Non-Jury Trials

E-file witness lists at least three court days before trial, email a courtesy copy to the specified address, use eFiling code “Witness List,” and add the trial date in the Filing Description field.

Witness lists must be e-filed at least three (3) court days before the trial date, to show to the jury at the outset of voir dire, with a courtesy copy e-mailed to SM4Continue@sbcourts.org. Use eFiling code “Witness List”. Add the trial date in the Filing Description field.

Page 4 | Non-Jury Trials

Motions in limine must be e-filed at least three court days before trial.

Motions in limine are to be e-filed at least three (3) court days before the trial date;

Page 5 | Jury Trials

Proposed jury instructions must be e-filed three court days before trial.

A list of proposed jury instructions by CACI numbers and any pinpoint instructions are to be e-filed three (3) court days before the trial date. Use eFiling code “Jury Instructions, Proposed, Filed”. Add the trial date in the Filing Description field.

Page 5 | Jury Trials

The joint statement of the case must be e-filed three court days before trial, with an emailed courtesy copy.

A joint statement of the case for the benefit of the jury to be read during voir dire, is to be e-filed three (3) court days before the trial date, with a courtesy copy e-mailed to SM4Continue@sbcourts.org. Use eFiling code “Statement”. Add the trial date in the Filing Description field followed by “Joint”.

Page 5 | Jury Trials

Opposition papers to motions in limine must be e-filed one court day before trial.

Opposition papers shall be e-filed one (1) court day before the trial date.

Page 5 | Jury Trials

The Zoom appearance request must be e-filed at least 10 days before trial.

In-person appearances of all parties, witnesses, and counsel is required. If exigent circumstances necessitate a Zoom appearance, local form SC-2073, Request to Appear by Zoom Videoconference/Order, must be e-filed for the court’s consideration at least 10-days prior to trial with service to the other side.

Page 5 | Non-Jury Trials

Service and Proof of Service Rules

Parties must exchange the Exhibit List and proposed exhibits at least five business days before the hearing or trial, unless the court sets another date; physical copies are allowed, and electronic delivery to a self-represented party requires consent and use of the party’s verified email address.

Parties shall exchange their Exhibit List and their proposed exhibits, organized as above, by providing to the other party, copies of the exhibits submitted to the court, at least five (5) business days prior to the scheduled hearing or trial, unless a different date is set by the court. Copies may be provided in their physical form or may be sent electronically to opposing counsel. Copies may be provided in their physical form or may be sent electronically to a self-represented party who consents to electronic delivery of the exhibits, at their verified e-mail address.

Page 4 | Exhibit Requirements

The Zoom appearance request must be served on the other side.

In-person appearances of all parties, witnesses, and counsel is required. If exigent circumstances necessitate a Zoom appearance, local form SC-2073, Request to Appear by Zoom Videoconference/Order, must be e-filed for the court’s consideration at least 10-days prior to trial with service to the other side.

Page 5 | Non-Jury Trials

Courtesy Copy Requirements

Bring courtesy copies of all exhibits to court on the first day of trial for the court, witness, clerk, and each counsel.

Courtesy copies of all exhibits shall be brought to the court on the first day of trial (Court copy, Witness copy, Clerk copy, and a copy for each Counsel).

Page 3 | Exhibit Requirements

Email one courtesy copy of the exhibit list to SM4Continue@sbcourts.org.

A joint exhibit list, to the extent possible, and separate exhibit lists otherwise, is to be e-filed at least three (3) court days before the trial date, with a courtesy copy e-mailed to SM4Continue@sbcourts.org.

Page 4 | Non-Jury Trials

Email one courtesy copy of each trial brief to SM4Continue@sbcourts.org.

Trial briefs are to be e-filed at least three (3) court days before the trial date, with a courtesy copy e- mailed to SM4Continue@sbcourts.org.

Page 4 | Non-Jury Trials

Email one courtesy copy of the witness list to SM4Continue@sbcourts.org.

Witness lists must be e-filed at least three (3) court days before the trial date, to show to the jury at the outset of voir dire, with a courtesy copy e-mailed to SM4Continue@sbcourts.org.

Page 4 | Non-Jury Trials

A courtesy copy of each witness list must be emailed to the specified address.

Witness lists must be e-filed at least three (3) court days before the trial date, to show to the jury at the outset of voir dire, with a courtesy copy e-mailed to SM4Continue@sbcourts.org. Use eFiling code “Witness List”. Add the trial date in the Filing Description field.

Page 5 | Jury Trials

A courtesy copy of each exhibit list must be emailed to the specified address.

A joint exhibit list, to the extent possible, and separate exhibit lists otherwise, is to be e-filed at least three (3) court days before the trial date, with a courtesy copy e-mailed to SM4Continue@sbcourts.org. Use eFiling code “Exhibit List”. Add the trial date in the Filing Description field.

Page 5 | Jury Trials

A courtesy copy of each trial brief must be emailed to the specified address.

Trial briefs are to be e-filed at least three (3) court days before the trial date, with a courtesy copy e- mailed to SM4Continue@sbcourts.org. Use eFiling code “Trial Brief”. Add the trial date in the Filing Description field.

Page 5 | Jury Trials

A courtesy copy of the joint statement of the case must be emailed to the specified address.

A joint statement of the case for the benefit of the jury to be read during voir dire, is to be e-filed three (3) court days before the trial date, with a courtesy copy e-mailed to SM4Continue@sbcourts.org. Use eFiling code “Statement”. Add the trial date in the Filing Description field followed by “Joint”.

Page 5 | Jury Trials

Sealing & Redaction Procedures

To lodge an MSC brief confidentially, select “Settlement Conference Statement” as the eFiling code.

If you wish an MSC Brief to be submitted confidentially, please select “Settlement Conference Statement,” as your eFiling code to ensure it is lodged confidentially.

Page 3 | Mandatory Settlement Conferences (MSCs)

Pre-Motion Conference Requirements

Motions in limine are usually heard on the first day of trial.

Motions in limine are usually heard on the first day of trial.

Page 5 | Jury Trials

Chambers Communication Rules

Do not include ex parte correspondence with exhibit submissions; arguments must be presented at trial.

IMPORTANT: DO NOT include any ex parte correspondence to the judge with your exhibit submissions. Any ex parte communication submitted will not be read or considered. You must present your arguments at the trial.

Page 4 | Exhibit Requirements

Contact the department for exhibit-numbering guidance if exhibits exceed 200.

If exhibits exceed 200, please contact the department for further guidance on numbering.

Page 4 | Exhibit Requirements

Counsel may contact the Department Secretary with questions using the listed phone number or email address.

Counsel may contact the Department Secretary, at 805-614-6515 or twinn@sbcourts.org if there are any questions.

Page 6 | Court Reporters

Contact the department secretary for guidance on arranging a private reporter.

Please contact the department secretary for further guidance on how to arrange for a private reporter.

Page 6 | Court Reporters

To request a civil ex parte hearing, contact Judicial Secretary Torey Winn by telephone.

To request a civil ex parte hearing, contact Judicial Secretary Torey Winn at (805) 614-6515.

Page 2 | Ex Parte Matters (Civil)

Court-wide rules

Applies court-wide

These 537 rules apply across Santa Barbara Superior Court. Where this judge's own standing orders above address the same topic, the judge's requirement controls.

Filing Requirements

All 219
  • Applies to
    Order to appoint minor s counsel

    The order appointing minor's counsel must expressly list the factors the court identifies as specific to the case.

  • Applies to
    Income and expense declaration

    Parties must be ordered to submit an Income and Expense Declaration for the court's ability-to-pay determination.

  • Applies to
    Request for additional compensation

    A written request for additional compensation above the initial ceiling must state the total amount previously approved for the attorney and support staff and establish good cause.

Filing Timing

All 84
  • Deadline
    5 court days

    The parties' declarations must be submitted five court days before the review date.

  • Deadline
    3 business days

    Hard-copy exhibits must be delivered to the Court at least three business days before the hearing or trial.

  • If the clerk's black-and-white copy of an additional exhibit of five pages or fewer needs a hard-copy supplement, the attorney or offering party must deliver the original to the Court immediately after the hearing.

Service

All 64
  • Deadline
    3 business days

    Parties must exchange the Exhibit List and proposed exhibits at least three business days before the hearing or trial, unless the court sets another date; copies may be physical or electronic, with electronic delivery to a self-represented party requiring consent and use of that party's verified email address.

  • Deadline
    1 court days
    Applies to
    Ex parte supporting papers

    To the extent practicable, supporting papers should be served by 10:00 a.m. on the court day before the hearing.

  • Applies to
    E filed document
    Service
    Electronic service

    E-filed documents must be served electronically on and by appearing parties represented by counsel and other persons entitled to service who expressly consent, except when law requires personal service or the court orders otherwise.

Communication

All 47
  • Contact
    Phone
    Phone
    805-882-4590

    A party with more than 200 exhibits must call the court department for numbering instructions.

  • If the court orders exhibits returned, a party must contact the department secretary to discuss return options.

  • Contact
    Phone
    Phone
    805-882-4590

    Call the department secretary between 8:00 a.m. and 4:00 p.m. at the number below for the hours they will be available to accept delivery and to obtain directions to their office.

Common questions about Judge Jed Beebe's rules

Are courtesy copies required for Judge Jed Beebe?

Courtesy-copy rule applies for exhibits. Details: delivery first day of trial. Bring courtesy copies of all exhibits to court on the first day of trial for the court, witness, clerk, and each counsel.

View ruleSource: page 3, section Exhibit Requirements

Does Judge Jed Beebe require a pre-motion conference or letter before filing a motion?

Motions in limine are usually heard on the first day of trial.

View ruleSource: page 5, section Jury Trials

What formatting rules apply to filings before Judge Jed Beebe?

Judge Jed Beebe's formatting rule includes for more than five exhibits, assemble the packet in an exhibit binder with numbered tab pages before each exhibit.. Packets containing more than five exhibits must be assembled in an exhibit binder with numbered tab pages before each exhibit.

View ruleSource: page 4, section Exhibit Requirements

What must be included with zoom appearance request filings before Judge Jed Beebe?

A person seeking a remote appearance based on extenuating circumstances must file local Form SC-2073.

View ruleSource: page 2, section Zoom Appearances

What must be included with case management statement filings before Judge Jed Beebe?

A Case Management Statement must be filed for every CMC unless the court orders otherwise.

View ruleSource: page 2, section Pre-Trial

How may parties contact Judge Jed Beebe's chambers?

The rule lists phone (805) 614-6515. To request a civil ex parte hearing, contact Judicial Secretary Torey Winn by telephone.

View ruleSource: page 2, section Ex Parte Matters (Civil)

How does Judge Jed Beebe handle sealed or redacted filings?

To lodge an MSC brief confidentially, select “Settlement Conference Statement” as the eFiling code.

View ruleSource: page 3, section Mandatory Settlement Conferences (MSCs)

Is electronic filing required before Judge Jed Beebe?

Yes. Electronic filing is required for the covered filings. Trial briefs must be filed electronically using eFiling code “Trial Brief.”

View ruleSource: page 4, section Non-Jury Trials

What filing deadlines does Judge Jed Beebe set?

The Zoom appearance request form must be filed at least 10 calendar days before the hearing.

View ruleSource: page 2, section Zoom Appearances

What rule applies to serving the opposing party before Judge Jed Beebe?

Details: recipient: the opposing party, timing: 5 business days before hearing. Parties must exchange the Exhibit List and proposed exhibits at least five business days before the hearing or trial, unless the court sets another date; physical copies are allowed, and electronic delivery to a self-represented party requires consent and use of the party’s verified email address.

View ruleSource: page 4, section Exhibit Requirements
Complete rules summary for Judge Jed Beebe

Plaintiff/Petitioner uses exhibit numbers 1–200; Defendant/Respondent uses 201–400.

A person seeking a remote appearance based on extenuating circumstances must file local Form SC-2073.

The Zoom appearance request form must be filed at least 10 calendar days before the hearing.

To request a civil ex parte hearing, contact Judicial Secretary Torey Winn by telephone.

Parties may use local form SC-1043 for the Exhibit List by printing or downloading it from the court’s website.

Family ex parte documents must be filed without a hearing date inserted.

A Case Management Statement must be filed for every CMC unless the court orders otherwise.

The court encourages parties to list specific discovery completion dates in the CMC Statement instead of using “per code.”

Each party must submit and serve its mandatory settlement conference statement no later than five court days before the initial settlement conference date.

Each party must submit and serve a mandatory settlement conference statement as required by the cited rules.

When there are no more than five exhibits and no more than 25 total exhibit pages, place a divider sheet before each exhibit; it must be blank except for the exhibit number at the bottom.

To lodge an MSC brief confidentially, select “Settlement Conference Statement” as the eFiling code.

For a confidential MSC brief, select the “Settlement Conference Statement” eFiling code and include the hearing date in the filing description field.

For a non-confidential MSC brief, select eFiling code “Brief” and include “MSC” and the hearing date in the filing description field.

Bring courtesy copies of all exhibits to court on the first day of trial for the court, witness, clerk, and each counsel.

Organize exhibits in the order in which they appear on the Exhibit List.

The Exhibit List must be the first page of the packet and list each exhibit’s number, type, and brief description in numerical order.

Packets containing more than five exhibits must be assembled in an exhibit binder with numbered tab pages before each exhibit.

Contact the department for exhibit-numbering guidance if exhibits exceed 200.

Parties must exchange the Exhibit List and proposed exhibits at least five business days before the hearing or trial, unless the court sets another date; physical copies are allowed, and electronic delivery to a self-represented party requires consent and use of the party’s verified email address.

Original deposition transcripts intended for trial must be available to the court in hard copy.

Do not include ex parte correspondence with exhibit submissions; arguments must be presented at trial.

E-file trial briefs at least three court days before trial, email a courtesy copy to the specified address, use eFiling code “Trial Brief,” and add the trial date in the Filing Description field.

Trial briefs must be filed electronically using eFiling code “Trial Brief.”

Email one courtesy copy of each trial brief to SM4Continue@sbcourts.org.

Use eFiling code “Trial Brief” and enter the trial date in the Filing Description field.

E-file a joint exhibit list when possible, or separate exhibit lists otherwise, at least three court days before trial; also email a courtesy copy and use the required code and filing-description date.

Exhibit lists must be filed electronically using eFiling code “Exhibit List.”

Email one courtesy copy of the exhibit list to SM4Continue@sbcourts.org.

A courtesy copy of the joint statement of the case must be emailed to the specified address.

More Judges in Santa Barbara Superior Court

Clifford R. Anderson
Judge
Colleen K. Sterne
Judge
Donna D. Geck
Judge
Elizabeth Diaz
Judge
Gustavo Lavayen
Judge
James F. Rigali
Judge
John McGregor
Judge
Karen O’Neil
Judge