Court-wide rules
Applies court-wideThese 167 rules apply across Superior Court of Delaware, New Castle County. Where this judge's own standing orders above address the same topic, the judge's requirement controls.
Filing Requirements
All 50- Applies to
- Pending appeals inventory
The Prothonotary of each county must prepare a Pending Appeals Inventory at the end of each month.
- Applies to
- Case information statement
A party identifies a qualifying case by entering the CCLD civil case code and Complex Commercial Litigation civil case type on the Case Information Statement.
- Applies to
- Pleadings and other filed papers
All pleadings and other papers filed with the court must include CCLD.
Filing Timing
All 30A motion opposing CCLD case identification must be filed before the Rule 16 scheduling conference unless the Panel Judge directs otherwise, and filing it does not extend deadlines for other pleadings, motions, or responses.
- Applies to
- Objections
Objections to be filed 15 days before the hearing date, and
- Applies to
- Brief
A brief in support of the settlement and any supporting documents to be filed 30 days before the hearing date;
Communication
All 23A lawyer should give all affected parties reasonable notice, whenever possible, before communicating with a court concerning pending or prospective litigation.
Ex parte communications with the court on pending matters should be avoided unless permitted by law.
A lawyer receiving possible hearing dates must share them with all relevant counsel and must not imply a court preference unless one was expressly stated.
Formatting
All 11Appendices and compendia should use tabs.
Parties should submit joint exhibits rather than separate plaintiff or defense exhibit sets.
Exhibits should be organized chronologically, or, when chronological ordering is not feasible in a highly expedited matter, parties should provide a chronological exhibit list as soon as practicable.
More categories
The Honorable Charles E. Butler was appointed to the Superior Court of Delaware in 2012; he was appointed Resident Judge for New Castle County on June 2, 2020.
Administrative contact: Rebecca Grant. Chambers phone: (302) 255-0656. Preference page updated September 8, 2026.
Are courtesy copies required for Judge Charles E. Butler?
Courtesy-copy rule applies for case dispositive motions and oppositions. Details: 2 copies. The original case-dispositive motion and response should be electronically filed with two courtesy copies delivered to chambers.
Does Judge Charles E. Butler require a pre-motion conference or letter before filing a motion?
Administrative-appeal oral argument occurs only if the court requests it.
What page or word limits apply to brief before Judge Charles E. Butler?
Judge Charles E. Butler's rule states these limits: 6 pages. In filing a case dispositive motion, Judge Butler will routinely grant dispensation from the 6 page limit for briefs of Superior Court Civil Case Management Plan IV A.2.c.
What formatting rules apply to filings before Judge Charles E. Butler?
Judge Charles E. Butler's formatting rule includes individually tabbed.. Brief exhibits, courtesy copies of motions, and letters must be individually tabbed.
What must be included with correspondence filings before Judge Charles E. Butler?
Correspondence to the judge must be signed by an attorney from the attorney of record's law firm.
What must be included with court action request filings before Judge Charles E. Butler?
A nonmotion request for court action must state every party's position or explain that the opposing party could not be reached.
How may parties contact Judge Charles E. Butler's chambers?
Substantive emails are docketed, must copy all counsel, and must include the civil action number.
How do I request an adjournment or extension before Judge Charles E. Butler?
Failure to meet the scheduling order's deadlines without showing good cause will likely result in the Court refusing an extension.
Is electronic filing required before Judge Charles E. Butler?
Yes. Electronic filing is required for the covered filings. The original motion and response should be e-filed with 2 courtesy copies delivered to chambers.
What filing deadlines does Judge Charles E. Butler set?
A motion in limine is expected at least two weeks before the pretrial conference, leaving opposing counsel one week to respond.
Complete rules summary for Judge Charles E. Butler
A motion in limine is expected at least two weeks before the pretrial conference, leaving opposing counsel one week to respond.
Brief exhibits, courtesy copies of motions, and letters must be individually tabbed.
Email is not appropriate when a party is self-represented.
Questions and comments about the judge's preferences should be directed to the Administrative Specialist or Judicial Case Manager.
Correspondence to the judge must be signed by an attorney from the attorney of record's law firm.
A nonmotion request for court action must state every party's position or explain that the opposing party could not be reached.
A requested court order should be accompanied by a proposed order form.
Email to the judge generally should not be sent without court approval, except in an exigent circumstance.
An email sent to the judge should also copy the judge's Administrative Specialist.
Administrative emails are not docketed; to create a record, their content should be docketed in a letter containing the civil action number.
Substantive emails are docketed, must copy all counsel, and must include the civil action number.
Counsel should identify related Superior Court cases on the Case Information Statement filed with the complaint or answer.
Counsel should promptly notify the appropriate Judicial Case Manager when a later-filed case was assigned to a different judge because a related case was omitted.
Entered scheduling orders must be complied with, and deviations require court approval.
A request to shorten the period before the pretrial conference should state whether either party intends to file a case-dispositive motion.
If the parties cannot agree within the normal scheduling range, they should contact the civil case manager, who may direct them to a court conference call.
Briefs and motions should use one-inch margins, 14-point Times New Roman, and double spacing.
Citations to unreported decisions should use Westlaw format when possible.
Briefs, exhibits, and appendices may not use clips or metal fasteners and must instead be stapled or bound.
Unreported cases unavailable in Westlaw and related exhibits ordinarily should be physically attached; a separate compendium may be used when volume makes attachment impractical.
Each routine motion must state whether it is opposed or unopposed.
Unopposed routine motions need not be noticed because the court will order them from chambers.
Opposition papers are due on the Friday before routine-motion presentation.
A case-dispositive motion should request notice for the court's convenience.
An opposed routine motion must be filed ten days before the noticed hearing date, excluding weekends and holidays.
The original case-dispositive motion and response should be electronically filed with two courtesy copies delivered to chambers.
The answering brief is due 30 days after filing a case-dispositive motion.
Counsel is expected to use Superior Court Civil Form 46 for pretrial stipulations.
The pretrial stipulation should identify all relevant legal or evidentiary issues and include brief citations supporting the authorities relied upon.
Trial counsel and pro hac vice counsel must attend the pretrial conference.

