Superior Court of Delaware, New Castle County Courtesy Copy Requirements
93 rules, 51 to 93 shown
When and how to deliver courtesy copies to chambers, including triggers, timing, and formatting.
Rules 51 to 93
Mandatory
One courtesy copy of every motion, brief, and appendix must be sent to chambers when filed.
One courtesy copy of all motions, briefs, and appendices must be sent to chambers contemporaneously with filing.
MandatoryCivil cases
A courtesy copy of the motion and its exhibits must be delivered to chambers, and a courtesy copy of the response and its exhibits must also be delivered to chambers.
with one courtesy copy (with exhibits) delivered to Judge Lugg in chambers. Responses are due no later than 7 calendar days after the filing of the motion, with one courtesy copy of a response (with exhibits) delivered to Judge Lugg in chambers.
Judge Sean P. LuggPage 6, section ADDITIONAL INFORMATION AND PROCEDURESMandatoryCivil cases
One courtesy copy of the response, including exhibits, must be delivered to Judge Lugg in chambers.
One courtesy copy of a response (with exhibits) delivered to Judge Lugg in chambers.
Judge Sean P. LuggPage 6, section ADDITIONAL INFORMATION AND PROCEDURESMandatoryCivil cases
One courtesy copy of a dispositive motion, including its exhibits, must be delivered to Judge Lugg in chambers.
One courtesy copy of the motion (with exhibits) must be delivered to Judge Lugg in chambers.
Judge Sean P. LuggPage 6, section ADDITIONAL INFORMATION AND PROCEDURESMandatoryCivil cases
One courtesy copy of each motion, brief, and appendix must be sent to chambers at the time of filing.
One courtesy copy of all motions, briefs, and appendices must be sent to chambers contemporaneously with filing.
Judge Sean P. LuggPage 6, section ADDITIONAL INFORMATION AND PROCEDURESMandatory
One courtesy copy of the motion and one of the response, including exhibits, must be filed in chambers.
One courtesy copy of both the motion and response (with exhibits) must be filed in chambers.
Judge Sheldon K. RennieSection Motions & BriefingMandatoryCivil cases
Two courtesy copies of a routine-motion response, including exhibits, must be delivered to Judge Rennie’s chambers.
Responses are due no later than 7 calendar days after the filing of the motion and in no case later than the Friday prior to the motion’s hearing, with two courtesy copies of a response (with exhibits) delivered to Judge Rennie in chambers.
Judge Sheldon K. RenniePage 5, section Additional Information and Procedures — Routine Civil MotionsMandatory
In a Complex Commercial Litigation Division case, parties need provide chambers with only one courtesy copy of each motion, response, or brief, including appendices and compendiums.
Notwithstanding CCLD Standing Order No. 1, the parties need only provide Chambers with one (1) courtesy copy of any motions, responses and briefs (including appendices and compendiums).
Judge Sheldon K. RennieSection Motions & BriefingMandatoryCivil cases
The original motion and its response must be filed with the Prothonotary’s Office, and two courtesy copies with exhibits must be delivered to Judge Rennie in chambers.
The original motion and the response thereto shall be filed with the Prothonotary’s Office with two courtesy copies (with exhibits) delivered to Judge Rennie in chambers.
Judge Sheldon K. RenniePage 5, section Additional Information and Procedures — Case Dispositive MotionsMandatory
A letter need only be electronically docketed, should be emailed to Judge Rennie's staff, and requires no separate courtesy copy for chambers.
A letter to Judge Rennie need only be docketed electronically in the subject case. No courtesy copy need be delivered to Judge Rennie's chambers. Instead, an electronic copy, as docketed, should be transmitted via email to Judge Rennie's Administrative Specialist, Civil Case Manager and Law Clerk.
Judge Sheldon K. RennieSection CommunicationsMandatoryCivil cases
Routine civil motions are presented on Thursdays at 9:00 a.m., must be filed at least 15 calendar days before presentation, and must be accompanied by two courtesy copies with exhibits for chambers.
Routine Civil Motions. Judge Rennie’s routine civil motions are on Thursdays at 9:00 a.m. Motions must be filed no less than fifteen 15 calendar days prior to the noticed presentation date with two courtesy copies (with exhibits) delivered to Judge Rennie in chambers.
Judge Sheldon K. RenniePage 5, section Additional Information and Procedures — Routine Civil MotionsMandatoryCivil cases
A response to a routine motion requires one courtesy copy, including exhibits, delivered to Judge Augusthy’s chambers.
Responses are due no later than 7 calendar days after the filing of the motion, with one courtesy copy of a response (with exhibits) delivered to Judge Augusthy in chambers.
Judge Sonia AugusthyPage 6, section ADDITIONAL INFORMATION AND PROCEDURESMandatoryCivil cases
A dispositive motion and its response each require one courtesy copy with exhibits delivered to Judge Augusthy’s chambers.
The original motion and the response thereto shall be filed with the Prothonotary’s Office with one courtesy copy (with exhibits) delivered to Judge Augusthy in chambers.
Judge Sonia AugusthyPage 6, section Case Dispositive MotionsMandatoryCivil cases
Routine motions must be filed at least 15 calendar days before the noticed presentation date, with one courtesy copy including exhibits delivered to Judge Augusthy’s chambers.
Motions must be filed no less than 15 calendar days prior to the noticed presentation date with one courtesy copy (with exhibits) delivered to Judge Augusthy in chambers.
Judge Sonia AugusthyPage 6, section ADDITIONAL INFORMATION AND PROCEDURESMandatory
One courtesy copy of a routine motion and one courtesy copy of its response, including exhibits, must be delivered to chambers.
A courtesy copy of both the motion and response (with exhibits) must be delivered to chambers.
MandatoryCivil cases
One courtesy copy of a routine civil motion, including its exhibits, must be delivered to Judge Augusthy’s chambers.
Motions must be filed no less than 15 calendar days prior to the noticed presentation date with one courtesy copy (with exhibits) delivered to Judge Augusthy in chambers.
Judge Sonia AugusthyPage 6, section Routine Civil MotionsMandatoryCivil cases
One courtesy copy of a routine-motion response, including its exhibits, must be delivered to Judge Augusthy’s chambers.
Responses are due no later than 7 calendar days after the filing of the motion, with one courtesy copy of a response (with exhibits) delivered to Judge Augusthy in chambers.
Judge Sonia AugusthyPage 6, section Routine Civil MotionsMandatoryCivil cases
For a case-dispositive motion and response, file the originals with the Prothonotary’s Office and deliver one courtesy copy, including exhibits, to Judge Augusthy’s chambers.
The original motion and the response thereto shall be filed with the Prothonotary’s Office with one courtesy copy (with exhibits) delivered to Judge Augusthy in chambers.
Judge Sonia AugusthyPage 6, section ADDITIONAL INFORMATION AND PROCEDURESImportantCivil cases
If papers must be delivered to a judge’s home in an expedited matter, only one copy should be delivered, and unreported-case compendia should not be served unless requested.
In expedited matters, it may be necessary to deliver papers to a judge’s home. Please deliver only one copy and do not serve compendia of unreported cases unless requested.
Important
Courtesy copies of each dispositive motion and response must be provided to the assigned judge.
Motions and Responses shall be eFiled in the assigned case and courtesy copies provided to the Assigned Judge.
Court-level rulesOfficial source Page 15, section VI. MOTION PROCEDURES FOR ASSIGNED CIVIL CASES – B. Dispositive MotionsImportantCivil cases
For remote hearings, provide the same courtesy copies as for in-person hearings, and submit exhibits and documents in three flash drives and three paper sets.
Provide courtesy copies just as you would for an in-person hearing. Submit exhibits and documents for the Court’s use as you would for an in-person hearing: three flash drives and three paper sets.
ImportantCivil cases
For Rule 12(b)(6) or 12(c) motions, parties should submit two properly bound copies of the operative pleadings and exhibits.
Parties should submit two properly bound copies of the operative pleadings and their exhibits in connection with Rule 12(b)(6) or 12(c) motions. These are pleading-stage motions, so the pleadings and the exhibits are the key documents. The Court does not have the resources to recreate the pleadings and exhibits from the docket, particularly when they are voluminous.
ImportantCivil cases
Courtesy copies sent to Chambers should not include exhibits.
The courtesy copies sent to Chambers should not include any exhibits.
Judge Calvin L. Scott Jr.Section Motions & Briefing — Dispositive MotionsImportant
The cover page of the courtesy copies should have the File & Serve Transaction ID Number printed on it.
The cover page of the courtesy copies should have the File & Serve Transaction ID Number printed on it.
ImportantCivil cases
A hard copy and an electronic Microsoft Word copy of the jury instructions must be sent to Chambers.
One hard copy AND an electronic copy in Microsoft Word format must be sent to Chambers via my
Judge Eric M. DavisPage 2, section Jury InstructionsImportantCivil cases
- Required
- Never
Courtesy copies of exhibits ordinarily should not be sent, but counsel may elect to include them by PDF with the filing's courtesy copy.
Normally, parties should not provide courtesy copies of exhibits to filings; however, courtesy copies of exhibits to filings may be provided by pdf if counsel, in their discretion, believe the exhibits should accompany the courtesy copy of the filing.
Judge Eric M. DavisSection CommunicationsImportantCivil cases
The parties must promptly deliver Chambers a courtesy copy of the motion and response.
A courtesy copy of the motion and response must be promptly delivered to Chambers.
Judge Kathleen M. MillerPage 3, section Routine Civil MotionsImportantCivil cases
Two courtesy copies of each dispositive or Daubert motion, response, and reply must be promptly delivered to Chambers.
Two courtesy copies of each must be delivered promptly to Chambers.
Judge Kathleen M. MillerSection Dispositive and Daubert MotionsImportantCivil cases
Two courtesy copies of each dispositive or Daubert motion, response, and reply must be promptly delivered to Chambers.
Two courtesy copies of each must be delivered promptly to Chambers.
Judge Kathleen M. MillerPage 3, section Dispositive and Daubert MotionsImportantCivil cases
The parties must promptly deliver a courtesy copy of the motion and response to Chambers.
A courtesy copy of the motion and response must be promptly delivered to Chambers.
Judge Kathleen M. MillerSection Routine Civil MotionsImportant
Two contemporaneous hard-copy courtesy copies of each motion should be delivered to Judge Vavala's Chambers when the motion is filed with the New Castle Prothonotary.
Motions must be filed with the New Castle Prothonotary's Office and two (2) hard copy courtesy copies should contemporaneously be provided to Judge Vavala's Chambers.
Judge Kathleen M. VavalaSection Motions & BriefingImportant
Courtesy copies should use spiral binding or another flat-opening binding, and a bound copy over three inches thick should be split into two volumes.
Judge Horton strongly prefers spiral binding or other bindings that allow the brief to lay flat when opened. Please give thought to the size of your courtesy copies; if the bound copy would be more than 3 inches thick, consider separating the copy into two volumes.
Judge Monica A. HortonSection COURTESY COPIESImportant
The first page of courtesy copies should display the File & Serve timestamp.
The first page of the courtesy copies should have the File & Serve time stamp printed on it.
Judge Patricia A. WinstonSection Courtesy CopiesImportant
The dispositive motion, response, and reply should be electronically filed, with one courtesy copy promptly delivered to chambers.
The original motion, response, and reply should be e-filed with 1 courtesy copy promptly delivered to chambers.
Judge Sheldon K. RennieSection Motions & BriefingImportantCivil cases
A courtesy copy of the pretrial stipulation must be delivered or sent by facsimile to chambers by the stated date.
A courtesy copy shall also be delivered or sent by facsimile to chambers by this date.
Judge Sheldon K. RenniePage 3, section Trial Scheduling OrderImportant
One courtesy copy of the dispositive motion, response, and reply should be promptly delivered to chambers.
The original motion, response, and reply should be e-filed with 1 courtesy copy promptly delivered to chambers.
NoteCivil cases
Unless extraordinary circumstances exist, a party seeking expedited proceedings should make a good-faith effort to give the other side informal courtesy copies of all relevant papers and promptly notify the court by letter whether expedition is contested.
Absent extraordinary circumstances, the party seeking expedited proceedings should make a good faith effort to provide informal courtesy copies of all relevant papers to the other side, ascertain whether expedition is contested, and promptly inform the Court by letter as to those efforts and any response.
Court-level rulesOfficial source Page 19, section C. BEST PRACTICES FOR LITIGATING CASES – 5. Scheduling GuidelinesNoteCivil cases
Counsel should provide Chambers with two courtesy copies of filings the judge should read or that require judicial action, but routine filings are exempt.
Counsel should provide Chambers with two courtesy copies of any filing that they want the judge to read or that otherwise requires judicial action, such as letters, motions, and briefs. Counsel need not provide copies of routine filings, such as short motions that do not contain argument (because a supporting brief will be filed separately), motions for admission pro hac vice, motions for commission, or Rule 4 certifications.
Court-level rulesOfficial source Page 14, section C. BEST PRACTICES FOR LITIGATING CASES — 2. Courtesy CopiesNote
Counsel is encouraged to use double-sided copying or printing for Chambers copies.
Counsel is encouraged to use double-sided copying or printing for copies submitted to Chambers.
Judge Monica A. HortonSection COURTESY COPIESNote
Counsel is encouraged to use double-sided copying or printing for courtesy copies submitted to chambers.
Counsel is encouraged to use double-sided copying or printing for copies submitted to Chambers.
Judge Patricia A. WinstonSection Courtesy CopiesNote
The judge strongly prefers spiral binding or another binding that allows the brief to lie flat when opened.
Judge Winston strongly prefers spiral binding or other bindings that allow the brief to lay flat when opened.
Judge Patricia A. WinstonSection Courtesy CopiesNote
A bound courtesy copy exceeding three inches thick should be considered for separation into two volumes.
if the bound copy would be more than 3 inches thick, consider separating the copy into two volumes.
Judge Patricia A. WinstonSection Courtesy CopiesNoteCivil cases
- Required
- Never
No courtesy copy of the letter must be delivered to Judge Wallace’s chambers.
No courtesy copy need be delivered to Judge Wallace's chambers.
Judge Paul R. WallaceSection Communications