Court Rules

Fifteenth Judicial Circuit of Florida, Palm Beach County Document Filing Requirements

1251 rules from official source documents

Rules 551 to 600, page 12 of 26

Required elements, certificates, and structural requirements for court documents.

CRITICAL

Residential foreclosure pleadings and documents must state “RESIDENTIAL FORECLOSURE” under the case number.

All pleadings/documents must clearly indicate "RESIDENTIAL FORECLOSURE" under the case number.

Judge Darren Dunifon Shull

CRITICAL

Applies to
Pretrial materials

Prior to calendar call, counsel must have: participated in mediation, held a pretrial conference, exchanged exhibit and witness lists, agreed on the length of time the trial will take, including jury selection where applicable, agreed on time periods during the upcoming trial docket when all counsel are available, filed the pretrial stipulation, collaborated on proposed jury instructions, providing trial clerk with a single copy, noting the parties differences, if any, on any specific provision, pre-marked the exhibits in accordance with instructions of the clerk and comptroller, scheduled for hearing prior to trial any motion in limine or other pretrial motion

Prior to calendar call, counsel must have: participated in mediation, held a pretrial conference, exchanged exhibit and witness lists, agreed on the length of time the trial will take, including jury selection where applicable, agreed on time periods during the upcoming trial docket when all counsel are available, filed the pretrial stipulation, collaborated on proposed jury instructions, providing trial clerk with a single copy, noting the parties differences, if any, on any specific provision, pre-marked the exhibits in accordance with instructions of the clerk and comptroller, scheduled for hearing prior to trial any motion in limine or other pretrial motion

Judge Darren Dunifon Shull

CRITICALCivil cases

Applies to
Proposed order
Must include
proposed order

If the hearing issue is resolved less than 24 hours before the hearing, excluding weekends, the moving party must appear at the scheduled hearing time with a proposed order.

If the issue is resolved less than twenty-four (24) hours prior to the hearing (excluding weekends), the moving party shall appear before the Court at the scheduled time of hearing with their proposed order.

Judge Darren Dunifon Shull

CRITICALCivil cases

Applies to
Proposed order
Must include
proposed order

If the issue is resolved less than twenty-four (24) hours before the hearing, excluding weekends, the moving party must appear at the scheduled hearing with their proposed order.

If the issue is resolved less than twenty-four (24) hours prior to the hearing (excluding weekends), the moving party shall appear before the Court at the scheduled time of hearing with their proposed order.

Judge Darren Dunifon Shull

CRITICAL

The Court will act on properly filed petitions or motions, not party letters, notes, or emails; file the appropriate pleading with the Clerk and send a copy to the opposing side.

Please note the Court does not act on letters, notes, or emails sent by either party. The Court acts on petitions or motions properly filed with the Clerk of the Court. File the appropriate petition or motion with the Clerk of the Court, and send a copy to the opposing side.

Judge Darren Dunifon Shull

CRITICAL

Applies to
Notice of hearing

Immediately after reserving hearing time, file and serve a notice of hearing identifying the motion and the docket numbers for the motion and any related memorandum.

A notice of hearing must be filed and served immediately after reserving hearing time. Please include the motion to be heard, the docket entry number, and the docket number for any memorandum related to the motion.

Judge Darren Dunifon Shull

CRITICAL

Applies to
Agreed order

Submit an agreed order through OLS with the required title, cover letter or sheet, and subject motion; the cover letter must certify all parties reviewed and agreed to its language, and missing attachments will result in rejection for correction.

If a motion(s) is resolved, an agreed order on that motion can be submitted to the Judges office through OLS and the Order must say "Agreed Order On Motion (Title of the Motion)". The Agreed Order MUST be uploaded via OLS. Please be sure to attach a cover letter/cover sheet and the subject motion. The cover letter should certify that all parties have reviewed and agreed to the language of the proposed agreed order. If any supporting attachments is missing the order will be rejected for correction.

Judge Darren Dunifon Shull

CRITICAL

Applies to
Emergency motion

An emergency motion must include “emergency” in its title, be filed with the Clerk, and have the emergency button checked on the Clerk’s website.

Your emergency motion must have the word emergency in the title of the motion and be sure to also file your motion with the Clerk of Court and check the emergency button on the Clerk's website so the motion is processed timely.

Judge Darren Dunifon Shull

CRITICALCivil cases

Applies to
Demonstrative aid

The plaintiff's demonstrative aid must identify which of the three standing categories the plaintiff claims.

Plaintiff’s demonstrative aid shall specify under which of the three categories it claims to have standing.

Judge Darren Dunifon Shull

CRITICALCivil cases

Applies to
Exhibit list

An updated, legible, and specific exhibit list must be provided to the trial clerk on the first day of trial.

An updated, legible, and specific exhibit list MUST be provided to the trial clerk on the first day of trial.

Judge Darren Dunifon Shull

CRITICALCivil cases

Applies to
Exhibits
Must include
exhibit list

All exhibits to be entered into evidence must be premarked using the Exhibit Card Template and affixed to the back of the exhibit.

All exhibits that will be entered into evidence must be pre-marked using the Exhibit Card Template (see attached) and affixed to the back of the exhibit.

Judge Darren Dunifon Shull

CRITICALCivil cases

Applies to
Demonstrative aid

A party advancing a position on the plaintiff's standing must provide the court and every other party with a standing demonstrative aid at least five business days before trial begins.

Therefore, prior to trial in any foreclosure case, any party which advances a position on plaintiff’s standing shall prepare and at least five business days prior to trial commencement, provide to the Court and to each other party a demonstrative aid which demonstrates existence of or lack of standing by the plaintiff both immediately before filing of the complaint and at time of trial.

Judge Darren Dunifon Shull

CRITICALCivil cases

Applies to
Exhibits
Must include
case number

The exhibit card must include the case number, a circled party type, and the exhibit number.

Must have case #, party type circled, and exhibit#.

Judge Darren Dunifon Shull

CRITICAL

Applies to
Order setting hearing

Immediately after reserving hearing time, upload an order setting hearing that identifies the motion and the docket entries for it and any related memorandum.

The order setting hearing must be uploaded immediately after reserving hearing time. It must identify the motion to be heard and include the corresponding docket entry number as well as the docket entry number for any memorandum related to the motion.

Judge Darren Dunifon Shull

CRITICALCivil cases

Applies to
Exhibit list
Must include
exhibit list

The exhibit list must include the case number, party name, party type, exhibit number, exhibit description, and hearing or trial date.

The list is to include the Case #, the party name, party type (Pltf., Resp., Mother, Father, etc.), exhibit #, description of the exhibit and hearing/trial date.

Judge Darren Dunifon Shull

CRITICAL

Applies to
Notice to set trial

When all parties are represented, the Notice to Set Trial must include every attorney’s name and telephone number; the order will be provided to registered parties by Judicial eService.

In cases where all parties are represented by counsel, the notice shall contain each attorney's name and telephone number, and the Order will be provided to all registered parties via Judicial eService.

Judge Darren Dunifon Shull

CRITICAL

Applies to
Notice to set trial

A Notice to Set Trial must state that the case is at issue and the amount of trial time requested.

Upon the filing of a Notice to Set Trial, the case will be set before a senior judge or the Judge presiding in Division AE. The notice shall indicate that the case is at issue and the amount of time requested for trial.

Judge Darren Dunifon Shull

CRITICALCivil cases

Applies to
Proposed order
Must include
proposed order

If the hearing issue is resolved within 24 hours of the hearing, excluding holidays and weekends, the moving party must either appear at the scheduled hearing time or contact the Judicial Assistant before uploading an agreed order.

If the issue which is the subject matter of the hearing is resolved prior to the hearing, contact the Judicial Assistant immediately for instructions on submission of a proposed order. If resolved less than twenty-four (24) hours prior to the hearing (excluding holidays and weekends), the moving party shall either: 1) appear before the Court at the scheduled hearing time; or 2) Contact the Judicial Assistant before uploading an agreed order resolving the subject matter of the hearing.

Judge Darren Dunifon Shull

CRITICAL

Applies to
Final judgment

A portion of the order’s text must appear on the signature page, and every Final Judgment must leave a 3-by-3-inch blank space at the top right for recording.

Administrative Order 5.204 requires that some portion of text of the Order be included on signature page. All Final Judgments must have a 3X3 inch space on the top-right-hand corner for recording purposes. The Clerk will not docket or record the Final Judgment without this space.

Judge Darren Dunifon Shull

CRITICAL

Applies to
Order

When a case includes a self-represented party, an uploaded order must state that the moving party must send that party a copy by U.S. Mail.

In cases where there are self-represented (pro se) parties, the uploaded orders must include a provision that the moving party is required to furnish a copy of the order/judgment to the pro se party via U.S. Mail.

Judge Darren Dunifon Shull

CRITICALCivil cases

Applies to
Exhibit list
Must include
exhibit list

An updated, legible, and specific exhibit list must be provided to the trial clerk on the first day of trial.

An updated, legible, and specific exhibit list MUST be provided to the trial clerk on the first day of trial.

Judge Darren Dunifon Shull

CRITICAL

Applies to
Motion
Must include
proposed order

For a motion compliant with A.O. 3.202, no hearing is necessary; the moving attorney must submit the proposed order and attach a copy of the motion through OLS.

No hearing is necessary if the Motion is in compliance with A.O. 3.202. The moving attorney must submit the Order for signature by the Judge and a copy of the motion as an attachment via the Court's Online Services (OLS).

Judge Darren Dunifon Shull

CRITICAL

Applies to
Motion
Must include
proposed order

A request to the Court must be made by motion, provided to all parties, and uploaded through OLS as an exhibit with a proposed form order.

If you are making a request to the Court, you must file a motion, which shall be provided to all parties and upload the same as an exhibit with a proposed form order by OLS to the division queue.

Judge Darren Dunifon Shull

CRITICAL

Applies to
Order

For an order regarding a hearing held in open court, put the hearing date and names of attending parties in the order’s first sentence.

If the order being submitted is regarding a hearing held in open court, the date of the hearing and names of the party or parties in attendance must be included in the first sentence of the order.

Judge Darren Dunifon Shull

CRITICALCivil cases

Applies to
Exhibit list

An exhibit list may not describe exhibits collectively as “all,” “any,” or “any and all.”

Exhibit list which states “all”, “any” and “any and all” are not accepted.

Judge Darren Dunifon Shull

CRITICALCivil cases

Applies to
Demonstrative aid

A copy of the note showing all indorsements and each allonge or assignment must be attached to the demonstrative aid.

A copy of the note showing indorsements and each allonge or assignment shall be attached to the demonstrative aid.

Judge Darren Dunifon Shull

CRITICAL

All pleadings and orders must list complete mailing and email addresses for every participating party.

All pleadings and Orders must have complete mailing addresses for all participating parties(see A.O. 2.306-9/08 & 2.310-5/14). All pleadings and Orders must have complete e-mail addresses for all participating parties(see A.O. 2.310-5/14).

Judge Darren Dunifon Shull

CRITICALCivil cases

Applies to
Redacted document

A producing party must identify that a document was redacted, state what was redacted, and provide the basis for each redaction on the document, in metadata, or in a log.

The producing party shall clearly note when a document has been redacted for the above reasons only, what information has been redacted, and provide the basis for the redaction. The basis for each redaction may be specified either on the face of the document, in the metadata, or in a log.

Judge Darren Dunifon Shull

CRITICALCivil cases

Applies to
Demonstrative aid

Each side's demonstrative aid must provide a timeline or chronology addressing whether the plaintiff is the holder, owner, or qualifying non-holder in possession of the note.

In other words, each side shall create a document which sets forth the timeline or chronology either establishing or disestablishing that the plaintiff is the (1) holder, 1 ===== PAGE 2 ===== (2) owner, or (3) non-holder in possession of the note with the rights of a holder.

Judge Darren Dunifon Shull

CRITICALCivil cases

Applies to
Exhibit list

An exhibit list must be provided to the Court at the start of the hearing and numbered chronologically.

An Exhibit list shall be provided to the Court at the start of the hearing and must be numbered chronologically.

Judge Darren Dunifon Shull

CRITICALCivil cases

Applies to
Examiner copy

Defense counsel must give the examiner a copy of the Order and explain why the examiner must comply.

Defense counsel must provide the examiner with a copy of this Order and explain the need for the examiner's compliance.

Judge Darren Dunifon Shull

CRITICALCivil cases

Applies to
Request for Court to Adjudicate Motion Based on Written Submissions

Before seeking a ruling on the papers, the movant must simultaneously file a Request for Court to Adjudicate Motion Based on Written Submissions.

Prior to seeking a ruling from the Court, the movant shall simultaneously file a “Request for Court to Adjudicate Motion Based on Written Submissions,”

Judge Debra Moses Stephens

CRITICALCivil cases

Applies to
Motion

A movant seeking a ruling on the papers must file and serve the motion and supporting materials on the opposing party.

If a moving party seeks a ruling on the papers, the movant must file and serve its motion and supporting materials on the opposing party.

Judge Debra Moses Stephens

CRITICALCivil cases

Applies to
Filing
Must include
proposed order

A party seeking to bring a filing to the Court's attention must upload an appropriate proposed order, set a hearing, or otherwise notify the Court.

If a party wants to bring a filing to the Court’s attention, it is the responsibility of that party to upload a proposed order (if appropriate under Divisional Instructions), set a hearing, or otherwise notify the Court.

Judge Debra Moses Stephens

CRITICALCivil cases

Applies to
Protective order motion

A motion for a protective order must include a fact-supported explanation of the annoyance, embarrassment, oppression, undue burden, or undue cost caused by compliance.

A motion seeking relief under this Rule must include a specific explanation, supported by facts, demonstrating how complying with the discovery request would cause annoyance, embarrassment, oppression, or undue burden or cost.

Judge Debra Moses Stephens

CRITICALCivil cases

Applies to
Proposed order
Must include
proposed order

The requesting party must email Chambers and upload a proposed order directing the opposing party to respond within ten days.

DivisionRH@pbcgov.org, and upload a proposed order directing the opposing party to respond within ten (10) days (“Order Directing Response”).

Judge Debra Moses Stephens

CRITICALCivil cases

Applies to
Discovery objection

A vagueness, irrelevance, or undue-burden objection must explain specifically and particularly the basis for the objection.

A party objecting on any of these grounds must explain the specific and particular way in which a request is vague, seeks irrelevant information or is unduly burdensome.

Judge Debra Moses Stephens

CRITICAL

Applies to
Motion

All motions in Division FS stalking-injunction cases must be filed with the Domestic Violence Clerk.

Division FS:Stalking Injunctions – all motions must be filed with the Domestic Violence Clerk

Judge Debra Moses Stephens

CRITICALCivil cases

Applies to
Non evidenceary motion
Must include
legal argument

Non-evidentiary motions must cite and comply with applicable rules and state factual grounds and applicable law specifically and with particularity.

Such motions must cite to and strictly comply with the requirements of the applicable rule(s), and the factual grounds and applicable law shall be stated specifically and with particularity.

Judge Debra Moses Stephens

CRITICALCivil cases

Applies to
Discovery response

Unless all unobjectionable materials are produced with the written response, the response must specify a production-completion date, using the requested date or a reasonable alternative proposed after consultation.

Hence, unless all unobjectionable materials are being produced contemporaneously with the written response, the response must specify a date by which production will be completed; the respondent may adopt the date proposed in the request or may propose its own reasonable time, after consultation with opposing counsel.

Judge Debra Moses Stephens

CRITICALCivil cases

Applies to
Response

A non-moving party must immediately notify the Court if it wants the Court to consider its response before ruling.

Any non-moving party wishing for the Court to consider its response before ruling shall immediately notify the Court.

Judge Debra Moses Stephens

CRITICALCivil cases

Applies to
Privilege objection

A privilege objection must identify the privilege and describe the communication's nature and subject matter, its sender and recipient, and their relationship.

The Rules require that objections based upon privilege identify the specific nature of the privilege being asserted, as well as, inter alia, the nature and subject matter of the communication at issue and the sender and receiver of the communication and their relationship to each other.

Judge Debra Moses Stephens

CRITICALCivil cases

Applies to
Cover letter

The cover letter must state whether the opposing party submitted a competing order and include other pertinent information for the judge.

The cover letter shall indicate whether the opposing party is submitting a competing order, along with any other pertinent information of which the Judge should be advised.

Judge Debra Moses Stephens

CRITICALCivil cases

Applies to
Proposed order
Must include
proposed order

No later than 15 days after issuance of the response order, the movant must upload through online scheduling a proposed order with the motion, highlighted and bookmarked case law, any opposition, and a cover letter copied to all counsel and pro se parties.

Upon expiration of the 10-day response deadline, and no later than 15 days after issuance of the Order Directing Response, the movant shall upload a proposed order through online scheduling with the following attached: the motion, applicable case law (bookmarked and highlighted); the response in opposition, if any; and a cover letter with copy to all counsel of record and pro se parties.

Judge Debra Moses Stephens

CRITICALCivil cases

Applies to
Written order
Must include
proposed order

Unless otherwise directed, the prevailing party must submit a written proposed order memorializing the Court's ruling through OLS within 48 hours after the hearing.

Unless otherwise directed, the prevailing party shall provide the Court with a written order memorializing the Court’s ruling, through online scheduling (OLS/proposed order submission), within forty-eight (48) hours of the hearing.

Judge Debra Moses Stephens

CRITICALCivil cases

Applies to
Discovery objection

A party asserting a vagueness objection must state it in writing and attempt to obtain clarification from opposing counsel.

If a party believes that a request or a term is vague, the party shall state the objections in writing and that party shall then attempt to obtain clarification from opposing counsel.

Judge Debra Moses Stephens

CRITICALCivil cases

Applies to
Discovery response

A response to a request for production must identify any documents being provided and state whether responsive documents are withheld, with the specific legal basis for any withholding.

The proper practice is to state (1) whether documents are being provided in response to the request and identify those documents by sequential number or category, and (2) whether any responsive documents are being withheld, and if so the specific legal basis for that objection.

Judge Debra Moses Stephens

CRITICALCivil cases

Applies to
Discovery objection

An objection that discovery is not reasonably calculated to lead to admissible evidence must state its basis or be overruled.

An objection that a discovery request is not reasonably calculated to lead to admissible evidence will be overruled by this Court unless the objection states its basis.

Judge Debra Moses Stephens

CRITICAL

Applies to
Proposed order

A proposed order may be uploaded only if it is agreed, the hearing has already occurred, or it is proper to consider ex parte; agreed orders must be titled as orders on agreed motions.

Please do not upload a proposed order unless: It is agreed. (Order should be titled : Order on Agreed Motion to …), or The hearing has already occurred, or It is proper to be considered ex parte

Judge Debra Moses Stephens

CRITICALCivil cases

Applies to
Notice of hearing

If the Court determines that a hearing is necessary, the movant must be directed to schedule the hearing and file the appropriate notice.

If it is determined that a hearing is necessary, the movant will be directed to schedule a hearing and file the appropriate notice.

Judge Debra Moses Stephens