Court Rules

Fifth Judicial Circuit of Florida, Citrus, Hernando, Lake, Marion and Sumter Counties Document Filing Requirements

417 rules from official source documents

Rules 101 to 150, page 3 of 9

Required elements, certificates, and structural requirements for court documents.

CRITICALCivil cases

Applies to
Motion to compel

A motion to compel must quote in full the objection and the grounds asserted.

2. quote in full the objection and grounds given therefore; and

Judge Dan R. Mosley

CRITICALCivil cases

Applies to
Proposed order

A party drafting a court-requested proposed order must present it to the other parties and advise the court whether they agree on its form and content.

In the event one party is drafting a proposed order at the request of the Court, the party shall present the proposed order to the other party or parties and advise the Court as to whether there is an agreement as to the form and content of the proposed order.

Judge Dan R. Mosley

CRITICALCivil cases

Applies to
Motion to compel

A motion to compel must state, with authority citations, why the objection should be overruled or sustained.

3. state (with citations of authority) the reason such objection should be overruled or sustained.

Judge Dan R. Mosley

CRITICAL

Applies to
Order
Must include
certificate of service

Every order must include a complete certificate of service.

All orders must include a complete Certificate of Service.

Judge Daniel B. Merritt Jr.

CRITICAL

Applies to
Motion

A legal memorandum and the prescribed motion title are required for written motions, subject to stated exceptions.

c. Legal Memorandum: Required for all written motions except continuance, discovery related, defaults, extension of time, or substitution/withdrawal of counsel. The Motion shall be titled “Motion to/for ______ and Memorandum of Law”.

Judge Don Barbee

CRITICAL

Applies to
Proposed order
Must include
certificate of service

Every proposed order must include a complete certificate of service.

Proposed orders should be submitted no more than 24 hours prior to the hearing and within five (5) days after the hearing is held and shall include a complete certificate of service.

Judge Don Barbee

CRITICAL

Applies to
Discovery motion

A discovery-content motion must identify the challenged interrogatory, question, or request, state the grounds for objection, and cite supporting legal authority.

e. Discovery: Motions related to the content of discovery shall include the interrogatory, question or request being challenged, the grounds for the objection, and the legal authority for the position taken by the movant.

Judge Don Barbee

CRITICAL

Applies to
Legal memorandum

A legal memorandum is generally required for written motions except the listed exceptions, and the motion must be titled “Motion to/for ______ and Memorandum of Law.”

Legal Memorandum: Required for all written motions except continuance, discovery related, defaults, extension of time, or substitution/withdrawal of counsel. The Motion shall be titled “Motion to/for ______ and Memorandum of Law”.

Judge Don Barbee

CRITICAL

Applies to
Motion

A requested hearing must be included with the motion and specify the time needed for argument.

The request for a hearing must accompany the motion and must estimate the time required for argument.

Judge Don Barbee

CRITICAL

Applies to
Proposed order

When the parties stipulate to a remote appearance, they must submit a proposed order.

if the parties stipulate to the remote appearance send in a proposed order.

Judge Don Barbee

CRITICAL

Applies to
Proposed order
Must include
certificate of service

Every proposed order must include a complete certificate of service.

Proposed orders should be submitted no more than 24 hours prior to the hearing and within five (5) days after the hearing is held and shall include a complete certificate of service.

Judge Don Barbee

CRITICAL

Applies to
Discovery motion

A motion challenging discovery must identify the challenged interrogatory, question, or request; state the grounds for objection; and cite legal authority for the movant’s position.

Motions related to the content of discovery shall include the interrogatory, question or request being challenged, the grounds for the objection, and the legal authority for the position taken by the movant.

Judge Don Barbee

CRITICAL

Applies to
Motion
Must include
certificate of conference

Every nondispositive motion must contain a certificate that a good-faith effort was made to resolve the dispute before filing.

All motions (other than dispositive motions) shall contain a certificate that a good faith effort has been made to resolve the dispute prior to filing the motion.

Judge Don Barbee

CRITICAL

Applies to
Motion

If the opposing side objects to a remote appearance, a party must file a motion and set it for hearing.

If the other side objects to a remote appearance, file a motion and set it for hearing.

Judge Don Barbee

CRITICAL

Applies to
Motion

A written request for a hearing must accompany the motion and include an estimate of the time needed for argument.

The request for a hearing must accompany the motion and must estimate the time required for argument.

Judge Don Barbee

CRITICAL

Applies to
Motion

If the opposing side objects to a remote appearance, a motion must be filed and set for hearing.

If the other side objects to a remote appearance, file a motion and set it for hearing.

Judge Don Barbee

CRITICAL

Applies to
Proposed order
Must include
proposed order

When the parties stipulate to a remote appearance, they must submit a proposed order.

In a nutshell, if the parties stipulate to the remote appearance send in a proposed order.

Judge Don Barbee

CRITICAL

Applies to
Response

A response must include a legal memorandum.

Opposing party shall have ten (10) days from receipt of a motion to file a response (along with legal memorandum).

Judge Don Barbee

CRITICAL

Applies to
Written statement

Within 45 days, counsel must file a written statement containing the specified factual, legal, discovery, and trial information.

Within 45 days of this Order, Counsel will file with the Clerk, serve opposing counsel, and deliver a copy to the undersigned Judge's Chambers, a written statement which shall contain the following:

Judge Donald E. Scaglione

CRITICAL

Applies to
Motion for telephonic appearance
Must include
proposed order

A courtesy copy of the motion for telephonic appearance and proposed order must be submitted to Judge Donald E. Scaglione at the DES Courtesy Copy link no later than one (1) week before the coordinated hearing.

A courtesy copy of the motion for telephonic appearance and proposed order must be submitted to Judge Donald E. Scaglione at the DES Courtesy Copy link no later than one (1) week before the coordinated hearing.

Judge Donald E. Scaglione

CRITICAL

Applies to
Jury instructions

Counsel must bring a CD containing copies of all jury instructions and the verdict form to trial.

A copy of all Jury Instructions and Verdict Form are to be copied on a CD and brought to the Trial by Counsel.

Judge Donald E. Scaglione

CRITICAL

Applies to
Exhibit schedule

Counsel must submit a schedule of all exhibits and documentary evidence that may be used at trial, and unlisted evidence requires leave of court upon a showing of good cause.

A schedule of all exhibits and documentary evidence which may be used Page 5 of 11 ===== PAGE 6 ===== at trial; ANY EVIDENCE NOT SPECIFICALLY LISTED CANNOT LATER BE USED IN THE TRIAL OF THIS CAUSE WITHOUT LEAVE OF COURT. Said leave of Court being granted only upon a showing of good cause why said evidence was not listed.

Judge Donald E. Scaglione

CRITICAL

Applies to
Notice of remote proceeding

A notice of a remote proceeding must state that the proceeding will occur by video conferencing.

indicate that the proceeding will occur by video conferencing.

Judge Donald E. Scaglione

CRITICAL

Applies to
Proposed order
Must include
proposed order

Before submitting a proposed order to the court, a lawyer must prepare it promptly, ensure it fairly and adequately reflects the ruling without argument, inflammatory remarks, or unannounced findings, and advise the court whether opposing counsel approved it.

7. A lawyer must promptly prepare a proposed order, ensure that the order fairly and adequately represents the court's ruling and does not include any argument, inflammatoiy remarks, or unannounced findings, before submitting the order to the court, and advise the court whether or not opposing counsel has approved the order. (See R. Regulating Fla. Bar 4-3.4(c)).

Judge Donald E. Scaglione

CRITICAL

Applies to
Motion practice motion
Must include
proposed order

Every motion-practice motion must be accompanied by a proposed order.

Proposed orders must be submitted with all motion practice motions.

Judge Donald E. Scaglione

CRITICAL

Applies to
Notice of remote proceeding

When available, a notice of a remote proceeding must include complete and accurate video conferencing links and login information.

include, if available, the video conferencing details, including complete and accurate links and login information.

Judge Donald E. Scaglione

CRITICALCivil cases

Applies to
Motion

If a hearing is required by law, the initial motion must prominently state that fact and provide legal authority supporting it.

If a hearing is required by law, please succinctly so state in a prominent location in your initial motion directed to that issue, and cogently provide the legal authority for your belief that a hearing on this subject is required by Florida law.

Judge Donald E. Scaglione

CRITICALCivil cases

Applies to
Pleading
Must include
ai disclosure

Any pleading prepared with Generative AI must disclose that use to the Court.

**If any Generative AI is used, you must note its use on the pleading to the Court.**

Judge Donald E. Scaglione

CRITICALCivil cases

Applies to
Request for relief
Must include
proposed order

Courtesy copies of all requests for relief must include a proposed order, and pro se or unrepresented parties must also receive stamped, pre-addressed envelopes.

All requests for relief (courtesy copy) should be sent with proposed orders and with stamped, pre-addressed envelopes for pro se and unrepresented parties.

Judge Donald E. Scaglione

CRITICALCivil cases

Applies to
Motion
Must include
certificate of conference

When conferral is required, the movant must file a certificate of conferral with the motion.

When conferral is required, the movant must file with the motion a certificate of conferral that must be substantially in the following form:

Judge Donald E. Scaglione

CRITICALCivil cases

Applies to
Emergency motion

An emergency motion must clearly and concisely explain why the court should deem it an emergency.

and must clearly and concisely explain why the court should deem this motion an emergency.

Judge Donald E. Scaglione

CRITICAL

Applies to
Motion

A motion to continue trial must be written and signed by the client.

A motion to continue trial shall be in writing and signed by the client.

Judge Donald E. Scaglione

CRITICALCivil cases

Applies to
Stipulated motion in limine
Must include
certificate of conference

Uncontested or stipulated motions in limine must certify that opposing counsel has no objection, and the certification must also appear in the proposed order.

Uncontested/stipulated Motions in Limine MUST indicate and certify that opposing Counsel has no objection to the entry of the order. Said certification shall also be contained in the body of the proposed Order that shall be provided to this Court as set forth above.

Judge Donald E. Scaglione

CRITICALCivil cases

Applies to
Emergency motion

An emergency motion must first be filed in writing with the court, with a courtesy copy sent directly to the court and copies emailed to all opposing counsel, before the court will consider it.

Such motion must first be filed in writing with the court (courtesy copy directly to the Court) and copies e-mailed to all opposing counsel, before such motion will be considered

Judge Donald E. Scaglione

CRITICAL

Applies to
Notice of remote proceeding

provide instructions for participation by telephone if a self-represented party does not have access to the video conferencing platform that is being used.

provide instructions for participation by telephone if a self-represented party does not have access to the video conferencing platform that is being used.

Judge Donald E. Scaglione

CRITICAL

Applies to
Motion

A motion seeking a continuance requires the client's signature or consent, and the client may not file a comment about the requested continuance.

This motion requires the client's signature and/or consent, and no comment shall be filed by the client regarding the continuance being sought.

Judge Donald E. Scaglione

CRITICALCivil cases

Applies to
Motion

When the other side will not agree, the motion must state the requested relief and entitlement reasons and be supported by a concise legal memorandum containing legal authority, subject to the separately referenced page limitation.

If the other side, for any reason, cannot or will not stipulate or agree to the relief requested, then, as further set forth in this order, counsel shall succinctly and cogently, subject to the page limitation of paragraph #13 below, set forth in their motion the relief they are requesting and the reasons they believe that they are entitled to such relief, supported by concise legal memorandum containing their legal authority.

Judge Donald E. Scaglione

CRITICALCivil cases

Applies to
Written notice of no objection

A party with no objection who will not file a responsive memorandum must file written notice with the clerk and provide a copy to the judge's office.

If a party has no objection to a motion and does not intend to file a responsive memorandum, counsel shall file a written notice of same with the clerk of the court, and provide a copy to the office of the judge, so indicating.

Judge Donald E. Scaglione

CRITICAL

Applies to
Motion
Must include
certificate of service

counsel seeking a continuance of hearings or trials shall certify, by a statement included in the signed certificate of service on the motion or notice filed with this Court, that counsel has that day provided a copy of the motion or agreed notice to his/her client(s) via US Mail, e-mail, or by hand delivery.

counsel seeking a continuance of hearings or trials shall certify, by a statement included in the signed certificate of service on the motion or notice filed with this Court, that counsel has that day provided a copy of the motion or agreed notice to his/her client(s) via US Mail, e-mail, or by hand delivery.

Judge Donald E. Scaglione

CRITICAL

Applies to
Pleading
Must include
ai disclosure

Any pleading prepared with generative artificial intelligence must disclose that use to the court.

**If any Generative AI is used, you must note its use on the pleading to the Court.**

Judge Donald E. Scaglione

CRITICALCivil cases

Applies to
Proposed order
Must include
proposed order

The parties must submit a Rule 56-compliant proposed order addressing the standards and facts within 10 days after the hearing.

The Parties shall submit to the Court within 10 days of hearing a Proposed Order complying with FRCP 1.510 (Fed R. 56) involving the standards and facts.

Judge Donald E. Scaglione

CRITICAL

Applies to
Witness list

Counsel must submit the names and addresses of all potential trial witnesses, and unlisted witnesses require leave of court upon a showing of good cause.

A witness list of the names and addresses of all individuals who may be called to testify at trial; ANY WITNESSES NOT LISTED CANNOT LATER BE USED IN THE TRIAL OF THIS CAUSE WITHOUT LEAVE OF COURT. Said leave of Court being granted only upon a showing of good cause why said witness was not listed.

Judge Donald E. Scaglione

CRITICAL

Applies to
Agreed proposed order

Every agreed proposed order must be accompanied by a written stipulation or confirmed party agreement.

Agreed proposed orders MUST be accompanied by a written stipulation or confirmed agreement by the parties.

Judge Donald E. Scaglione

CRITICALCivil cases

Applies to
Transport order

A moving party requesting the personal appearance and transport of an incarcerated party or witness must obtain a transport order.

THE COURT requires the moving party rehuesting the personal appearance and transport of an incarcerated party/witness to obtain a transport order.

Judge Donald E. Scaglione

CRITICALCivil cases

Applies to
Notice of hearing
Must include
local rule certificate

The Notice of Hearing must include a Certificate of Compliance stating that the meet-and-confer occurred or detailing the good-faith attempts made to schedule it.

Counsel who schedules the hearing shall include in the Notice of Hearing the Certificate of Compliance certifying that the meet and confer occurred (or did not occur and setting out the good faith attempts to schedule the conference).

Judge Donald E. Scaglione

CRITICAL

Applies to
Jury instructions

Plaintiff must submit proposed general jury instructions, and Defendant must submit proposed defense or special instructions.

Plaintiff shall submit proposed general instructions as to the cause of action and Defendant shall submit proposed defense or special instructions sought.

Judge Donald E. Scaglione

CRITICALCivil casesCourt notice

Applies to
Proposed order
Must include
certificate of service

All proposed orders must include a proper certificate of service.

Additionally, review and comply with proper certificate of service for all proposed orders.

Judge Donald E. Scaglione

CRITICALCivil cases

Applies to
Opposition brief

An opposing party must file with the clerk and serve opposing counsel and the judge a cited opposition memorandum within ten days after being served.

Each party opposing any written motion or other application shall file with the Clerk of Court and serve all opposing counsel AND THIS JUDGE, within ten (10) days after being served with such motion or application, a legal memorandum with citations of authority, in opposition to the relief requested.

Judge Donald E. Scaglione

CRITICAL

Applies to
Pretrial memorandum

Counsel must submit a pretrial brief memorandum identifying the parties, factual contentions, type of action and relief, defenses, any counterclaim and relief, and facts either party will admit.

A brief memorandum setting forth the general nature of the proceedings, including: i. the names of all parties; ii. factual contentions of each party; iii. type of action and relief sought; iv. defenses interposed; v. type of counterclaim, if any, and the relief sought thereby; and vi. all facts either party will admit.

Judge Donald E. Scaglione

CRITICALCivil cases

Applies to
Reply brief

If further argument is needed after receiving an opposition memorandum, counsel must immediately notify the judge's office of the intent to file and serve a reply memorandum.

If, upon receipt of an opposing memorandum, counsel determines further argument of his client's position on the initial motion is required, counsel must immediately notify the office of the judge that he/she intends to file and serve a reply memoranda.

Judge Donald E. Scaglione