Skip to main content
Court Rules

New York Supreme Court, Kings County Pre-Motion Conference Requirements

25 rules

Pre-motion conference and letter requirements before filing motions, including sequential steps.

Rules 1 to 25

  1. MandatoryCivil cases

    After sending the disclosure-dispute letter, the requesting party must contact Chambers to arrange a conference, preferably by telephone, and no discovery motion will be entertained without compliance.

    The party requesting relief shall then contact Chambers to arrange a conference (preferably by telephone) to resolve such dispute. If no effort is made by counsel to schedule such conference, the Court will infer that the matter has been resolved and will take no action. The Court may order that a motion be made but no discovery motion will be entertained without prior compliance with this rule.

    Court-level rulesOfficial source Section Motions
  2. Mandatory

    All motions require appearances and oral argument.

    All motions require appearances and oral argument.

    Court-level rulesOfficial source Section Motion Calendar Calls
  3. Mandatory

    A motion seeking discovery may not be filed without the court’s prior approval.

    Discovery motions are not permitted without prior Court approval.

  4. Mandatory

    Before filing a discovery motion, the movant must satisfy Commercial Division Rules 14 and 14-a and request a virtual conference no more than five days after uploading the dispute letter to NYSCEF.

    Prior to the filing Discovery Motions moving party shall have satisfied Commercial Division Rules 14 and 14-a, (22 NYCRR 202.7[a]) and request a Virtual Conference with Court no more than 5 days after dispute letter uploaded in NYSCEF.

    Judge Cenceria P. EdwardsSection DISCOVERY
  5. MandatoryCivil cases

    A motion may be decided on default for failure to file papers and appear, submit a consent order, or obtain an adjournment.

    Motions may be decided on default if there is a failure to file papers and appear, a failure to submit a consent order, or a failure to obtain an adjournment.

    Judge Gina AbadiSection MOTIONS
  6. MandatoryCivil cases

    In-person oral argument is required for every motion.

    In person oral argument is required on all motions.

    Judge Gina AbadiSection MOTIONS
  7. MandatoryCivil cases

    If the matter is not settled or accepted as a fully executed stipulation, the parties must appear in person.

    If the matter is not settled or resolved via fully executed stipulation with confirmation from the Court that it is being accepted, the parties are to appear in person.

    Judge Gina AbadiSection MOTIONS
  8. MandatoryCivil cases

    PARTIES HAVE RESOLVED A MOTION ON CONSENT AND UPLOADED A PROPOSED ORDER VIA NYSCEF AT LEAST THREE BUSINESS DAYS PRIOR TO THE RETURN DATE; AND

    PARTIES HAVE RESOLVED A MOTION ON CONSENT AND UPLOADED A PROPOSED ORDER VIA NYSCEF AT LEAST THREE BUSINESS DAYS PRIOR TO THE RETURN DATE; AND

    Judge Gina AbadiSection Hon. Gina Abadi Civil Part 18 Rules
  9. MandatoryCivil cases

    An in-person appearance is generally required for all motions, subject to the stated consent-resolution exception.

    AN IN-PERSON APPEARANCE IS REQUIRED ON ALL MOTIONS EXCEPT WHERE:

    Judge Gina AbadiSection Hon. Gina Abadi Civil Part 18 Rules
  10. MandatoryCivil cases

    The movant must obtain confirmation from the part clerk that an appearance is unnecessary before relying on the consent-resolution exception.

    THE MOVANT GETS CONFIRMATION FROM THE PART CLERK THAT THEY DO NOT HAVE TO APPEAR.

    Judge Gina AbadiSection Hon. Gina Abadi Civil Part 18 Rules
  11. Mandatory

    If counsel cannot resolve a disclosure dispute, requesting counsel must email the law clerks with all parties copied, briefly describe the dispute, request a virtual conference, and obtain a conference with the court before filing a discovery motion.

    If counsel are unable to resolve any disclosure dispute in this fashion, counsel requesting the conference shall email the law clerks, with all parties copied, briefly outlining the nature of the dispute and requesting a virtual conference. No party shall file a discovery motion without first conferencing the matter with the court.

  12. MandatoryCivil cases

    Oral argument is required for all opposed motions.

    MOTIONS: All motions for Part 67 shall be noticed and heard on Wednesday. Motions for JCP and CTRP shall follow the specific part routine. Oral argument is required on all opposed motions. The first call on motions is at 10:00 a.m., and the second call is at 11:30 a.m. All papers must be filed in accordance with the CPLR. Answering papers shall be filed in the Motion Support Office or with the Clerk of the Part.

    Judge Kenneth ShermanSection MOTIONS
  13. MandatoryCivil cases

    Oral argument is mandatory for every unresolved motion, and all counsel and litigants must be prepared on the return date.

    Oral argument is required on all unresolved motions. All Counsel/Litigants must be prepared with knowledge of the motion(s)/case and be ready for oral argument on the return date.

    Judge Peter P. SweeneySection MOTIONS are heard on MONDAYS
  14. MandatoryCivil cases

    For an adjourned motion, fully briefed papers must be submitted one week before the return date.

    Fully briefed papers are due one week prior to the return date.

    Judge Reginald A. BoddieSection 10. Motion Practice
  15. MandatoryCivil cases

    The court will not accept a sur-reply unless good cause is shown and the court grants a request to file it.

    Regarding sur-replies, the CPLR does not provide for sur-reply papers and the court will not accept these papers unless good cause is shown and a request to file those papers is granted.

    Judge Richard J. MontelioneSection MOTION PRACTICE IN PART 99
  16. MandatoryCivil cases

    A reply to an OSC is not permitted unless the court grants a good-cause application or directs a reply.

    Replies are not permitted unless the court grants an application based on good cause or otherwise directs a reply.

    Judge Richard J. MontelioneSection MOTION PRACTICE IN PART 99
  17. MandatoryCivil cases

    An OSC requesting a temporary restraining order or temporary stay generally may not be heard ex parte without good cause.

    An Order to Show Cause (OSC) with a request for a temporary restraining order, including a request for a temporary stay of an action, will generally not be heard ex parte unless good cause is shown.

    Judge Richard J. MontelioneSection MOTION PRACTICE IN PART 99
  18. MandatoryCivil cases

    All motions must be orally argued on the record.

    ALL MOTIONS ARE ORALLY ARGUED ON THE RECORD.

    Judge Rupert V. BarrySection MOTIONS
  19. ImportantCivil cases

    A fully briefed motion may be placed on the next available oral argument calendar, but oral argument will not occur on the day the application is made.

    Upon a motion being fully briefed the parties may make an application to put it on the oral argument calendar on the next available date. No oral argument will be heard on the day of the application to place a motion on the oral argument calendar.

    Judge Brian L. GotliebSection GENERAL MOTION CALENDAR
  20. ImportantCivil cases

    The court will not conduct a second calendar call.

    There will not be a second call.

    Judge Gina AbadiSection MOTIONS
  21. Important

    Discovery disputes should be resolved through court conference when practicable, and counsel must first attempt resolution in good faith.

    Discovery disputes are preferred to be resolved through court conference as opposed to motion practice, if practicable. Counsel must consult with one another in a good faith effort to resolve all disclosure disputes.

  22. ImportantCivil cases

    Once a motion is fully briefed, the parties may apply on the return date to schedule oral argument for the next available Friday morning; argument will not be heard on the application date.

    Upon a motion being fully briefed the parties may make an application on the return date to put it on the oral argument calendar on the next available date which will be a Friday morning. No oral argument will be heard on the day of the application to place a motion on the oral argument calendar.

    Judge Joy F. CampanelliSection CVAP4M Rules
  23. ImportantCivil cases

    When a non-lawyer movant retained counsel, the movant may apply to supplement the papers or add reply facts, and a granted application also permits a sur-reply.

    If the original motion was brought by a non-lawyer and the movant retained counsel, an application may be made to supplement the papers or include additional facts in a reply and if the application is granted the court will also allow a sur-reply in those instances.

    Judge Richard J. MontelioneSection MOTION PRACTICE IN PART 99
  24. ImportantCivil cases

    A fully briefed motion may be placed on the next available oral-argument date, but oral argument will not occur on the application date.

    Upon a motion being fully briefed the parties may make, an application to put it on the oral argument calendar on the next available date. No oral argument will be heard on the day of the application to place a motion on the oral argument calendar.

    Judge Richard VelasquezSection MOTION CALENDARS
  25. Note

    Motions are ordinarily decided on submission unless an oral-argument request has been submitted through NYSCEF.

    All motions are on submission, except those wherein a request has been submitted for oral argument via NYSCEF.

    Court-level rulesOfficial source Section MOTIONS

Common questions about New York Supreme Court, Kings County pre-motion conference requirements

Does New York Supreme Court, Kings County require a pre-motion conference or letter before filing a motion?

New York Supreme Court, Kings County: Yes. A pre-motion letter is required for discovery. After sending the disclosure-dispute letter, the requesting party must contact Chambers to arrange a conference, preferably by telephone, and no discovery motion will be entertained without compliance.

View ruleOfficial source Source: page 1, section Motions

Judge Richard J. Montelione: The court will not accept a sur-reply unless good cause is shown and the court grants a request to file it.

View ruleOfficial source Source: page 1, section MOTION PRACTICE IN PART 99

Judge Gina Abadi: A motion may be decided on default for failure to file papers and appear, submit a consent order, or obtain an adjournment.

View ruleOfficial source Source: page 1, section MOTIONS

22 more rules answer this question.