AI orders
Each line is a short summary. Read the order itself for the exact wording, timing and signature rules before you file.
Judge Kathleen Waterman-Marshall has an AI order.
Disclose AI use. Certify that a person reviewed the AI material. The order requires an AI certificate or statement even if no AI was used. Name the AI tool. Identify the parts AI drafted. Covers pleadings, motions, briefs or memoranda.
The court's words
Artificial intelligence (AI) programs: All submissions with respect to a motion must include a certification by an attorney (or self-represented party) either that no generative artificial intelligence program was used in the drafting of any affidavit, affirmation, or memorandum of law contained within the submission, or that a generative artificial intelligence program was used but all generated text, including citations, quotations, and legal analysis were reviewed for accuracy and approved by an attorney (or the self-represented party). If the certification states a generative artificial intelligence program was used, the program must be identified and the documents which include matter generated by the program must be specified along with which parts of the documents were drafted by the program. One certification pertaining to a party’s submission comprised of several such documents shall suffice.
From the order of New York Supreme Court, New York County.
Court-wide rules
Applies court-wideThese 265 rules apply across New York Supreme Court, New York County. Where this judge's own standing orders above address the same topic, the judge's requirement controls.
Filing Requirements
All 60- Applies to
- Filing agent authorization
A filing agent must submit an authorization form before or with the attorney’s first NYSCEF filing in the action.
- Applies to
- Attorney filing account
- Must include
- notice of electronic filing
An attorney using a filing agent must have a User ID and password so the agent’s filings are associated with the attorney of record.
- Applies to
- Hard copy submission
An attorney or participating unrepresented litigant submitting a hard-copy document in an e-filed case must place a Notice of Hard-Copy Submission on the back page facing out.
E-Filing
All 59- Applies to
- Proposed judgment
The filer should file to the case in question (select “File to Existing Case”) and a screen will appear that presents options for the filing of (i) motion documents or (ii) non-motion documents. Although a motion may have elicited the court’s directive, the motion itself has been concluded and so the filer should choose the selection under “Non-Motion Documents” labeled “Proposed Judgment to Clerk or Court.”
For cases commenced on or after February 19, 2013, e-filing through NYSCEF is mandatory except for the listed case types, and all subsequent documents must be e-filed.
Unrepresented litigants are automatically exempt from mandatory e-filing but may voluntarily participate.
Filing Timing
All 38- Deadline
- 3 business days
Failure to electronically refile hard-copy documents within three business days will cause the originals to be discarded and may result in an incomplete court record.
A motion on notice or notice of petition must be e-filed no later than eight days before the return date.
- Deadline
- 24 hours
The Clerk normally takes 24 hours to review and process a proposed order to show cause.
Sealing
All 25An order granting relief to correct a filing must be submitted to the County Clerk using the applicable notice form, with the sealing-order procedure using the NYSCEF sealing notification and a copy of the order.
An infant's compromise order containing confidential personal information must be uploaded under seal.
Counsel and parties must comply with rules restricting disclosure of confidential personal information.
- Education: B.A. in the Honors Program in Liberal Studies, Adelphi University
- Education: Graduate of Benjamin N. Cardozo School of Law
- Prior position: Adjunct Professor of Law in the Legal Writing Department of Cardozo Law School since 2016
- Elected: Began her judicial career in January 2019, upon her election to the NYC Civil Court
- Prior position: Acting Family Court Judge in Kings County Family Court
- Appointed: In December 2021, appointed to Supreme Court Justice status in New York County
- Prior position: Trial attorney for twenty years before becoming a judge
- Prior position: Taking a position as the Principal Law Clerk to Supreme Court Justice Arthur F. Engoron in 2014
- Prior position: In 2010, transitioned from the private to the public sector, taking a position in a non-profit law firm that represented children in high conflict custody and neglect proceedings
- Address: 60 Centre Street, New York, NY 10007
- Part: Part 31 General IAS Trial Part
- Chambers: Room 660
- Chambers Phone: (646) 386-4289
- Courtroom: Room 335
- Courtroom Phone: (646) 386-4296
- Assistant Law Clerk: Mary S. Tan, Esq.
- Principal Law Clerk: David Collins, Esq.
Does Judge Kathleen Waterman-Marshall require a pre-motion conference or letter before filing a motion?
Opposed, fully submitted substantive motions will be argued in person in Courtroom 355 unless otherwise directed, while unopposed motions will not be scheduled for oral argument.
What must be included with preliminary conference order filings before Judge Kathleen Waterman-Marshall?
Parties must confer on all discovery matters and email the part clerk an agreed-upon, signed draft PCO by noon on the day before the preliminary conference.
What must be included with joint discovery plan filings before Judge Kathleen Waterman-Marshall?
In complex discovery cases, counsel must submit a joint discovery plan with the PCO containing specified issue, discovery, disclosure, disputes, witness, non-party discovery, and ESI information, after which it will be so ordered and uploaded to NYSCEF.
How may parties contact Judge Kathleen Waterman-Marshall's chambers?
Ex parte communications with the court are strictly prohibited, and correspondence must include counsel for all parties and all self-represented parties.
How do I request an adjournment or extension before Judge Kathleen Waterman-Marshall?
Parties may not unilaterally adjourn oral argument, even with the opposing party's consent.
Is electronic filing required before Judge Kathleen Waterman-Marshall?
Yes. Electronic filing is required for the covered filings. Letters to the judge must be filed through NYSCEF.
What filing deadlines apply to stipulation and notice filings before Judge Kathleen Waterman-Marshall?
Counsel must notify the court as soon as practicable after settlement or resolution of an active case or pending motion.
What rule applies to service for letter before Judge Kathleen Waterman-Marshall?
Details: method: service by email, recipient: all parties, timing: at filing. Copies of letters to the judge must be emailed simultaneously with filing to all counsel and self-represented parties.
Does Judge Kathleen Waterman-Marshall encourage junior lawyer participation?
Yes. Judge Kathleen Waterman-Marshall's rules include a junior lawyer participation incentive. Courtroom participation by attorneys who enhance diversity in the bar or have been admitted for fewer than five years is strongly encouraged through speaking and leading roles, including oral argument or lead participation in discovery or settlement conferences.
Complete rules summary for Judge Kathleen Waterman-Marshall
Parties may not unilaterally adjourn oral argument, even with the opposing party's consent.
Courtroom participation by attorneys who enhance diversity in the bar or have been admitted for fewer than five years is strongly encouraged through speaking and leading roles, including oral argument or lead participation in discovery or settlement conferences.
Ex parte communications with the court are strictly prohibited, and correspondence must include counsel for all parties and all self-represented parties.
Written appearance and status inquiries, conference scheduling and adjournment requests, proposed conference orders, and stipulations should be directed to the part clerk.
Telephone calls should be directed to the part clerk at the courtroom number, while calls to chambers are prohibited except in an emergency.
Letters to the judge are strongly discouraged except in an emergency and, when submitted, must be filed on NYSCEF with simultaneous email copies to all counsel and self-represented parties.
Letters to the judge must be filed through NYSCEF.
Copies of letters to the judge must be emailed simultaneously with filing to all counsel and self-represented parties.
Counsel must notify the court as soon as practicable of a settlement or resolution of an active case or pending motion by filing a stipulation or notice through NYSCEF.
Counsel must notify the court as soon as practicable after settlement or resolution of an active case or pending motion.
Parties must confer on all discovery matters and email the part clerk an agreed-upon, signed draft PCO by noon on the day before the preliminary conference.
The draft preliminary conference order must be emailed to the part clerk by noon on the preceding day.
The agreed draft PCO must be emailed to the part clerk no later than 12:00 noon on the day before the preliminary conference.
After the judge signs the PCO, the part clerk will upload it to NYSCEF.
EBT dates must be no later than four months after the PCO date.
The compliance conference must occur six months after the PCO date.
The note of issue is due 12 months after the PCO for standard discovery and 15 months after the PCO for complex discovery.
In complex discovery cases, counsel must submit a joint discovery plan with the PCO containing specified issue, discovery, disclosure, disputes, witness, non-party discovery, and ESI information, after which it will be so ordered and uploaded to NYSCEF.
The joint discovery plan will be so ordered and uploaded to NYSCEF with the PCO.
Parties must confer on outstanding discovery and email the part clerk an agreed, signed draft CCO or SCO by noon on the preceding day.
The draft CCO or SCO must be emailed to the part clerk no later than 12:00 noon on the day before the applicable conference.
After the judge signs a CCO or SCO, the part clerk will upload it to NYSCEF.
The status conference must be held six months after the CCO date or the most recent SCO date.
If parties cannot agree on a PCO, CCO, or SCO after good-faith efforts, they must appear in person with a proposed order completed except for the disputed issue.
Discovery-conference adjournment requests must be made at least one week before the conference unless an emergency exists, and same-day attorney consent adjournments are not accepted.
Notices to Produce, Notices to Admit, Interrogatories, and their written responses must be filed through NYSCEF, but produced documents are excluded.
When ESI production is disputed, the parties must exchange an ESI protocol.
All papers must state the motion sequence number whenever one is available.
A summary judgment motion must be electronically filed no later than 60 days after the Notice of Issue is filed.
Counsel are strongly encouraged, but not required, to submit a proposed default judgment order explaining the basis for granting relief or denying an opposed motion.


