AI orders
Each line is a short summary. Read the order itself for the exact wording, timing and signature rules before you file.
Judge Ronald Castorina Jr. has an AI order.
Certify that a person reviewed the AI material. The order requires an AI certificate or statement even if no AI was used. Covers pleadings, motions, briefs or memoranda.
The court's words
In addition to the foregoing, all submissions with respect to a motion must include a certification by an attorney (or self-represented party) either that no generative artificial intelligence program was used in the drafting of any affidavit, affirmation, or memorandum of law contained within the submission, or that a generative artificial intelligence program was used but that all generated text, including citations, quotations, and legal analysis, was reviewed for accuracy and approved by an attorney (or the self-represented party).
From the order of New York Supreme Court, New York County.
Disclose AI use. Name the AI tool. Put the statement in the filing itself. Covers evidence or trial materials.
The court's words
The identification shall state, to the extent known: the tool or process used; the identity of the person who directed its use; the nature and extent of the AI contribution; and whether the original, unaltered source material has been preserved and is available for inspection.
From the order of New York Supreme Court, New York County.
Certify that a person reviewed the AI material. Certify that the citations or authorities were verified as real and accurate. Required only when AI was used. Signing or filing the paper counts as the certification.
The court's words
Accordingly, any attorney or party who uses an artificial intelligence tool, as defined in 22 NYCRR 161.2(a), in preparing any paper, as defined in 22 NYCRR 161.2(b), filed in or submitted to this Court or served on another party in a case before this Court is required to carefully review the paper and independently ensure that it contains no fabricated or fictitious cases, statutes, or other material. By signing such paper, an attorney or party certifies that such a review has been conducted and that the paper contains no such fabricated or fictitious content.
From the order of New York Supreme Court, New York County.
Disclose AI use. Put the statement in the filing itself. Covers pleadings, motions, briefs or memoranda.
The court's words
For motions, such identification shall be made with the moving or opposing papers.
From the order of New York Supreme Court, New York County.
Disclose AI use. Required only when AI was used. Covers evidence or trial materials.
The court's words
Any party intending to offer at trial, at a hearing, or in support of or in opposition to a motion any exhibit that was, in whole or in material part, created, generated, enhanced, restored, upscaled, translated, transcribed, or otherwise materially altered by an AI tool shall so identify the exhibit.
From the order of New York Supreme Court, New York County.
More of the court's words (1)
Any audio or video evidence that was created or altered by an artificial intelligence tool must additionally be identified in accordance with the ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE (AI) PROGRAMS section of these Rules.
Disclose AI use. Name the AI tool. Required only when AI was used. Put the statement in the filing itself. Covers expert reports, opinions or testimony. Applies to expert witnesses.
The court's words
Where an expert, forensic evaluator, or appraiser has used an AI tool in forming any opinion disclosed pursuant to CPLR 3101(d) or in preparing any report submitted to this Court, the disclosure or report shall identify the tool and describe its role in the methodology employed with sufficient particularity to permit examination of its reliability.
From the order of New York Supreme Court, New York County.
Disclose AI use. Name the AI tool. Identify the parts AI drafted. Required only when AI was used.
The court's words
If the certification states that a generative artificial intelligence program was used, the certification must identify the program, specify the documents that include matter generated by the program, and identify which parts of those documents were drafted by the program. One certification pertaining to a party's submission comprised of several such documents shall suffice.
From the order of New York Supreme Court, New York County.
Court-wide rules
Applies court-wideThese 265 rules apply across New York Supreme Court, New York County. Where this judge's own standing orders above address the same topic, the judge's requirement controls.
Filing Requirements
All 60- Applies to
- Filing agent authorization
A filing agent must submit an authorization form before or with the attorney’s first NYSCEF filing in the action.
- Applies to
- Attorney filing account
- Must include
- notice of electronic filing
An attorney using a filing agent must have a User ID and password so the agent’s filings are associated with the attorney of record.
- Applies to
- Hard copy submission
An attorney or participating unrepresented litigant submitting a hard-copy document in an e-filed case must place a Notice of Hard-Copy Submission on the back page facing out.
E-Filing
All 59- Applies to
- Proposed judgment
The filer should file to the case in question (select “File to Existing Case”) and a screen will appear that presents options for the filing of (i) motion documents or (ii) non-motion documents. Although a motion may have elicited the court’s directive, the motion itself has been concluded and so the filer should choose the selection under “Non-Motion Documents” labeled “Proposed Judgment to Clerk or Court.”
For cases commenced on or after February 19, 2013, e-filing through NYSCEF is mandatory except for the listed case types, and all subsequent documents must be e-filed.
Unrepresented litigants are automatically exempt from mandatory e-filing but may voluntarily participate.
Filing Timing
All 38- Deadline
- 3 business days
Failure to electronically refile hard-copy documents within three business days will cause the originals to be discarded and may result in an incomplete court record.
A motion on notice or notice of petition must be e-filed no later than eight days before the return date.
- Deadline
- 24 hours
The Clerk normally takes 24 hours to review and process a proposed order to show cause.
Sealing
All 25An order granting relief to correct a filing must be submitted to the County Clerk using the applicable notice form, with the sealing-order procedure using the NYSCEF sealing notification and a copy of the order.
An infant's compromise order containing confidential personal information must be uploaded under seal.
Counsel and parties must comply with rules restricting disclosure of confidential personal information.
- Address: 60 Centre Street, New York, NY 10007
- Part: Part 44 Matrimonial Part
- Chambers: Room 564
- Chambers Phone: (646) 386-4795
- Courtroom: Room 321
- Courtroom Phone: (646) 386-3370
- Law Clerk: David Pascarella, Esq.
- Secretary: Megan DePalma
Are courtesy copies required for Judge Ronald Castorina Jr.?
Courtesy-copy rule applies for stipulation to be so ordereds, subpoena for signatures, proposed orders, and proposed judgments. Details: delivery upon filing, by email. Courtesy copies of documents filed to NYSCEF for signature must be emailed to the Principal Law Clerk.
Does Judge Ronald Castorina Jr. require a pre-motion conference or letter before filing a motion?
A preliminary conference must occur at the first appearance or on the return date of the first motion unless the Court directs otherwise, with all parties and counsel present.
What page or word limits apply to settlement position statement before Judge Ronald Castorina Jr.?
Judge Ronald Castorina Jr.'s rule states these limits: 2 pages. The statement explaining the rationale for a party's position may not exceed two pages.
What page or word limits apply to affidavits affirmations and memoranda of law before Judge Ronald Castorina Jr.?
Judge Ronald Castorina Jr.'s rule states these limits: 25 pages. Excludes table of contents and table of authorities. Affidavits, affirmations, and memoranda of law may not exceed 25 double-spaced pages, excluding the table of contents and table of authorities.
What formatting rules apply to filings before Judge Ronald Castorina Jr.?
Judge Ronald Castorina Jr.'s formatting rule includes file format paper and bring hard copies of proposed preliminary conference orders to the conference when the parties cannot agree on the order's terms.. If the parties cannot agree on the Preliminary Conference Order, they must bring hard copies of proposed orders to the conference.
What must be included with exhibit filings before Judge Ronald Castorina Jr.?
The rule requires ai disclosure. An AI-exhibit identification must state, to the extent known, the tool or process, directing person, nature and extent of the AI contribution, and preservation and availability of the original source material.
What must be included with qualified domestic relations order filings before Judge Ronald Castorina Jr.?
The rule requires proposed order. A Qualified Domestic Relations Order filed after the Judgment must be accompanied by written approval of the settlement plan.
How may parties contact Judge Ronald Castorina Jr.'s chambers?
Ex parte communications with the Court are strictly prohibited and will not be reviewed or considered.
How do I request an adjournment or extension before Judge Ronald Castorina Jr.?
Every adjournment requires prior Court approval, and an unapproved stipulation to adjourn is invalid and will not be honored.
Does Judge Ronald Castorina Jr. require motion papers to be bundled?
No. The rule prohibits holding covered papers for bundling. Custody and visitation motions may not be combined with motions concerning financial issues.
Is electronic filing required before Judge Ronald Castorina Jr.?
Yes. Electronic filing is required for the covered filings. Counsel must electronically upload a completed and signed Matrimonial Preliminary Conference Order to NYSCEF at least two days before the preliminary conference.
What filing deadlines does Judge Ronald Castorina Jr. set?
Judgments of Divorce must be submitted within 60 days, failing which the action may be deemed abandoned and dismissed.
What rule applies to service for unsigned order before Judge Ronald Castorina Jr.?
Details: recipient: all parties. A movant seeking interim relief other than an ex parte order of protection must forward the unsigned order to every party or counsel with a letter stating the hearing date, time, and location.
Complete rules summary for Judge Ronald Castorina Jr.
The AI-disclosure rules do not apply to listed routine, non-substantive technical processes that do not alter substantive content.
An AI-exhibit identification must state, to the extent known, the tool or process, directing person, nature and extent of the AI contribution, and preservation and availability of the original source material.
Judgments of Divorce must be submitted within 60 days, failing which the action may be deemed abandoned and dismissed.
A Qualified Domestic Relations Order not submitted with the Judgment is due within 45 days after signing and must include written plan approval.
Every adjournment requires prior Court approval, and an unapproved stipulation to adjourn is invalid and will not be honored.
A Qualified Domestic Relations Order filed after the Judgment must be accompanied by written approval of the settlement plan.
A conference or motion adjournment request must be sent jointly by email at least two days before the appearance, with all counsel and any pro se parties copied, and must also copy the Judge's secretary.
Unless an emergency exists, a hearing or trial adjournment request must be made at least two weeks in advance and include an affidavit of actual engagement when applicable.
Every email to the Court must identify the case caption and index number in the subject line and include all counsel and any pro se parties as recipients.
Ex parte communications with the Court are strictly prohibited and will not be reviewed or considered.
Email and letters must not be used to litigate or as a substitute for a motion and should be used only for short scheduling matters or a conference request concerning a discrete urgent issue.
Because Chambers does not receive automatic NYSCEF upload notice, a courtesy copy of any letter, affidavit, or stipulation submitted to be so-ordered must be emailed directly to the Judge's law clerk.
Each adjournment request must be submitted in one joint email, provide three proposed dates acceptable to all sides, state whether it is consensual, and comply with Part 125.
A preliminary conference must occur at the first appearance or on the return date of the first motion unless the Court directs otherwise, with all parties and counsel present.
At least two days before the preliminary conference, counsel must upload a completed and signed Matrimonial Preliminary Conference Order to NYSCEF.
Counsel must electronically upload a completed and signed Matrimonial Preliminary Conference Order to NYSCEF at least two days before the preliminary conference.
The Court will not conduct a substantive preliminary conference unless each party has filed a complete Statement of Net Worth.
If the parties cannot agree on the Preliminary Conference Order, they must bring hard copies of proposed orders to the conference.
Each party must timely file a full, accurate, and sworn Statement of Net Worth before a substantive preliminary conference.
At least one day before the compliance conference, the parties must upload a jointly completed proposed Compliance Conference Order through NYSCEF.
The proposed Compliance Conference Order is due through NYSCEF at least one day before the compliance conference.
The parties must electronically upload the proposed Compliance Conference Order through NYSCEF.
At least two days before a settlement conference, each party must email the Court an updated Statement of Net Worth, a marital-property and proposed-distribution list, and a two-page-maximum statement of position rationale.
The settlement-conference submission must be emailed to the Court at least two days before the conference.
Each party must communicate the required settlement-conference materials to the Court by email.
The statement explaining the rationale for a party's position may not exceed two pages.
A Note of Issue is mandatory before the pre-trial conference.
The Note of Issue filing deadline is before the pre-trial conference.
At least one week before the pre-trial conference, the parties must file through NYSCEF and exchange the listed pretrial submissions, including financial documents, witness and exhibit lists, expert reports, marked pleadings, and memoranda.
The parties must electronically file the listed pre-trial submissions through NYSCEF.


