New York Supreme Court, Westchester County Pre-Motion Conference Requirements
100 rules, 51 to 100 shown
Pre-motion conference and letter requirements before filing motions, including sequential steps.
Rules 51 to 100
Mandatory
No party may file a discovery motion without authorization or direction from the Court; counsel should instead use the Section III.F dispute-resolution procedures.
In lieu of discovery motion practice, it is the policy of the Court to make itself and its staff available to resolve disputes related to pretrial discovery. Therefore, no discovery motion is to be made by any party unless authorized or directed by the Court. Instead, counsel should abide by the procedures set forth in Section III.F above to resolve discovery disputes.
Judge Paul I. MarxPage 7, section III.C. Discovery DisputesMandatory
Parties may not file motions concerning discovery disputes.
The parties are NOT to make any motion concerning discovery.
Judge Robert S. OndrovicPage 5, section DISCOVERY DISPUTESMandatory
After an RJI and request for a preliminary conference are filed and the case is assigned to the Part, the court schedules a preliminary conference at which personal appearances are mandatory.
Upon assignment of a case to this Part following the filing of an RJI and Request for a Preliminary Conference, the Court will schedule such a conference at which personal appearances are mandatory.
Judge Robert S. OndrovicPage 4, section PRELIMINARY CONFERENCEMandatory
The dates in a Preliminary Conference Order may be modified only by court order.
No modifications of the dates in the Preliminary Conference Order are permitted except by Order of the Court.
Judge Robert S. OndrovicPage 4, section PRELIMINARY CONFERENCEMandatory
Before raising a discovery dispute, counsel or a self-represented litigant must make good-faith, substantive telephone or written communication with the other side concerning the claimed noncompliance; a pro forma letter is insufficient.
Counsel (or self-represented litigant) who believes that discovery is not being conducted in accordance with the Court’s Order is to discuss, in good faith, as required by Court Rule § 202.7, the claimed noncompliance with opposing counsel or self-represented litigant. A pro forma letter does not constitute a good faith effort. There must be actual substantive communication between counsel, either telephonically or in writing, regarding the claimed failure to engage in discovery and the claimed noncompliance or reason for noncompliance.
Judge Robert S. OndrovicPage 5, section DISCOVERY DISPUTESMandatory
Motions are ordinarily decided on the papers, without a return-date appearance, unless the Court specifically requires oral argument.
All motions will be decided by submission and personal appearances on the return date are not required unless the Court specifically directs oral argument.
Judge Robert S. OndrovicPage 6, section MOTIONSMandatory
An Order to Show Cause may be brought only for a genuine emergency, when a stay is required, or for a post-judgment application.
An Order to Show Cause shall be brought only when there is genuine emergency, a stay is required, or the application is being filed post-judgment.
Judge Rolf M. ThorsenPage 4, section 5. Motions — Orders to Show CauseMandatory
A party seeking a motion must give notice and upload a written pre-motion conference request stating the anticipated motion's basis; the request and any permitted response are limited to two pages, and a response must be filed through NYSCEF within one business day after service.
Pursuant to Section C.3. (Motions) of the Matrimonial Part Operational Rules, any party seeking to make a motion must file a written letter request for a pre-motion conference on notice to all other parties and upload the letter to NYSCEF. The letter request should state the basis of the anticipated motion and may not exceed two (2) pages. All parties so served may serve and file a letter response, not to exceed two (2) pages, via NYSCEF within one (1) business day from service of the notification letter
Judge Rolf M. ThorsenPage 4, section 5. Motions — Pre-Motion ConferenceMandatory
Parties may not file discovery motions unless the court authorizes or directs them.
The parties are NOT to make any motion concerning discovery (unless authorized or directed by the Court).
Judge Thomas QuinonesPage 3, section II. CONFERENCESMandatory
Requests to modify discovery schedules must be raised and addressed at the compliance conference.
Requests for modifications to discovery schedules shall be raised and addressed at the compliance conference.
Judge Thomas QuinonesPage 3, section II. CONFERENCESMandatory
Before requesting a pre-motion discovery conference, a party must make a good-faith effort to resolve the dispute through meaningful direct discussion without the court.
A party that encounters a discovery dispute shall make a good faith effort (without the Court) to resolve the dispute by engaging in meaningful discussion(s), by telephone or email or other means of direct communication, prior to requesting a pre-motion discovery conference with the Court (22 NYCRR 202.20-f).
Judge Thomas QuinonesPage 3, section II. CONFERENCESMandatory
A party may not file a discovery motion unless the Court authorizes or directs it.
Therefore, no discovery motion is to be made by any party unless authorized or directed by the Court.
Judge Walter RiveraPage 5, section DISCOVERY DISPUTESMandatory
Attorneys must contact the Preliminary Conference Part by email or telephone conference call and confer with the court in good faith before filing a deposition-related motion.
b. Attorneys seeking rulings on objections or making application for any other relief pertaining to the depositions shall communicate with the Preliminary Conference Part by email or telephone conference call for a determination and shall make no motion in the absence of a conference with the Court and a good faith effort to resolve the matter without unnecessary motion practice.
Judge William J. GiacomoPage 14, section DepositionsMandatory
Discovery-related motions, including discovery-based dismissal motions and cross-motions, may not be filed until a pre-motion conference has been requested and held, and the parties must confer in good faith before requesting the conference.
No discovery-related motion (including a motion to dismiss predicated upon a discovery violation and including any discovery cross-motion) may be interposed and e-filed until a pre- motion conference has been requested and held. The parties are expected to confer in good faith prior to requesting a pre-motion conference.
Judge William J. GiacomoPage 2, section CONFERENCESImportant
Parties are expected to attend pre-motion conferences and attempt in good faith to resolve all discovery disputes.
The parties will be expected to attend such conferences and attempt in good faith to resolve all discovery disputes.
Important
Parties are expected to attend pre-motion conferences and attempt in good faith to resolve all discovery disputes.
The parties shall be expected to attend pre-motion conferences and attempt in good faith to resolve all discovery disputes (22 NYCRR 202.8 [f]).
Important
Either party may seek further proceedings when an FSCP issue concerns statutory or rule compliance, including alleged lack of good faith.
If an issue arises during FSCP proceedings relating to compliance with CPLR R 3408, Uniform Rule § 202.12-a or these Rules – including an alleged lack of good faith – either party may apply to the Court for further proceedings (see CPLR R 3408[n]).
Important
Absent exigent circumstances, parties should confer in good faith in person or by telephone before requesting a pre-motion conference.
Moreover, absent exigent circumstances, the parties are expected to confer in good faith either in-person or by telephone prior to requesting a pre-motion conference (22 NYCRR 202.20-f).
Important
Opposing counsel has twenty-four hours to file a response to a pre-motion conference request, and the response may not exceed two pages.
Opposing counsel will be permitted within twenty-four hours to file a response to the request and are not to exceed two pages.
Important
A party requests a pre-motion conference by emailing the IAS Part Clerk and giving notice to all other parties.
A party may request a pre-motion conference by e-mailing the IAS Part Clerk on notice to all other parties.
Important
A party may request an earlier preliminary-conference date by showing appropriate circumstances, emailing the Part Clerk, and notifying every other party.
Any party may seek to advance the date of a preliminary conference upon a showing of appropriate circumstances (22 NYCRR 202.12 [i]). The request to advance the conference date shall be made via e-mail to MedMalWestchester@nycourts.gov, on notice to all other parties.
Important
Before the Court Notice control date, a party may request judicial assistance with the stipulation by emailing the MDPM Part Clerk and providing notice to all parties.
In the event that a party requires guidance from the Court with respect to the preparation of the preliminary conference stipulation, the party may request a preliminary conference prior to the control date set forth in the Court Notice. The request for a preliminary conference shall be made via e-mail to MedMalWestchester@nycourts.gov, on notice to all parties.
Important
Parties are expected to attend pre-motion conferences and resolve discovery disputes in good faith so the court can address issues before motion practice, without barring other appropriate motions.
The parties are expected to attend such conferences and attempt in good faith to resolve all discovery disputes. Nothing in these rules shall be construed to prevent or limit counsel from making any motion deemed appropriate to best represent a party’s interests. However, to foster the just, expeditious and inexpensive resolution of discovery disputes, pre- motion conferences shall be held to permit the Court the opportunity to resolve issues before motion practice ensues.
Important
Absent exigent circumstances, parties must be expected to confer in good faith in person or by telephone before requesting a pre-motion conference.
Moreover, absent exigent circumstances, the parties are expected to confer in good faith either in-person or by telephone prior to requesting a pre-motion conference (22 NYCRR §202.20- f).
Important
Opposing counsel may respond to a pre-motion conference request within 24 hours using no more than two pages, and the Court must address a properly submitted request within two business days after a complete submission.
Opposing counsel will be permitted within twenty-four hours to file a response to the request and are not to exceed two pages. Properly submitted requests for pre-motion conferences shall be addressed by the Court within two business days from a complete submission.
Important
A pre-motion conference request should be filed on NYSCEF, emailed to the assigned justice's chambers or a Court-Attorney Referee, and kept within two pages.
Requests for pre-motion conferences should be filed on NYSCEF and e-mailed to the Chambers of the assigned Justice or to a Court-Attorney Referee and are not to exceed two pages.
Important
A party may request a pre-motion conference by emailing the stated chambers address and providing notice to all other parties.
A party may request a pre-motion conference by e-mailing MedMalWestchester@nycourts.gov, on notice to all other parties.
Important
When required, the Court will hold a Temporary Restraining Order conference at a date and time set by the Court.
A conference on the request for a Temporary Restraining Order, if required, will be conducted by the Court at a date and time set by the Court.
Judge Alexandra D. MurphyPage 3, section II. MOTION PRACTICE RULES — D. Orders to Show Cause and Requests for Temporary ReliefImportant
Absent exigent circumstances, the parties are expected to confer in good faith either in-person or by telephone prior to requesting a pre- motion conference (22 NYCRR § 202.20-f).
Absent exigent circumstances, the parties are expected to confer in good faith either in-person or by telephone prior to requesting a pre- motion conference (22 NYCRR § 202.20-f).
Judge Charles D. WoodPage 4, section III. Motions, E. DiscoveryImportant
A discovery conference may be requested by submitting a one-page-or-shorter letter application to the Part Clerk by email and filing it in NYSCEF.
A discovery conference may be obtained by submitting a letter application, not exceeding one (1) page in length, to the Part Clerk, via email and efiling same in NYSCEF.
Judge David F. EverettPage 5, section D. Discovery Disputes for Cases Assigned to this PartImportant
No appearance is required on a motion’s return date unless the court directs one.
There will be no appearances on the return date of any motion unless this Court so directs.
Judge Diane M. ClerkinPage 10, section VI. MOTIONS GENERALLY — A. Return Dates and AppearancesImportant
When electronic discovery is reasonably likely, attorneys must confer on an e-discovery stipulation, and any unresolved issue will be addressed at the preliminary conference.
Where it is reasonably likely that a case will include electronic discovery, attorneys for the parties shall meet and confer to discuss and agree on a stipulation governing such electronic discovery. If the parties, after conferring, are unable to reach a stipulation, the Court will address same at the preliminary conference.
Judge Diane M. ClerkinPage 7, section II. GENERAL RULESImportant
When a dispositive motion filed with the RJI substitutes for a preliminary-conference request, the Court sets a control date for filing the conference stipulation.
In the event that a dispositive motion is filed and accompanies the RJI rather than a request for a preliminary conference, the Court will issue a control date for the submission of a preliminary conference ===== PAGE 8 ===== stipulation.
Judge Diane M. ClerkinPage 7, section II. GENERAL RULESImportant
Counsel must consult and make a good-faith effort to reach agreement before the preliminary conference.
Counsel shall consult regarding the matters to be addressed at the preliminary conference and shall make a good faith effort to reach agreement in advance of the conference
Judge Diane M. ClerkinPage 5, section V.C.2.b. Conferences in Tax Certiorari Proceedings — Preliminary ConferencesImportant
Unless the court orders otherwise in a particular case, motions are submitted without oral argument.
Absent a specific order to the contrary from this Court in a particular case, all motions shall be submitted without oral argument.
Judge Diane M. ClerkinPage 10, section VI. MOTIONS GENERALLY — A. Return Dates and AppearancesImportant
If good-faith discussions fail, a party may request a discovery pre-motion conference by emailing the Part Clerk and noticing all other parties.
If the parties’ good faith discussions fail to resolve the discovery dispute, the parties may request a pre-motion conference by emailing the Part Clerk on notice to all other parties.
Judge Diane M. ClerkinPage 9Important
When a protective order prohibits contact with the opposing party, the party must contact the Part Clerk about the discovery noncompliance instead of contacting the opposing party.
Exception: Where an Order of Protection prohibits one party from contacting another party, the party who believes that discovery is not being complied with shall contact the Part Clerk without contacting the opposing party.
Judge James L. HyerPage 8, section Court ConferencesImportant
Parties served with the pre-motion notification may serve and file a response through NYSCEF within one business day after service.
All parties so served may serve and file a letter response via NYSCEF within one (1) business day from service of the notification letter.
Judge Keri A. FiorePage 5, section VII. Motions — b. Pre-Motion ConferenceImportant
The Court schedules an in-person Preliminary Conference within 45 days after an RJI is filed, and the RJI-filing party must notify all other parties of the conference date in writing.
The Court will schedule an in-person Preliminary Conference within 45 days after a Request for Judicial Intervention (RJI) has been filed on a matter. The Part Clerk will forward to the party filing the RJI a letter or email setting forth the date on which the Preliminary Conference will be conducted. The party who files the RJI shall advise all other parties of the Preliminary Conference date in writing.
Judge Paul I. MarxPage 3, section D. Preliminary ConferenceImportant
A return-date appearance is not required unless the Court specifically states that one is to occur.
There will be no appearances unless specifically stated by the court.
Judge Robert S. OndrovicPage 6, section MOTIONSImportant
Unless the Court directs otherwise, motions are decided on written submission without an appearance.
Unless otherwise advised by the Court, all motions are by submission only.
Judge William J. GiacomoPage 4, section MOTION PRACTICE RULESImportant
When required, the Court will hold a Temporary Restraining Order conference at a date and time selected by the Court.
A conference on the request for a Temporary Restraining Order, if required, will be conducted by the Court at a date and time set by the Court.
Judge William J. GiacomoPage 4, section MOTION PRACTICE RULESNote
Cases assigned to the ECP bypass the DCM Preliminary Conference Part and proceed on an expedited track.
Assignment to the ECP shall bypass the DCM Preliminary Conference Part and proceed on an expedited track.
Court-level rulesOfficial source Page 3, section II. ENVIRONMENTAL CLAIMS PART ASSIGNMENT PROCEDURESNote
Motions are submitted without oral argument unless the IAS Justice enters a contrary order or the assigned Part Rules provide otherwise.
Absent a specific order to the contrary from the IAS Justice in a particular case or as otherwise provided in the assigned IAS Justice’s Part Rules, all motions will be submitted without oral argument.
Court-level rulesOfficial source Page 10, section E. Working Copies, Certification and Oral ArgumentNote
Counsel may make any motion they deem appropriate to best represent a party’s interests.
Counsel will not be precluded from making any motion deemed appropriate to best represent a party’s interests.
Note
A required conference on a temporary restraining order request will be scheduled by the court.
A conference on the request for a Temporary Restraining Order, if required, will be conducted at a date and time set by the court.
Judge Charles D. WoodPage 4, section III. Motions, D. Orders to Show Cause and Requests for Temporary ReliefNote
Preliminary conferences are held in person on Monday through Thursday mornings at 9:30 a.m.
Preliminary conferences are held in person at a general calendar call on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday and Thursday mornings at 9:30 a.m.
Judge Diane M. ClerkinPage 7, section II. GENERAL RULESNote
Counsel should attempt to resolve issues with opposing counsel before making a motion.
Prior to making any motion, Counsel should attempt to resolve issues with opposing counsel.
Judge Diane M. ClerkinPage 7, section VII. MotionsNote
A pre-motion conference is recommended, and counsel may request one to resolve disputed issues.
In an attempt to resolve disputed issues, the Court recommends and counsel may request a pre-motion conference.
Judge Diane M. ClerkinPage 7, section VII. MotionsNote
A pre-motion conference request is not required after filing a Note of Issue.
In accordance with MPOR Section V (A), a request for a pre-motion conference shall not be required after the filing of a Note of Issue.
Judge Keri A. FiorePage 5, section VII. Motions — b. Pre-Motion Conference