Court Rules
All enforcement actions
Enforcement ActionLow RiskMultistate

DOJ, States Sue Landlords for Algorithmic Rent-Fixing; Cortland Settles

Greystar Real Estate Partners LLC, Blackstone's LivCor LLC, Camden Property Trust, Cushman & Wakefield Inc, Pinnacle Property Management Services LLC, Willow Bridge Property Company LLC, Cortland Management LLCJanuary 7, 2025Connecticut Attorney General

Summary

The U.S. Department of Justice and ten states filed an amended complaint against six major landlords for using algorithmic pricing and sharing competitively sensitive information to suppress competition and raise rents. Cortland Management LLC agreed to a consent decree requiring it to cease these practices, cooperate with the investigation, and submit to court-monitored oversight. The landlords collectively manage over 1.3 million rental units across the United States.

Remedy

Cortland must cooperate with the government investigation, stop using competitors' competitively sensitive data to train or run pricing models, halt use of third-party pricing algorithms without a court-appointed monitor, and refrain from soliciting, disclosing, or using such information with other property managers for rent setting.

InjunctionConsent DecreeAudit Requirement

Contract Impact

In-house legal teams should review vendor agreements with property management firms and software providers (e.g., pricing algorithm vendors like RealPage), as well as any data-sharing or joint venture agreements between landlords. Focus on clauses governing data sharing, algorithmic pricing mechanisms, antitrust representations, audit rights, and termination for illegal practices. Given the consent decree with Cortland, contracts may need amendments to prohibit the use of shared pricing algorithms, require independent rent determination, include obligations to cooperate with government investigations, and establish monitoring/oversight provisions. Ensure contracts contain clear indemnification for antitrust violations and require certifications of compliance with competition laws.

Contract Search Terms

algorithmic pricing clauserent setting algorithmscompetitively sensitive information sharingprice coordination agreementantitrust compliance clausedata sharing agreementmarket allocationprice-fixingmonitoring obligationsconsent decree requirements

Laws Cited

Tunney Act

Violation Types

Entity Details

Entity

Greystar Real Estate Partners LLC, Blackstone's LivCor LLC, Camden Property Trust, Cushman & Wakefield Inc, Pinnacle Property Management Services LLC, Willow Bridge Property Company LLC, Cortland Management LLC

Also known as: Greystar, LivCor, Camden, Cushman & Wakefield, Pinnacle Property Management, Willow Bridge, Cortland

Industry

Real Estate

Multistate Coalition

U.S. Department of JusticeCaliforniaNorth CarolinaColoradoMinnesotaOregonTennesseeWashingtonIllinoisMassachusetts

Official Sources

Related Enforcement Actions

CT

SunRun, Inc.

$500K

Connecticut Attorney General William Tong announced settlements with SunRun, Inc., Elevate Solar Solutions, and two salespeople over allegations of deceptive solar sales, including impersonating consumers and locking homeowners into long-term contracts without consent. SunRun must pay $300,000 and provide consumer relief; Elevate and the salespeople face a stated $200,000 penalty, with $100,000 suspended subject to ongoing compliance.

CT

Mylan

$8.0M

Connecticut announced an $8 million settlement with Mylan over allegations that it used agreements to delay generic EpiPen competitors and took other actions that inflated prices. Mylan also agreed to provide 10,000 free EpiPens; the release states that Mylan denies wrongdoing.

CT

U.S. Department of Homeland Security

Connecticut Attorney General William Tong joined a coalition of 22 attorneys general in filing an amicus brief challenging DHS’s policy and practice of conducting warrantless civil immigration arrests. The press release describes a court challenge, not a privacy enforcement action or monetary penalty.

CT

Frontier Communications Parent Inc.

$625K

Connecticut reached a $625,000 settlement with Frontier Communications Parent Inc. over an April 2024 breach in which compromised employee and vendor credentials were used to access internal systems and exfiltrate unencrypted personal information of 58,841 Connecticut residents. The settlement requires Frontier to strengthen its security program, implement specific safeguards and training, and obtain an independent third-party assessment.

CT

Boston Children’s Health Physicians and XTIUM

$2.6M

Connecticut and New York found that Boston Children’s Health Physicians and its security vendor, XTIUM, failed to use reasonable safeguards, resulting in hackers accessing sensitive personal, medical, and employee information. The companies agreed to pay penalties totaling $2.64 million and implement enhanced cybersecurity measures.

CT

Character Technologies, Inc.

Connecticut joined a coalition of state attorneys general filing a notice in Character Technologies, Inc.’s bankruptcy proceedings, raising concerns about the company’s safety and privacy practices and the sensitive information it holds. The states seek protections for children and consumers if the company’s business or assets are sold or transferred; the filing does not impose a fine or other remedy.