Court Rules

Limits & Logistics

Document Limits

Joint Summary
2 pgs
Settlement Conference StatementCourt-wide
5 pgs
Trial BriefCourt-wide
5 pgs

Courtesy Copies

Ex Parte Papers

  • Before Noon Day Prior to Hearing

Joint Summary

  • No Later Than Friday Prior to Conference

Opposition, Reply

EEC Request

Court-wide
  • 1 copy

Communication

Phone

Clerk

(619) 450-7006
Scheduling
Hours: 8:00 a.m. to 3:00 p.m.
Phone
Court-wide
(619) 450-7478
Phone
Court-wide
Scheduling
Phone
Court-wide

Duty Judge

Emergencies
Filters:

Page & Word Limits1 rule

Page LimitsMandatory

The joint summary of disputed issues may not exceed two pages.

Joint summary
Up to 2 pages

Court's wording

The parties are required to file a joint summary of disputed issues, not exceeding two pages, and to have a courtesy copy delivered to the Department 72 mailbox (located inside the Civil Business Office) no later than the Friday prior to the conference.

Department 72 Policies and Procedures · Oct 2026 · p. 2
|SectionDiscovery Motions/Informal Discovery Conferences

Document Format Requirements9 rules

FormattingMandatory

Each exhibit must be marked with a discrete number and should be correctly identified. By way of example, it is impermissible to label "Dr. Jones' file" collectively as Exhibit 25.

FormattingMandatory

With respect to any party or witness who appears at trial via Microsoft Teams, no party or witness may testify by audio only, or by telephone, unless all parties stipulate that the testimony may be taken by audio only.

Department 72 Policies and Procedures · Oct 2026 · p. 3
|SectionGuidelines for Remote Appearances of Witnesses at Trials
FormattingMandatory

Each party shall arrange for the video appearance of any third-party witness appearing remotely it intends to call. Witnesses who have been properly subpoenaed shall cooperate with the parties in the making of these arrangements unless their appearance has been excused by the Court.

Department 72 Policies and Procedures · Oct 2026 · p. 3
|SectionGuidelines for Remote Appearances of Witnesses at Trials
FormattingMandatory

In addition, the following are due the day trial commences: 1. Two sets of exhibit binders (original for the witness, pre-marked with Court Exhibit tags, and one copy for the Court).

FormattingMandatory

Each party shall assure that the proceedings are not being recorded or reported in any manner other than by the duly-authorized court reporter.

Department 72 Policies and Procedures · Oct 2026 · p. 4
|SectionGuidelines for Remote Appearances of Witnesses at Trials
FormattingMandatory

Each party must ensure remote video feeds let the Court and opposing counsel clearly see and hear the witness and assess that the witness is not being coached or using unseen materials.

Court's wording

Each party shall ensure that their video feed and that of their witnesses appearing remotely is of sufficient quality and scope so that the Court and opposing counsel may see and hear the witness clearly, and be able to assure that no witness is susceptible to coaching or has the ability to rely on any materials out of sight of the Court and/or opposing counsel.

Department 72 Policies and Procedures · Oct 2026 · p. 4
|SectionGuidelines for Remote Appearances of Witnesses at Trials
FormattingMandatory

Parties and counsel shall assure that any non-party witness who will testify at trial will not see or hear any of the trial proceedings that occur before they testify, or that occur after they testify and before they are excused from providing further testimony.

Department 72 Policies and Procedures · Oct 2026 · p. 4
|SectionGuidelines for Remote Appearances of Witnesses at Trials
FormattingImportant

Absent good cause, parties are expected to personally appear at settlement conferences, trial readiness conferences, and trial calls.

FormattingNote

The Court recommends that each party and witness have more than one device available to them in the event that problems arise with the device they intend to use primarily.

Department 72 Policies and Procedures · Oct 2026 · p. 4
|SectionGuidelines for Remote Appearances of Witnesses at Trials

Document Filing Requirements12 rules

Filing RequirementsMandatory

The moving papers must be submitted for review by the Court, and the Court may set a hearing during ex parte hours if such hearing is deemed necessary.

Department 72 Policies and Procedures · Oct 2026 · p. 1
|SectionPetitions for Compromise of Claim
Filing RequirementsMandatory

The moving papers must be submitted for review by the Court,

Department 72 Policies and Procedures · Oct 2026 · p. 1
|SectionGuardian Ad Litem/Publication of Summons
Filing RequirementsMandatory

Guardian ad litem applications must use forms CIV-010, ADM-430, and CIV-011; obsolete forms will not be accepted.

Court's wording

Please note that the Guardian Ad Litem forms were updated as of January 1, 2024. The required forms as of January 2024 are CIV-010 (Application), ADM-430 (Attachment to Application), and CIV-011 (Order). See the court’s website to download the most current forms. Obsolete forms will not be accepted.

Department 72 Policies and Procedures · Oct 2026 · p. 1
|SectionGuardian Ad Litem/Publication of Summons
Filing RequirementsMandatory

Guardian Ad Litem applications will not be granted ex parte unless the moving party complies with Local Rule 2.4.6.

Department 72 Policies and Procedures · Oct 2026 · p. 1
|SectionGuardian Ad Litem/Publication of Summons
Filing RequirementsMandatory

The parties must file a joint summary of disputed issues for the informal discovery conference.

Court's wording

The parties are required to file a joint summary of disputed issues, not exceeding two pages, and to have a courtesy copy delivered to the Department 72 mailbox (located inside the Civil Business Office) no later than the Friday prior to the conference.

Department 72 Policies and Procedures · Oct 2026 · p. 2
|SectionDiscovery Motions/Informal Discovery Conferences
Filing RequirementsMandatory

Counsel must bring a Joint Trial Notebook to Friday Trial Call containing the listed trial materials and sections.

Document
Joint trial notebook

Must include

  • Exhibit list
  • Table of contents

Court's wording

The Court requires counsel to bring to the Friday Trial Call a Joint Trial Notebook comprised of the following: 1. Table of contents. 2. Copy of Joint Trial Readiness Report, and operative pleadings. 3. Copies of In Limine motions and oppositions, in order (motion followed by opposition). 4. Copy of Joint Witness List with a short sentence describing the witness (i.e., Dr. Steven Smith, an orthopedic surgeon from County Hospital). 5. Copy of Joint Exhibit List. The list must be carefully reviewed to ensure the description of the Exhibit matches the Exhibit. 6. Copies of Trial Briefs. 7. Joint Statement of the Case, in neutral form suitable to be read to prospective jurors. (Competing version not acceptable.) 8. Voir Dire questions counsel requests Court to ask (if any). 9. Jury Instructions - packet of agreed-upon instructions and packet of not agreed-upon instructions with post-it notes indicating who opposes the instruction.

Filing RequirementsMandatory

Applications must include proof of service on the State Bar of California, proof of payment of the required fee, and a proposed order.

Document
Pro hac vice application

Must include

  • Proposed order
  • Certificate of service
Filing RequirementsMandatory

In addition, the following are due the day trial commences: 4. Copies of Deposition Transcripts that will be used during trial. These are to be lodged by placing them on the shelf in front of the bench.

Filing RequirementsMandatory

In addition, the following are due the day trial commences: 3. Three copies of the Joint Exhibit List.

Filing RequirementsMandatory

In addition, the following are due the day trial commences: 2. Three copies of the Joint Witness List.

Filing RequirementsMandatory

Proposed stipulated protective orders for protection of confidential information will only be approved if the language in the proposed order is consistent with California Rules of Court, rules 2.550 and 2.551.

Department 72 Policies and Procedures · Oct 2026 · p. 3
|SectionStipulated Protective Orders / Motions to Seal
Filing RequirementsMandatory

Please provide a proposed order with any stipulation.

Document
Continuance stipulation

Include

  • Proposed order

Filing & Service rules

Electronic Filing Rules

Ex parte papers must be e-filed, except that e-filing is optional for self-represented parties.

Before noon on the day prior to the hearing, ex parte papers must be e-filed, and courtesy copies of the papers must be delivered to the Department 72 mailbox in the Civil Business Office. NOTE: E-filing is optional for self-represented parties.

Page 1 | Ex Parte

Filing Timing and Cure Windows

Before noon on the day prior to the hearing, ex parte papers must be e-filed, and courtesy copies of the papers must be delivered to the Department 72 mailbox in the Civil Business Office.

Before noon on the day prior to the hearing, ex parte papers must be e-filed, and courtesy copies of the papers must be delivered to the Department 72 mailbox in the Civil Business Office.

Page 1 | Ex Parte

An informal discovery conference does not toll the statutory deadline for filing a motion to compel.

An IDC does not toll the statutory deadline to file a motion to compel.

Page 2 | Discovery Motions/Informal Discovery Conferences

A party opposing a pro hac vice application may appear ex parte within five days of service to request a briefing schedule.

If a party opposes an application, that party may appear ex parte within five days of service to request a briefing schedule.

Page 2 | Pro Hac Vice

Service and Proof of Service Rules

A pro hac vice application must include proof that it was served on the State Bar of California.

Applications must include proof of service on the State Bar of California, proof of payment of the required fee, and a proposed order.

Page 2 | Pro Hac Vice

Materials a witness relies on during testimony must be provided to all counsel upon request.

Any and all materials that any witness relies on to refresh recollection or otherwise during the course of his or her testimony shall be provided to all counsel upon request.

Page 4 | Guidelines for Remote Appearances of Witnesses at Trials

Each party must send the Court and opposing counsel a hard copy of every pre-marked exhibit it intends to introduce by 3 p.m. on the court day before trial.

Each party shall send a hard copy of any pre-marked exhibit it intends to introduce to both the Court and opposing counsel no later than 3 p.m. on the court day preceding the scheduled trial date.

Page 4 | Guidelines for Remote Appearances of Witnesses at Trials

To the extent possible, each party must provide a remote witness with a hard copy of any exhibit the witness will view during testimony before the witness testifies.

Each party shall, to the extent possible, provide a hard copy of any exhibit it intends to have a witness appearing remotely view during that witness’s testimony to the witness in advance of the time the witness testifies. Advance planning is essential.

Page 4 | Guidelines for Remote Appearances of Witnesses at Trials

Filing Fees and Waivers

A pro hac vice application must include proof of payment of the required fee.

Applications must include proof of service on the State Bar of California, proof of payment of the required fee, and a proposed order.

Page 2 | Pro Hac Vice

Courtesy Copy Requirements

Before noon on the day prior to the hearing, ex parte papers must be e-filed, and courtesy copies of the papers must be delivered to the Department 72 mailbox in the Civil Business Office.

Before noon on the day prior to the hearing, ex parte papers must be e-filed, and courtesy copies of the papers must be delivered to the Department 72 mailbox in the Civil Business Office.

Page 1 | Ex Parte

A courtesy copy of the joint summary must be delivered to the Department 72 mailbox no later than the Friday before the conference.

The parties are required to file a joint summary of disputed issues, not exceeding two pages, and to have a courtesy copy delivered to the Department 72 mailbox (located inside the Civil Business Office) no later than the Friday prior to the conference.

Page 2 | Discovery Motions/Informal Discovery Conferences

Parties are encouraged to submit courtesy copies of time-sensitive filings such as oppositions and replies. Courtesy copies should be delivered to the Department 72 mailbox located inside the Civil Business Office.

Parties are encouraged to submit courtesy copies of time-sensitive filings such as oppositions and replies. Courtesy copies should be delivered to the Department 72 mailbox located inside the Civil Business Office.

Page 1 | Law and Motion

Sealing & Redaction Procedures

The parties' agreement or stipulation alone is not sufficient to seal records.

Records will not be sealed based solely on the agreement or stipulation of the parties.

Page 3 | Stipulated Protective Orders / Motions to Seal

When documents are conditionally lodged under seal in support of or opposition to a motion, the substantive motion will not be decided before the hearing on the motion or application to seal.

If documents have been lodged conditionally under seal in support of/opposition to a motion, the substantive motion will not be decided until after the hearing on the motion or application to seal.

Page 3 | Stipulated Protective Orders / Motions to Seal

Motions and applications to seal must comply with California Rules of Court, rules 2.550 and 2.551.

Motions and applications to seal must comply with rules 2.550 and 2.551.

Page 3 | Stipulated Protective Orders / Motions to Seal

Parties may apply ex parte for a hearing on a motion to seal before the pending substantive motion, or may instead seek to continue the substantive motion.

Parties may appear ex parte to request a hearing on a motion to seal in advance of a pending substantive motion, or alternatively to continue the substantive motion.

Page 3 | Stipulated Protective Orders / Motions to Seal

Pre-Motion Conference Requirements

The moving party must meet and confer with the opposing party to select a mutually agreeable date for the informal discovery conference.

The moving party is required to meet and confer with the opposing party to select a mutually agreeable date for the IDC.

Page 2 | Discovery Motions/Informal Discovery Conferences

An informal discovery conference is encouraged before filing any discovery motion.

Prior to filing any discovery motion(s), an informal discovery conference (IDC) is encouraged.

Page 1 | Discovery Motions/Informal Discovery Conferences

Adjournment & Extension Requirements

Trial continuances are disfavored and are available only under CRC 3.1332.

Trial continuances are disfavored, and only available under CRC 3.1332.

Page 2 | Trial Readiness Conferences

Disputed requests for continuances should be made by way of a noticed motion or an ex parte application. Please review CRC Rules 3.1200 through 3.1207 in connection with any ex parte application.

Disputed requests for continuances should be made by way of a noticed motion or an ex parte application. Please review CRC Rules 3.1200 through 3.1207 in connection with any ex parte application.

Page 3 | Continuances

Parties may request continuances of the listed dates and deadlines by written stipulation.

Stipulated requests to continue any applicable dates (trial, trial readiness, motion cut-off, case management conferences, status conferences) and deadlines may be made by written stipulation.

Page 3 | Continuances

The parties may stipulate to extend deadlines to facilitate resolution of a discovery dispute without a motion.

However, the parties may stipulate to extend deadlines to help facilitate a resolution of a discovery dispute without the need for a motion.

Page 2 | Discovery Motions/Informal Discovery Conferences

Chambers Communication Rules

Noticed motion hearings require a reservation, which may be made through the calendar clerk or online scheduling tool; the online tool may offer later dates.

Noticed motion hearings are by reservation only. To reserve a date, contact the calendar clerk at the number provided above or use the online scheduling tool. Note: the online scheduling tool tends to provide hearing dates further into the future than the calendar clerk can provide.

Page 1 | Law and Motion

Ex parte appearances are by reservation only; contact the calendar clerk to reserve a hearing.

Ex parte appearances are scheduled on Tuesdays and Thursdays at 8:30 am, by reservation only. To reserve an ex parte hearing, contact the calendar clerk at the number provided above.

Page 1 | Ex Parte

Default prove-ups are heard by reservation only. Contact the calendar clerk at the number provided above.

Default prove-ups are heard by reservation only. Contact the calendar clerk at the number provided above.

Page 1 | Default Prove-Up

To reserve a date, please contact the Court’s calendar clerk at the number provided above.

To reserve a date, please contact the Court’s calendar clerk at the number provided above.

Page 1 | Discovery Motions/Informal Discovery Conferences

The Calendar phone number is (619) 450-7006, and phone hours are 8:00 a.m. to 3:00 p.m.

Calendar: (619) 450-7006 - Phone hours: 8:00 a.m. to 3:00 p.m.

Page 1 | Phone Numbers

Parties may request oral argument at the hearing or notify the courtroom clerk beforehand of their intent to argue and the estimated argument time.

Parties may request oral argument at the time of the hearing, or may notify the courtroom clerk of their intent to argue and a time estimate for argument prior to the hearing.

Page 1 | Law and Motion

A party wishing to submit on the tentative ruling may notify the courtroom clerk by telephone before the hearing.

Parties who wish to submit on the Court’s tentative ruling may notify the courtroom clerk by telephone prior to the hearing.

Page 1 | Law and Motion

Court-wide rules

Applies court-wide

These 304 rules apply across San Diego Superior Court. Where this judge's own standing orders above address the same topic, the judge's requirement controls.

Filing Requirements

All 101
  • Applies to
    Request for court reporter

    A request for a court reporter by a party with a fee waiver should use the designated form.

  • Applies to
    Exhibit exception application

    Applications for specified exhibit exceptions must be made in writing to the Criminal Supervising Judge or designee, with notice to the exhibits custodian and all parties.

  • Applies to
    Exhibit record

    When an exhibit is ordered returned, the submitting party must provide the court with a complete photographic or electronic record of it.

Filing Timing

All 48
  • Unless otherwise specified, references to a day mean a calendar day.

  • Such a request should be made using the Request for Court Reporter by a Party with a Fee Waiver form (SDSC Form #ADM-379), available on the court’s website, www.sdcourt.ca.gov, and must be filed with the clerk at least 10 days before the proceeding. If the requesting party received less than 10 days' notice of the hearing or trial, the requesting party must file the request as soon as practicable.

  • A party seeking to be heard about a transfer ordered without a hearing or outside a hearing must request a hearing within 10 days after notice of transfer.

Service

All 46
  • The exhibits custodian and all parties must receive notice of applications for the specified exhibit exceptions.

  • If further proceedings require a civil-case exhibit, the party that introduced it must promptly deliver it to the court and notify all parties.

  • The judgment creditor receives conformed copies showing the appearance date, time, and place for service.

Communication

All 28
  • Court users are asked to request interpreters as far in advance as possible.

  • Requests for disability accommodations should be made as far in advance as possible and pursuant to California Rules of Court, rule 1.100.

  • Court users are asked to advise the court as soon as possible when an interpreter is no longer needed.

About Judge Marcella O. McLaughlin

Judge Marcella O. McLaughlin is a judge on the Superior Court of California, County of San Diego, presiding in Department 72. The court is the state trial court serving San Diego County.

Practitioners will find the policies and procedures for Department 72 in the judge's published document, 'Department_72_Policies_and_Procedures.pdf'.

Common questions about Judge Marcella O. McLaughlin's rules

Are courtesy copies required for Judge Marcella O. McLaughlin?

Courtesy-copy rule applies for ex parte papers. Details: delivery before noon day prior to hearing. Before noon on the day prior to the hearing, ex parte papers must be e-filed, and courtesy copies of the papers must be delivered to the Department 72 mailbox in the Civil Business Office.

View ruleSource: page 1, section Ex Parte

Does Judge Marcella O. McLaughlin require a pre-motion conference or letter before filing a motion?

The moving party must meet and confer with the opposing party to select a mutually agreeable date for the informal discovery conference.

View ruleSource: page 2, section Discovery Motions/Informal Discovery Conferences

What page or word limits apply to joint summary before Judge Marcella O. McLaughlin?

Judge Marcella O. McLaughlin's rule states these limits: 2 pages. The joint summary of disputed issues may not exceed two pages.

View ruleSource: page 2, section Discovery Motions/Informal Discovery Conferences

What formatting rules apply to filings before Judge Marcella O. McLaughlin?

Judge Marcella O. McLaughlin's formatting rule includes mark each exhibit with a discrete number and identify it correctly; do not label a collection of materials collectively as one exhibit.. Each exhibit must have a discrete number and be correctly identified; collectively labeling a file as one exhibit is impermissible.

View ruleSource: page 3, section Trial Requirements

What must be included with guardian ad litem or publication of summons application filings before Judge Marcella O. McLaughlin?

Moving papers for guardian ad litem and publication-of-summons applications must be submitted for court review.

View ruleSource: page 1, section Guardian Ad Litem/Publication of Summons

What must be included with guardian ad litem application filings before Judge Marcella O. McLaughlin?

A guardian ad litem application will not be granted ex parte unless the moving party complies with Local Rule 2.4.6.

View ruleSource: page 1, section Guardian Ad Litem/Publication of Summons

How may parties contact Judge Marcella O. McLaughlin's chambers?

Ex parte appearances are by reservation only; contact the calendar clerk to reserve a hearing.

View ruleSource: page 1, section Ex Parte

How does Judge Marcella O. McLaughlin handle sealed or redacted filings?

Motions and applications to seal must comply with California Rules of Court, rules 2.550 and 2.551.

View ruleSource: page 3, section Stipulated Protective Orders / Motions to Seal

How do I request an adjournment or extension before Judge Marcella O. McLaughlin?

Trial continuances are disfavored and are available only under CRC 3.1332.

View ruleSource: page 2, section Trial Readiness Conferences

Is electronic filing required before Judge Marcella O. McLaughlin?

Yes. Electronic filing is required for the covered filings. Ex parte papers must be e-filed, except that e-filing is optional for self-represented parties.

View ruleSource: page 1, section Ex Parte

Are filing fees or waivers addressed before Judge Marcella O. McLaughlin?

A fee is required for covered filings. A pro hac vice application must include proof of payment of the required fee.

View ruleSource: page 2, section Pro Hac Vice

When is a filing treated as filed before Judge Marcella O. McLaughlin?

The rule states a noon filing cutoff. Before noon on the day prior to the hearing, ex parte papers must be e-filed, and courtesy copies of the papers must be delivered to the Department 72 mailbox in the Civil Business Office.

View ruleSource: page 1, section Ex Parte

What rule applies to serving agency before Judge Marcella O. McLaughlin?

Proof of service is required for the covered service rule. Details: recipient: agency. A pro hac vice application must include proof that it was served on the State Bar of California.

View ruleSource: page 2, section Pro Hac Vice
Complete rules summary for Judge Marcella O. McLaughlin

The Calendar phone number is (619) 450-7006, and phone hours are 8:00 a.m. to 3:00 p.m.

Ex parte appearances are by reservation only; contact the calendar clerk to reserve a hearing.

Ex parte papers must be e-filed, except that e-filing is optional for self-represented parties.

Before noon on the day prior to the hearing, ex parte papers must be e-filed, and courtesy copies of the papers must be delivered to the Department 72 mailbox in the Civil Business Office.

Before noon on the day prior to the hearing, ex parte papers must be e-filed, and courtesy copies of the papers must be delivered to the Department 72 mailbox in the Civil Business Office.

Moving papers for guardian ad litem and publication-of-summons applications must be submitted for court review.

A guardian ad litem application will not be granted ex parte unless the moving party complies with Local Rule 2.4.6.

Guardian ad litem applications must use forms CIV-010, ADM-430, and CIV-011; obsolete forms will not be accepted.

Petition-for-compromise moving papers must be submitted for court review; the Court may set a hearing during ex parte hours if it deems one necessary.

Default prove-ups are heard by reservation only. Contact the calendar clerk at the number provided above.

Noticed motion hearings require a reservation, which may be made through the calendar clerk or online scheduling tool; the online tool may offer later dates.

Parties are encouraged to submit courtesy copies of time-sensitive filings such as oppositions and replies. Courtesy copies should be delivered to the Department 72 mailbox located inside the Civil Business Office.

A party wishing to submit on the tentative ruling may notify the courtroom clerk by telephone before the hearing.

Parties may request oral argument at the hearing or notify the courtroom clerk beforehand of their intent to argue and the estimated argument time.

An informal discovery conference is encouraged before filing any discovery motion.

To reserve a date, please contact the Court’s calendar clerk at the number provided above.

The moving party must meet and confer with the opposing party to select a mutually agreeable date for the informal discovery conference.

The parties must file a joint summary of disputed issues for the informal discovery conference.

The joint summary of disputed issues may not exceed two pages.

A courtesy copy of the joint summary must be delivered to the Department 72 mailbox no later than the Friday before the conference.

An informal discovery conference does not toll the statutory deadline for filing a motion to compel.

The parties may stipulate to extend deadlines to facilitate resolution of a discovery dispute without a motion.

A pro hac vice application must include proof of service on the State Bar of California, proof of payment of the required fee, and a proposed order.

A pro hac vice application must include proof that it was served on the State Bar of California.

A pro hac vice application must include proof of payment of the required fee.

A party opposing a pro hac vice application may appear ex parte within five days of service to request a briefing schedule.

Trial continuances are disfavored and are available only under CRC 3.1332.

Counsel must bring a Joint Trial Notebook to Friday Trial Call containing the listed trial materials and sections.

Two sets of exhibit binders are due the day trial begins: an original for the witness, pre-marked with Court Exhibit tags, and a copy for the Court.

Each exhibit must have a discrete number and be correctly identified; collectively labeling a file as one exhibit is impermissible.

More Judges in San Diego Superior Court

Adam Wertheimer
Judge
Blaine K. Bowman
Judge
Carolyn M. Caietti
Judge
Christopher S. Morris
Judge
Cynthia A. Freeland
Judge
Daniel S. Belsky
Judge
Daniel Segura
Judge
Euketa Oliver
Judge