Court Rules

Ninth Judicial Circuit of Florida, Orange and Osceola Counties Courtesy Copy Requirements

172 rules from official source documents

Rules 1 to 50, page 1 of 4

When and how to deliver courtesy copies to chambers, including triggers, timing, and formatting.

CRITICALCivil cases

Counsel must provide courtesy copies of all materials intended for reliance at a hearing to the court and opposing counsel at least three court days before the hearing.

Counsel is required to provide the court (and opposing counsel) with courtesy copies of any memoranda, case law or any other materials on which counsel may rely at a scheduled hearing at least three (3) court days before the scheduled hearing.

Court-level rulesOfficial source

CRITICALCivil cases

Counsel must provide the court and opposing counsel courtesy copies of materials relied upon at a scheduled hearing at least five court days before the hearing.

Counsel is required to provide the court (and opposing counsel) \ /ith courtesy copies of any memoranda, case law or any other materials on which counsel may rely at a scheduled hearing at least five (5) court days before the scheduled hearing.

Court-level rulesOfficial source

CRITICAL

Defense counsel must email a courtesy copy of a speedy-trial demand or notice of expiration immediately upon filing it to 15orange@ninthcircuit.org.

Defense counsel shall send a courtesy copy of a demand for speedy trial or notice of expiration of the time for speedy trial to 15orange@ninthcircuit.org immediately upon filing the notice or demand.

Judge A. James Craner

CRITICAL

A courtesy copy of a motion for rehearing or reconsideration must be provided to chambers or the judicial assistant.

• Motions for Re-hearing/Reconsideration: The Court has no way of knowing of the filing of a Motion for Re-hearing or Reconsideration without a courtesy copy to chambers or the JA.

Judge Alicia Peyton Robinson

CRITICAL

At least three business days before the hearing, the moving party must provide the Judicial Assistant with PDF courtesy copies of the notice of hearing, motion, and proposed order.

At least three (3) business days prior to the hearing, the moving party must provide the Judicial Assistant with a .pdf copy of the Notice of Hearing, Motion and a proposed order.

Judge Alicia Peyton Robinson

CRITICAL

Courtesy copies should be submitted to the court no later than three (3) days before any hearing or trial.

Courtesy copies should be submitted to the court no later than three (3) days before any hearing or trial.

Judge Alicia Peyton Robinson

CRITICAL

Courtesy copies should be submitted to the court by e-mail to 29orange@ninthcircuit.org.

Courtesy copies should be submitted to the court by e-mail to 29orange@ninthcircuit.org.

Judge Alicia Peyton Robinson

CRITICAL

Courtesy copies of pleadings, motions, and case law must be submitted before a hearing or trial.

Submit courtesy copies of pleadings, motions, and case law to the Court before any hearing or trial.

Judge Alison Kerestes

CRITICAL

Courtesy copies of case law and other specified documents must be submitted for every evidentiary proceeding.

Courtesy copies of case law or other specified document must be submitted to the court for any evidentiary proceeding.

Judge Andrew A. Bain

CRITICAL

Courtesy copies of case law and other specified documents must reach the Court no later than 72 hours before the evidentiary proceeding.

Courtesy copies must be delivered to the court no later than 72 hours before any evidentiary proceeding.

Judge Andrew A. Bain

CRITICAL

A copy of the motion-in-limine hearing notice must be emailed to chambers at 24osceola@ninthcircuit.org.

A copy of the hearing notice must be provided to chambers by email to 24osceola@ninthcircuit.org.

Judge Andrew A. Bain

CRITICAL

When applicable law requires a jury trial on damages, a trial notice must be filed, a courtesy copy must be emailed to chambers, and the case will be placed on the jury trial docket.

If applicable law requires a jury trial on damages, a notice for trial must be filed and provide a courtesy copy to chambers via the division email. The case will be placed on a jury trial docket.

Judge Andrew A. Bain

CRITICAL

When applicable law requires a non-jury trial or final evidentiary hearing on damages, the party seeking judgment must file a trial notice and provide chambers a courtesy copy by division email.

If applicable law requires a non-jury trial or final evidentiary hearing on damages, the party seeking entry of judgment shall file a notice for trial and provide a courtesy copy to chambers via the division email, and:

Judge Andrew A. Bain

CRITICAL

For short matters, counsel must submit proposed orders to the division email before the hearing and send a courtesy copy of the Notice of Hearing to the court.

Counsel shall proposed Orders submit to the division email prior to the hearing. Must send a courtesy copy of the Notice of Hearing to the court.

Judge Andrew A. Bain

CRITICAL

The moving party must send a courtesy copy of the Notice of Hearing to the court for a virtual ex parte hearing.

These hearings will be conducted virtually on Webex. The moving party MUST send a courtesy copy of the Notice of Hearing to the court.

Judge Andrew A. Bain

CRITICALCivil cases

Parties must send the judicial assistant one courtesy copy of the notice of hearing upon filing it.

Upon filing the NOH, the Parties are required to send a courtesy copy of the filed NOH to the Court’s JA.

Judge Brian S. Sandor

CRITICAL

Copies of the motion, Notice of Hearing with virtual link, and proposed order must reach the Court at least 48 business hours before an ex parte or short-matter hearing.

A courtesy copy of the motion, notice of hearing (with the virtual link), and proposed order (with addressed, stamped envelopes for non-e-filing parties) must be provided to the Court at least 48 Business hours prior to the hearing.

Judge Brian S. Sandor

CRITICAL

Courtesy copies are mandatory for ex parte and short-matter hearings.

Courtesy copes must be provided for ex parte and short matters.

Judge Brian S. Sandor

CRITICAL

For materials exceeding 50 pages, one courtesy copy of the Notice of Hearing, motions, supporting memoranda, and/or case law must be sent to the Judicial Assistant by email through an online sharing platform at least three business days before the hearing.

In addition to filing the Notice of Hearing with the Clerk of Court, pursuant to Admin. Order 2012-03 ¶7, a copy of the Notice of Hearing, Motion(s), supporting memoranda and/or case law to be heard must be furnished by Dropbox, Google Drive, OneDrive, or similar online sharing platforms, if over 50 pages, to the Judicial Assistant via email at 48orange@ninthcircuit.org at least three (3) business days prior to the hearing to ensure an opportunity for the Court to review.

Judge Brian S. Sandor

CRITICAL

If any party is not using e-filing, the Court must receive the hearing packet with copies and envelopes at least three business days before the hearing.

If all parties are not on e-filing, the hearing packet must be received by the Court with copes and envelopes at least 3 business days prior to the hearing.

Judge Brian S. Sandor

CRITICALCivil cases

Parties must deliver copies of oral-argument materials to the court at least five business days before the hearing.

Parties shall deliver copies of materials to the court in preparation for oral argument at least five (5) business days prior to a hearing.

Judge Chad K. Alvaro

CRITICAL

When applicable law requires a non-jury trial or final damages hearing, the party seeking judgment must file a notice for trial and provide chambers a courtesy copy by division email.

If applicable law requires a non-jury trial or final evidentiary hearing on damages, the party seeking entry of judgment shall file a notice for trial and provide a courtesy copy to chambers via the division email

Judge Christine E. Arendas

CRITICAL

When applicable law requires a jury trial on damages, a notice for trial must be filed with a courtesy copy sent to chambers by division email.

If applicable law requires a jury trial on damages, a notice for trial must be filed and provide a courtesy copy to chambers via the division email. The case will be placed on a jury trial docket.

Judge Christine E. Arendas

CRITICAL

A trial brief must be submitted to chambers no later than five business days before trial begins.

If a trial brief is to be filed with the Court, it must be submitted to chambers no later than five (5) business days before the trial is scheduled to commence.

Judge Christine E. Arendas

CRITICAL

Email copies of motions, the notice of hearing, and hearing materials to the division email at least three business days before the hearing.

Copies of motions to be heard, along with the notice of hearing and any hearing materials, must be emailed to division20b@ocnjcc.org at least three (3) business days before the hearing.

Judge Christine E. Arendas

CRITICAL

Hearing materials, including hard copies, must reach chambers at least five business days before the hearing; in most instances, legal memoranda should not exceed 10 double-spaced pages.

Hearing materials must be submitted to chambers at least five (5) business days before the hearing. Note: In most instances legal memoranda should not exceed 10 double- spaced pages. Hard copies are required.

Judge Christine E. Arendas

CRITICAL

A copy of a motion-in-limine hearing notice must be emailed to chambers at division20b@ocnjcc.org.

A copy of the hearing notice must be provided to chambers by email to division20b@ocnjcc.org

Judge Christine E. Arendas

CRITICAL

A copy of every motion for rehearing, reconsideration, or new trial must be emailed to division20b@ocnjcc.org when the motion is filed.

A copy of all motions for rehearing, reconsideration, or new trial must be delivered to division20b@ocnjcc.org at the time of filing for review by the Court.

Judge Christine E. Arendas

CRITICAL

When the relevant documents exceed 10 pages, provide hard copies to chambers instead of emailing them.

If the documents exceed 10 pages, hard copies must be provided to chambers rather than through email.

Judge Christine E. Arendas

CRITICAL

Hearing materials must also be furnished to Chambers at least five business days before the hearing.

In addition to filing the notice of hearing with the Clerk of Court, hearing materials must be furnished to Chambers at least five (5) business days before the hearing.

Judge Christine E. Arendas

CRITICAL

Although supporting and opposing legal memoranda are optional, counsel filing one must provide chambers copies of the memorandum and cited legal authorities.

Legal memoranda in support of, or in opposition to, motions are optional. If filed, counsel must furnish the Judge with chambers copies of the memorandum and copies of any legal authorities cited therein.

Judge Christy C. Collins

CRITICAL

A motion for rehearing, reconsideration, or new trial is not set for hearing unless directed by the Judge, and counsel must simultaneously provide the Judge a chambers copy and a cover letter requesting a hearing if desired.

Motions for rehearing, reconsideration or new trial will not be set for hearing unless the Judge so directs. Counsel filing such a motions shall simultaneously provide a chambers copy directly to the Judge with a cover letter requesting a hearing, if one is desired.

Judge Christy C. Collins

CRITICALCivil cases

Trial briefs are optional, but any submitted trial briefs must be provided as hard copies to Chambers at least five working days before trial.

Trial Briefs: Not required, but if you choose to submit them, please provide hard copies to Chambers (6215) at least five (5) working days prior to trial to allow adequate time for review

Judge Christy C. Collins

CRITICAL

A courtesy copy of case law must be submitted to the court for every evidentiary proceeding.

Courtesy copies of case law must be submitted to the court for any evidentiary proceeding.

Judge Christy C. Collins

CRITICAL

Attorneys and self-represented litigants must provide sufficient copies of each exhibit for the clerk, court, and every party to review during the hearing or trial.

All attorneys and self-represented litigants must bring sufficient copies of each exhibit for the clerk, the court, and each party to review during the hearing or trial.

Judge Christy C. Collins

CRITICAL

Motion papers and supporting memoranda or case law to be heard must reach chambers by email or hard copy at least three business days before the hearing, with the same information copied to opposing counsel.

Motion(s), supporting memoranda and/or case law to be heard must be received, by email or hard copy to chambers at least THREE (3) business days prior to the hearing to ensure an opportunity for the Court to review. Copy opposing counsel with the same information provided to the Court.

Judge Denise Kim Beamer

CRITICAL

For ex parte and short matters, one courtesy copy of the motion, notice of hearing with virtual link, and proposed order must reach the Court at least three business days before the hearing.

A courtesy copy of the motion, notice of hearing (with the virtual link/info), and proposed order (with addressed, stamped envelopes for non-e-filing parties) must be provided to the Court at least 3 business Courtesy days before the hearing.

Judge Denise Kim Beamer

CRITICAL

A copy of a motion for rehearing, reconsideration, or a new trial or final hearing must be sent directly to chambers upon filing.

A. Upon filing said Motion, you must send a copy directly to chambers for review as the Clerk does not provide them to the Court.

Judge Denise Kim Beamer

CRITICAL

Two hard copies of the exhibits and filed objections must be brought to court, one for the judge and one for the clerk.

b. Bring 2 hard copies of the exhibits and the filed objections (one for the Judge and one for the Clerk) to the Court for use at the hearing.

Judge Denise Kim Beamer

CRITICAL

When the Court directs a written response to a motion, the responding party must email a courtesy copy to 37Orange@ninthcircuit.org, preferably as a reply to the original motion submission.

When the Court directs that a written response to a motion be filed, the party filing the response must email a courtesy copy of the response to 37Orange@ninthcircuit.org, preferably as a reply email to the original submission of the motion.

Judge Diego M. Madrigal III

CRITICAL

Trial briefs are optional, but if filed, the original and a chambers copy must be provided to the judge no later than five business days before trial begins.

Trial briefs are optional; but if one is to be filed, the original should be filed and chamber’s copy provided and received by the judge not later than five (5) business days before the beginning of trial.

Judge Elaine A. Barbour

CRITICAL

Attorneys and self-represented litigants must bring sufficient copies of every exhibit for the clerk, court, and each party.

All attorneys and self-represented litigants must bring sufficient copies of each exhibit for the clerk, the court, and each party to review during the hearing or trial.

Judge Elaine A. Barbour

CRITICAL

Defense counsel must email a courtesy copy of a speedy-trial demand or notice of expiration immediately upon filing.

Defense counsel shall send a courtesy copy of a demand for speedy trial or notice of expiration of the time for speedy trial to bvelez@ninthcircuit.org immediately upon filing the notice or demand.

Judge Gisela T. Laurent

CRITICAL

Email the Judicial Assistant a courtesy copy of the motion, notice of hearing with the video link, and proposed order at least seven business days before an Ex Parte/Short Matter hearing.

A Courtesy copy of the motion, notice of hearing with the video link, and proposed order must be provided to the Judicial Assistant, via email, at least seven (7) business days before the hearing. Failure to do so may result in the hearing not being held.

Judge Greg A. Tynan

CRITICALCriminal cases

After hearing time is secured, the moving party must file the original Notice of Hearing with the Clerk and provide the Judge one courtesy copy.

It is then your responsibility to file an original Notice of Hearing with the Clerk's Office (physically or by e-file). A courtesy copy of the Notice of Hearing is required for the Judge.

Judge Hal C. Epperson Jr.

CRITICALCriminal cases

Attorneys seeking a virtual pretrial appearance must file a motion and email the Judicial Assistant one courtesy copy of the motion and proposed order by 3:00 p.m. the day before pretrial.

Attorneys must file a motion to appear virtually for pretrial and email a courtesy copy of the motion and proposed order to appear virtually to the Judicial Assistant by 3:00 p.m. the day prior to Pre-trial.

Judge Hal C. Epperson Jr.

CRITICAL

A party filing a pleading or correspondence must forward a copy to the Court and every other interested party.

The Court is not notified if an interested party files a pleading or correspondence in the Court file unless a copy of that item is forwarded to us and to all other interested parties by the filer.

Judge Heather L. Higbee

CRITICAL

At least seven business days before an ex parte or short-matter hearing, counsel must obtain Judicial Assistant confirmation and email the motion, notice of hearing with video link, and proposed order.

Ex Parte/Short matter hearings must be confirmed by the Judicial Assistant. A Courtesy copy of the motion, notice of hearing with the video link, and proposed order must be provided to the Judicial Assistant, via email, at least seven (7) business days before the hearing.

Judge Heather L. Higbee

CRITICAL

Case law and other non-exhibit documents submitted for the Court's review must be emailed separately to the Court and opposing party at least three business days before the hearing or trial.

(1) All case law and other non-exhibit documents that a party wishes the Court to review must be provided to the Court and the opposing party by email at least three business days prior to the hearing or trial. Each case or document should be provided as a separate file.

Judge Holly Derenthal

CRITICAL

Copies of all exhibits must be emailed to the Judicial Assistant at 47Orange@ninthcircuit.org at least three business days before the hearing or trial.

Parties must email 47Orange@ninthcircuit.org copies of all exhibits to the Judicial Assistant at least three business days prior to the hearing or trial.

Judge Holly Derenthal
Common questions about Ninth Judicial Circuit of Florida, Orange and Osceola Counties courtesy copy requirements

Are courtesy copies required in Ninth Judicial Circuit of Florida, Orange and Osceola Counties?

Ninth Judicial Circuit of Florida, Orange and Osceola Counties: Courtesy-copy rule applies for memorandas, case laws, and other hearing materials. Details: delivery before hearing. Counsel must provide courtesy copies of all materials intended for reliance at a hearing to the court and opposing counsel at least three court days before the hearing.

View ruleOfficial source Source: page 3, section 5. Courtesy copies of materials for hearings

Judge Alicia Peyton Robinson: Courtesy-copy rule applies for reconsideration. A courtesy copy of a motion for rehearing or reconsideration must be provided to chambers or the judicial assistant.

View ruleOfficial source Source: page 11, section K. Other Division Procedures

Judge A. James Craner: Courtesy-copy rule applies for speedy trial demands and notice of expirations. Details: delivery immediately upon filing, by email. Defense counsel must email a courtesy copy of a speedy-trial demand or notice of expiration immediately upon filing it to 15orange@ninthcircuit.org.

View ruleOfficial source Source: page 7, section B. PRETRIAL CONFERENCES AND CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCES

169 more rules answer this question.