Court Rules

Ninth Judicial Circuit of Florida, Orange and Osceola Counties Courtesy Copy Requirements

172 rules from official source documents

Rules 101 to 150, page 3 of 4

When and how to deliver courtesy copies to chambers, including triggers, timing, and formatting.

CRITICALCivil cases

The cover letter, motions, supporting memoranda, and/or case law to be heard must reach chambers by email and hard copy at least five (5) business days before the hearing.

Cover letter, Motion(s), supporting memoranda and/or case law to be heard must be received, by email AND hard copy to chambers at least five (5) business days prior to the hearing to ensure an opportunity for the Court to review.

Judge Tanya Davis Wilson

CRITICALCivil cases

Trial briefs are not required for jury trials, but for non-jury trials hard copies must reach chambers and an electronic Word copy must be emailed or provided on a flash drive at least three business days before trial.

10. TRIAL BRIEFS: If jury trial, not required. If non-jury trial, hard copies must be delivered to Judge’s Chambers as well as a copy emailed in Word to Chambers, or in the alternative, provided on a flash drive at least three (3) business days before trial.

Judge Tanya Davis Wilson

CRITICAL

One hard copy of the Joint Pretrial Statement must be delivered to chambers no later than three business days before the Pretrial Conference.

Joint Pretrial Statement: Signed by attorneys/pro se parties and filed and a hard copy delivered to chambers no later than 3 business days prior to Pretrial Conference. (§6b)

Judge Tanya Davis Wilson

CRITICALCivil cases

For ex parte and short matters, courtesy copies of the notice of hearing and motion must be emailed to the judicial assistant at least three business days before the hearing after checking the AI calendar; late copies may result in cancellation of the hearing.

A courtesy copy of the notice of hearing and motion must be provided to the Court at least 3 business days before the hearing. Please check AI Courtesy calendar before emailing the JA to make sure the date is not full. Copies Any copies delivered after this deadline may not be reviewed and may cause the hearing to be canceled. Courtesy copies must be provided for ex parte and short matters.

Judge Tanya Davis Wilson

CRITICAL

If counsel files a legal memorandum in support of or opposition to a motion, counsel must provide the Judge with chambers copies of the memorandum and its cited legal authorities.

If filed, counsel must furnish the Judge with chambers copies of the memorandum and copies of any legal authorities cited therein.

Judge Tanya Davis Wilson

CRITICALCivil cases

Failure to provide both email and hard-copy courtesy copies to chambers at least five business days before the hearing may result in cancellation of the hearing.

Failure to provide courtesy copies by email AND hard copy to chambers at least five (5) business days prior to the hearing may result in the hearing being cancelled.

Judge Tanya Davis Wilson

CRITICAL

Chambers copies and authority lists must be accompanied by a cover letter identifying the case style and number and hearing date and time, affirmatively showing service on opposing counsel, and delivered to the Judge at least five business days before the hearing.

Chambers copies and authority lists must be under cover letter referencing the case style and number and stating the date and time of the hearing, show affirmatively that a copy has been sent to opposing counsel and shall be delivered to the Judge at least five (5) business days before the hearing.

Judge Tanya Davis Wilson

CRITICALCivil cases

Counsel must provide courtesy copies of materials relied on at a scheduled hearing to the court and opposing counsel at least five court days before the hearing.

Counsel is required to provide the court (and opposing counsel) \ /ith courtesy copies of any memoranda, case law or any other materials on which counsel may rely at a scheduled hearing at least five (5) court days before the scheduled hearing.

Judge Tanya Davis Wilson

CRITICALCivil cases

A copy of a motion for rehearing, reconsideration, or new trial must be sent directly to chambers when the motion is filed.

Upon filing said Motion, you must send a copy directly to chambers for review as the Clerk does not provide them to the Court.

Judge Tanya Davis Wilson

CRITICAL

A motion for rehearing, reconsideration, or new trial must be accompanied by a simultaneous chambers copy sent directly to the Judge with a cover letter requesting a hearing if desired.

Counsel filing such a motions shall simultaneously provide a chambers copy directly to the Judge with a cover letter requesting a hearing, if one is desired.

Judge Tanya Davis Wilson

CRITICAL

One hard copy of the trial brief must be delivered to chambers three business days before trial.

A hard copy must be delivered to chambers 3 business days prior to Trial.

Judge Tanya Davis Wilson

CRITICAL

Defense counsel must email a courtesy copy to 10orange@ninthcircuit.org immediately upon filing a speedy-trial demand or notice of expiration.

Defense counsel shall send a courtesy copy of a demand for speedy trial or notice of expiration of the time for speedy trial to 10orange@ninthcircuit.org immediately upon filing the notice or demand.

Judge Vincent Falcone III

CRITICAL

Defense counsel must email a courtesy copy of a speedy-trial demand or notice of expiration immediately upon filing.

Defense counsel shall send a courtesy copy of a demand for speedy trial or notice of expiration of the time for speedy trial to 11orange@ninthcircuit.org immediately upon filing the notice or demand.

Judge Vincent S. Chiu

CRITICALCriminal cases

Email courtesy copies of the motion to appear virtually and the proposed order to the Judicial Assistant by 3:00 p.m. the day before pretrial.

Attorneys must file a motion to appear virtually for pretrial and email a courtesy copy of the motion and proposed order to appear virtually to the Judicial Assistant by 3:00 p.m. the day prior to Pre-trial.

Judge Wayne C. Wooten

CRITICALCriminal cases

A courtesy copy of the Notice of Hearing must be provided to the judge.

A courtesy copy of the Notice of Hearing is required for the Judge.

Judge Wayne C. Wooten

WARNING

Relied-upon case law and equitable distribution worksheets should be provided to the court no later than three days before the hearing or trial.

When Required: Case Law and Equitable Distribution Worksheets being relied on should be provided to the Court no later than three (3) days before the hearing or trial.

Judge Alicia Peyton Robinson

WARNING

Attorneys and self-represented litigants must bring enough copies of each exhibit for the clerk, the court, and every party.

All attorneys and self-represented litigants must bring sufficient copies of each exhibit for the clerk, the court, and each party to review during the hearing or trial.

Judge Alicia Peyton Robinson

WARNING

Courtesy copies should be submitted to the court no later than three days before a hearing or trial.

Submission Deadlines: Courtesy copies should be submitted to the court no later than three (3) days before any hearing or trial.

Judge Alicia Peyton Robinson

WARNING

A motion filed within two court days of its hearing should be accompanied by a courtesy copy emailed or hand-delivered to the court.

If the pleading is filed within 2 Court days of the scheduled hearing, a copy of Motion should be emailed or hand delivered to the Court.

Judge Andrew A. Bain

WARNING

Trial briefs are optional, but any submitted trial brief should be provided as a hard copy to Chambers at least five working days before trial.

11. Trial Briefs: Not required, but if you choose to submit them, please provide hard copies to Chambers (6460) at least five (5) working days prior to trial to allow adequate time for review

Judge Andrew A. Bain

WARNING

A proposed order should include a courtesy copy of the applicable motion and any supporting documents or affidavits not already docketed with the Clerk.

In submitting Proposed Orders, please attach a courtesy copy of the motion, if applicable, and any required supporting documentation or affidavits if NOT docketed with the Clerk.

Judge Andrew A. Bain

WARNING

Courtesy copies of case law and other specified documents may be submitted by email or on a USB flash drive.

Submission Method: E-mail, or USB flash drive.

Judge Andrew A. Bain

WARNING

A courtesy copy of the Joint Pretrial Statement must be sent to the division email when the statement is filed.

Parties must confer on and fill out the Pretrial Conference Checklist the email it to 24osceola@ninthcircuit.org in addition to filing a Joint Pretrial Statement addressing the matters described below, no later than 5 days prior to the Pretrial Conference, with a courtesy copy sent to the division email.

Judge Andrew A. Bain

WARNINGCriminal cases

If the State does not provide a satisfactory response to the follow-up email within 48 hours, Defense may file the motion to compel and forward a courtesy copy to the Court.

If Defense has not received a satisfactory response to the follow-up email within 48 hours, Defense can file its Motion to Compel and forward a courtesy copy to the Court.

Judge Barbara J. Leach

WARNINGCriminal cases

If you file an NOA within 3 business days of Arraignment, please email a courtesy copy to 14Orange@ninthcircuit.org to ensure our Trial Clerks are aware of the filing.

If you file an NOA within 3 business days of Arraignment, please email a courtesy copy to 14Orange@ninthcircuit.org to ensure our Trial Clerks are aware of the filing.

Judge Barbara J. Leach

WARNINGCivil cases

Trial briefs are optional, but if submitted, hard copies must be provided to chambers at least three business days before trial.

Trial Briefs are not required, but if you choose to submit them, please provide hard copies to Judge Kest’s Chambers (1740) at least three (3) business days prior to trial to allow adequate time for review.

Judge Brian S. Sandor

WARNING

Courtesy copies are required for ex parte or short matters.

Courtesy copies must be provided for ex parte/short matters as well.

Judge Brian S. Sandor

WARNINGCivil cases

A courtesy copy of a motion capable of being resolved on the pleadings and its proposed order must be provided to chambers.

If you have a motion that can be addressed on the pleadings, please provided a courtesy copy of the motion and proposed order to chambers, and the court will rule on the motion, order the opposing side to respond, or direct the parties to set a hearing.

Judge Brian S. Sandor

WARNING

Courtesy copies delivered after the 48-business-hour deadline may not be reviewed and may result in cancellation of the hearing.

Any copies delivered after this deadline may not be reviewed and may cause the hearing to be cancelled.

Judge Brian S. Sandor

WARNING

A motion for rehearing, reconsideration, or new trial will not be set for hearing unless the Judge directs, and counsel filing it must simultaneously provide the Judge a chambers copy with a cover letter requesting a hearing if desired.

Motions for rehearing, reconsideration or new trial will not be set for hearing unless the Judge so directs. Counsel filing such a motions shall simultaneously provide a chambers copy directly to the Judge with a cover letter requesting a hearing, if one is desired.

Judge Christine E. Arendas

WARNING

One copy of the Notice for Trial should be sent directly to the Judge’s Chambers.

A copy of the Notice for Trial should be sent directly to the Judge’s Chambers.

Judge Christine E. Arendas

WARNINGCivil cases

Trial briefs are optional, but any submitted trial brief must have hard copies provided to Chambers at least five working days before trial.

Trial Briefs: Not required, but if you choose to submit them, please provide hard copies to Chambers (6460) at least five (5) working days prior to trial to allow adequate time for review

Judge Christine E. Arendas

WARNINGCivil cases

Trial briefs are optional, but any submitted trial briefs must be provided as hard copies to Chambers at least five working days before trial.

Trial Briefs: Not required, but if you choose to submit them, please provide hard copies to Chambers (6460) at least five (5) working days prior to trial to allow adequate time for review

Judge Christine E. Arendas

WARNING

Supporting and opposition memoranda are optional, but if filed, counsel must give the Judge chambers copies of the memorandum and every cited legal authority.

Legal memoranda in support of, or in opposition to, motions are optional. If filed, counsel must furnish the Judge with chambers copies of the memorandum and copies of any legal authorities cited therein.

Judge Christine E. Arendas

WARNING

A copy of the Notice for Trial should be sent directly to the judge’s chambers.

A copy of the Notice for Trial should be sent directly to the Judge’s Chambers.

Judge Christy C. Collins

WARNING

Courtesy copies of motions for rehearing should be emailed to the court for review.

Courtesy copies of Motions for Rehearing should be emailed to the Court for review.

Judge Craig A. McCarthy

WARNING

For virtual hearings, the clerk's copies must be delivered to Room 320, where they may be dropped off.

c. Copies for the Clerk may be dropped off at Room 320 (required for virtual hearings).

Judge Denise Kim Beamer

WARNING

A party seeking a hearing must email the judicial office one courtesy copy of the motion after completing the meet-and-confer requirement.

After complying with the meet and confer requirement, a party seeking Hearing of a motion must email a courtesy copy of the motion to 37orange@ninthcircuit.org.

Judge Diego M. Madrigal III

WARNING

A courtesy copy of case law must be brought to an evidentiary hearing if it was electronically submitted to the court and opposing party at least three days before the hearing.

Courtesy copies of case law must be brought to the proceeding, a copy of same having been previously electronically submitted to the court and opposing party three (3) days prior to any evidentiary hearing.

Judge Elaine A. Barbour

WARNING

Items intended for the Court must be courtesy copied to the Court because the Clerk does not provide copies to the Judge or Judicial Assistant.

Do not submit anything to the Court that you have not copied to opposing counsel(s)/party(ies). Items submitted to the Clerk of Court are not submitted to the Court. Items accepted by the Clerk of Court are not copied to the Judge or Judicial Assistant and the Judge and Judicial Assistant are unaware of these items unless they are Courtesy copied to the Court.

Judge Greg A. Tynan

WARNING

Courtesy copies of motions for rehearing should be emailed to the Court for review.

Courtesy copies of Motions for Rehearing should be emailed to the Court for review.

Judge Holly Derenthal

WARNING

The Judicial Assistant cannot guarantee Court review of hearing materials submitted fewer than three business days before the hearing.

If the material is received less than three business days prior to the hearing, the Judicial Assistant cannot guarantee review by the Court of the documentation submitted.

Judge John D.W. Beamer

WARNING

A special-set hearing request must include courtesy copies of the relevant motions as attachments to the email sent to chambers.

Copy the table below when requesting for a hearing along with courtesy copy(s) of the motion(s) attached to the email.

Judge John D.W. Beamer

WARNINGCivil cases

The parties should submit courtesy copy to the Judicial Assistant via email (40Orange@ninthcircuit.org) of the filed Motion with a proposed Agreed Order for the Courts’ consideration.

The parties should submit courtesy copy to the Judicial Assistant via email (40Orange@ninthcircuit.org) of the filed Motion with a proposed Agreed Order for the Courts’ consideration.

Judge John E. Jordan

WARNING

Trial briefs are optional, but if filed, one electronic copy must be delivered to Chambers at least five working days before trial.

Trial briefs are optional but if one is filed, an electronic copy for the Court shall be delivered to Chambers no less than five (5) working days before trial.

Judge John E. Jordan

WARNING

Opposing counsel or the pro se party must receive a copy containing the same information provided to the Court.

Please copy opposing counsel or pro se party with the same information provided to the Court.

Judge Kevin B. Weiss

WARNING

Self-represented litigants excused from email service may submit courtesy copies by U.S. mail.

Self-represented litigants excused from e-mail service may submit courtesy copies to the court by U.S. mail.

Judge LaShawnda K. Jackson

WARNING

One copy of the notice of hearing must be emailed to the division once it has been filed.

A copy of your Notice of Hearing must be sent to the division email once filed.

Judge LaShawnda K. Jackson

WARNING

A courtesy copy of each trial brief must be delivered to the judge.

No later than three (3) business days before trial, the parties must each file a trial brief and deliver copies to opposing counsel and the undersigned judge.

Judge Luis F. Calderon

WARNINGCivil cases

Trial briefs are optional, but any submitted trial brief must be provided as hard copies to Judge Calderon’s Chambers at least five working days before trial.

Trial Briefs: Not required, but if you choose to submit them, please provide hard copies to Judge Calderon’s Chambers at least five (5) working days prior to trial to allow adequate time for review

Judge Luis F. Calderon