Court-wide rules
Applies court-wideThese 4 rules apply across New York Supreme Court, Erie County. Where this judge's own standing orders above address the same topic, the judge's requirement controls.
Filing Requirements
All 3- Applies to
- 236B financial affidavit
Both sides must exchange completed 236B Financial Affidavits before the first court conference.
- Applies to
- Final judgment roll
Within a few weeks after the specified stipulation or fully executed agreements, one attorney must submit the final judgment roll, including the final Findings and Judgment.
- Applies to
- Proposed dispositions
Parties or their attorneys will exchange "proposed dispositions" after the information has been exchanged to allow the Court to narrow or resolve some or all of the issues.
Service
All 1A certified copy of the final judgment must be served on both parties.
Are courtesy copies required for Judge Donna M. Siwek?
Details: delivery as soon as practical after nyscef filing. Working copies of motion papers must be delivered to the Court as soon as practical after NYSCEF filing.
Does Judge Donna M. Siwek require a pre-motion conference or letter before filing a motion?
Litigants must generally comply with Uniform Rules for Trial Courts Part 202 except where the court order states otherwise.
What formatting rules apply to filings before Judge Donna M. Siwek?
Judge Donna M. Siwek's formatting rule includes binding securely bound, exhibit tabs required., and double-sided copies are not permitted.. Working copies must be securely bound with exhibit tabs, and double-sided copies are prohibited.
What must be included with order to show cause filings before Judge Donna M. Siwek?
Orders to show cause requesting temporary restraining orders must comply with Uniform Rule §202.7(f).
What must be included with summary judgment motion filings before Judge Donna M. Siwek?
The Court neither requires nor accepts a Statement of Material Facts for motions for summary judgment.
How may parties contact Judge Donna M. Siwek's chambers?
The rule lists email ametz@nycourts.gov. Correspondence to the Court must be sent to Ann Metz by email or mail and must not be filed on NYSCEF.
How do I request an adjournment or extension before Judge Donna M. Siwek?
Trial adjournments are granted only in exceptional circumstances upon written request to the Court and not merely on counsel's consent.
Does Judge Donna M. Siwek require motion papers to be bundled?
Working copies must be securely bound and tabbed with exhibit tabs.
Is electronic filing required before Judge Donna M. Siwek?
Motion papers may not be submitted by fax or email.
When is a filing treated as filed before Judge Donna M. Siwek?
Orders must be uploaded within 14 days of the Court's decision and must indicate that the proposed order was sent to all opposing counsel or pro se litigants.
Complete rules summary for Judge Donna M. Siwek
Litigants must generally comply with Uniform Rules for Trial Courts Part 202 except where the court order states otherwise.
Correspondence to the Court must be sent to Ann Metz by email or mail and must not be filed on NYSCEF.
Conference adjournment requests must be submitted by email at least 48 hours in advance, copied to all counsel, and state that counsel were consulted and whether they consent.
Trial adjournments are granted only in exceptional circumstances upon written request to the Court and not merely on counsel's consent.
Requests for oral argument are discretionary with the Court.
Requests for Adjournments should be made by email to mwroblew@nycourts.gov with a copy to ametz@nycourts.gov and kroach@nycourts.gov and should indicate that all counsel have been consulted and whether they consent.
Working copies must be securely bound and tabbed with exhibit tabs.
Working copies of motion papers must be delivered to the Court as soon as practical after NYSCEF filing.
Working copies of reply affidavits must be delivered to Chambers no later than noon two days before the return date.
Working copies must be securely bound with exhibit tabs, and double-sided copies are prohibited.
Motion papers may not be submitted by fax or email.
Orders to show cause requesting temporary restraining orders must comply with Uniform Rule §202.7(f).
The Court neither requires nor accepts a Statement of Material Facts for motions for summary judgment.
Unless the Court orders otherwise, motions for summary judgment must be timely made under CPLR §3212(a).
Disclosure or discovery motions must include an affirmation of good-faith efforts, and counsel must have actually discussed the dispute; letters or emails alone are insufficient.
Orders must be uploaded within 14 days of the Court's decision and must indicate that the proposed order was sent to all opposing counsel or pro se litigants.
An uploaded order must indicate that the proposed order was sent to all opposing counsel or pro se litigants.
A party seeking to limit disclosure must submit a CPLR §3122(b) privilege log within 14 days of receiving the records.
Correspondence to the Court must not be filed electronically through NYSCEF.
Reply affidavits must be filed through NYSCEF, with working copies delivered to Chambers no later than noon two days before the return date.


