New York Supreme Court, Erie County Service and Proof of Service Rules
32 rules
E-service, mail, personal service, proof of service, certificate, and timing requirements.
Rules 1 to 32
MandatoryCivil cases
A certified copy of the final judgment must be served on both parties.
A certified copy will need to be served on both parties.
MandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- TRO
Temporary restraining orders must be issued on notice to the opposing party or opposing counsel.
TROs must be on notice to the opposing party or opposing counsel.
Judge Deborah A. ChimesPage 2, section MOTIONSMandatory
Requests for temporary relief must provide notice to opposing counsel if known unless the court directs otherwise.
Unless the court directs otherwise, All requests for temporary relief must be upon notice to the opposing counsel, if known.
Judge Deborah A. HaendigesPage 1, section MOTIONS: CivilMandatory
- Service
Where the premises are occupied, notice of any motions should be mailed to the defendant(s), regardless of whether they are in default in answering the complaint.
Where the premises are occupied, notice of any motions should be mailed to the defendant(s), regardless of whether they are in default in answering the complaint.
Judge Debra GivensPage 2, section FORECLOSURESMandatory
All mo on papers (including responding papers) should be properly served upon counsel and the Court. Refer to me schedules and procedures set forth in the CPL. The Court must be in receipt of all papers at least three (3) days prior to the return date.
All mo on papers (including responding papers) should be properly served upon counsel and the Court. Refer to me schedules and procedures set forth in the CPL. The Court must be in receipt of all papers at least three (3) days prior to the return date.
Judge Debra GivensPage 1, section CRIMINAL MATTERSMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Motion
- Service
- Mail to opposing party
When the premises are occupied, notice of motions should be mailed to the defendants even if they have not answered the complaint and are in default.
Where the premises are occupied, notice of any motions should be mailed to the defendant(s), regardless of whether they are in default in answering the complaint.
Judge Dennis E. WardPage 2, section MORTGAGE FORECLOSURESMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Default application
- Service
- Mail to opposing party
Default applications must include an affidavit showing mailed service on the defendant, including the return date, and the Court Notice explaining virtual appearance.
Default applications shall include an affidavit of service showing that a mailed copy of the papers, with the return date, was served on the defendant, together with the Court Notice, which advises the defaulting party how to appear virtually.
Judge Dennis E. WardPage 1, section MOTIONSMandatoryCivil cases
- Service
If parties cannot agree on a proposed order, the proposed order and notice of settlement must be served with ten days' notice by mail or five days' notice by personal service, returnable at the original proposed order's date and time.
If the parties are unable to agree to a proposed Order, the proposed Order and notice of settlement will be served in accordance with Uniform Rule Section 202.48 which provides for ten (10) days mailed notice or five (5) days notice if by personal service and made returnable on the same date and time as the original proposed Order.
Judge Diane Y. DevlinPage 2, section CIVILMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Settlement proposal
Each party must provide a written settlement proposal to the other party at least two weeks before the initial appearance.
Each party must submit a settlement proposal to the other party in writing no less than two weeks before the initial appearance.
Judge Emilio ColaiacovoPage 2, section Matrimonial ConferencesMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Reply papers
Reply papers must be served at least four dates before the return date unless the Court approves otherwise.
Reply papers must be served no less than four (4) dates prior to the return date unless approved by the Court.
Judge Emilio ColaiacovoPage 1, section Special TermMandatoryCivil cases
A temporary restraining order must be served or otherwise placed on notice to opposing counsel when that counsel is known.
TROs must be on notice to opposing counsel if known.
Judge Emilio ColaiacovoPage 3, section Temporary Restraining Orders (TRO)MandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Expert witness disclosure
Unless the trial order provides otherwise, plaintiff expert disclosures must be served at least sixty days before trial and defendant expert disclosures at least thirty days before trial.
Unless the trial order states otherwise, Plaintiff expert witness disclosures are to be served no later than sixty (60) days prior to trial and defendant expert witness disclosures are to be served no later than thirty (30) days prior to the trial.
Judge J. David SampsonPage 2, section TRIALS AND REFERENCESMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Proposed order
The Court will not sign an order without proof that it was submitted to opposing counsel or a pro se party for review and without a reasonable review period.
Orders will not be signed without proof of submission to opposing counsel or pro se party to review and a reasonable time period for review.
Judge J. David SampsonPage 2, section ORDERSMandatoryCivil cases
- Service
A notice withdrawing a motion must be emailed to Shannon Burke and Mary Pazik.
Notice of withdrawal of a motion is to be sent by email to Shannon Burke AND Mary Pazik.
Judge John B. LicataPage 2, section MOTIONSMandatoryCivil cases
Reply papers must be served upon the court by 5 p.m. on the Monday preceding the motion’s return date.
except for reply papers which are to be served upon the court by 5 p.m. on the Monday preceding the return date of the ===== PAGE 2 ===== motion.
Judge John B. LicataPage 1, section MOTIONSMandatory
- Applies to
- Proposed order
Orders based on the court's decision must be submitted to all counsel for approval before being submitted to the court.
Orders based upon a decision of this court shall be submitted to all counsel for approval prior to submission to the court.
Judge John DelMontePage 2, section MOTIONSMandatory
- Applies to
- Proposed order
- Service
When the parties cannot agree on a proposed order, the proposed order and notice of settlement must be served with ten days' notice by mail or five days' notice by personal service and be returnable at the original proposed order's date and time.
If the parties are unable to agree to a proposed order, the proposed order and notice of settlement shall be served in accordance with Uniform Rule §202.48 which provides for ten days mailed notice or five days notice if by personal service and made returnable on the same date and time as the original proposed Order.
Judge John DelMontePage 2, section MOTIONSMandatory
When an initiating pleading has already been filed, the fee-waiver application and notice of motion must be served on the case parties and the appropriate government counsel.
If yes, you must: - Serve this Application to Waive Court Fees and Costs (UCS-FW1) with Notice of Motion (UCS-FW2) on the: o Other parties in the case o Corporation Counsel (if filed in NYC) o County Attorney (if filed outside of NYC)
Judge John DelMontePage 7, section Application to Waive Court Fees and CostsMandatory
- Applies to
- Reply brief
Reply papers must be served at least four dates before the return date unless the Court approves otherwise.
Reply papers must be served no less than four (4) dates prior to the return date unless approved by the Court.
Judge Jorge S. de RosasPage 1, section Special TermMandatory
The order filed for signature must include verification of service on all opposing counsel or pro se litigants.
together with verification that the order has been served upon all opposing counsel (or pro se litigants)
Judge Joseph LorigoPage 2, section ORDERSMandatory
Moving, opposing, and reply papers must be served in compliance with CPLR § 2214 unless the Court specifically authorizes otherwise.
Counsel must comply with CPLR § 2214 when serving moving, opposing, and reply papers unless otherwise and specifically authorized by the Court.
Judge Joseph LorigoPage 1, section MOTIONS / ORDERS TO SHOW CAUSEMandatory
A TRO request must be provided on notice to opposing counsel and pro se litigants.
TROs must be on notice to the opposing counsel and pro se litigants
Judge Joseph LorigoPage 2, section MOTIONS / ORDERS TO SHOW CAUSEMandatory
- Applies to
- TRO
A temporary restraining order must be noticed to opposing counsel if known or to any involved government entity.
TROs: will be handled on a case-by-case basis. TROs must be on notice to Defendant/Respondent’s counsel (if known) or to any government entity involved.
Judge Kelly A. VaccoPage 2, section CIVIL SPECIAL TERM MATTERSMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Motion for default judgment
When a default is entered without a prior appearance by the defaulting party, serve the default judgment motion through the same method used for the summons and complaint and include an affidavit of service.
To the extent a default is taken in the absence of any prior appearance by the defaulting party, please serve a copy of the motion for default judgment upon that party through the same means by which service of the summons and complaint was effectuated and include an affidavit of service in your motion papers.
Judge Michael A. SiragusaPage 2, section MATRIMONIAL ACTIONSMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Debt collection notice
- Service
- Mail to opposing party
A plaintiff must give the court clerk a stamped, unsealed envelope addressed to the defendant together with the required notice.
Pursuant to the amendment, a Plaintiff shall submit to the court clerk a “stamped, unsealed envelope addressed to the defendant” together with the notice as described in the Act.
Judge Raymond W. WalterPage 2, section Consumer Credit Fairness ActMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Temporary restraining order
A temporary restraining order must be provided to opposing counsel when opposing counsel is known.
TROs must be on notice to opposing counsel, if known.
Judge Raymond W. WalterPage 4, section OrdersMandatory
- Applies to
- Default application
A default application must include an affidavit of service showing that the papers and return date were served on the defendant.
Include an affidavit of service demonstrating that a copy of the papers including the return date, was served upon the defendant.
Judge Shannon M. HeneghanPage 2, section Default ApplicationsImportantCivil cases
Counsel seeking an adjournment must confirm it and the rescheduled dates in writing to all parties and the Court.
Confirmation of any adjournment together with its rescheduled dates must be made in writing to all parties and to the Court by counsel seeking the adjournment.
Judge Diane Y. DevlinPage 2, section CONFERENCESImportantCivil cases
Temporary restraining orders, when possible, require notice to the opposing attorney.
Temporary Restraining Orders, where possible, will require notice to the opposing attorney.
Judge Diane Y. DevlinPage 1, section CIVILImportantCivil cases
Motions in limine must be served for argument before trial begins on the special term before proof, or as otherwise scheduled by the Court.
Motions in limine will be served to be argued before the start of trial on the special term before proof or as otherwise scheduled by the Court.
Judge Diane Y. DevlinPage 2, section TRIAL DEADLINESImportantCivil cases
- Applies to
- Debt collection notice
- Service
- Mail to opposing party
Failure to submit the required stamped, unsealed defendant-addressed envelope and notice may result in denial of a debt-collection summary-judgment motion.
Absent such compliance, summary judgment motions to collect a debt may be denied.
Judge Raymond W. WalterPage 2, section Consumer Credit Fairness ActImportant
- Applies to
- Court notice
- Service
- Mail to all parties
The moving party will be directed to mail the Court's notice to non-answering parties as a reminder of the scheduled default date.
The Court will upload a separate Court Notice which the moving party will be directed to mail to the non-answering parties reminding them of the scheduled date.
Judge Shannon M. HeneghanPage 2, section Default Applications
Common questions about New York Supreme Court, Erie County service and proof of service rules
What rule applies to serving all parties in New York Supreme Court, Erie County?
Details: recipient: all parties. A certified copy of the final judgment must be served on both parties.
What rule applies to service for reply brief in New York Supreme Court, Erie County?
Judge Jorge S. de Rosas: Details: timing: before hearing. Reply papers must be served at least four dates before the return date unless the Court approves otherwise.
What rule applies to service for settlement proposal in New York Supreme Court, Erie County?
Judge Emilio Colaiacovo: Details: recipient: the opposing party, timing: before hearing. Each party must provide a written settlement proposal to the other party at least two weeks before the initial appearance.
What rule applies to service by mail in New York Supreme Court, Erie County?
Judge Debra Givens: Details: method: service by mail. Where the premises are occupied, notice of any motions should be mailed to the defendant(s), regardless of whether they are in default in answering the complaint.
Judge Diane Y. Devlin: Details: method: service by mail. If parties cannot agree on a proposed order, the proposed order and notice of settlement must be served with ten days' notice by mail or five days' notice by personal service, returnable at the original proposed order's date and time.
What rule applies to service for default application in New York Supreme Court, Erie County?
Judge Shannon M. Heneghan: Proof of service is required for the covered service rule. Details: recipient: the opposing party. A default application must include an affidavit of service showing that the papers and return date were served on the defendant.
Judge Dennis E. Ward: Proof of service is required for the covered service rule. Details: method: service by mail, recipient: the opposing party. Default applications must include an affidavit showing mailed service on the defendant, including the return date, and the Court Notice explaining virtual appearance.
What rule applies to service for debt collection notice in New York Supreme Court, Erie County?
Judge Raymond W. Walter: Details: method: service by mail, recipient: the opposing party. A plaintiff must give the court clerk a stamped, unsealed envelope addressed to the defendant together with the required notice.
1 more rule answers this question.