New York Supreme Court, Erie County Filing Timing and Cure Windows
103 rules, 1 to 50 shown
Filing cutoffs, deemed-filed rules, rejection handling, cure periods, and outage procedures.
Cutoffs and deemed-filed rules
MandatoryCivil cases
All submissions, including replies, must be e-filed by 5:00 p.m. on the Wednesday before the return date.
All submissions, including replies, must be e-filed no later than 5:00 p.m. on the Wednesday prior to the return date.
Judge Deborah A. ChimesPage 2, section MOTIONSMandatoryCivil cases
Orders must be uploaded within 14 days of the Court's decision and must indicate that the proposed order was sent to all opposing counsel or pro se litigants.
Orders must be uploaded within 14 days from the Court’s decision, with an indication that the proposed order has been sent to all opposing counsel/pro se litigants.
Judge Donna M. SiwekPage 2, section MotionsMandatory
The privilege log and Bill of Particulars must be submitted on notice to opposing counsel within 14 days after the requesting party receives the records.
Once the party seeking to limit disclosure has received a copy of the records, they shall submit a privilege log consistent with CPLR §3122(b) and a copy of the Bill of Particulars on notice to opposing counsel within 14 days.
Judge Kelly A. VaccoPage 3, section IN CAMERA PROCEDUREMandatory
All motion papers, including replies, must be received by 5:00 p.m. on the Thursday before the motion return date.
All motion papers including any reply must be received by the Court not later than 5:00pm on the Thursday prior to the Motion return date. Counsel should schedule to account for this altered time frame.
Judge Shannon M. HeneghanPage 2, section Motions GenerallyImportantCivil cases
The court may adjourn a motion or reject an untimely submission when a submission is late.
At the Court’s discretion, late submissions may result in an adjournment of the motion or rejection of the untimely submission.
Judge Deborah A. ChimesPage 2, section MOTIONS
Filing deadlines
Mandatory
- Deadline
- 3 business days
- Applies to
- Cross motion
A cross motion filed fewer than three business days before the initial motion's return date will not be heard on that return date.
However, if a cross motion is filed fewer than three business days before the motion is returnable, the cross motion will not be heard on the return date for the initial motion.
Judge Amy C. MartochePage 2, section CIVIL MATTERSMandatoryCriminal cases
Assistant District Attorneys must provide NYSIS before arraignment on an indictment, a bail motion, or an SCI plea.
Assistant District Attorneys to provide a copy of NYSIS to the court prior to arraignments on indictments, bail motions, and SCI pleas.
Judge Betty Calvo-TorresPage 1, section MOTIONS, HEARINGS, PLEAS, SENTENCINGSMandatoryCriminal cases
All motion papers, including responding papers, must be delivered to chambers at least five days before the return date.
All motion papers (including responding papers) must be delivered to chambers at least 5 days prior to the return date.
Judge Betty Calvo-TorresPage 1, section MOTIONS, HEARINGS, PLEAS, SENTENCINGSMandatoryCriminal cases
- Deadline
- 48 hours
All SCI paperwork and the defendant information sheet must be provided to the Court at least 48 hours before the scheduled plea.
All SCI paperwork and Defendant information sheet is to be provided to the Court at least 48 hours in advance of the scheduled plea.
Judge Betty Calvo-TorresPage 1, section MOTIONS, HEARINGS, PLEAS, SENTENCINGSMandatoryCriminal cases
All moving and responding papers must be delivered to chambers at least five days before the return date.
All moving papers, responding papers, etc. must be delivered to chambers at least 5 days prior to the return date.
Judge Betty Calvo-TorresPage 1, section MOTIONS, HEARINGS, PLEAS, SENTENCINGSMandatoryCivil cases
Applications for discovery deadlines must be submitted to the Court’s confidential law clerk as soon as practicable and before the applicable deadline expires.
Applications for all discovery deadlines shall be made to the Court’s confidential law clerk as soon as practicable and prior to the expiration of such deadline
Judge Catherine Nugent PanepintoPage 2, section CONFERENCES: CivilMandatoryCivil cases
The preliminary conference must occur within 45 days after the Court receives the filed RJI.
Preliminary conference will be held within forty-five (45) days of the Court’s receipt of filed RJI.
Judge Catherine Nugent PanepintoPage 2, section CONFERENCES: CivilMandatoryCivil cases
Summary-judgment motions should be filed no later than 120 days after the note of issue is filed, unless the Court grants leave for good cause.
Motions for Summary Judgement should be made no later than one hundred twenty (120) days after the filing of the note of issue, except with leave of Court on good cause shown.
Judge Catherine Nugent PanepintoPage 1, section MOTIONSMandatory
The Court must receive all papers at least three days before the return date.
The Court must be in receipt of all papers at least three (3) days prior to the return date.
Judge Debra GivensPage 1, section CRIMINAL MATTERSMandatoryCivil cases
Summary judgment motions must be filed within 30 days after the note-of-issue date stated in the Trial Letter, unless another date is specified.
Summary judgment motions are to be filed within 30 days of the note of issue date set forth in the Trial Letter unless another date is specified.
Judge Dennis E. WardPage 1, section SETTLEMENT CONFERENCES & TRIALSMandatoryCivil cases
If the case does not settle, a Statement of Proposed Disposition is required one week before trial.
If the case does not settle, a Statement of Proposed Disposition, pursuant to 22 NYCRR 202.16(h), is required one week prior to trial.
Judge Dennis E. WardPage 2, section MATRIMONIAL ACTIONSMandatoryCivil cases
Discovery not completed by the discovery cutoff date in the Trial Letter is deemed waived, regardless of whether the note of issue is filed.
Any discovery not completed by the discovery cutoff date set forth in the Trial Letter is deemed waived, whether or not the note of issue is filed.
Judge Dennis E. WardPage 1, section SETTLEMENT CONFERENCES & TRIALSMandatoryCivil cases
All discovery must be completed by the court-set date for filing the note of issue.
All discovery must be completed by the date set by the court for filing of the note of issue.
Judge Dennis E. WardPage 1, section SETTLEMENT CONFERENCES & TRIALSMandatoryCivil cases
Motions in limine must be filed on eight days' notice and scheduled for argument on the Wednesday during the week before jury selection begins.
Motions in limine must be filed on 8 days notice, and must be scheduled for argument on the Wednesday of the week prior to the week of jury selection.
Judge Dennis E. WardPage 2, section SETTLEMENT CONFERENCES & TRIALSMandatoryCivil cases
Expert disclosure under CPLR 3101 is due 30 days before trial.
Expert disclosure pursuant to CPLR 3101 is required 30 days before trial.
Judge Dennis E. WardPage 1, section SETTLEMENT CONFERENCES & TRIALSMandatoryCivil cases
Expert disclosures must be made 30 days before trial.
Expert disclosure will be made thirty (30) days before trial.
Judge Diane Y. DevlinPage 2, section TRIAL DEADLINESMandatoryCivil cases
Dispositive motions must be made within 120 days after the Note of Issue is filed.
Dispositive Motions will be made within 120 days from the filing of the Note of Issue.
Judge Diane Y. DevlinPage 1, section CIVILMandatoryCivil cases
Opposition papers must be uploaded one week before the return date, and replies must be submitted by noon on the Tuesday before argument.
Opposition papers are due to be uploaded one week before the return date, and replies are due by noon on Tuesday prior to the argument.
Judge Diane Y. DevlinPage 1, section CIVILMandatoryCivil cases
Proposed jury verdict sheets and requests to charge must be submitted to chambers two weeks before jury selection.
Proposed Jury Verdict Sheets and Requests to Charge will be submitted to chambers two (2) weeks before jury selection.
Judge Diane Y. DevlinPage 2, section TRIAL DEADLINESMandatory
Unless the court directs otherwise, the prevailing party must submit orders within 30 days.
Unless otherwise directed by the Court, Orders are to be submitted within 30 days by the prevailing party.
Judge Edward A. PacePage 4, section ORDERSMandatory
Deadlines may not be extended without a further court order.
Deadlines may not be extended without further order of the Court.
Judge Edward A. PacePage 4, section PRE-TRIAL RULESMandatory
The required transcript citations must be included before the court considers the post-trial motion.
all post-trial motion(s) and responding papers must refer to the NYSCEF Document Number assigned to each transcript with page(s) and line(s) cited in all papers in support or in opposition to the motion(s) prior to the Court’s consideration of the motion(s).
Judge Edward A. PacePage 3, section MOTIONSMandatory
- Deadline
- 48 hours
The final judgment roll submission ordinarily requires an in-person appearance with clients, but the appearance is avoided only if all checklist documents from both sides are provided to chambers 48 hours before the return date.
The submission date is an in-person appearance with clients. In order to avoid the appearance, you must provide all necessary documents listed on the Judgment Roll Checklist, from both sides, to chambers 48 hours prior to the return date.
Judge Edward A. PacePage 5Mandatory
Stipulated exhibits must be submitted to NYSCEF at least one week before trial unless the court directs otherwise.
All stipulated exhibits must be made into a PDF, Bates stamped, if voluminous, and marked for identification (e.g., “Exh. 1”), and the notation “EVD”, and submitted to NYSCEF at least one week before the commencement of the trial, unless otherwise directed by the Court.
Judge Edward A. PacePage 4, section PRE-TRIAL RULESMandatory
Each party must submit requests for prior and after-trial jury charges and proposed verdict sheets no later than the day before the final pretrial conference.
The Court requires each party to submit Requests for Prior to and After Trial Jury Charges and Proposed Verdict Sheets to the Court no later than the day before the Final Pre-Trial Conference, which will be set by the trial judge.
Judge Edward A. PacePage 3, section PRE-TRIAL RULESMandatory
Counsel has 30 days after the court receives a fully executed agreement or written ratification to submit the final judgment roll.
Once a fully executed agreement or written ratification has been received by the Court, counsel will have 30 days to submit the final judgment roll.
Judge Edward A. PacePage 5MandatoryCivil cases
The prevailing party must submit the order within 30 days of the decision and state that it was sent to all opposing counsel or pro se litigants without objection.
Orders must be submitted by the prevailing party within thirty (30) days from decision date with indication that the Order has been sent out to all opposing counsel or pro se litigant and that no objection has been received.
Judge Emilio ColaiacovoPage 3, section OrdersMandatoryCivil cases
Answering papers and cross-motions must be received when counsel is served and at least seven days before the return date unless the Court approves otherwise.
Answering papers and/or cross-motions must be received at the same time counsel is served pursuant to the applicable provisions of the CPLR, but no less than seven (7) days prior to the return date unless approved by the Court.
Judge Emilio ColaiacovoPage 1, section Special TermMandatoryCivil cases
Formal requests to charge and proposed verdict sheets must be submitted to the Law Clerk one week before jury selection in Microsoft Word format.
Formal requests to charge and proposed verdict sheets must be submitted one week prior to jury selection in Microsoft Word format to the Law Clerk.
Judge Emilio ColaiacovoPage 2, section Trials and Hearings: Commercial/Medical MalpracticeMandatoryCivil cases
Marked pleadings and papers for motions in limine must be submitted at least two days before trial begins.
Marked pleadings and papers for motions in limine must be submitted at least two [2] days prior to start of trial.
Judge Emilio ColaiacovoPage 2, section Trials and Hearings: Commercial/Medical MalpracticeMandatoryCivil cases
All motions must be scheduled to be returnable during the court's scheduled Special Term dates.
All Motions shall be made returnable during scheduled Special Term dates.
Judge Gerald Greenan IIIPage 1, section Special TermMandatoryCivil cases
If no objection to the order is received within seven days, the court will sign the order without further delay.
If no objection has been received within seven (7) days, the Order will be signed without further delay.
Judge Gerald Greenan IIIPage 2, section OrdersMandatoryCivil cases
Filing deadlines must comply with the CPLR unless the court specifically authorizes an alternative with opposing counsel's consent.
The deadline for filing papers is to be in compliance with the CPLR, unless specifically authorized by the Court with consent of opposing counsel.
Judge Gerald Greenan IIIPage 2, section Motions and Orders to Show CauseMandatoryCivil cases
Unless the trial order states otherwise, the listed jury-order materials must be submitted two weeks before jury selection or trial, with requests to charge and proposed verdict sheets in Microsoft Word.
Generally, the trial order will state that marked pleadings, requests to charge (in Microsoft Word), proposed verdict sheets (in Microsoft Word), motions in limine and a proposed paragraph statement of the case to be submitted with the jury order are required two (2) weeks prior to jury selection or trial.
Judge J. David SampsonPage 2, section TRIALS AND REFERENCESMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Reply
Reply papers must be e-filed at least two days before the return date.
Reply papers must be e-filed by no later than two (2) days prior to the return date.
Judge J. David SampsonPage 1, section MOTIONSMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Motion
All motions in limine must be made returnable no later than one week before jury selection.
All motions in limine shall be made returnable no later than one (1) week prior to jury selection.
Judge J. David SampsonPage 2, section TRIALS AND REFERENCESMandatoryCivil cases
All motion papers must be e-filed at least ten days before the return date.
All motion papers must be e-filed at least ten (10) days prior to the return date.
Judge J. David SampsonPage 1, section MOTIONSMandatoryCivil cases
- Deadline
- 3 business days
Any oral-argument request must be submitted to the Court at least three business days before the return date.
Any such request must be made to the Court at least three (3) business days in advance of the return date.
Judge J. David SampsonPage 1, section MOTIONSMandatoryCivil cases
The Court will hold a preliminary conference within forty-five days after receiving a filed RJI.
Pursuant to 22 NYCRR 202.12 (b), a preliminary conference will be held within forty-five (45) days of the Court’s receipt of a filed RJI.
Judge J. David SampsonPage 2, section CONFERENCESMandatoryCivil cases
Answering papers and cross-motions must be received at least three days before the return date.
Answering papers and/or cross-motions must be received no later than at least three (3) days prior to the return date.
Judge J. David SampsonPage 1, section MOTIONSMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Proposed order
Unless the Court reserves decision, the moving party must submit the order within twenty-one days.
Where the Court has not reserved decision, orders are to be submitted within twenty-one (21) days by the party who brought the motion.
Judge J. David SampsonPage 2, section ORDERSMandatory
Opposition papers must be uploaded one week before the return date, and reply papers must be uploaded by noon on the Tuesday before the return date.
Opposition papers are due to be uploaded one week before the return date, and replies are due by noon on Tuesday before the return date.
Judge John DelMontePage 1, section MOTIONSMandatory
A dispositive motion must be filed within 90 days after the Note of Issue is filed.
Dispositive Motions shall be filed within 90 days from the filing of the Note of Issue.
Judge John DelMontePage 1, section MOTIONSMandatory
Marked pleadings and motions in limine must be submitted at least three days before jury selection or the start of a non-jury trial.
Marked pleadings and motions in limine must be submitted at least three (3) days prior to jury selection or the start of a non-jury trial.
Judge Jorge S. de RosasPage 3, section Trials and HearingsMandatory
Responding submissions and cross-motions must be received when counsel is served and at least seven days before the return date unless the Court approves otherwise.
Responding submissions and/or cross-motions must be received at the same time counsel is served pursuant to the applicable provisions of the CPLR, but no less than seven (7) days prior to the return date unless approved by the Court.
Judge Jorge S. de RosasPage 1, section Special Term
Common questions about New York Supreme Court, Erie County filing timing and cure windows rules
What filing deadlines does New York Supreme Court, Erie County set?
Judge Betty Calvo-Torres: Assistant District Attorneys must provide NYSIS before arraignment on an indictment, a bail motion, or an SCI plea.
Judge Jorge S. de Rosas: Marked pleadings and motions in limine must be submitted at least three days before jury selection or the start of a non-jury trial.
Judge Joseph Lorigo: The order must be accompanied by confirmation that no objection was received within three business days after service.
72 more rules answer this question.
What filing deadlines apply to proposed order filings in New York Supreme Court, Erie County?
Judge Edward A. Pace: Unless the court directs otherwise, the prevailing party must submit orders within 30 days.
Judge J. David Sampson: Unless the Court reserves decision, the moving party must submit the order within twenty-one days.
What filing deadlines apply to opposition and reply filings in New York Supreme Court, Erie County?
Judge John DelMonte: Opposition papers must be uploaded one week before the return date, and reply papers must be uploaded by noon on the Tuesday before the return date.
What filing deadlines apply to discovery deadline application filings in New York Supreme Court, Erie County?
Judge Catherine Nugent Panepinto: Applications for discovery deadlines must be submitted to the Court’s confidential law clerk as soon as practicable and before the applicable deadline expires.
What filing deadlines apply to rji filings in New York Supreme Court, Erie County?
Judge Catherine Nugent Panepinto: The preliminary conference must occur within 45 days after the Court receives the filed RJI.
What filing deadlines apply to responding papers filings in New York Supreme Court, Erie County?
Judge Mary Slisz: Responding papers must be submitted at least two business days before the motion return date.