New York Supreme Court, New York County Document Filing Requirements
406 rules, 101 to 150 shown
Required elements, certificates, and structural requirements for court documents.
Rules 101 to 150
Mandatory
- Applies to
- Discovery motion
Failure to comply with the discovery-motion requirements may result in denial, and the court may decide the motion on submission or schedule a discovery conference instead of argument.
Failure to comply with these requirements will result in the denial of the motion. Additionally, the court has the discretion to decide a discovery motion on submission or to schedule a discovery conference in lieu of hearing argument on the same.
Judge David CohenPage 3, section 2. MOTION PRACTICEMandatory
- Applies to
- Trial memorandum
The required trial memorandum must state the relevant facts and the legal arguments that will be contested at trial.
a brief trial memorandum of law setting forth the relevant facts of the case and setting forth the legal arguments to be contested at trial
Judge David CohenPage 5, section 4. TRIALSMandatory
- Applies to
- Order
Orders must be legible, identify the case as a Part 58 action, name Justice Cohen, and list the names, addresses, and telephone numbers of counsel appearing at the conference.
All orders must be legible, must indicate that the case is a Part 58 action, and must contain Justice Cohen’s name, as well as the names, addresses and telephone numbers of all counsel appearing at the conference.
Judge David CohenPage 4, section 3. PRELIMINARY AND COMPLIANCE CONFERENCESMandatory
- Applies to
- Summary judgment motion
Failure to submit the required undisputed statement of facts may result in denial with leave to renew, an adjournment, or another action the court deems proper.
Pursuant to 22 NYCRR 202.8-g(e), a movant’s failure to submit an undisputed statement of facts will result in the denial of the motion with leave to renew upon proper papers, adjournment of the motion to allow the movant time to submit an undisputed statement of facts, or any other action this Court deems just and proper.
Judge David CohenPage 2, section 2. MOTION PRACTICEMandatory
- Applies to
- Stipulation
A stipulation resolving a motion or extending a court deadline must be emailed to the Part 58 Clerk, and stipulations requiring clerk action must direct the action and include form EF-22 in e-filed cases.
Where such a stipulation resolves a motion or extends a deadline previously set by the court, it must be e- mailed to the Part 58 Clerk at SFC-Part58-Clerk@nycourts.gov so that the court may so-order the same. A stipulation resolving a motion which requires a Clerk to take action, such as a motion to consolidate, change venue, or amend a caption or pleading, must contain language directing the Clerk to take such specific action in accordance with CPLR 8019(c) and, in e-filed cases, must be accompanied by NYSCEF form EF-22.
Judge David CohenPage 3, section 2. MOTION PRACTICEMandatory
- Applies to
- Trial submission
At the first trial appearance, all parties must provide specified trial materials, including pleadings, discovery-related documents, relevant authorities, motions in limine, a revisable proposed verdict sheet, and a trial memorandum.
At the first appearance before Justice Cohen for trial, all parties shall provide: all marked pleadings and bills of particular, all notices to admit and responses thereto, any relevant case law, prior decisions bearing directly on the issues to be raised at trial, all motions in limine, a proposed verdict sheet (subject to revision), and a brief trial memorandum of law setting forth the relevant facts of the case and setting forth the legal arguments to be contested at trial.
Judge David CohenPage 5, section 4. TRIALSMandatory
- Applies to
- Stipulation
All parties must sign or electronically sign proposed stipulations before they are submitted to the court.
Proposed stipulations must be signed or e-signed by all parties before submission to the court.
Judge David CohenPage 4, section 3. PRELIMINARY AND COMPLIANCE CONFERENCESMandatory
- Applies to
- Jury instructions
The parties must provide the court with proposed jury instructions in preparation for the charge conference.
In preparation for the charge conference, the parties shall provide the court with proposed jury instructions.
Judge David CohenPage 5, section 4. TRIALSMandatory
- Applies to
- Discovery motion
A discovery motion must be supported by an affirmation describing the consultation and identifying the court conference participant and date, or stating good cause for no conferral.
If such a motion is filed, the affirmation of good faith submitted in support of the same must “indicate the time, place and nature of the consultation and the issues discussed and any resolutions, or shall indicate good cause why no such conferral with counsel for opposing parties was held” (22 NYCRR 202.7[c]). The affirmation of good faith must also indicate the identity of the individual who conferenced the case with the parties (i.e., Justice Cohen or which of his Law Clerks), as well as the date on which the case was conferenced by the court.
Judge David CohenPage 3, section 2. MOTION PRACTICEMandatory
- Applies to
- Case or motion status notice
Counsel and self-represented litigants must promptly notify Part 58 in writing of specified settlements, dispositions, mootness, death, or bankruptcy events.
Counsel and self-represented litigants are under a continuing obligation to notify Part 58 in writing, and as soon as possible, if an action is settled, discontinued, or otherwise disposed of, if a case or motion has become totally or partially moot, or if a party has died or filed a petition in bankruptcy.
Judge David CohenPage 2, section 1. ADJOURNMENTS AND OTHER COMMUNICATIONS WITH THE PART CLERK AND CHAMBERSMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Proposed witness list
The parties must provide a list of proposed witnesses, including interpreter needs and the required language and dialect.
A list of proposed witnesses, including the need for any interpreters with the required language and dialect;
Judge Eric SchumacherPage 1, section V. TrialsMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Deposition transcript
- Must include
- exhibit list
Each deposition transcript must be a separate labeled exhibit, accompanied by a word index identifying the deposed individual.
Each deposition transcript shall be submitted as a separate exhibit. Parties shall include a word index with all transcripts. Deposition transcripts shall be labeled to indicate both their exhibit number/letter and to identify the deposed individual.
Judge Eric SchumacherPage 4, section III.C.5MandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Memorandum of law
- Must include
- legal argument
Substantive legal arguments and statutory or case-law references must be presented in a separately filed memorandum of law, not in an affirmation or affidavit.
All substantive legal arguments, including references to statutes and case law, shall be made in memoranda of law, only, which shall be filed separately from any affirmations or affidavits. Legal arguments ===== PAGE 4 ===== are not to be included in affirmations. Do not cite cases in affirmations. Instead, file a memorandum of law.
Judge Eric SchumacherPage 3, section III.C.4MandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Proposed jury instructions
When a proposed jury instruction is not verbatim, requires factual or contention-based characterization or description, or is not based on the PJI, the exact requested language and supporting authority must be emailed simultaneously as a DOCX file to Justice Schumacher, both law clerks, and opposing counsel.
If a PJI instruction is not verbatim or requires characterization or description of the evidence or the parties’ contentions, or if the language is not based on the PJI, the exact requested language, together with the authority for it, must be emailed in .docx format to Justice Schumacher, both law clerks, and opposing counsel simultaneously.
Judge Eric SchumacherPage 2, section V. TrialsMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Discontinuance application
An application to discontinue that requires a court order must be made by a motion on notice.
Applications to discontinue requiring an order of the court must be made by motion on notice (see CPLR 3217[b][2]).
Judge Eric SchumacherPage 4, section III. MotionsMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Pro hac vice applicant affidavit
The applicant affidavit must disclose the number of New York pro hac vice applications, the number granted or denied, and whether the applicant has ever or currently faces a disciplinary proceeding.
The applicant’s affidavit must advise the court as to the total number of times the applicant has applied to be admitted in New York pro hac vice and how many times the application has been granted and/or denied. The affidavit must also state whether the pro hac vice applicant has ever been or is presently the subject of a disciplinary proceeding.
Judge Eric SchumacherPage 4, section III.DMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Proposed jury instructions
Any PJI section numbers cited in proposed jury instructions must be current on the submission date.
As the PJI is a living, frequently modified document, the PJI section numbers cited must be current as of the date of submission.
Judge Eric SchumacherPage 2, section V. TrialsMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Proposed jury instructions and verdict sheet
For jury trials, the parties must provide proposed jury instructions and a proposed verdict sheet.
Proposed jury instructions and verdict sheet.
Judge Eric SchumacherPage 2, section V. TrialsMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Trial day estimate
The parties must provide an estimate of the number of trial days required.
An estimate of the number of required trial days;
Judge Eric SchumacherPage 1, section V. TrialsMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Motion papers
Omnibus papers may not be filed for multiple motions, and any repeated paper must be filed separately in each motion sequence with an appropriate label.
You may not file omnibus affidavits, affirmations, memoranda of law, etc. Do not submit papers intended to be applicable to multiple motions (e.g., a party submitting the same affirmation in motion seq. nos. 001–003 must file it once in each sequence number, labeling each accordingly). Exhibits are exempt if you hyperlink any citation to such a document. The court strongly prefers that only one copy of any given exhibit be filed to NYSCEF.
Judge Eric SchumacherPage 3, section III. MotionsMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Pro hac vice application
- Must include
- proposed order
Each pro hac vice application must include separate PDFs containing a supporting attorney affidavit, an applicant affidavit, a recent certificate of good standing, and a proposed order.
Each application must include, in separate PDFs: (1) an affidavit of support from a member of the Bar of the State of New York; (2) an affidavit from the applicant; (3) a recent certificate of good standing from the applicant; and, (4) a proposed order.
Judge Eric SchumacherPage 3, section III. MotionsMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Marked pleadings
The parties must provide all marked pleadings.
All marked pleadings and bills of particulars;
Judge Eric SchumacherPage 1, section V. TrialsMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Subpoenaed documents
Counsel, rather than court personnel, is responsible for ensuring that all subpoenaed documents arrive in the subpoenaed records room at 60 Centre Street.
It is the duty of counsel, not court personnel, to ensure all subpoenaed documents have arrived in the subpoenaed records room at 60 Centre Street.
Judge Eric SchumacherPage 2, section V. TrialsMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Prior decisions
The parties must provide all prior trial-court decisions and any appellate decisions in the case.
All prior decisions in the case, including any appellate decisions;
Judge Eric SchumacherPage 1, section V. TrialsMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Certificate of readiness and note of issue
A certificate of readiness and note of issue may not be filed until the party files a stipulation or obtains an order stating that discovery is complete.
You are not to file the certificate of readiness and note of issue without first filing a stipulation, or receiving an order, as to that all discovery is complete.
Judge Eric SchumacherPage 3, section LMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Applicant affidavit
The applicant affidavit must disclose prior pro hac vice applications and their outcomes, state whether the applicant has had a disciplinary proceeding, and certify compliance with the Part 13 Rules.
The applicant’s affidavit must: (1) advise the court as to the total number of times the applicant has applied to be admitted in New York pro hac vice and how many times the application has been granted and/or denied; (2) state whether the pro hac vice applicant has ever been or is presently the subject of a disciplinary proceeding; and (3) certify that the applicant has read and will abide by the Part 13 Rules.
Judge Eric SchumacherPage 3, section III. MotionsMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Deposition testimony citation
References to deposition testimony must cite the exact page and line numbers relied upon and may not merely attach the entire transcript or selected portions.
Any reference to deposition testimony must cite to the exact page and line numbers relied upon rather than merely attaching the entire transcript or “relevant portions.”
Judge Eric SchumacherPage 4, section III.C.6MandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Voluminous exhibit citation
References to other voluminous exhibits must include pinpoint citations identifying the exact location within the exhibit.
Any reference to any other voluminous exhibit annexed to a motion must include pinpoint citations so that the exact location within the exhibit can be easily located.
Judge Eric SchumacherPage 4, section III.C.7MandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Notice of motion
A pro hac vice admission application must be made by motion and include a supporting affidavit from a New York Bar member, an applicant affidavit, and a recent certificate of good standing.
All applications for admission pro hac vice shall be made by notice of motion. The motion shall include an affidavit of support from a member of the Bar of the State of New York, an affidavit from the applicant, and a recent certificate of good standing from the applicant.
Judge Eric SchumacherPage 4, section III.DMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Affirmation
Substantive legal arguments and case citations must be presented in a separately filed memorandum of law, not in an affirmation or affidavit.
All substantive legal arguments, including references to statutes and case law, shall be made in memoranda of law, only, which shall be filed separately from any affirmations or affidavits. Legal arguments are not to be included in affirmations. Do not cite cases in affirmations. Instead, file a memorandum of law.
Judge Eric SchumacherPage 3, section III. MotionsMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- In limine or other application
Every in limine motion or other pretrial application must include citations to relevant authorities.
Any such motion or application must include citations to relevant authorities.
Judge Eric SchumacherPage 2, section V. TrialsMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Conference form
The conference form must be completed in full and identify all remaining discovery; blank, incomplete, or judge-dependent entries are rejected.
You must fill out the entire form, setting forth all remaining discovery. Blank, incomplete, “must see the judge,” etc. fill will be rejected.
Judge Eric SchumacherPage 1, section II. Discovery ConferencesMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Motion withdrawal or resolution stipulation
After a fully submitted motion is resolved, the movant must immediately file and email the part clerk a stipulation withdrawing or otherwise resolving it.
If a motion is resolved after it is fully submitted, the movant shall immediately inform the court by filing and emailing to the part clerk a stipulation withdrawing or otherwise resolving the motion.
Judge Eric SchumacherPage 2, section III. Motions A.1MandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Motion
If a fully submitted motion is resolved, the movant must immediately file and email the part clerk a stipulation withdrawing the motion.
If a motion is resolved after it is fully submitted, the movant shall immediately inform the court by filing and emailing to the part clerk a stipulation withdrawing the motion.
Judge Eric SchumacherPage 3, section III.A.1MandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Ebt transcripts
The parties must provide copies of EBT transcripts intended for any trial use.
Copies of EBT transcripts intended for use at trial for any purpose;
Judge Eric SchumacherPage 1, section V. TrialsMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Proposed jury instructions
For proposed jury instructions quoted verbatim from the Pattern Jury Instructions, citation of the PJI section numbers is sufficient.
If the proposed instructions are taken verbatim from the Pattern Jury Instructions (hereinafter PJI), PJI section numbers will suffice.
Judge Eric SchumacherPage 2, section V. TrialsMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Notices to admit
The parties must provide any notices to admit.
Any notices to admit;
Judge Eric SchumacherPage 1, section V. TrialsMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Outstanding discovery list
Counsel must bring a list of all outstanding discovery to a compliance conference.
At compliance conferences, counsel must bring a list of all outstanding discovery.
Judge Francis A. Kahn IIIPage 4, section IV. ALL CONFERENCESMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Motion
Citations to deposition testimony must identify the transcript page and line numbers.
Citation to deposition testimony must include notation of page and line number in transcript.
Judge Francis A. Kahn IIIPage 3, section III. MOTIONS - WORKING COPIES OF MOTION PAPERS ARE NOT REQUIRED.MandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Deposition transcript
The entire deposition transcript must be provided rather than excerpts.
Entire transcript must be provided not simply excerpts.
Judge Francis A. Kahn IIIPage 3, section III. MOTIONS - WORKING COPIES OF MOTION PAPERS ARE NOT REQUIRED.MandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Exhibits
Each electronically submitted exhibit must be identified and described in its heading.
All exhibits electronically submitted must be described in the heading of the attached exhibit (e.g. Exhibit A – Bill of Particulars), so that it is known what document is filed in the exhibit.
Judge Francis A. Kahn IIIPage 3, section III. MOTIONS - WORKING COPIES OF MOTION PAPERS ARE NOT REQUIRED.MandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Order
If a decision presents a problem, an order supported by an attorney affirmation must be filed and emailed to the Part's email address.
If there is a problem with a decision, please file an order with attorney affirmation and email the same to the part email address.
Judge Francis A. Kahn IIIPage 4, section IV. ALL CONFERENCESMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Motion in limine
In-limine motions must be submitted in writing as soon as practicable or as scheduled at a pretrial conference, with a copy to every party.
All motions in limine must be presented in writing to the court as soon as practicable or as specifically scheduled at any pretrial conference, with a copy to all parties.
Judge Gerald LebovitsPage 5, section VI.A. General Trial ProcedureMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Motion in limine
All in-limine and other motions and applications must be furnished before trial begins.
Before the start of trial, the parties must furnish all in-limine or other motions and applications.
Judge Gerald LebovitsPage 5, section VI.A. General Trial ProcedureMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Preliminary conference form
- Must include
- page count, word count, proposed order
Every item on a Preliminary Conference form must be completed or marked “n/a” when inapplicable.
2. In a Preliminary Conference form, all items must be completed or marked “n/a” if not applicable.
Judge Gerald LebovitsPage 5, section V. ConferencesMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Exhibit
Every exhibit must be numbered.
Each exhibit must be numbered.
Judge Gerald LebovitsPage 2, section IV.A. GeneralMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Affirmation in support
When a later summary-judgment deadline has been ordered or an extension granted, the support affirmation must state the governing deadline and when the court set or extended it.
If the court has set a motion deadline longer than 60 days after the note of issue, or granted an extension of a 60-day deadline, counsel’s affirmation in support must include the governing motion deadline and state when the court set a longer deadline or granted an extension.
Judge Gerald LebovitsPage 3, section IV.E. Summary-Judgment MotionsMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Trial preparation submission
At the first court appearance, each party must furnish the specified trial-preparation materials, including proposed witnesses, trial-day estimates, pleadings, decisions, notices to admit, EBT excerpts, a five-page trial memorandum, and two business cards per attorney.
Upon the first appearance before this court, the parties must furnish a list of proposed witnesses, including the need for any interpreters, with the required language and dialect; an estimate of required trial days; all marked pleadings and bills of particulars; all decisions in the case, including any appellate decisions; any notices to admit; copies of those portions of EBTs intended for use at trial for any purpose; a trial memorandum not to exceed five pages briefly setting forth the party’s position and the relevant factual and legal issues to be tried, citing relevant case law; and two business cards for each attorney.
Judge Gerald LebovitsPage 5, section VI.A. General Trial ProcedureMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Affirmation in support
Counsel’s summary-judgment support affirmation must state the note-of-issue filing date.
Counsel’s affirmation in support must include the note of issue filing date.
Judge Gerald LebovitsPage 3, section IV.E. Summary-Judgment MotionsMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Motion
Every motion or application must include citations to relevant authority.
Any motion or application must include citations to relevant authority.
Judge Gerald LebovitsPage 5, section VI.A. General Trial Procedure