New York Supreme Court, New York County Document Filing Requirements
406 rules, 201 to 250 shown
Required elements, certificates, and structural requirements for court documents.
Rules 201 to 250
Mandatory
- Applies to
- Proposed verdict sheet
The parties must submit proposed verdict sheets and requests to charge by the start of the second trial day, preferably before trial begins.
The parties shall submit proposed verdict sheets and requests to charge (subject to amendment), citing the PJI sections, preferably before the commencement of trial, but not later than the start of the second day.
Judge John J. KelleyPage 8, section IX. TrialMandatory
- Applies to
- Settlement conference fact statement
Before the mediation-style settlement conference, the parties must submit a short written statement of the action's underlying facts to the Part 56 Part Clerk.
Prior to the two-hour mediation-style settlement conference, the parties shall submit, to the Part 56 Part Clerk, a short written statement of the facts underlying the action, and all parties shall inform the court of their estimation of the full value of the action if liability is proven, with citations to appellate precedent determining the fair and reasonable value of the injuries claimed by the plaintiff, without set-offs for comparative fault or collateral sources.
Judge John J. KelleyPage 6, section VII. Settlement ConferencesMandatory
- Applies to
- Proposed jury charges
Any suggested changes to a PJI must be submitted by email to the Justice’s law clerks as the full text with all changes red-lined in Word format.
If any changes to the PJI are suggested, counsel must submit the full text with all changes red-lined in Word format by email to the Justice’s law clerks.
Judge John J. KelleyPage 8, section IX. TrialMandatory
- Applies to
- Papers
All papers must state the motion sequence number whenever one is available.
Motion Sequence Number: All papers shall state the motion sequence number, when available.
Judge Kathleen Waterman-MarshallPage 3, section MOTIONSMandatory
- Applies to
- Witness list
Counsel must bring witness lists to the pretrial conference.
▪ Witness Lists;
Judge Kathleen Waterman-MarshallPage 4, section TRIALSMandatory
- Applies to
- Joint discovery plan
In complex discovery cases, counsel must submit a joint discovery plan with the PCO containing specified issue, discovery, disclosure, disputes, witness, non-party discovery, and ESI information, after which it will be so ordered and uploaded to NYSCEF.
Joint Discovery Plan: If the case is on a complex discovery track, counsel shall submit a joint Discovery Plan with PCO. The Discovery Plan shall contain: a statement of the issues in the cases and the discovery sought for each issue (both substance and temporal scope); proposed deadlines for disclosure; identification of categories of information that are not in dispute and those that are potentially in dispute; identification of non-party discovery and material witnesses, known and potential; and ESI issues. The Discovery Plan will be So-Ordered and uploaded to NYSCEF with the PCO.
Judge Kathleen Waterman-MarshallPage 2, section DISCOVERY CONFERENCES ORDERSMandatory
- Applies to
- Motion submission
- Must include
- ai disclosure
Every motion-related submission must include an attorney or self-represented-party certification stating either that no generative AI was used or that the filer reviewed and approved all generated text, with the program, affected documents, and generated portions identified when AI was used; one certification may cover several documents in a party's submission.
Artificial intelligence (AI) programs: All submissions with respect to a motion must include a certification by an attorney (or self-represented party) either that no generative artificial intelligence program was used in the drafting of any affidavit, affirmation, or memorandum of law contained within the submission, or that a generative artificial intelligence program was used but all generated text, including citations, quotations, and legal analysis were reviewed for accuracy and approved by an attorney (or the self-represented party). If the certification states a generative artificial intelligence program was used, the program must be identified and the documents which include matter generated by ===== PAGE 4 ===== the program must be specified along with which parts of the documents were drafted by the program. One certification pertaining to a party’s submission comprised of several such documents shall suffice.
Judge Kathleen Waterman-MarshallPage 3, section USE OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE (“AI”) IN FILINGSMandatory
- Applies to
- Proposed conference order
If parties cannot agree on a PCO, CCO, or SCO after good-faith efforts, they must appear in person with a proposed order completed except for the disputed issue.
Parties who are unable to agree on the terms of any Conference Order (PCO, CCO, SCO), despite their good faith efforts to do so, shall appear in-person before the Court on the scheduled conference date with their proposed Conference Order, completed except for the disputed matter, prepared to discuss the issue for the Court’s ruling.
Judge Kathleen Waterman-MarshallPage 2, section APPEARANCES AT SCHEDULED DISCOVERY CONFERENCESMandatory
- Applies to
- Esi protocol
When ESI production is disputed, the parties must exchange an ESI protocol.
ESI: If the production of ESI is an issue, the parties shall exchange an ESI protocol (22 NYCRR 202.12[e][3]).
Judge Kathleen Waterman-MarshallPage 3, section DISCOVERY CONFERENCES ORDERSMandatory
- Applies to
- Pretrial conference materials
The Part Clerk schedules a pretrial conference at which counsel must have settlement authority and be prepared to discuss the listed trial matters.
When a trial is assigned to Justice Waterman-Marshall, the Part Clerk will schedule a Pre-Trial Conference, during which counsel, who must have authority to discuss settlement, SHALL BRING TO THE CONFERENCE AND BE PREPARED TO DISCUSS THE FOLLOWING:
Judge Kathleen Waterman-MarshallPage 4, section TRIALSMandatory
- Applies to
- Exhibit list
Counsel must bring exhibit lists to the pretrial conference identifying exhibits expected to be admitted by consent.
▪ Exhibit Lists, each indicating any exhibits that will be admitted into evidence on consent;
Judge Kathleen Waterman-MarshallPage 4, section TRIALSMandatory
- Applies to
- Preliminary conference order
Parties must confer on all discovery matters and email the part clerk an agreed-upon, signed draft PCO by noon on the day before the preliminary conference.
Preliminary Conference Order (“PCO”): Parties shall meet and confer about all discovery matters and submit an agreed upon, signed draft PCO (22 NYCRR 202.12) for the judge’s review and signature by email to the Part Clerk by 12:00 noon on the day prior to the Preliminary Conference.
Judge Kathleen Waterman-MarshallPage 2, section DISCOVERY CONFERENCES ORDERSMandatory
- Applies to
- Joint statement
Counsel must bring a Joint Statement describing the case and identifying the people, places, and institutions likely to be mentioned during trial.
▪ A Joint Statement summarizing the nature of the case, and a list of people, places, and institutions that are likely to be mentioned during the course of the trial, to be read to potential jurors during jury selection;
Judge Kathleen Waterman-MarshallPage 4, section TRIALSMandatory
- Applies to
- Compliance or status conference order
Parties must confer on outstanding discovery and email the part clerk an agreed, signed draft CCO or SCO by noon on the preceding day.
Compliance Conference Order (“CCO”) or Status Conference Order (“SCO”): Parties shall meet and confer about outstanding discovery matters and submit an agreed upon, signed draft, CCO or SCO as appropriate, for the judge’s review and signature by email to the Part Clerk by 12:00 noon on the day prior to the scheduled for the Conference.
Judge Kathleen Waterman-MarshallPage 2, section DISCOVERY CONFERENCES ORDERSMandatory
- Applies to
- Proposed jury charges and verdict sheet
Counsel must bring proposed jury charges and a verdict sheet to the pretrial conference.
▪ Proposed Jury Charges and Verdict Sheet; and
Judge Kathleen Waterman-MarshallPage 4, section TRIALSMandatory
- Applies to
- Motion
Every motion must be filed by Order to Show Cause and must state its motion sequence number on the first page.
All motions must be made by Order to Show Cause and indicate the respective motion sequence number on the first page.
Judge Linda M. CapittiPage 2, section V. MOTIONSMandatory
- Applies to
- Notice of motion
Motions filed by Notice of Motion will not be considered.
Motions made by Notice of Motion will not be considered.
Judge Linda M. CapittiPage 2, section V. MOTIONSMandatory
- Applies to
- Stipulation
When an adjournment is granted, counsel must upload a NYSCEF stipulation listing four dates and times when all counsel and parties are available.
If an adjournment request is granted, counsel must upload a stipulation to the New York State Courts Electronic Filing system (“NYSCEF”) listing four (4) dates and times that all counsel and parties are available.
Judge Linda M. CapittiPage 1, section II. ADJOURNMENTSMandatory
- Applies to
- Proposed preliminary conference order
A hard copy of the proposed preliminary conference order, signed by the parties and counsel, must be provided to the court on the preliminary conference date.
A hard copy of the proposed preliminary conference order signed by the parties and counsel must be provided to the court on the preliminary conference date.
Judge Linda M. CapittiPage 2, section IV. PRELIMINARY CONFERENCESMandatory
- Applies to
- Preliminary conference order
At least one day before the preliminary conference, counsel or parties must upload a completed and signed matrimonial preliminary conference order and statements of net worth to NYSCEF, along with a child support worksheet and proposed parenting plan when applicable.
At least one (1) day before the preliminary conference, counsel or parties must upload to NYSCEF: (i) a completed and signed matrimonial preliminary conference order; (ii) statements of net worth; and (iii) a child support worksheet and proposed parenting plan (if applicable).
Judge Linda M. CapittiPage 2, section IV. PRELIMINARY CONFERENCESMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Proposed jury instructions
Proposed jury instructions must be specifically tailored to the action.
Proposed jury instructions must be specifically tailored to the action.
Judge Lori S. SattlerPage 3, section VII. TrialsMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Proposed preliminary conference order
After joinder and filing of a preliminary-conference request, the parties must confer about discovery and submit a proposed preliminary conference order through NYSCEF and email.
Within a reasonable time after issue has been joined and a preliminary conference request has been filed, the parties shall meet and confer regarding a preliminary discovery schedule, which shall be memorialized in a Proposed Preliminary Conference Order that shall be presented to the court to be so ordered by filing on NYSCEF and via email to the Part Clerk.
Judge Lynn R. KotlerPage 1, section II. ConferencesMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Witness list
Counsel must serve and submit a witness list after a trial is assigned to Part 8.
c. a witness list;
Judge Lynn R. KotlerPage 3, section VIII. TrialsMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Marked pleadings
Counsel must serve and submit marked pleadings after a trial is assigned to Part 8.
a. marked pleadings;
Judge Lynn R. KotlerPage 3, section VIII. TrialsMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Counterstatement of material facts
A party opposing a summary-judgment motion must submit a counterstatement of material facts.
Any party opposing the motion shall submit a counterstatement of material facts.
Judge Lynn R. KotlerPage 2, section IV. MotionsMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Jury verdict sheet
Counsel must serve and submit a proposed jury verdict sheet after a trial is assigned to Part 8 when applicable.
g. proposed jury verdict sheet (if applicable);
Judge Lynn R. KotlerPage 3, section VIII. TrialsMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Pretrial memoranda
Counsel must serve and submit pretrial memoranda after a trial is assigned to Part 8 when applicable.
e. pretrial memoranda (if applicable);
Judge Lynn R. KotlerPage 3, section VIII. TrialsMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Bill of particulars
Counsel must serve and submit the bill of particulars after a trial is assigned to Part 8.
b. the bill of particulars;
Judge Lynn R. KotlerPage 3, section VIII. TrialsMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Expert disclosures
Counsel must serve and submit expert disclosures after a trial is assigned to Part 8.
d. expert disclosures;
Judge Lynn R. KotlerPage 3, section VIII. TrialsMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Jury instructions
Counsel must serve and submit proposed jury instructions after a trial is assigned to Part 8 when applicable.
f. proposed jury instructions (if applicable);
Judge Lynn R. KotlerPage 3, section VIII. TrialsMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Summary judgment notice of motion
A summary-judgment movant, except under CPLR 3213, must attach a separate and concise numbered statement of undisputed material facts.
Upon any motion for summary judgment, other than a motion made pursuant to CPLR 3213, the movant shall annex to the notice of motion a separate, short and concise statement, in numbered paragraphs, of the material facts as to which the moving party contends there is no genuine issue to be tried.
Judge Lynn R. KotlerPage 2, section IV. MotionsMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Summary of contentions
Counsel must serve and submit a one-paragraph summary of the parties' contentions after a trial is assigned to Part 8.
h. a one paragraph summary of the parties’ contentions.
Judge Lynn R. KotlerPage 3, section VIII. TrialsMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Note of issue
A note of issue should not be filed before discovery is complete.
Note of issue should not be filed unless discovery is complete.
Judge Lynn R. KotlerPage 3, section VII. Note of IssueMandatory
- Applies to
- Ex parte order of protection application
An ex parte order-of-protection application must include the Family Protection Registry Information Sheet, and the litigant must be present.
Ex-parte applications for orders of protection must be accompanied by the Family Protection Registry Information Sheet and the litigant must be present.
Judge Michael L. KatzPage 2, section Orders of ProtectionMandatory
- Applies to
- Final status conference
All discovery must be completed before the final status conference.
All discovery shall be completed before the final status conference.
Judge Michael L. KatzPage 2, section Preliminary, compliance and status conferencesMandatory
- Applies to
- Compliance conference schedule
The compliance-conference date must be set during the preliminary conference.
The date of the compliance conference shall be set at the time of the preliminary conference.
Judge Michael L. KatzPage 2, section Preliminary, compliance and status conferencesMandatory
- Applies to
- Motion
Every motion, opposition, and reply paper must state the motion sequence number and return date on its first page.
All motion papers (including opposition and reply papers) shall state the motion sequence number and return date of the motion on the first page.
Judge Michael L. KatzPage 1, section MotionsMandatory
- Applies to
- Pretrial submission
Unless there is a pretrial conference, the parties must exchange and file the disposition statement, updated net-worth statement, tax returns, witness list, and exhibit list with pre-marked exhibits at least two weeks before trial.
Parties shall exchange and file with the court the following documents at the pre-trial conference, if any, or at least two weeks prior to the first day of trial if there is no pre-trial conference: (i) statement of proposed disposition; (ii) updated statement of net worth; (iii) most recently filed tax returns; (iv) witness list; and (v) exhibit list (with pre-marked exhibits).
Judge Michael L. KatzPage 2, section Pre-trial conferencesMandatory
- Applies to
- Preliminary conference submission
At the preliminary conference, each party must submit a sworn net-worth statement, recent state and federal tax returns, and the two most recent paycheck stubs.
The following documents shall be submitted at the preliminary conference: (i) each party’s sworn statement of net worth; (ii) the most recently filed state and federal income tax returns; and (iii) each party’s two most recent paycheck stubs.
Judge Michael L. KatzPage 2, section Preliminary, compliance and status conferencesMandatory
- Applies to
- Motion
A motion to consolidate pending Family Court family-offense proceedings must include complete copies of the relevant pleadings and orders with docket numbers.
Motions to consolidate family offense proceedings pending in the Family Court must contain a complete copy of the relevant pleadings and orders (with relevant docket numbers).
Judge Michael L. KatzPage 2, section Orders of ProtectionMandatory
- Applies to
- Proposed parenting plan
For custody-only trials involving no financial issues, the parties must file a proposed parenting plan instead of a statement of proposed disposition and need not file an updated net-worth statement.
If the trial concerns the issue of custody only and involves no financial issues, the parties shall file a proposed parenting plan instead of a statement of proposed disposition, and need not file an updated statement of net worth.
Judge Michael L. KatzPage 2, section Pre-trial conferencesMandatory
- Applies to
- Trial evidence and witnesses
During direct testimony, counsel may offer only documents previously disclosed on the exhibit list, and only witnesses previously disclosed on the witness list may testify.
As a general rule, no counsel or party will be permitted to offer a document into evidence during a witness’ direct testimony unless the document was disclosed on the previously exchanged exhibit list, and no witness will be permitted to testify unless the witness was disclosed on the previously exchanged witness list.
Judge Michael L. KatzPage 2, section Trials and HearingsMandatory
- Applies to
- Sur reply
Sur-replies are prohibited unless the court gives prior permission.
Sur-replies are not accepted without prior court permission.
Judge Michael L. KatzPage 1, section MotionsMandatory
- Applies to
- Motion
Motions must generally be brought by order to show cause unless the court directs otherwise.
All motions shall be made by order to show cause unless otherwise directed by the court.
Judge Michael L. KatzPage 1, section MotionsMandatory
- Applies to
- Reply papers
Reply papers are prohibited in motions or special proceedings initiated by Order to Show Cause unless expressly permitted.
In accordance with Rule 13(b), section IV, of the Rules of the Justices of the New York County Supreme Court, Civil Branch, no reply papers shall be permitted in connection with motions or special proceedings initiated by order to show cause, except by express permission of the
Judge Nicholas MoynePage 2, section 2. MotionsMandatory
- Applies to
- Motion or special proceeding
A motion or special proceeding may be initiated by Order to Show Cause only when required by statute or the Part Rules or when emergency interim relief is sought.
A motion or special proceeding shall only be initiated by order to show cause where required by statute (see, e.g., CPLR 321[b][2], 5015[a]), these rules, or where emergency interim relief is sought.
Judge Nicholas MoynePage 2, section 2. MotionsMandatory
- Applies to
- Proposed order to show cause
Every proposed Order to Show Cause must provide for service of responsive papers and reserve space for the court to insert the service date.
All proposed orders to show cause shall include a provision for the service of responsive papers, with a space reserved for the date of service, which shall be filled in by the court.
Judge Nicholas MoynePage 2, section 2. MotionsMandatory
- Applies to
- So ordered subpoena request
Every request for a so-ordered subpoena must include a brief statement explaining why the so-order is needed and why the discovery is appropriate.
All requests for a so-ordered subpoena shall be accompanied by a brief statement indicating the need for the subpoena to be so-ordered and why such discovery is appropriate.
Judge Nicholas MoynePage 4, section 5. So-Ordered SubpoenasMandatory
- Applies to
- Notice required by CPLR 8019(c)
- Must include
- notice of electronic filing
Within 15 days after entry of the so-ordered caption stipulation, a party directed by the court must serve a copy on the Trial Support Office and separately file and upload the CPLR 8019(c) notice on Form EF-22.
After the court “so orders” the stipulation, one of the parties, as will be directed by the court in the so-ordered stipulation, shall, within 15 days of the entry of the so-ordered stipulation, serve a copy of the so-ordered stipulation upon the Trial Support Office (60 Centre Street, Room 148, New York, NY 10007), and shall separately file and upload the notice required by CPLR 8019(c) on a completed Form EF-22, whereupon the Trial Support Office shall thereupon amend the court records accordingly.
Judge Nicholas MoynePage 3, section 4. Stipulations Other Than for AdjournmentsMandatory
- Applies to
- Proposed discovery conference order
The plaintiff must complete the proposed discovery conference order, leave the next-submission and note-of-issue deadline spaces blank, and email the completed order to the part clerk.
The plaintiff shall be responsible for filling out the proposed discovery conference order, leaving blank the spaces provided for the next discovery order submission date and note of issue filing deadline, and emailing the completed proposed discovery order to the Part Clerk.
Judge Nicholas MoynePage 4, section 6. Discovery Conferences and Disputes