FTC and Illinois Sue Premium Home Service for Fake Home Repair Listings and Reviews
Summary
The FTC and State of Illinois, via the Department of Justice, filed a complaint against B.E.S.T. GDR LLC (d/b/a Premium Home Service) and its owner Yosef Bernath for creating thousands of fake home repair business listings with fabricated five-star reviews to deceive consumers. The defendants allegedly routed consumer calls to unqualified representatives, arranged for unlicensed technicians, and violated the FTC Act, Reviews and Testimonials Rule, Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act, and Illinois consumer protection laws. No monetary penalty has been imposed yet as the case is in initial filing stages.
Contract Impact
In-house legal teams should review vendor agreements with marketing, lead generation, and review management vendors to ensure they prohibit the creation of fake business listings, fabricated reviews, and deceptive endorsements, and require compliance with the FTC Act and Reviews and Testimonials Rule. Clauses governing online advertising, testimonial collection, and consumer financial information collection should be updated to mandate truthful representations, prohibit fraudulent statements to obtain financial data, and align with federal and state consumer protection laws. Customer-facing service agreements should also be reviewed to eliminate deceptive claims about local presence, technician availability, and service quality. Additionally, agreements with third-party call centers or offshore representatives should include clauses requiring accurate disclosures to consumers about service provider location and technician qualifications.
Contract Search Terms
Laws Cited
Violation Types
Entity Details
Entity
B.E.S.T. GDR LLC, d/b/a Premium Home Service
Industry
OtherOfficial Sources
Official Press Release
https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/news/press-releases/2026/05/ftc-illinois-take-action-stop-deceptive-conduct-company-created-thousands-business-listings-fake
best gdr llc et al united states state illinois v timeline i
https://www.ftc.gov/legal-library/browse/cases-proceedings/best-gdr-llc-et-al-united-states-state-illinois-v-timeline-item-2026-05-11
commr meador premium home service statement
https://www.ftc.gov/system/files/ftc_gov/pdf/commr-meador-premium-home-service-statement.pdf
Federal Trade Commission Enforcement Page
https://www.ftc.gov/enforcement
Source Evidence
"Illinois-based B.E.S.T. GDR LLC, which does business as PHS"
"violated the FTC Act by making deceptive claims about being a local home-repair business operating from a specific address, making deceptive claims about sending technicians on a specific date and time from a local business, and making deceptive claims related to fake reviews"
"violated the Reviews and Testimonials Rule by writing, creating, buying, or selling fake reviews and seeking and using fake reviews from employees and relatives"
"violated the Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act by making false, fictitious, or fraudulent statements to obtain consumers’ financial information"
"The complaint also alleges PHS violated Illinois consumer protection laws."
"May 11, 2026"
Related Enforcement Actions
Hims & Hers Health, Inc.
The FTC amended its lawsuit against telehealth provider Hims and Hers, adding Arizona, Florida, Nebraska, Ohio, and Wisconsin as co-plaintiffs. The complaint alleges that the company shared consumers’ sensitive health information with advertising platforms despite privacy claims, and misled consumers about prescription charges and subscription cancellation; the case remains for the court to decide.
Stream Auto Outlet
The FTC alleged that Stream Auto Outlet advertised vehicles at prices lower than consumers ultimately had to pay, including by adding required down payments, dealer fees, and unwanted add-ons. The proposed order prohibits misrepresenting vehicle costs or terms and requires price advertisements to prominently show the actual price, apart from government-required charges.
Progress Residential and Pretium Partners
$49.8M
The FTC and four states alleged that Progress Residential and Pretium Partners misled renters about rental prices and fees, improperly withheld security deposits, and engaged in other unlawful conduct. Under a proposed settlement, the companies will pay $49.75 million and must change their pricing, deposit, and customer-service practices.
Amazon.com, Inc.
The FTC and 22 state attorneys general filed an updated complaint alleging that Amazon secretly added surcharges to advertising auction prices and misled advertisers about the reasons for price increases. The release describes newly unredacted allegations; it does not report a judgment, settlement, or monetary penalty.
McDonnell & Associates LLC, also doing business as First Capital Group
The FTC alleges that McDonnell & Associates LLC and other defendants used false legal threats and other deceptive tactics to collect more than $20 million in debts consumers often did not owe. A federal court issued a temporary restraining order freezing the defendants’ assets and placing the company under a court-appointed receiver while the case continues.
Riverside Payments Inc.
$600K
The FTC and Washington alleged that Riverside Payments and affiliates misrepresented savings and cancellation terms, concealed fees and auto-renewing contracts, and obtained consumers’ financial information using false or fraudulent statements. The proposed stipulated order requires a $600,000 payment, customer notice and a period to rescind agreements without penalty, and prohibits deceptive claims while requiring clear disclosures, informed consent for negative-option billing, and a simple cancellation method.