FTC GOAT Shipping and Refund Policy Settlement
Consumers Affected
6,205
Summary
The FTC alleged that GOAT failed to ship some priority-processing orders as promised and did not offer customers the required option to accept a delay or cancel for a prompt refund. It also alleged that GOAT failed to honor its Buyer Protection refund policy; under the settlement, the company provided direct refunds and the FTC is sending additional redress payments to 6,205 customers.
Remedy
GOAT directly refunded more than $736,000 to affected customers in 2025. The FTC is now sending checks or PayPal payments to 6,205 additional customers; the release says the redress payments total more than $100,000.
Contract Impact
Review customer terms, marketplace seller agreements, and logistics/vendor contracts for enforceable shipping deadlines, prompt notice when an order will be delayed, and customers’ ability to cancel for a prompt refund. Confirm that refund and buyer-protection promises are supported by operational procedures, apply to products that are inauthentic, incorrect, or not as described, and do not permit substitution of partial refunds or store credit where a full refund is promised. Vendor agreements should allocate responsibility for shipment tracking, delay reporting, refund processing, complaint handling, and records needed to demonstrate compliance.
Contract Search Terms
Laws Cited
Violation Types
Entity Details
Entity
GOAT USA, Inc.
Industry
RetailOfficial Sources
Source Evidence
"online marketplace GOAT"
"FTC’s Mail, Internet or Telephone Order Merchandise Rule"
"failed to mail some priority processing orders as fast as promised and did not offer buyers the option of agreeing to the delay or cancelling the order and receiving a prompt refund"
"the company frequently denied those refund requests, only provided partial refunds or issued in-store credits."
Related Enforcement Actions
Dollar General Corporation
The FTC and state co-plaintiffs filed an amended complaint alleging that Dollar General repeatedly charged customers more at checkout than prices displayed on shelves, price tags, and advertisements. The complaint alleges violations of federal and state laws; the case has not been decided by the court, and the press release reports no penalty or remedy.
Elk River Inc.
$4.4M
The FTC alleged that Elk River Inc. falsely marketed safety harnesses as “Made in USA” even though most components and materials originated outside the United States. The proposed settlement imposes a $4.4 million judgment, partially suspended after payment of $72,527, bars specified misleading origin claims, and requires consumer notice.
Hims & Hers Health, Inc.
The FTC amended its lawsuit against telehealth provider Hims and Hers, adding Arizona, Florida, Nebraska, Ohio, and Wisconsin as co-plaintiffs. The complaint alleges that the company shared consumers’ sensitive health information with advertising platforms despite privacy claims, and misled consumers about prescription charges and subscription cancellation; the case remains for the court to decide.
Stream Auto Outlet
The FTC alleged that Stream Auto Outlet advertised vehicles at prices lower than consumers ultimately had to pay, including by adding required down payments, dealer fees, and unwanted add-ons. The proposed order prohibits misrepresenting vehicle costs or terms and requires price advertisements to prominently show the actual price, apart from government-required charges.
Progress Residential and Pretium Partners
$49.8M
The FTC and four states alleged that Progress Residential and Pretium Partners misled renters about rental prices and fees, improperly withheld security deposits, and engaged in other unlawful conduct. Under a proposed settlement, the companies will pay $49.75 million and must change their pricing, deposit, and customer-service practices.
Amazon.com, Inc.
The FTC and 22 state attorneys general filed an updated complaint alleging that Amazon secretly added surcharges to advertising auction prices and misled advertisers about the reasons for price increases. The release describes newly unredacted allegations; it does not report a judgment, settlement, or monetary penalty.