Fifteenth Judicial Circuit of Florida, Palm Beach County Pre-Motion Conference Requirements
97 rules, 1 to 50 shown
Pre-motion conference and letter requirements before filing motions, including sequential steps.
Rules 1 to 50
MandatoryCivil cases
A hearing on a subsequent temporary-relief application requires authorization from the assigned judge.
Hearings on subsequent applications for temporary relief shall be set with authorization of the assigned judge.
MandatoryCivil cases
A temporary-relief hearing may not be set unless the parties first complete mediation and report an impasse.
No temporary relief hearing shall be set unless the parties have first submitted to mediation and an impasse has been reported.
MandatoryCivil cases
All temporary-relief issues must be scheduled on the court's evidentiary motion calendar.
All temporary relief issues, including but not limited to support, time-sharing, equitable distribution, residence, fees, and costs shall be scheduled on the court's evidentiary motion calendar.
MandatoryCivil cases
Competing temporary-relief applications must ordinarily be heard together unless the court finds that impracticable.
Should both parties file temporary relief applications, the matters shall be heard at the same time unless the Court deems it impracticable.
MandatoryCivil cases
Within 45 days after the entitlement determination, the parties must confer item by item about disputed fees and costs and attempt to resolve the dispute through good-faith negotiations.
Within forty-five (45) days from the date of the Entitlement Determination, the parties must meet and confer as the issue of the amount of attorneys’ fees and costs to clarify the extent and basis of any objections to the reasonableness of fees and costs on an item-by-item basis and resolve as much of the dispute as possible through good faith negotiations.
Court-level rulesOfficial source Section Order Directing Pre-Hearing Schedule for Attorney Fees and Cost MotionsMandatory
Before scheduling a UMC motion, attorneys must make reasonable efforts to confer and resolve or narrow the dispute, and the noticing attorney must certify a good-faith attempt to resolve it.
Mandatory compliance with Local Rule #4 is strictly enforced. Attorneys are required to "make reasonable efforts to actually speak to one another and engage in reasonable compromises to resolve or narrow the disputes before seeking court intervention." Prior to scheduling, the "attorney noticing the motion shall attempt to resolve the matter and shall certify to the Court the good faith attempt to resolve."
Mandatory
Before filing and serving a notice of hearing for a Uniform Motion Calendar or specially set hearing, the noticing attorney must attempt to resolve the matter and certify the good-faith attempt, except when a moving or non-moving party is pro se.
Prior to filing and serving a Notice of Hearing for a Uniform Motion Calendar hearing or a specially set hearing, the attorney noticing the motion for hearing shall attempt to resolve the matter and shall certify the good faith attempt to resolve.
Mandatory
Before a matter is placed on the uniform motion calendar, the noticing party or attorney must attempt to resolve it and certify that the attempt was made in good faith.
(2) Prior to setting a matter on the motion calendar, the party or attorney noticing the motion shall attempt to resolve the matter and shall certify the good faith attempt to resolve.
MandatoryCivil cases
Within 15 days after service of the written objections, the parties and their experts must meet and confer about each disputed fee-and-cost item.
Within fifteen (15) days after service of any objections required by paragraph 4 of this Order, the parties and their respective experts shall meet for the purposes of conferring over each disputed item of the Claim.
Court-level rulesOfficial source Section Order Directing Pre-Hearing Schedule for Attorney Fees and Cost MotionsMandatoryCivil cases
Before filing any motion involving electronically stored information, the parties must inquire of the relevant data custodians and consider using a special magistrate or e-discovery mediation to resolve the dispute.
Before bringing any Motion before this Court involving ESI, the Parties (i) shall make inquiry of the relevant data custodian(s) by any discovery method(s) they deem appropriate, and (ii) shall consider the use of a special magistrate and/or e-discovery mediation to resolve the dispute.
Mandatory
The good-faith resolution attempt requires reasonable efforts by counsel to speak in person or by telephone and make genuine efforts to resolve or narrow disputes before seeking court intervention.
The term "attempt to resolve the matter" in paragraph 2 shall require counsel to make reasonable efforts to speak to one another (in person or via telephone) and engage in reasonable compromises in a genuine effort to resolve or narrow the disputes before seeking Court intervention.
MandatoryCivil cases
Before a discovery hearing is scheduled, counsel must make actual efforts to confer in person or by electronic means, and merely exchanging emails or texts is insufficient.
The conferral contemplated by this Administrative Order and Local Rule 4 must be done prior to scheduling the hearing. A good faith “attempt to resolve” the matter is defined by Local Rule 4 to contemplate actual efforts to speak with counsel in person or via electronic means, not merely the exchange of emails or texts. See, 15th Cir. Local Rule 4(3) & fn 2.
Court-level rulesOfficial source Page 1, section IN RE: MOTIONS TO COMPEL DISCOVERY OR FOR PROTECTION FROM DISCOVERYMandatory
Rehearing, reconsideration, and similar motions cannot be set for oral argument without a court order, except motions for new trial or rehearing under Rule 1.530 or a similar procedural rule.
With the exception of motions for new trial or rehearing pursuant to Rule 1.530, Fla.R.Civ.P., or similar procedural rule, no petition for rehearing, motion for reconsideration, or like pleading shall be set for oral argument except upon court order.
Judge Caryn SipersteinSection Motion for Rehearing/Reconsideration/ClarificationMandatoryCivil cases
The parties and their experts must hold a remote conference to discuss the specific fee and cost objections no later than five days before Calendar Call.
Both parties and their respective experts shall meet, via remote conference, to discuss the specific objections to the fees and costs being claimed no later than five (5) days prior to Calendar Call.
Judge Caryn SipersteinSection IN RE: STANDING ORDER ON MOTIONS FOR ATTORNEYS' FEES AND COSTSMandatoryCivil cases
(v) direct that before moving for an order relating to discovery, the movant must request a conference with the court;
(v) direct that before moving for an order relating to discovery, the movant must request a conference with the court;
Judge Caryn SipersteinPage 192, section APPENDIX 3-2 — COMPARISON OF FLORIDA AND FEDERAL RULES OF E-DISCOVERYMandatory
The parties must attend mediation before setting a hearing to determine the amount of attorney’s fees and costs.
The parties must attend mediation prior to setting the hearing to determine the amount.
Judge Caryn SipersteinSection Motions on Attorney FeesMandatory
Before filing a motion, the movant must confer by telephone in good faith with opposing parties, including self-represented parties, and record the conference in the proposed order.
Before filing, movants must confer by telephone with opposing parties including self represented parties in a good faith effort to resolve the issues raised in the motion and indicate the same in the proposed order.
Judge Caryn SipersteinSection MotionsMandatory
Every Daubert motion must be scheduled and heard before trial begins.
All Daubert motions shall be scheduled and heard prior to the commencement of the trial.
Judge Charles E. BurtonSection Notice/Motion to Set Cause for TrialMandatory
Movants must make a good-faith conferral effort with opposing parties before filing a non-dispositive motion.
Before filing a non-dispositive motion, movants must confer with opposing parties in a good faith effort to resolve the motion.
Judge Charles E. BurtonSection Adversary Probate ProceedingsMandatory
A motion must be filed and docketed with the Clerk before a hearing date may be provided or set.
Motions must be filed and docketed with clerk before hearing dates can be given or a hearing can be set.
Judge Charles E. BurtonSection Probate - Service and Preparation of OrdersMandatory
Coordinate UMC hearings with opposing counsel or the self-represented litigant unless all parties agree to short notice.
UMC hearings must be coordinated with opposing counsel or pro se litigant (unless short notice is agreed by all parties).
Judge Daliah H. WeissSection B. Scheduling ProceduresMandatory
After filing the temporary-relief motion, mediation on the requested relief must occur before a hearing will be scheduled.
Mediation ON THE TEMPORARY RELIEF SOUGHT (following the filing of the motion for temporary relief) must be held before a temporary relief hearing will be scheduled. See Administrative Order 5.207 (PDF).
Judge Daliah H. WeissSection B. Scheduling ProceduresMandatory
Motions set for special hearings must go to mediation before the hearing, except temporary-custody motions.
Except for Temporary custody, ALL the motions in special set hearings, must go to MEDIATION before the special set hearing occurs. This is Mandatory.
Judge Dane LeitnerSection Special Set HearingsMandatory
Before a special-set hearing is set, the parties must attend a five-minute status conference on the UMC calendar and upload a proposed order setting the hearing.
The Judicial Assistant will special set hearings after the parties have attended a 5 minute status conference set by the parties on the UMC calendar. The parties must upload a proposed order setting the hearing.
Judge Dane LeitnerSection Special Set HearingsMandatory
After filing a temporary-relief motion, the parties must mediate the temporary relief sought before a hearing will be scheduled.
Mediation ON THE TEMPORARY RELIEF SOUGHT (following the filing of the motion for temporary relief) must be held before a temporary relief hearing will be scheduled Administrative Order 5.207.
Judge Dane LeitnerSection Temporary Relief HearingsMandatory
Motions for rehearing, clarification, or new trial must not be set for hearing unless the court directs otherwise.
DO NOT set motions for rehearing, clarification or new trial to be heard unless directed to do so by the Court.
Judge Danielle SherriffSection Motions for rehearing, clarification, rehearing and new trialMandatoryCivil cases
Before filing a discovery motion or seeking court intervention, counsel must speak in person or by telephone and make a genuine effort to compromise; the court encourages filing discovery objections without a motion when it can rule directly.
If a discovery dispute arises, counsel must actually speak to one another (in person or via telephone) and engage in reasonable compromise in a genuine effort to resolve their discovery disputes before seeking Court intervention. No discovery motions shall be filed until after the parties have engaged in this process. The Court encourages filing the discovery objections without a motion if the Court can simply review the request and objection in order to rule, thereby saving the parties unnecessary briefing and expense.
Judge Danielle SherriffPage 5, section III. PROCEDURES FOR DISCOVERY DISPUTES — A. Pre-hearing CommunicationMandatory
Counsel must actually communicate to satisfy the good-faith conference requirement.
GOOD FAITH CONFERRALS REQUIRE COUNSEL TO ACTUALLY TALK.
Judge Danielle SherriffSection Good Faith Conferral Prior to Filing All Motions - Eliminating Unnecessary Hearings - Strict Compliance with Local Rule 4Mandatory
A motion requiring more immediate attention must be set by a manually noticed hearing agreed to by the parties.
If the motion requires more immediate attention, it must be set through a manual notice by agreement of the parties.
Judge Danielle SherriffSection 10 Minute Hearings - Uniform Motion Calendar (UMC) - Online SchedulingMandatory
In addition to Local Rule 4's requirement to confer before setting a hearing, parties are expected to confer before filling all motions.
In addition to Local Rule 4's requirement to confer before setting a hearing, parties are expected to confer before filling all motions.
Judge Danielle SherriffSection Good Faith Conferral Prior to Filing All Motions - Eliminating Unnecessary Hearings - Strict Compliance with Local Rule 4Mandatory
If the Court finds an emergency, it will schedule the hearing unilaterally, and all parties must be available absent exigent circumstances.
If the court determines that an emergency exists, a hearing will be scheduled unilaterally by the court. All parties shall make themselves available for the emergency hearing, barring exigent circumstances.
Judge Darren Dunifon ShullSection F. Emergency and Other Urgent MattersMandatory
Before scheduling a motion, attorneys must make reasonable efforts to confer and compromise, attempt to resolve the matter, and certify their good-faith effort to the Court.
Mandatory compliance with Local Rule #4 is strictly enforced. Attorneys are required to "make reasonable efforts to speak to one another and engage in reasonable compromises to resolve or narrow the disputes before seeking court intervention." Prior to scheduling, the "attorney noticing the motion shall attempt to resolve the matter and shall certify to the Court the good faith attempt to resolve."
Judge Darren Dunifon ShullSection B. Scheduling ProceduresMandatory
Schedule UMC hearings through OLS by agreement between the parties; do not call the Judicial Assistant to schedule or cancel one.
UMC's are set using the Court's Online Services (OLS). Scheduling is solely between the parties. Please do not call the Judicial Assistant to schedule or cancel a UMC hearing.
Judge Darren Dunifon ShullSection B. Scheduling ProceduresMandatory
Motions set for special hearing must go to mediation before the hearing, except motions for default, dismissal, or summary judgment.
ALL the motions in special set hearings, must go to MEDIATION before the special set hearing occurs (EXCEPT Motion for Default, Motion for Dismiss and Motion for Summary Judgement).
Judge Darren Dunifon ShullSection B. Scheduling ProceduresMandatory
A motion to withdraw must be set for UMC with proper notice to the client and all parties or attorneys, unless the client signs consent; with consent, no hearing is needed, but the attorney must upload a proposed withdrawal order with the signed consent attached.
Motions to Withdraw must be set for a UMC hearing, with proper notice to the client, in accordance with Florida Rules of General Practice and Judicial Administration 2.505(f)(i), and all parties/attorneys. HOWEVER, if there is a signed CONSENT from the Client, no hearing is necessary, HOWEVER the Attorney must upload a proposed Order Withdrawing and attach the signed consent from the Client.
Judge Darren Dunifon ShullSection D. Motions to WithdrawMandatory
Schedule motions requiring more than 10 minutes on the Court’s online calendar and coordinate with the parties; for hearings over 30 minutes, file and mail a trial-docket notice identifying the motion, filing date, and requested hearing time.
For motions that require more than 10 minutes, the motion shall be scheduled on the Court's online calendar and coordinated with all appropriate parties. The hearings are set by order and the order is automatically uploaded to the Court for signature. If the hearing will take longer than 30 minutes, you need to file a notice to be placed on a trial docket, indicating the motion to be heard, the filing date of the motion(s) and how much hearing time is requested. Send it via U.S. Mail and the judicial assistant will prepare an order setting the motion on the next available docket.
Judge Darren Dunifon ShullSection D. Residential Foreclosure TrialsMandatoryCivil cases
Before filing a discovery motion or seeking court intervention, counsel must communicate in person or by telephone and make a genuine effort to compromise; the court encourages filing the objections alone when they are sufficient for ruling.
If a discovery dispute arises, counsel must actually speak to one another (in person or via telephone) and engage in reasonable compromise in a genuine effort to resolve their discovery disputes before seeking Court intervention. No discovery motions shall be filed until after the parties have engaged in this process. The Court encourages filing the discovery objections without a motion if the Court can simply review the Page 5 of 6 ===== PAGE 6 ===== request and objection in order to rule, thereby saving the parties unnecessary briefing and expense.
Judge Darren Dunifon ShullPage 5, section III. PROCEDURES FOR DISCOVERY DISPUTES — A. Pre-hearing CommunicationMandatory
Schedule uncontested summary-judgment motions online before a senior judge, but do not set uncontested foreclosure summary judgments on the Division AE online calendar; follow the scheduling prompts.
All uncontested Summary Judgment motions will be scheduled online and set before a senior judge. DO NOT SET UNCONTESTED FORECLOSURE SUMMARY JUDGMENTS ON THE DIVISION AE ONLINE CALENDAR - follow the prompts for scheduling.
Judge Darren Dunifon ShullSection D. Residential Foreclosure TrialsMandatory
A party seeking exclusion under Daubert must file a motion identifying the basis of the challenge, and all Daubert motions must be scheduled and heard before the trial docket begins.
DAUBERT: Any party seeking to exclude evidence under a Daubert analysis shall file a motion with the court specifically identifying the basis for the Daubert challenge. All Daubert motions shall be scheduled and heard prior to the commencement of the trial docket.
Judge Darren Dunifon ShullSection H. Pretrial Procedures and ConferencesMandatory
The parties must attend a five-minute status conference set on the UMC calendar before the Judicial Assistant special sets a hearing.
The Judicial Assistant will special set hearings after the parties have attended a 5-minute status conference set by the parties on the UMC calendar.
Judge Darren Dunifon ShullSection B. Scheduling ProceduresMandatoryCivil cases
A motion requiring an evidentiary hearing cannot be decided without holding that hearing.
No motions requiring an evidentiary hearing will be determined without a hearing.
Judge Debra Moses StephensPage 3, section III. MOTION PRACTICEMandatory
A criminal Zoom appearance is permitted only after conferring with the Assistant State Attorney, confirming hearing duration, and obtaining a court order.
You may not appear by Zoom unless you have: Conferred with the Assistant State Attorney, Pam Ford: (561/624-6632) (pford@sa15.org), and Confirmed the length of time for the hearing, and You have received an order from this Court.
Judge Debra Moses StephensSection Criminal DivisionsMandatoryCivil cases
Before seeking court intervention or filing a discovery motion, counsel must speak in person or by telephone and make a genuine effort to compromise and resolve the dispute.
If a discovery dispute arises, counsel must actually speak to one another (in person or via telephone) and engage in reasonable compromise in a genuine effort to resolve their discovery disputes before seeking Court intervention. No discovery motions shall be filed until after the parties have engaged in this process.
Judge G. Joseph CurleyPage 5, section A. Pre-hearing CommunicationMandatory
Before filing a non-dispositive motion, the movant must confer in good faith with opposing parties to try to resolve the issues.
Before filing a non-dispositive motion, movants must confer with opposing parties in a good faith effort to resolve the issues raised in the motion.
Judge G. Joseph CurleySection Mandatory Compliance with Conferral RulesMandatory
Before scheduling a special set hearing, clear the date and time with all parties and file the motion; an unfiled motion cannot be set.
Prior to scheduling a special set hearing online, you must clear the hearing date and time with ALL parties, and have previously filed your motion. Motions that have not been filed cannot be set for hearing.
Judge G. Joseph CurleySection Specially Set Hearings (15 and 30 minutes)Mandatory
Before requesting a special-set hearing, the motion must be docketed, availability must be cleared with interested parties, and an email request must be sent to the Division.
1. file/ docket the motion; 2. confer with all interested parties to gauge availability for the hearing, and to clear the hearing date and time ultimately provided by the Court for reservation; and 3. send an email request to the Division email: CAD-DivisionAD@pbcgov.org to obtain a special set hearing date and reservation.
Mandatory
Counsel must make reasonable efforts to communicate in person or by telephone and pursue reasonable compromises to resolve or narrow disputes before seeking court intervention.
The term "attempt to resolve the matter" in paragraph 2 shall require counsel to make reasonable efforts to speak to one another (in person or via telephone) and engage in reasonable compromises in a genuine effort to resolve or narrow the disputes before seeking Court intervention.
Judge Jaimie GoodmanPage 1, section IN RE: UNIFORM MOTION CALENDAR AND SPECIALLY SET HEARINGSMandatory
Before filing and serving a notice of hearing, the noticing attorney must attempt to resolve the matter and certify that the attempt was made in good faith.
Prior to filing and serving a Notice of Hearing for a Uniform Motion Calendar hearing or a specially set hearing, the attorney noticing the motion for hearing shall attempt to resolve the matter and shall certify the good faith attempt to resolve.
Judge Jaimie GoodmanPage 1, section IN RE: UNIFORM MOTION CALENDAR AND SPECIALLY SET HEARINGSMandatory
Email or other written communications may be used, but if they do not resolve the matter, counsel must make reasonable efforts to speak in person or by telephone before filing and serving the notice of hearing.
The requirements of this rule do not preclude the use of e-mail or other written communication in an effort to resolve a pending motion. Compliance with this rule, including "making reasonable efforts to speak to one another" in person or by telephone before filing and serving a Notice of Hearing is required when e-mail or other written communication efforts are unsuccessful.
Judge Jaimie GoodmanPage 1, section IN RE: UNIFORM MOTION CALENDAR AND SPECIALLY SET HEARINGSMandatory
Failure to make a good-faith resolution attempt may result in the motion being stricken or sanctions being imposed, although the court may waive the requirement in appropriate circumstances.
Failure to make a good faith attempt at resolving the issues may, in the Court's discretion, result in the motion being stricken from the Uniform Motion Calendar **or specially set hearing** and/or the imposition of sanctions. The Court may waive the good faith attempt at resolving the issues in appropriate circumstances.
Judge Jaimie GoodmanPage 2, section IN RE: UNIFORM MOTION CALENDAR AND SPECIALLY SET HEARINGS
Common questions about Fifteenth Judicial Circuit of Florida, Palm Beach County pre-motion conference requirements
Does Fifteenth Judicial Circuit of Florida, Palm Beach County require a pre-motion conference or letter before filing a motion?
Fifteenth Judicial Circuit of Florida, Palm Beach County: A hearing on a subsequent temporary-relief application requires authorization from the assigned judge.
Judge Caryn Siperstein: Rehearing, reconsideration, and similar motions cannot be set for oral argument without a court order, except motions for new trial or rehearing under Rule 1.530 or a similar procedural rule.
Judge Charles E. Burton and Judge Samantha Schosberg Feuer: Every Daubert motion must be scheduled and heard before trial begins.
93 more rules answer this question.