Court Rules

Fifth Judicial Circuit of Florida, Citrus, Hernando, Lake, Marion and Sumter Counties Filing Timing and Cure Windows

178 rules from official source documents

Rules 51 to 100, page 2 of 4

Filing cutoffs, deemed-filed rules, rejection handling, cure periods, and outage procedures.

Filing deadlines

CRITICAL

The joint final pretrial statement, motions in limine, deposition objections, proposed jury instructions, and verdict form must be filed 14 days before the pretrial conference; untimely motions in limine are deemed abandoned.

Deadline for filing: The joint final pretrial statement, Any motion in limine, Objections to depositions, Proposed jury instructions, and Verdict form | 14 days before the pretrial conference Note: If not filed by this date, motions in limine will be deemed abandoned.

Judge Donald E. Scaglione

CRITICALCivil cases

All motions in limine must be filed before the pre-trial conference to be considered.

All Motions in Limine MUST BE FILED PRIOR TO THE PRE-TRIAL CONFERENCE IN ORDER TO BE CONSIDERED.

Judge Donald E. Scaglione

CRITICAL

Applies to
Motion to continue trial

A continuance motion must be filed promptly after good cause first appears.

A motion to continue trial must be filed promptly after the appearance of good cause to support such motion.

Judge Donald E. Scaglione

CRITICALCivil cases

The movant's summary-judgment motion must be filed consistently with deadlines in the case-management order or other court orders.

The movant must file and serve the motion for summary judgment consistent with the deadlines specified in the case management order or any court-ordered deadlines.

Judge Donald E. Scaglione

CRITICAL

All pretrial motions must be resolved before the pretrial hearing.

Resolution of All Pretrial Motions | Prior to Pretrial Hearing |

Judge Donald E. Scaglione

CRITICAL

All pending motions and pleadings must be filed at least seven days before the hearing, court, or trial.

Thus the Court requires all pending motions/pleadings be filed at least seven (7) days prior to hearing/court/trial.

Judge Donald E. Scaglione

CRITICAL

Defendants must file their witness list at least 90 days before pretrial.

Deadline for Defendant(s) to file witness list | 90 days before pretrial

Judge Donald E. Scaglione

CRITICALCivil cases

All contested motions in limine must be filed no later than 20 days before the pre-trial conference.

ALL CONTESTED MOTIONS IN LIMINE MUST BE FILED NO LATER 20 DAYS PRIOR TO THE PRE-TRIAL.

Judge Donald E. Scaglione

CRITICAL

Failure to comply with the order's deadlines may result in sanctions, including striking a party's pleadings.

Failure to comply with deadlines may subject the parties to sanctions, including but not limited to striking of

Judge Donald E. Scaglione

CRITICAL

All Daubert motions must be filed within 30 days after expert discovery closes.

Deadline for filing any *Daubert* motions | 30 days after the close of expert discovery

Judge Donald E. Scaglione

CRITICALCivil cases

The proposed order must be submitted to the court within 10 days after the hearing.

The Parties shall submit to the Court within 10 days of hearing a Proposed Order complying with FRCP 1.510 (Fed R. 56) involving the standards and facts.

Judge Donald E. Scaglione

CRITICAL

Dispositive and Daubert motions must be heard at least 45 days before pretrial or they will be deemed abandoned.

Deadline to have any dispositive and *Daubert* motions heard | 45 days before the pretrial Note: If not heard by this date, dispositive and *Daubert* motions will be deemed abandoned

Judge Donald E. Scaglione

CRITICAL

The case-management and pretrial-order deadlines will be strictly enforced absent good cause.

The deadlines established in this Case Management/Pretrial Order shall be strictly enforced by the court unless good cause can be shown.

Judge Donald E. Scaglione

CRITICAL

Counsel must promptly file all paperwork needed to close a dismissed or settled case.

Counsel must expeditiously file all paperwork necessary to close the case.

Judge Donald E. Scaglione

CRITICAL

All dispositive motions must be filed within 120 days after fact discovery closes.

Deadline for filing any dispositive motions | 120 days after close of fact discovery

Judge Donald E. Scaglione

CRITICAL

By the previously specified deadline, jury instructions and verdict forms must be filed with the clerk and emailed to the division email address in Word format.

By the deadline set forth above, jury instructions and verdict forms must be filed with the Clerk and e-mailed in Word format to the division email address in accordance with the following:

Judge Donald E. Scaglione

CRITICAL

Daubert motions must also be filed before the pretrial conference or hearing.

Filed before Pretrial

Judge Donald E. Scaglione

CRITICAL

The order sets case-dependent trial completion targets of 12 or 18 months, or 24 or 30 months.

Trial | 12 or 18 Months, or 24/30 months

Judge Donald E. Scaglione

CRITICALCivil cases

Paperwork intended for consideration at the hearing must be filed five days beforehand with a courtesy copy sent to the Court.

Any paperwork to be considered at the hearing must be filed 5 days prior to hearing, with a courtesy copy to the Court.

Judge Donald E. Scaglione

CRITICAL

Fact and expert discovery must be completed within 270 days in streamlined cases and within 450 days in general cases, measured from filing of the complaint.

Completion of Fact & Expert Discovery | 270 Days Streamline 450 Days General |

Judge Donald E. Scaglione

CRITICAL

The exhibit list must be filed at least 21 days before the pretrial conference.

Deadline to file Exhibit List | 21 days before the pretrial conference

Judge Donald E. Scaglione

CRITICALCivil cases

A Zoom Notice of Hearing must be filed with the Court at least five days before the hearing.

A Zoom Notice of Hearing must be filed with the Court at least 5 days prior to hearing date.

Judge Donald E. Scaglione

CRITICALCivil cases

All evidence intended for consideration must be submitted five days before an evidentiary hearing to the clerk, Court, parties, and witnesses.

Parties must submit all Evidence to be considered 5 days prior to hearing with the clerk, Court and all parties and witnesses.

Judge Donald E. Scaglione

CRITICALCivil cases

Deadline
10 business days

A party objecting to proposed relief must notify the court immediately and in writing within 10 business days, unless the matter requires no response or is uncontested.

Unless the matter is stipulated to in writing by all interested parties, or is a matter that otherwise requires no response, or is otherwise clearly indicated to be uncontested, the Court may wait ten (10) business days to see if any further objections, pleadings, or responses directed to the issue are received. IT IS INCUMBENT ON ANYONE OBJECTING TO ANY PROPOSED RELIEF TO NOTIFY THE COURT IMMEDIATELY AND IN WRITING WITHIN THE TEN (10) BUSINESS DAY PERIOD.

Judge Donald E. Scaglione

CRITICAL

Deadline
5 working days

All parties must acknowledge the hearing-attendance procedures through one of the specified filings or email at least five working days before the hearing.

***THE COURT REQUIRES ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF THE ABOVE BY RECEIPT OF A MOTION AND ORDER (COURTCALL), NOTICE OF ZOOM HEARING OR INVITATION TO THE COURT (ZOOM APPEARANCE), OR EMAIL (ACKNOWLEDGING PERSONAL APPEARANCE) WITHIN 5 WORKING DAYS PRIOR TO HEARING DATE.***

Judge Donald E. Scaglione

CRITICAL

Mediations | 270 Days Streamlined 450 Days General & Complex 500 Days Complex At least 45 Days Prior to Pretrial Hearing

Mediations | 270 Days Streamlined 450 Days General & Complex 500 Days Complex At least 45 Days Prior to Pretrial Hearing

Judge Donald E. Scaglione

CRITICAL

Procrastination in discovery and counsel unavailability do not constitute good cause to change the order's deadlines.

Procrastination in completing discovery or the unavailability of counsel will not constitute good cause for a change to these deadlines.

Judge Donald E. Scaglione

CRITICAL

Fact and expert discovery must be completed within 500 days in complex cases.

500 Days Complex

Judge Donald E. Scaglione

CRITICALCivil cases

The opposing party has 10 days from the filing date of the motion in limine to file a response.

The opposing party shall have TEN days from the filing date of the Motion in Limine to file a Response thereto.

Judge Donald E. Scaglione

CRITICAL

Deadline
5 business days

A Zoom appearance request must be made by motion at least five business days before the event, with an emailed courtesy copy to the Judicial Assistant and a proposed order uploaded to the portal.

Requests to appear by Zoom must be made by motion filed with the Clerk, with a courtesy copy emailed to the Judicial Assistant at PBarto@circuit5.org and a proposed order uploaded to the portal, no later than five (5) business days before the scheduled event.

Judge Erin Daly

CRITICAL

Deadline
48 hours

All evidence must be submitted to the Court at least 48 hours before the hearing in accordance with the procedures outlined on Judge Daly’s website. Failure to comply may result in exclusion of the evidence.

All evidence must be submitted to the Court at least 48 hours before the hearing in accordance with the procedures outlined on Judge Daly’s website. Failure to comply may result in exclusion of the evidence.

Judge Erin Daly

CRITICAL

An in limine motion ordinarily will be resolved without a hearing unless oral argument is requested and granted or the court orders otherwise, and it must be filed no later than 30 days before the pretrial hearing or may be denied as untimely.

16. In limine motions. Unless oral argument is requested and granted, or otherwise ordered by the Court, in limine motions will be resolved without a hearing. All motions in limine must be filed no later than 30 days before the start of the pretrial hearing or the Court may deny the motion as being untimely.

Judge Erin Daly

CRITICAL

Evidence may be emailed as an attachment or physically delivered to Judge Daly's Chambers at least five days before the hearing.

Evidence may be sent by email attachment or by physical delivery to Judge Daly’s Chambers, at least five (5) days prior to the scheduled hearing.

Judge Erin Daly

CRITICAL

At least five days before a hearing, all intended evidence must be submitted as pre-marked PDF exhibits to the opposing party and emailed to the Court.

Exhibits: Five days prior to any hearing, submit all evidence which you intend to rely on as pre-marked exhibits via PDF format to opposing counsel or pro se party and email to the Court at pbarto@circuit5.org.

Judge Erin Daly

CRITICAL

Deadline
48 hours

A party granted permission for a Zoom appearance must share intended hearing evidence with the opposing party and Court no later than 48 hours before the hearing.

If a motion for zoom appearance is granted, any documents, photographs or evidence that a party intends to use at the hearing must be shared with the opposing party and the Court no later than 48 hours before the hearing.

Judge Erin Daly

CRITICAL

filing All Objections to pleadings At least 60 days prior to pre- At least 60 days prior to pre- Filing of all trial conference, notice for trial conference, notice for pre-trial motions hearing prior to PTC hearing prior to PTC

filing All Objections to pleadings At least 60 days prior to pre- At least 60 days prior to pre- Filing of all trial conference, notice for trial conference, notice for pre-trial motions hearing prior to PTC hearing prior to PTC

Judge Erin Daly

CRITICAL

Evidence exceeding 50 pages must be mailed 15 days before a virtual hearing to the court at the stated address.

If your evidence exceeds fifty (50) pages, then you will need to mail in evidence fifteen (15) days in advance as follows: Attn: Circuit Judge George L. Singeltary II at 110 North Apopka Avenue #101, Inverness, FL 34450.

Judge George L. Singeltary II

CRITICAL

Deadline
10 business days

Evidence for a virtual hearing must be mailed at least ten business days before the hearing after pre-marking is completed.

Once completed, you will then need to mail in said evidence at least ten (10) business days in advance of the hearing.

Judge George L. Singeltary II

CRITICAL

A Notice of Conflict must be filed immediately upon discovery of the conflict, with a courtesy copy to the Court.

This notice should be filed immediately upon discovery of the conflict with a courtesy copy to the Court.

Judge Jason J. Nimeth

CRITICAL

A pretrial statement must be filed no later than ten days, excluding weekends and holidays, before the pretrial conference.

Pretrial statements shall be filed no later than 10 days (excluding weekends and holidays) before the Pretrial Conference.

Judge Jennifer Bass

CRITICAL

Opposing party or counsel has 10 days from receipt of a motion to respond, and failure to respond may result in an order treating the motion as unopposed.

Opposing party/counsel shall have ten (10) days from receipt of a motion to file a response. Failure to timely respond may result in the issuance of an Order as if motion was unopposed.

Judge Joel D. Fritton

CRITICAL

Case law submitted for the Court's consideration must be provided at least 48 hours before the proceeding.

Said case law shall be submitted to the Court a minimum of 48 hours in advance of the proceeding date in order to give sufficient time for the Court to review same.

Judge Joel D. Fritton

CRITICAL

Counsel must request a hearing interpreter through the Fifth Circuit website's online form at least seven days before the proceeding.

If an Interpreter will be needed for any hearing, a request must be submitted by counsel through the Fifth Circuit website at www.circuit5.org, using the online form provided at least seven (7) days prior to the proceeding.

Judge Joel D. Fritton

CRITICAL

A waiver of appearance must be e-filed before the day of the specified court proceeding.

Said Waiver of Appearance shall be signed by the defendant and e-filed prior to the day of the proceeding.

Judge Joel D. Fritton

CRITICALCivil cases

A hearing must be requested immediately upon filing an objection, and failure to set the objection for immediate hearing constitutes abandonment of the examination request.

A hearing must be immediately requested on any objection filed. Failure to set the objection for immediate hearing will be deemed an “Abandonment of the Request” under the rules.

Judge Lisa Herndon

CRITICALCivil cases

Objections to a compulsory examination must be filed within 30 days of the written request, assuming process was served at least 15 days before service of the request.

Objections to “Examination of Persons” under Fla. R. Civ. P. 1.360(a)(1)(A) must be filed no later than 30 days from the written request assuming service of process has occurred at least 15 days prior to the request being served.

Judge Lisa Herndon

CRITICAL

A motion for summary judgment may be filed after 20 days from commencement of the action, and service must occur at least 40 days before the hearing.

Filing and Service Filing shall be any time Filing shall be any time of Motions for after the expiration of 20 after the expiration of 20 days from the days from the Summary commencement of the commencement of the Judgment action action Service at least 40 days Service at least 40 days before the time fixed for before the time fixed for the hearing the hearing

Judge Lisa Herndon

CRITICALCivil cases

Deadline
5 business days

Case law and exhibits must be emailed to swaldron@circuit5.org at least five business days before the hearing.

If you have case law or exhibits to provide, please send them to swaldron@circuit5.org, at least 5 business days prior to the hearing, to allow time for the Court’s review prior to the hearing.

Judge Lisa Herndon

CRITICALCivil cases

An untimely motion in limine or response will not be considered by the Court.

Any filings (either Motions or Responses) that are untimely, in accordance with this provision will not be considered by this Court.

Judge Peter M. Brigham

CRITICALCivil cases

A stipulated motion in limine must be filed before the pre-trial conference.

A) Any Motions in Limine that are stipulated to between the parties (after meeting) shall be filed with an agreed upon PROPOSED ORDER granting the relief requested for this Court's consideration and signature PRIOR TO PRE-TRIAL.

Judge Peter M. Brigham