Court-wide rules
Applies court-wideThese 98 rules apply across New York Supreme Court, Bronx County. Where this judge's own standing orders above address the same topic, the judge's requirement controls.
Filing Requirements
All 29- Applies to
- Agreement to mediate
In matrimonial presumptive mediation cases, all parties or their attorneys must complete the agreement to mediate, upload it to NYSCEF, and email a copy to the Matrimonial ADR Coordinator.
- Applies to
- Agreement to mediate
In non-matrimonial presumptive mediation cases, all parties or their attorneys must complete the agreement to mediate, upload it to NYSCEF, and email a copy to the ADR Department.
- Applies to
- Working copy
Each covered document must first be filed through NYSCEF, after which its working copy delivered to the Part must have a firmly affixed, outward-facing copy of the related NYSCEF Notice on the back page; the Part will not accept a working copy without that notice.
E-Filing
All 18- Applies to
- Agreement to mediate
The completed agreement to mediate must be submitted through NYSCEF, with an additional copy emailed to BXSUPADR@nycourts.gov.
- Applies to
- Agreement to mediate
The completed matrimonial agreement to mediate must be submitted through NYSCEF, with an additional copy emailed to BXSUPADRMAT@NYCourts.gov.
A motion on notice or notice of petition in a New York Supreme Court e-filed case must be filed through NYSCEF.
Filing Timing
All 18- Deadline
- 3 business days
The supporting papers and proof of hard-copy service must be e-filed within three business days after service.
After filing through NYSCEF and paying the motion fee, the Motion Support Office automatically calendars the matter, and the filer need not take further action.
Proof of Service of the Orders to Show Cause, as well as any interposed Counterclaims or Answers, shall be e-filed with NYSCEF or filed with the Court in cases that are not e- filed, and may also be emailed to bxsup-electionmatters@nycourts.gov on or before April 22, 2024, by 9:30 a.m.
Adjournments
All 10A compliant motion adjournment may be obtained by filing a stipulation of all parties through NYSCEF using the designated Stipulation to Adjourn Motion filing.
A non-stipulated adjournment or notice request is sent to Chambers for judicial decision, and the requesting attorney must notify the adversary of the result.
An adjournment of the hearing's commencement requires compelling reasons and approval from both the Referee and the referring Justice.
- Part: Part IA-15
Are courtesy copies required for Judge Ben Barbato?
Chambers does not require working copies of electronically filed motion papers.
Does Judge Ben Barbato require a pre-motion conference or letter before filing a motion?
Motions are ordinarily decided on submission unless the court specifically schedules oral argument or a conference by Microsoft Teams.
What must be included with note of issue filings before Judge Ben Barbato?
A Note of Issue may not be filed unless it is fully stipulated or the court grants leave through its Law Clerk.
What must be included with pretrial notice filings before Judge Ben Barbato?
A notice requesting a pretrial conference must be signed or agreed to by all parties.
How may parties contact Judge Ben Barbato's chambers?
The rule lists email PARTIA15@nycourts.gov. Every email to the Court must copy all other parties; ex parte communications are not accepted and noncompliant emails may be deleted without response.
How do I request an adjournment or extension before Judge Ben Barbato?
Failure to contact the court before the scheduled pretrial conference date causes the conference to be administratively adjourned to a future date.
Is electronic filing required before Judge Ben Barbato?
Yes. Electronic filing is required for the covered filings. When discovery issues are fully resolved, the parties must e-file a fully executed stipulation on NYSCEF and email a copy to Part 15 with the specified subject-line format.
What filing deadlines does Judge Ben Barbato set?
A motion for summary judgment is due sixty days after the Note of Issue is filed, and the parties may not stipulate to extend that period.
Complete rules summary for Judge Ben Barbato
When discovery issues are fully resolved, the parties must e-file a fully executed stipulation on NYSCEF and email a copy to Part 15 with the specified subject-line format.
Stipulations must be uploaded to NYSCEF; an acceptable stipulation will be so ordered and sent to the clerk for NYSCEF upload.
If all parties agree discovery is complete, they must file the fully executed stipulation on NYSCEF, or email it to Part 15 in non-electronic cases, by the scheduled status/compliance conference date.
A Note of Issue may not be filed unless it is fully stipulated or the court grants leave through its Law Clerk.
Every email to the Court must copy all other parties; ex parte communications are not accepted and noncompliant emails may be deleted without response.
When parties reasonably disagree that discovery remains outstanding, they may request an accelerated compliance conference by emailing the Court’s Law Clerks.
Failure to contact the court before the scheduled pretrial conference date causes the conference to be administratively adjourned to a future date.
A notice requesting a pretrial conference must be signed or agreed to by all parties.
A request for an accelerated compliance conference must identify the specific discovery disagreement and the good-faith efforts to resolve it.
A settlement-conference request must include the case name, index number, and attorneys’ names and contact phone numbers.
Motions are ordinarily decided on submission unless the court specifically schedules oral argument or a conference by Microsoft Teams.
To request a settlement conference, the parties must confer with one another and email the request to Part 15.
Chambers does not require working copies of electronically filed motion papers.
A motion for summary judgment is due sixty days after the Note of Issue is filed, and the parties may not stipulate to extend that period.
Any email sent to the court about a motion must copy all other parties in the case.
The parties must contact the court immediately about developments affecting resolution of a pending motion.
The discovery-completion stipulation must certify that discovery is complete and provide for filing the Note of Issue.
On or before the designated Pre-trial Conference date, the parties shall e-file (if the matter is an e-file case) and e-mail a notice to the Court (PARTIA15@nycourts.gov) indicating whether the parties (1) are requesting a pre-trial virtual settlement conference before the Judge; (2) are agreeing to binding arbitration, a summary jury trial, or a virtual bench trial, (3) have agreed to settle the matter, including the settlement amount if not confidential; or (4) are advising that none of the above applies, and there are no outstanding pre-trial issues in the matter that require Court intervention/resolution.
In addition, please disclose the insurance policy limits for the defendant(s).
Settlement conferences are conducted virtually through Microsoft Teams.

