New York Supreme Court, Bronx County Pre-Motion Conference Requirements
84 rules, 1 to 50 shown
Pre-motion conference and letter requirements before filing motions, including sequential steps.
Rules 1 to 50
Mandatory
Unless otherwise directed, the moving party shall try to resolve contemplated non-dispositive motion practice informally through a telephone or virtual conference with the Special Referee. The moving party shall involve this informal resolution process by written notice to the Referee and all parties. The moving party must also contact the Referee to schedule a phone or virtual conference on the application.
Unless otherwise directed, the moving party shall try to resolve contemplated non-dispositive motion practice informally through a telephone or virtual conference with the Special Referee. The moving party shall involve this informal resolution process by written notice to the Referee and all parties. The moving party must also contact the Referee to schedule a phone or virtual conference on the application.
Mandatory
Unless the referring Justice directs otherwise, the parties must schedule a phone or virtual conference with the Referee to establish the procedure for filing a formal motion.
Unless the referring Justice directs otherwise, the parties shall schedule a phone or virtual conference with the Referee to set the procedure for filing a formal motion under the circumstances.
MandatoryCivil cases
No motions in this Part may be submitted without oral argument, and every motion must be orally argued without exception.
There are NO SUBMITTED MOTIONS IN THIS PART, AND ALL MOTIONS WITHOUT EXCEPTION MUST BE ORALLY ARGUED.
Judge Alison TuittPage 2, section III. Oral ArgumentsMandatoryCivil cases
A discovery-related motion filed before the Motion Scheduling Order is issued will be denied.
Discovery-related motions made prior to the Motion Scheduling Order being issued will be denied.
Judge Alison TuittPage 2, section 2. Discovery MotionsMandatoryCivil cases
Before filing any discovery-related motion, parties must request both a Discovery Conference and a Motion Scheduling Order from the Court.
Parties shall request a Discovery Conference with the Court AND a Motion Scheduling Order BEFORE the filing of any discovery-related motion (BxSupCiv-IA5@nycourts.gov).
Judge Alison TuittPage 2, section 2. Discovery MotionsMandatoryCivil cases
All discovery-related conferences must be held in person without exception.
All discovery-related conferences will be heard in person without exception.
Judge Alison TuittPage 2, section 2. Discovery MotionsMandatoryCivil cases
Before filing a discovery-related motion, counsel must make good-faith efforts to resolve the dispute and then seek a conference with the Court.
Prior to the submission of any motions on discovery-related matters, counsels must first seek a conference with the Court to resolve discovery disputes. Prior to seeking a conference with the Court, parties must make good faith efforts to resolve disputes without Court intervention.
Judge Bianka PerezPage 3, section V. Motions — A. DiscoveryMandatoryCivil cases
A discovery motion must be supported by counsel's affidavit or affirmation and requires the Court's permission to file.
Discovery motions shall be supported by an affidavit or affirmation from counsel, as set forth in 22 NYCRR 202.20-f and require permission from the Court.
Judge Bianka PerezPage 3, section V. Motions — A. DiscoveryMandatoryCivil cases
Oral argument is mandatory for discovery-dispute motions and must follow full submission of the motion to the Motion Support Office.
Oral argument of motions regarding disclosure disputes are mandatory and, after the motion is fully submitted in the Motion Support Office, Room 217, shall be scheduled and held in person in Part 30 on Thursdays or Fridays at 9:30 a.m. or 2:30 p.m.
Judge Erik L. GrayPage 3, section ORAL ARGUMENTMandatory
Before filing a discovery motion, a party must request a pre-motion conference by filing a letter request to NYSCEF and emailing it to the listed chambers address.
Prior to filing a discovery motion, parties shall request a pre-motion conference via letter request filed to NYSCEF and e-mailed to BxSupCiv-IA17@nycourts.gov.
Judge Erin Noelle GuvenPage 8, section Discovery MotionsMandatory
Filing a motion does not stay discovery; any discovery stay must be requested in a separate request.
The filing of any motion shall NOT stay discovery. A stay of discovery must be requested separately.
Judge Erin Noelle GuvenPage 8, section Other Guidance on MotionsMandatory
The discovery pre-motion letter must identify the specific disputes and describe the parties' good-faith resolution efforts.
The letter shall set forth the specific discovery issue(s) to be addressed at the conference and the details of their good faith efforts to resolve the dispute prior to seeking Court intervention.
Judge Erin Noelle GuvenPage 8, section Discovery MotionsMandatory
Failure to comply with the cited discovery-conference requirements results in denial without prejudice and may be renewed with proper papers.
Failure to adhere to either section will result in denial of the motion, without prejudice to renew on proper papers.
Judge Erin Noelle GuvenPage 8, section Discovery MotionsMandatory
Parties must first attempt to resolve discovery disputes through informal procedures rather than motion practice.
Parties shall attempt to resolve all discovery disputes through informal procedures, as opposed to motion practice, pursuant to 22 NYCRR §202.20-f[a].
Judge Erin Noelle GuvenPage 8, section Discovery MotionsMandatory
Each party ordinarily receives only one opportunity to move for summary judgment unless sufficient justification is shown or the court previously authorizes another opportunity.
Unless sufficient justification is demonstrated, or unless expressly authorized by the Court in a prior order, each party shall be afforded only one opportunity to make a motion for summary judgment.
Judge Erin Noelle GuvenPage 7, section Summary Judgment MotionsMandatory
The Court will schedule an in-person oral-argument appearance for every compliant discovery motion.
The Court will schedule an in-person appearance for oral argument on ALL discovery motions made in compliance with these rules.
Judge Erin Noelle GuvenPage 8, section Discovery MotionsMandatory
A discovery motion may not be combined with a request for other relief.
Discovery motions shall not be combined with requests for any other relief.
Judge Erin Noelle GuvenPage 8, section Discovery MotionsMandatoryCivil cases
A discovery motion filed without a prior Rule 14 Conference will be held in abeyance until the conference occurs.
Discovery motions made absent a prior Rule 14 Conference will be held in abeyance until such a conference is held.
Judge Fidel GomezPage 5, section DISCOVERY DISPUTESMandatoryCivil cases
Orders to Show Cause are generally returnable on Wednesdays, other than court holidays or as otherwise indicated, and appearances are required.
All Orders to Show Cause are returnable on Wednesdays, except for court holidays, unless otherwise indicated. Appearances are required.
Judge Fidel GomezPage 8, section Motions Brought by Order to Show CauseMandatoryCivil cases
Before seeking a Rule 14 Conference, the parties must consult in good faith to resolve their discovery disputes.
Pursuant to Commercial Division Rule 14, the parties must first consult with one another in a good faith effort to resolve all discovery disputes.
Judge Fidel GomezPage 5, section DISCOVERY DISPUTESMandatoryCivil cases
Before seeking judicial intervention, the parties must consult in good faith to try to resolve all discovery disputes.
Accordingly, pursuant to 22 NYCRR 202.20-f(b), before seeking judicial intervention, the parties must first consult with one another in a good faith effort to resolve all discovery disputes.
Judge Fidel GomezPage 5, section DISCOVERY DISPUTESMandatoryCivil cases
Discovery motions filed before a conference with the Court are held in abeyance until the conference occurs.
In the spirit of 22 NYCRR 202.20-f(a), discovery motions made prior to a conference with the Court will be held in abeyance until such conference is held.
Judge Fidel GomezPage 5, section DISCOVERY DISPUTESMandatoryCivil cases
An order-to-show-cause application must demonstrate a need for exigent or urgent relief or it will not be signed.
22 NYCRR 202.8-d is strictly enforced and an application brought by Order to Show Cause that fails to demonstrate that exigent or urgent relief is required will be not be signed.
Judge Fidel GomezPage 8, section Motions Brought by Order to Show CauseMandatoryCivil cases
If good-faith efforts do not resolve a discovery dispute, the parties must submit a Rule 14 Conference request letter describing the dispute and resolution efforts through NYSCEF.
If a dispute cannot be resolved after such good faith effort, the parties must submit a letter requesting a Rule 14 conference and advising the Court of the nature of the dispute and the efforts made to resolve it. The request must be submitted to the Court via NYSCEF.
Judge Fidel GomezPage 5, section DISCOVERY DISPUTESMandatoryCivil cases
If good-faith consultation fails, the party seeking judicial intervention must submit a letter requesting a conference and describing the dispute and resolution efforts.
If a dispute cannot be resolved after such good faith effort, the parties must follow the protocol prescribed by Commercial Division Rule 14 (202 NYCRR 202.70), which, inter alia, requires that the party seeking judicial intervention submit a letter requesting a conference and advising the Court of the nature of the dispute and the efforts made to resolve it.
Judge Fidel GomezPage 5, section DISCOVERY DISPUTESMandatoryCivil cases
A sur-reply may not be submitted without leave of court.
No sur-replies shall be submitted absent leave of court.
Judge Fidel GomezPage 7, section General Motion RulesMandatoryCivil cases
Commercial Division Rule 24 procedure must be followed before a qualifying motion, but it does not apply to Rule 24(b) motions or CPLR § 3215 motions.
The procedure prescribed by Commercial Division Rule 24 must be followed before any qualifying motion is made, including those promulgated by Rules 14 and 24. This Rule shall not apply to motions listed in Rule 24(b) and those made pursuant to CPLR § 3215.
Judge Fidel GomezPage 6, section MOTION PROCEDUREMandatory
Before filing a discovery motion, the parties must follow 22 NYCRR 202.20-f; if the dispute persists, they must seek a Tuesday pre-motion conference by email with a letter describing the issues and resolution attempts.
With respect to any discovery-related disputes, the parties will adhere to 22 NYCRR 202.20-f before filing a motion; if the dispute persists, the parties shall make an application for a pre-motion conference, which will be scheduled on the Tuesday calendar for the part. Such applications shall be made via email to fserrano@nycourts.gov. The parties shall attach a letter to said email specifying the issues and attempts made to resolve such disputes.
Judge Marissa SotoPage 5, section DISCOVERYMandatory
A motion to withdraw as counsel will not be decided unless there is a noticed appearance before the Court.
No motions to withdraw as counsel will be decided without a noticed appearance before the Court.
Judge Marissa SotoPage 9, section MOTIONS TO WITHDRAW AS COUNSEL BROUGHT BY NOTICE OF MOTIONMandatory
Email exchange alone is insufficient unless the affirmation documents the communication history or the other party’s refusal to communicate by telephone, virtually, or in person.
Emails alone do not satisfy the requirements of 22 NYCRR 202.20-f, unless the affirmation includes a history or an indication that the non-complying party has refused to communicate over the phone, virtually, or in-person.
Judge Mary Ann BriganttiPage 7, section 3. Discovery Motions & ConferencesMandatory
A conference ordinarily requires a telephone, virtual, or in-person meeting with the party from whom discovery is requested.
A party has not fulfilled its obligation to confer pursuant to 22 NYCRR 202.20-f unless they have spoken over the phone or have met virtually or in-person with the party from whom the moving party is requesting discovery.
Judge Mary Ann BriganttiPage 7, section 3. Discovery Motions & ConferencesMandatory
A party may file a discovery motion only after conferring in good faith with the party from whom discovery is sought.
A Discovery Motion shall only be made after the parties have conferred in good faith.
Judge Mary Ann BriganttiPage 7, section 3. Discovery Motions & ConferencesMandatory
Discovery motions are highly discouraged and may be filed only with the Court’s permission after the required steps and a conference with the Court.
Discovery motions are highly discouraged and require the Court’s permission to file. The parties may not file a discovery motion prior to following the above steps and conferencing with the Court.
Judge Mary Lynn Nicolas-BrewsterPage 9, section E. DiscoveryMandatory
Each discovery action must include a preliminary conference and compliance conference, additional status conferences as needed, and the parties must consult before each such conference.
Every action shall have one preliminary conference (“P.C.”), one compliance conference (“C.C.”), and as many status conferences as are necessary, and parties shall consult prior to all preliminary, compliance, or status conferences, pursuant to 22 NYCRR 202.11.
Judge Matthew Parker-RasoPage 3, section Consultation Prior to Preliminary, Compliance & Status ConferenceMandatory
The parties must appear at a preliminary conference if the Part Clerk does not receive a completed proposed order at least two business days beforehand.
Appearances on all P.C.’s are required if a completed proposed P.C. Order is not received by the part clerk at least two (2) business days prior to the scheduled P.C.
Judge Matthew Parker-RasoPage 3, section Consultation Prior to Preliminary, Compliance & Status ConferenceMandatory
In-person appearances are mandatory at all compliance and status conferences.
In Person appearances at all Compliance Conferences and Status Conferences are mandatory.
Judge Matthew Parker-RasoPage 3, section Consultation Prior to Preliminary, Compliance & Status ConferenceMandatoryCivil cases
After unsuccessful good-faith efforts, the parties must apply by email for a pre-motion conference that states the nature of the discovery dispute and the applicable law.
If the parties are unable to resolve a discovery dispute after good faith efforts, an application shall be made for a pre-motion conference to discuss the discovery dispute and all other discovery issues in the case. The application shall be made via e-mail to BXMEDMAL-IA34@nycourts.gov and shall state the nature of the discovery dispute and the applicable law relative thereto.
Judge Michael FrishmanPage 4, section Discovery Motion RulesMandatoryCivil cases
When good-faith efforts fail to resolve a discovery dispute, the parties must apply for a pre-motion conference addressing the dispute and related discovery issues.
If the parties are unable to resolve a discovery dispute after good faith efforts, an application shall be made for a pre-motion conference to discuss the discovery dispute and all other discovery issues in the case.
Judge Naita SemajPage 3, section Discovery MotionsMandatoryCivil cases
Discovery motions are highly discouraged and require court permission; counsel must make good-faith efforts to resolve disputes and seek a court conference before filing a discovery motion.
Discovery Motions are highly discouraged and require the Court’s permission to file. Pursuant to 22 NYCRR 202.20-f, discovery disputes should be resolved through informal procedures, such as conferences, to the maximum extent possible. Prior to the submission of any motions on discovery-related matters, counsels must first seek a conference with the Court to resolve discovery disputes. Prior to seeking a conference with the Court, parties must make good faith efforts to resolve disputes without Court intervention.
Judge Paul AlpertPage 4, section Discovery MotionsMandatoryCivil cases
Every discovery motion requires oral argument.
All discovery motions shall require oral argument.
Judge Paul AlpertPage 4, section Discovery MotionsMandatoryCivil cases
Parties should resolve discovery disputes through informal procedures and must seek a court conference before filing any discovery-related motion.
To the maximum extent possible, discovery disputes should be resolved through informal procedures, such as conferences, as opposed to motion practice (22 NYCRR 202.20-f [a]). Parties shall seek a conference with the Court BEFORE the filing of any discovery-related motion (BxSupCiv-IA35@nycourts.gov).
Judge Raymond P. FernandezPage 3, section a. Discovery MotionsMandatory
A party must file an RJI for a motion under CPLR §3211 and may file an RJI after service of process to request a preliminary conference.
A party must file an RJI, for any motion filed pursuant to CPLR §3211 or a party may file an RJI at any time after service of process to request a Preliminary Conference.
Judge Shawn T. KellyPage 2, section REQUEST FOR JUDICIAL INTERVENTION (RJI)MandatoryCivil cases
Parties must request a conference before filing any discovery motion.
As with all other motions, parties must request a conference prior to filing any discovery motions.
Judge Veronica Romero GuerreroPage 2, section Compliance ConferencesMandatoryCivil cases
All motions must be brought by Order to Show Cause, and parties must request a conference before filing motion papers; good-faith consultation with one another is strongly suggested.
ALL MOTIONS SHALL BE BY ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE Parties must request a conference prior to filing any motion papers to allow the opportunity to resolve the matter. It is strongly suggested that parties consult one another in a good faith effort to resolve any disputes prior to requesting a conference with the Court.
Judge Veronica Romero GuerreroPage 2, section MotionsMandatoryCivil cases
Oral argument is required for every Order to Show Cause unless the court directs otherwise.
Oral argument is required on all Orders to Show Cause unless otherwise directed by the Court.
Judge Veronica Romero GuerreroPage 2, section MotionsMandatory
When court intervention is necessary after a good-faith discovery effort, the parties must file an NYSCEF letter requesting an in-person discovery conference and briefly describe the issue.
If, after making a good faith effort to resolve any discovery dispute, intervention of the Court is necessary, the parties shall file a letter to NYSCEF requesting a discovery conference containing a brief description of the issue. Discovery conferences are held in-person.
Judge Wilma GuzmanPage 8, section VIII. DISCOVERY MOTIONSMandatory
A discovery motion may not be filed until the parties have attempted to resolve the dispute and participated in a court pre-motion conference.
Discovery motions may not be filed until the parties have (i) conferred to attempt to resolve the dispute pursuant to 22 NYCRR § 202.7(a)(2), and (ii) participated in a pre-motion conference with the Court.
Judge Wilma GuzmanPage 8, section VIII. DISCOVERY MOTIONSMandatory
A discovery motion requires a prior request for a pre-motion conference.
Discovery motions may not be filed without first requesting a pre-motion conference.
Judge Wilma GuzmanPage 8, section VIII. DISCOVERY MOTIONSImportantCivil cases
A discovery-dispute pre-motion conference application should be emailed to the Court and state the dispute's nature and applicable law.
The application should be made via email to BxSupCiv-IA19A-30@nycourts.gov, state the nature of the discovery dispute and the applicable law relative thereto.
Judge Alicia GerezPage 2, section Disclosure DisputesImportantCivil cases
Before filing a discovery motion, counsel should consult in good faith to try to resolve the discovery dispute.
Prior to making a discovery motion, Counsel should consult one another in a good faith effort to resolve any discovery disputes in compliance with Uniform Rule § 202.7(a)(2).
Judge Alicia GerezPage 2, section Disclosure Disputes
Common questions about New York Supreme Court, Bronx County pre-motion conference requirements
Does New York Supreme Court, Bronx County require a pre-motion conference or letter before filing a motion?
New York Supreme Court, Bronx County: Unless otherwise directed, the moving party shall try to resolve contemplated non-dispositive motion practice informally through a telephone or virtual conference with the Special Referee. The moving party shall involve this informal resolution process by written notice to the Referee and all parties. The moving party must also contact the Referee to schedule a phone or virtual conference on the application.
Judge Veronica Romero Guerrero: Parties must request a conference before filing any discovery motion.
Judge Alison Tuitt: No motions in this Part may be submitted without oral argument, and every motion must be orally argued without exception.
81 more rules answer this question.