New York Supreme Court, Monroe County Document Filing Requirements
102 rules, 1 to 50 shown
Required elements, certificates, and structural requirements for court documents.
Rules 1 to 50
MandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Notice of motion
Notices of motion in Foreclosure Special Term must state that the motion is on submission only, unless the court indicates otherwise.
All motions in Foreclosure Special Term are on submission only unless otherwise indicated by the court, and all notices of motion shall so state.
MandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Deposition objections
Failure to comply with the order waives trial objections to the proposed testimony and may result in preclusion of non-designated testimony.
The failure to comply with this Order shall waive any trial objections to the proposed testimony, and result in the preclusion of any non-designated testimony.
Judge Daniel J. DoylePage 19, section General RulesMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Deposition objections
Written objections to deposition testimony must be provided to the court and opposing counsel at least seven days before the Pretrial Conference or they will be waived.
objections to deposition testimony shall be made in writing and provided to the Court and opposing counsel no later than seven (7) days prior to the Pretrial Conference scheduled herein, or will be deemed waived.
Judge Daniel J. DoylePage 19, section General RulesMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Order to show cause
A copy of each case cited in the supporting memorandum of law must be attached to the application.
Copies of the cases cited in the application’s supporting Memorandum of Law must be attached thereto.
Judge Daniel J. DoylePage 20, section General RulesMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Trial memorandum
Each party must submit a concise but comprehensive trial memorandum addressing every anticipated question of law, with copies of cited cases attached.
Each party shall submit a trial memorandum of law to the Court and opposing counsel. The memorandum shall be brief, but comprehensive, and must address each question of law that the party expects to arise at trial. Copies of the cases cited in the memorandum shall be attached thereto.
Judge Daniel J. DoylePage 19, section General RulesMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Case information statement
The opposing parties must complete any missing relevant information and submit it at least two days before the scheduled conference.
The opposing party or parties shall complete the relevant information below not already completed and submit at least two (2) days in advance of the scheduled conference.
Judge Daniel J. DoylePage 11, section APPENDIX AMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Video testimony objections
Written objections to proposed video testimony must be provided to the court and opposing counsel at least seven days before the Pretrial Conference or they will be waived.
Any objections thereto shall be made in writing and provided to the Court and opposing counsel no later than seven (7) days prior to the Pretrial Conference scheduled herein, or will be deemed waived.
Judge Daniel J. DoylePage 19, section General RulesMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Scheduling order amendment request
- Must include
- proposed order
A request to extend or amend the Scheduling Order must be accompanied by a proposed amended scheduling order.
A request for extension or amendment of the Scheduling Order MUST be made by letter request to the Court, on notice to opposing counsel, at least ten (10) business days in advance of the date to be extended, and it also MUST be accompanied by a proposed Amended Scheduling Order.
Judge Daniel J. DoylePage 7, section RULE # 13 - Adherence to Discovery Schedule.MandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Motion in limine
Each party must submit motions in limine with a memorandum addressing every anticipated question of law or unique evidentiary issue.
Each party shall submit any motions in limine and a memorandum that addresses each question of law or unique evidentiary issue that the party expects to arise at trial.
Judge Daniel J. DoylePage 20, section General RulesMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Proposed order
A proposed order that references an attached decision must include that decision, and all proposed orders must be filed electronically.
(h) Proposed Orders. When submitting proposed orders that specifically reference an attached decision, said decision must be included therewith. ALL PROPOSED ORDERS MUST BE E-FILED. With e-filing you may also send a copy in either Word or WordPerfect format to the Court.
Judge Daniel J. DoylePage 7, section Proposed OrdersMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Exhibits
Each exhibit uploaded to NYSCEF must have a short description of the actual item rather than merely the exhibit letter or number.
Exhibits uploaded to NYSCEF must be done on an individualized basis [not all in one PDF] with a short description of the actual item [not just a repetition of the Exhibit letter or number].
Judge Daniel J. DoylePage 5, section IV. Local Commercial Rules — RULE #’s 4 & 21 - Electronic Submission of Papers / Courtesy CopiesMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Notice of motion
Every notice of motion must be submitted with the return date left blank so the Court can assign a Special Term date.
All Notices of Motions MUST be submitted with blank return dates to permit the Court to assign a Special Term date.
Judge Daniel J. DoylePage 6, section IV. Local Commercial Rules — (b) Form of Motion Papers and return datesMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Exhibits
A motion may not use a condensed or excerpted transcript as an exhibit; any cited transcript must be provided in full, and noncompliant submissions will be rejected.
Condensed or excerpted transcripts are NOT permitted as motion exhibits. Full transcripts must be provided as exhibits when cited to by the parties. Noncompliant submissions will be rejected.
Judge Daniel J. DoylePage 6, section IV. Local Commercial Rules — (e) Condensed or excerpted transcriptsMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Video testimony objections
Failure to comply with the order waives all trial objections to the proposed video testimony.
The failure to comply with this Order shall waive any trial objections to the proposed video testimony.
Judge Daniel J. DoylePage 19, section General RulesMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Video testimony
Each party must provide the court with a copy of proposed video-recorded testimony and a transcript.
Each party shall provide the Court with a copy of any proposed video-recorded testimony along with a transcript thereof.
Judge Daniel J. DoylePage 19, section General RulesMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Amended scheduling order
A proposed amended scheduling order must contain the specified language concerning the Note of Issue, dismissal from the calendar, restoration procedures, and the additional affidavit required for restoration after one year.
The proposed Amended Scheduling Order must contain the following language: ORDERED, that a Note of Issue and Statement of Readiness is to be filed on or before __________, 202__. FAILURE OF THE PLAINTIFF TO FILE A NOTE OF ISSUE AND CERTIFICATE OF READINESS BY THE DATE PROVIDED HEREIN WILL RESULT IN THIS MATTER BEING DEEMED STRICKEN "OFF" THE COURT'S CALENDAR WITHOUT FURTHER NOTICE PURSUANT TO 22 NYCRR § 202.27. If so dismissed, the case may be restored without motion within one year of such dismissal by: (1) the filing of a Note of Issue and Certificate of Readiness; and, (2) the forwarding of a copy thereof with a letter requesting restoration to the Court's Assignment Clerk. Also, restoration after one year shall, before the filing of a Note of Issue and Certificate of Readiness, require the additional documentation of a sworn affidavit by a person with knowledge showing a reasonable excuse for the delay, a meritorious cause of action, a lack of prejudice to the defendant, and the absence of intent to abandon the case. 7
Judge Daniel J. DoylePage 7, section RULE # 13 - Adherence to Discovery Schedule.MandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Case information statement
The party requesting the preliminary conference must prepare and submit the Case Information Statement on notice to the opposing parties, concurrently with the RJI for cases already assigned to Justice Doyle or within seven days after chambers notifies the party that assignment and scheduling have occurred.
This statement shall be prepared by the party requesting the preliminary conference and submitted – on notice to the opposing party or parties - concurrently with the RJI for cases already assigned to Justice Doyle, or within seven (7) days of notification from chambers that the case has been assigned to Justice Doyle and the conference has been scheduled.
Judge Daniel J. DoylePage 11, section APPENDIX AMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Case information statement
- Must include
- caption, judge name, case number
The requesting party must prepare and submit a Case Information Statement, with notice to the opposing party, by the applicable submission deadline.
A Case Information Statement shall be prepared by the party requesting the preliminary conference and submitted – on notice to the opposing party – with the request for cases already assigned to Justice Doyle, or within seven (7) days of notification from chambers that the case has been assigned to Justice Doyle and the conference has been scheduled by chambers.
Judge Daniel J. DoylePage 3, section II. Pretrial ConferencesMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Exhibits
An item already in NYSCEF becomes part of the motion record only if added as a motion exhibit or expressly incorporated by reference.
Items already in NYSCEF are not part of the motion record unless added as motion exhibits, or at the very least expressly incorporated by reference.
Judge Daniel J. DoylePage 5, section IV. Local Commercial Rules — RULE #’s 4 & 21 - Electronic Submission of Papers / Courtesy CopiesMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Exhibit list
- Must include
- exhibit list
Each party must mark its exhibits and submit a list identifying all exhibits and those stipulated into evidence.
Each party shall mark all exhibits (numbers for plaintiff; letters for defendant) and shall submit to the Court and opposing counsel a list of all such exhibits indicating which exhibits are stipulated into evidence.
Judge Daniel J. DoylePage 19, section General RulesMandatory
- Applies to
- Notice of motion
A notice of motion must specify the exact relief requested.
The movant must specify in the notice of motion or order to show cause the exact relief counsel seeks.
Judge Elena F. CariolaPage 5, section IV. Motion Practice — A. General ProceduresMandatory
- Applies to
- Case information sheet
The party requesting the preliminary conference must prepare a Case Information Sheet and, for an already assigned case, submit it on notice to the opposing party concurrently with the RJI.
A Case Information Sheet shall be prepared by the party requesting the preliminary conference and submitted- on notice to the opposing party – concurrently with the RJI for cases already assigned to Justice Cariola, or within seven (7) days of notification from chambers that the case has been assigned to Justice Cariola and the conference has been scheduled.
Judge Elena F. CariolaPage 3, section II. Pretrial ConferencesMandatory
- Applies to
- Proposed findings decision or referees report
All cases require proposed findings and a decision when the Judicial Services Center took default testimony, or a referee's report of findings of fact and conclusions of law when the referee took the testimony or will review testimonial affidavits.
20) Proposed Findings/Decision (if J.S.C. took default testimony) or Referee’s Report of Findings of Fact & Conclusions of Law (if referee took default testimony or will review testimonial affidavits) (all cases).
Judge Elena F. CariolaPage 28Mandatory
- Applies to
- Testimonial affidavit or oral testimony
The testimonial affidavit or testimony must enable the court to make the 13 factual findings concerning equitable distribution.
□ b) enabling court to make the 13 factual findings regarding equitable distribution;
Judge Elena F. CariolaPage 27Mandatory
- Applies to
- County clerk certificate of filing
When conversion divorce is sought, a County Clerk's Certificate of Filing a Separation Agreement or Decree is required.
NA 16) County Clerk’s Certificate of Filing Separation Agreement or Decree (whenever conversion divorce is sought) (DRL § 170[6]).
Judge Elena F. CariolaPage 27Mandatory
- Applies to
- Motions in limine
Failure to timely submit a motion in limine or objection waives that motion or objection.
The failure to comply with this Order shall waive any motions in limine or objections thereto.
Judge Elena F. CariolaPage 21, section Motions in Limine and Memorandum of LawMandatory
- Applies to
- Separation agreement or oral stipulation
When they exist, the submission must include the separation agreement or the transcript of oral stipulation, the affidavit concerning appearance and adoption, and all modifications made by valid marital agreement.
15) Separation Agreement OR Transcript of Oral Stipulation and Affidavit of Appearance and Adoption of Oral Stipulation, plus all modifications by valid marital agreement (whenever they exist).
Judge Elena F. CariolaPage 27Mandatory
- Applies to
- Proposed judgment or decree
A proposed judgment or decree conforming to 22 NYCRR § 202.50(b), Appendix A-2, is required in all cases.
21) Proposed Judgment/Decree (all cases–see 22 NYCRR 202.50[b]-- Appendix A-2, including:
Judge Elena F. CariolaPage 28Mandatory
- Applies to
- Proposed findings decision or referees report
The findings submission must include the Appendix A-2 findings, as appropriate, concerning maintenance, child support, child care, insurance, uncovered medical expenses, education, and other matters supported by the testimonial allegations.
Include findings as approved by 22 NYCRR 202.50 (b) – Appendix A-2, modified as appropriate, including factual findings as to maintenance, child support, child care, health insurance and payment of cost thereto (if child[ren]), health care expenses not covered by insurance, educational expenses, and the other findings based on the allegations required for testimony or testimonial affidavit (see above).
Judge Elena F. CariolaPage 28Mandatory
- Applies to
- Service affidavit or admission
For all cases, a filed Affidavit of Service must include the specified information and proof or acknowledgment of service; an Affidavit of Defendant must state whether Defendant seeks spousal maintenance as payee or note a prior written agreement addressing maintenance.
3) Admission of Service or Affidavit of Service or Affidavit of Defendant/stipulation (all cases). Affidavit of Service must have: Filed: □ a) statement of how affiant knew the person served was defendant (DRL §232 (b), or photo of defendant: and □ b) physical description of person served (CPLR 306); and □ c) date, time and place of service; and □ d) name of person making the service □ e) proof of service of Notice of Guideline Maintenance (or acknowledgment of service of the Notice of Guideline Maintenance); □ f) proof of service of Notice of Automatic Order (or acknowledgment of service) □ j) Affidavit of Defendant: statement that Defendant IS or IS NOT seeking spousal maintenance as payee OR prior written agreement addresses spousal maintenance;
Judge Elena F. CariolaPage 26, section General RulesMandatory
- Applies to
- Testimonial affidavit or oral testimony
The testimonial affidavit or testimony must establish everything required to be alleged in the complaint in all cases.
□ a) establishing everything required to be alleged in complaint - see above (all cases);
Judge Elena F. CariolaPage 27Mandatory
- Applies to
- Testimonial affidavit or oral testimony
In every case with a separation agreement or stipulation, the testimonial submission must support the findings that it was fair and reasonable when made and is not now unconscionable.
□ f) providing information to support a finding that the separation agreement/stipulation was fair and reasonable when made and is not now unconscionable (all cases with a separation agreement/stipulation).
Judge Elena F. CariolaPage 28Mandatory
- Applies to
- Motion
- Must include
- proposed order
For an unopposed motion, the movant must provide a proposed order through NYSCEF in e-filed cases within 14 days of the motion return date.
Should a motion be unopposed, the movant shall provide a proposed order to the Court, via NYSCEF in e-filed matters, within fourteen (14) days of the motion return date.
Judge Elena F. CariolaPage 7, section IV. Motion Practice — C. Motion Orders and DecisionsMandatory
- Applies to
- Proposed judgment or decree
When applicable, the proposed judgment or decree must state terms for custody, visitation, child support, child care, education expenses, health insurance, uncovered medical expenses, and income-deduction orders.
□ a) terms setting forth provisions for custody, visitation, child support, child care, education expenses, health insurance and health care expenses not covered by insurance and income deduction order (in all cases where there are such provisions);
Judge Elena F. CariolaPage 28Mandatory
- Applies to
- Request for judicial intervention
A time-stamped copy of the Request for Judicial Intervention is required in all cases.
12) Copy of Request for Judicial Intervention (all cases). (must be time-stamped)
Judge Elena F. CariolaPage 27Mandatory
- Applies to
- Testimonial affidavit or oral testimony
In minor-child cases proposing deviation from the Child Support Standards Act presumptive amounts and percentages, the testimonial submission must support the ten child-support findings and address the factors substantively; a defaulting defendant must at least allege income or earning capacity.
d) enabling the court to make the child support findings set forth in 22 NYCRR 202.5 (b) - Appendix B modified as appropriate, including 10 factual findings regarding child support (DRL 240[f]) in cases where there are minor child(ren) and child support proposed deviates from the Child Support Standards ===== PAGE 28 ===== Act presumptive amount and percentages (NOTE: Do not just list factors and indicate they were considered); if the Defendant has defaulted, at least an allegation as to defaulting spouse’s income/income earning capacity;
Judge Elena F. CariolaPage 27, section Page 27-28 continuationMandatory
- Applies to
- Affidavit of regularity
An Affidavit of Regularity explaining default or written consent is required in all cases.
Affidavit of Regularity (CPLR 3012, 3215) explaining how matter is in default or that opposing party has consented in writing (all cases);
Judge Elena F. CariolaPage 27Mandatory
- Applies to
- Affidavit of regularity
The Affidavit of Regularity must state that the automatic-order and guideline-maintenance notices were served on the defendant or acknowledged in the defendant's affidavit.
□ statement that Notice of Automatic Orders AND Notice of Guideline Maintenance were served on the Defendant or acknowledged by Defendant in Affidavit of Defendant;
Judge Elena F. CariolaPage 27Mandatory
- Applies to
- Proposed findings decision or referees report
The submission must state that every represented and unrepresented party was informed of the Notice of Guideline Maintenance under DRL § 236(B)(6).
□ a) statement that each party (whether represented or unrepresented) has been informed of the Notice of Guideline Maintenance pursuant to DRL §236(B)(6)
Judge Elena F. CariolaPage 28Mandatory
- Applies to
- Notice of motion
A Notice of Motion must be filed without a return date.
A ‘Notice of Motion’ shall be filed without indicating a return date.
Judge Elena F. CariolaPage 5, section IV. Motion Practice — A. General ProceduresMandatory
- Applies to
- Testimonial affidavit or oral testimony
Each party taking divorce must provide a testimonial affidavit and/or a transcript of oral testimony.
19) Testimonial affidavit and/or oral testimony (transcript) for each party taking divorce:
Judge Elena F. CariolaPage 27Mandatory
- Applies to
- Testimonial affidavit or oral testimony
Without a written custody agreement, the testimonial submission must support a finding that the proposed custody arrangement is in the children's best interests, particularly in a split-custody situation.
□ e) supporting a finding that the custody arrangement proposed is in the child(ren)’s best interests (particularly in split custody situation) if there is no written custody agreement; and
Judge Elena F. CariolaPage 28Mandatory
- Applies to
- Proposed findings decision or referees report
For child support, the submission must address simultaneous issuance of an income-deduction order or income execution, an agreed alternative arrangement, or specific good cause found under DRL § 240(2)(b).
□ b) if child support, a statement that the Court or the Support Collection Unit shall issue an income deduction order or an income execution simultaneously unless the parties have a written agreement for an alternative arrangement OR specified reason(s) that the Court finds to constitute good cause pursuant to DRL § 240(2)(b)
Judge Elena F. CariolaPage 28Mandatory
- Applies to
- Net worth statement
A substantially compliant current net-worth statement is required for each divorcing party, with at least one complete statement and specified income attachments; a defaulting party's statement should be provided if possible.
11) Current Net Worth Statement in substantial compliance with 22 NYCRR 202.16 (Appendix A-1) for each party taking divorce, with net worth statement for defaulting party if possible, but minimum is one complete Statement of Net Worth; must have the required attachments (W-2's, 1099's, recent tax return, recent pay stub, other income statement)
Judge Elena F. CariolaPage 27Mandatory
- Applies to
- Complaint
A case with a summons must file a time-stamped verified complaint containing the specified verification, residency, grounds, relief, marriage, military-status, prior-action, age, child, and spousal-maintenance information.
4) Verified Complaint (all cases with a Summons), containing: (must be time-stamped) □ a) completed verification (DRL §211); Filed: □ b) residency requirements; (DRL §230); □ c) grounds (DRL §170); DRL 170(7) □ d) ancillary relief requested; □ e) statement satisfying DRL §253 or indicating civil marriage makes it inapplicable; ☐ f) opposing party’s military status; ☐ g) statement that no prior judgments or pending actions exist and relief has not been granted in prior action; ☐ h) allegation that both parties are over 18; and ☐ i) names and birth dates of unemancipated children, or that there are no children; □ j) statement that Plaintiff IS or IS NOT seeking spousal maintenance as payee OR prior written agreement addresses spousal maintenance;
Judge Elena F. CariolaPage 26, section General RulesMandatory
- Applies to
- Note of issue and statement of readiness
A copy of the Note of Issue and Statement of Readiness is required in all cases.
13) Copy of Note of Issue and Statement of Readiness (all cases). Filed:
Judge Elena F. CariolaPage 27Mandatory
- Applies to
- Objection to video recorded testimony
Each objection to video testimony must identify the relevant page/line and minute/second and provide a specific basis, with legal support if necessary.
Each objection must delineate the page/line number and minute/second of the video testimony, and provide a specific basis for the objection with legal support if necessary.
Judge Elena F. CariolaPage 22, section Video-Recorded TestimonyMandatory
- Applies to
- Case initiation filing
Every case initiation filing must include a statement on whether oral proof will be offered and a Part 130 certification.
1) Statement as to whether oral proof will be offered AND Part 130 certification (all cases).
Judge Elena F. CariolaPage 26, section General RulesMandatory
- Applies to
- Testimonial affidavit or oral testimony
Absent a written agreement or oral stipulation resolving the issues, the testimonial submission must support the required maintenance findings, guideline information, and grounds for deviation, and a defaulting defendant's submission must at least allege income or earning capacity.
c) enabling court to make the 20 findings regarding maintenance, information for the guidelines calculation and reason(s) for deviation (if applicable); (DRL §236B[5] & [6]); (in all cases where there is no written agreement or oral stipulation specifically resolving these issues); if the Defendant has defaulted, at least an allegation as to defaulting spouse’s income/income earning capacity;
Judge Elena F. CariolaPage 27Mandatory
- Applies to
- Drl 76 h affidavit
A DRL § 76-h affidavit is required when minor children are involved unless the required allegations already appear in the complaint.
8) DRL § 76-h affidavit (whenever there are minor children, but not necessary if such allegations are contained in the complaint).
Judge Elena F. CariolaPage 27
Common questions about New York Supreme Court, Monroe County document filing requirements
What must be included with notice of motion filings in New York Supreme Court, Monroe County?
New York Supreme Court, Monroe County: Notices of motion in Foreclosure Special Term must state that the motion is on submission only, unless the court indicates otherwise.
Judge Elena F. Cariola: A notice of motion must specify the exact relief requested.
Judge Erin S. Skinner: The notice of motion must be filed without a return date.
4 more rules answer this question.
What must be included with case information sheet filings in New York Supreme Court, Monroe County?
Judge Elena F. Cariola: The party requesting the preliminary conference must prepare a Case Information Sheet and, for an already assigned case, submit it on notice to the opposing party concurrently with the RJI.
What must be included with proposed findings decision or referees report filings in New York Supreme Court, Monroe County?
Judge Elena F. Cariola: All cases require proposed findings and a decision when the Judicial Services Center took default testimony, or a referee's report of findings of fact and conclusions of law when the referee took the testimony or will review testimonial affidavits.
5 more rules answer this question.
What must be included with proposed order filings in New York Supreme Court, Monroe County?
Judge Erin S. Skinner: For an unopposed motion, the movant must provide a proposed order at least 14 days before the return date.
Judge Daniel J. Doyle: A proposed order that references an attached decision must include that decision, and all proposed orders must be filed electronically.
2 more rules answer this question.
What must be included with deposition objections filings in New York Supreme Court, Monroe County?
Judge Daniel J. Doyle: Failure to comply with the order waives trial objections to the proposed testimony and may result in preclusion of non-designated testimony.
2 more rules answer this question.
What must be included with disclosure motion filings in New York Supreme Court, Monroe County?
Judge Erin S. Skinner: The rule requires proposed order. Disclosure motions and responses must include a proposed order specifying the relief requested and the exact amount of costs, disbursements, and attorneys’ fees for the prevailing party.