Skip to main content
Court Rules

New York Supreme Court, New York County Pre-Motion Conference Requirements

87 rules, 51 to 87 shown

Pre-motion conference and letter requirements before filing motions, including sequential steps.

Filters
Severity
Case type

Rules 51 to 87

  1. Mandatory

    The Court will not accept a sur-reply without prior approval.

    Sur-replies will not be accepted by the Court without prior approval.

    Judge Yael WilkofskyPage 4, section MOTIONS
  2. Mandatory

    All parties must attend in person on the record for OSCs seeking emergency interim relief.

    All OSCs which request emergency interim relief require in-person appearances on the record and the parties are required to attend.

    Judge Yael WilkofskyPage 4, section MOTIONS
  3. Mandatory

    Before filing a discovery motion, counsel must consult in good faith and, if no resolution is reached, request a virtual conference by emailing the specified court contacts.

    Prior to filing a discovery motion, counsel must consult one another in a good faith effort to resolve any discovery disputes and, in the absence of a resolution, request a virtual conference with the Court by e-mailing the Principal Law Clerk, the Assistant Law Clerk and the Part 51 e-mail.

    Judge Yael WilkofskyPage 5, section MOTIONS
  4. ImportantCivil cases

    Discovery ordinarily must continue while a summary judgment motion is pending unless good cause supports a stay.

    Discovery must continue during the pendency of a summary judgment motion, unless good cause is shown for a stay.

    Judge Adam SilveraPage 3, section III. Motions
  5. Important

    Discovery motions are discouraged, and the parties must meet and confer in good faith to resolve discovery disputes before seeking judicial intervention.

    A. Rule 14 Conference: Pursuant to Commercial Division Rules 14 and 14-a, discovery motions are discouraged, and the parties shall meet and confer in good faith to resolve discovery disputes prior to seeking judicial intervention.

    Judge Anar Rathod PatelPage 5, section IX. Discovery
  6. Important

    Motions are submitted only unless the Court advises otherwise, and a party may request oral argument by making the stated designation.

    D. Oral Argument: All motions are by submission only unless otherwise advised by the Court. Parties may request oral argument by stating “Oral Argument Requested” on

    Judge Anar Rathod PatelPage 4, section VIII. Motions, D. Oral Argument
  7. Important

    Personal appearances on the return date are not required unless the Court directs an appearance.

    C. Return Date: Personal appearances are not required on the return date unless directed by the Court.

    Judge Anar Rathod PatelPage 4, section VIII. Motions, C. Return Date
  8. Important

    For an unresolved discovery dispute, parties should request a pre-motion conference with a law clerk by emailing the Principal and Assistant Law Clerk.

    If a discovery dispute arises that cannot be resolved by the DCM Part, please request a pre-motion conference with a Law Clerk by e-mailing both the Principal and Assistant Law Clerk

    Judge Ariel D. CheslerPage 2, section IV. Motion Practice – Discovery Motions
  9. ImportantCivil cases

    An Order to Show Cause must first be processed by the Ex Parte Motion Office, and the movant should confirm processing and submission to chambers before asking the Part for status.

    All Orders to Show Cause must first be processed by the Ex Parte Motion Office. A movant should first contact that office to ensure that the Order to Show Cause has been processed and submitted to chambers before inquiring with the Part about the status of the Order to Show Cause.

    Judge Brendan T. LantryPage 3, section IV. Motions — e. Orders to Show Cause
  10. ImportantCivil cases

    The Court may in its discretion hold the conference or grant leave to make the discovery motion without one.

    It is within the Court’s discretion to hold a conference or grant leave to move without conducting a conference first.

    Judge Brendan T. LantryPage 3, section IV. Motions — c. Discovery motions
  11. Important

    A request for oral argument must be included in the notice of motion or opposition papers, and the Court will notify the parties only if the request is granted.

    Requests for oral arguments shall be included in the Notice of Motion or in the Opposition papers. After review, the Court will notify the parties only if the application for oral argument is granted.

    Judge Carol SharpePage 2, section 3. MOTION PRACTICE — f. Oral Arguments
  12. Important

    Every Order to Show Cause must first be processed by the Ex Parte Motion Office, and the movant should confirm processing and submission to Chambers before asking the Part Clerk about its status.

    All Orders to Show Cause must first be processed by the Ex Parte Motion Office. A movant should first contact the Ex Parte Motion Office to ensure that the Order to Show Cause has been processed and submitted to Chambers before inquiring with the Part Clerk about the status of the Order to Show Cause.

    Judge Dana M. CatanzaroPage 4, section VII. ORDERS TO SHOW CAUSE AND SPECIAL PROCEEDINGS
  13. ImportantCivil cases

    Discovery motions are strongly discouraged.

    Discovery motions are strongly discouraged.

    Judge Eric SchumacherPage 5, section III. Motions
  14. ImportantCivil cases

    Summary judgment motions filed before discovery is complete are strongly discouraged.

    Motions for summary judgment prior to the completion of discovery are strongly discouraged (see CPLR 3212[f]).

    Judge Eric SchumacherPage 5, section III. Motions
  15. ImportantCivil cases

    Discovery is not automatically stayed while motions are pending unless the court orders otherwise.

    Unless otherwise indicated in an order of this court, discovery is not automatically stayed pending the determination of any motions in cases assigned to this part (see CPLR 3214 [b]).

    Judge Eric SchumacherPage 5, section III. Motions
  16. ImportantCivil cases

    Stays related to CPLR 321(b)(2) and discovery stays generally are exempt from the advance in-person appearance requirement.

    Stays related to CPLR 321(b)(2) or of discovery generally are exempt from the advance in-person appearance requirement.

    Judge Eric SchumacherPage 4, section III.E.2.a
  17. ImportantCivil cases

    An order to show cause with a temporary restraining order is not automatically heard the same day unless the sale occurs that day, and the judge retains discretion over hearing and decision methods.

    Just because an OSC has an TRO does not mean that it will be heard the same day unless the sale is the same day. The Judge will either give it a return date for oral argument, put it on submissions or decide it on the papers. Again, this is at the Judge’s discretion.

    Judge Francis A. Kahn IIIPage 4, section V. Order to Show Cause
  18. ImportantCivil cases

    Instead of filing a discovery motion, parties are encouraged to request a conference by e-filing a NYSCEF letter, although the Court may decline the conference.

    If a discovery dispute arises, parties in lieu of filing a motion, are encouraged to request a conference by e-filing a letter on NYSCEF requesting a conference. Conferences will be granted at the Court’s discretion.

    Judge Francis A. Kahn IIIPage 3, section III. MOTIONS - WORKING COPIES OF MOTION PAPERS ARE NOT REQUIRED.
  19. ImportantCivil cases

    The Court alone decides whether oral argument will be heard.

    Oral argument is heard solely at the discretion of the Court.

    Judge Francis A. Kahn IIIPage 3, section III. MOTIONS - WORKING COPIES OF MOTION PAPERS ARE NOT REQUIRED.
  20. Important

    A party may file a good-faith partial summary-judgment motion before the note of issue when negotiating a joint statement would be futile or would prejudicially delay filing.

    Nor is any party precluded from filing a pre-note-of-issue partial summary judgment motion if they in good faith believe that negotiating a joint statement would be futile or that doing so will cause a prejudicial delay in filing their motion.

    Judge Jennifer G. SchecterPage 10, section Summary-Judgment Motions
  21. Important

    The court may permit oral argument in other matters upon good cause, which requires explaining why the papers alone cannot fully apprise the court of the contested issues.

    The court may, however, upon good cause shown, permit oral argument in other matters. Proof of good cause shall include a showing as to why the papers alone are insufficient to apprise or fully explain to the court the nature of the contested issues.

    Judge John J. KelleyPage 2, section II. Motions
  22. ImportantCivil cases

    Before filing a strongly discouraged discovery motion, counsel must attempt good-faith resolution and, if unsuccessful, request a conference with a log detailing the materials sought.

    Discovery motions are strongly discouraged. Counsel must consult in a good faith effort to resolve discovery disputes before filing and, absent resolution, must request a conference with the Court, coming prepared with a log specifically delineating the materials sought.

    Judge Ronald Castorina Jr.Page 5, section MOTIONS
  23. Important

    The parties must engage in meaningful settlement discussions before the Settlement Conference.

    Prior to the SC, the parties are to engage in meaningful settlement discussions.

    Judge Yael WilkofskyPage 3, section CONFERENCES
  24. Important

    The Court will schedule a Settlement Conference case by case only when the parties are seriously ready and willing to resolve their disputes.

    SCs shall be scheduled by the Court on a case-by-case basis ONLY where the parties are seriously ready and willing to resolve their issues.

    Judge Yael WilkofskyPage 3, section CONFERENCES
  25. Note

    The court encourages pre-motion or settlement conferences where possible, with requests emailed to both the Principal and Assistant Law Clerk.

    The Part encourages pre-motion/settlement conferences wherever possible to avoid unnecessary litigation and motion practice, to do so, e-mail your request to both the Principal and Assistant Law Clerk

    Judge Ariel D. CheslerPage 2, section IV. Motion Practice – General Motion Requirements
  26. Note

    The court will schedule oral argument on motions at its discretion, except for motions to renew or reargue.

    Oral argument on motions, except motions to renew or reargue will be scheduled at the court’s discretion.

    Judge Ariel D. CheslerPage 2, section IV. Motion Practice – General Motion Requirements
  27. Note

    The Court encourages parties to resolve discovery disputes without filing motions.

    The Court encourages parties to resolve discovery disputes without motion practice.

    Judge Dana M. CatanzaroPage 2, section III. MOTION PRACTICE
  28. NoteCivil cases

    A discovery motion may be calendared for a conference with the Court.

    Discovery motions may be calendared for a conference with the Court.

    Judge Francis A. Kahn IIIPage 3, section III. MOTIONS - WORKING COPIES OF MOTION PAPERS ARE NOT REQUIRED.
  29. NoteCivil cases

    The court discourages filing discovery or disclosure motions.

    Disclosure motions are discouraged.

    Judge Gerald LebovitsPage 3, section IV.D. Disclosure Motions
  30. Note

    The DCM Clerk will issue a scheduling order or schedule a preliminary conference based on the RJI filing date.

    A Case Scheduling Order will be issued, or a Preliminary Conference will be scheduled, by the DCM Clerk based on the date the Request for Judicial Intervention (“RJI”) was filed.

    Judge Ilana J. MarcusPage 2, section Motion Practice
  31. Note

    Discovery conferences in the City Part are scheduled by the DCM rather than the individual assignment parts.

    Discovery conferences for cases in the City Part are scheduled by the Differentiated Case Management Part (“DCM”), not by the individual assignment parts.

    Judge Ilana J. MarcusPage 2, section Motion Practice
  32. Note

    To the maximum extent possible, discovery disputes should be resolved informally through conferences rather than motion practice.

    To the maximum extent possible, discovery disputes should be resolved through informal procedures, such as conferences, as opposed to motion practice (22 NYCRR § 202.20-f la]).

    Judge Ilana J. MarcusPage 2, section Motion Practice
  33. NoteCivil cases

    Except for discovery motions, prior permission or pre-motion letters are not required before filing a motion, although parties may request a pre-motion conference for disputes likely to resolve quickly.

    B. Pre-Motion Letters. Except for discovery motions (Section VI below), no prior permission or letters pursuant to Commercial Division Rule 24 are required before making a motion. If the parties believe the dispute may be resolved quickly without the need for formal motion practice, they can request a pre- motion conference.

    Judge Joel M. CohenPage 3, section VI. MOTION PRACTICE
  34. NoteCivil cases

    Motions ordinarily are submitted without oral argument unless rescheduled case by case, and oral argument is typically held Tuesday.

    Motions will be submitted without argument or rescheduled for oral argument on a case-by-case basis. Oral argument is typically held on a Tuesday.

    Judge Lynn R. KotlerPage 2, section IV. Motions
  35. NoteCivil cases

    To the maximum extent possible, discovery disputes should be addressed through informal conferences rather than motion practice.

    Pursuant to the Uniform Civil Rules for the Supreme Court and the County Court § 202.20-f: “[t]o the maximum extent possible, discovery disputes should be resolved through informal procedures, such as conferences, as opposed to motion practice.”

    Judge Lynn R. KotlerPage 1, section II. Conferences
  36. NoteCivil cases

    Advance court permission is not required before filing a motion.

    Advance permission to bring any motion is not required.

    Judge Lynn R. KotlerPage 2, section IV. Motions
  37. Note

    Counsel are encouraged to contact the court by conference call before filing a motion.

    To reduce the need for motion practice, counsel are encouraged to contact the court by conference call prior to filing a motion.

    Judge Michael L. KatzPage 1, section Motions

Back to top