Butler County Court of Common Pleas, General Division Document Filing Requirements
126 rules, 101 to 126 shown
Required elements, certificates, and structural requirements for court documents.
Rules 101 to 126
MandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Motion
- Must include
- caption
A motion must be submitted as a separate motion and captioned as a motion.
All motions must be filed as motions and captioned as such.
Judge Greg S. StephensPage 6, section 4. Briefs – Length and ContentsMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Pretrial statement
Each party must file a pretrial statement containing specified claims and defenses, admitted facts, disputed issues, witness and expert information, a categorized exhibit list, anticipated pretrial motions, special damages, trial-time estimates, and settlement-negotiation information.
Each party shall prepare and file with the Clerk of Courts a pretrial statement which shall contain the following: 7 ===== PAGE 8 ===== 1) A concise statement of its claims and defenses; 2) Those facts established by admissions in the pleadings, admissions by discovery, and stipulations of counsel; 3) The contested issues of fact; 4) The contested issues of law, with citations of authority for the party’s position; 5) The names of fact witnesses expected to testify, together with a brief statement of the subject matter of each witness’ testimony, and a brief summary of the anticipated testimony. 6) The names and qualifications of expert witnesses expected to testify, together with a brief statement of the subject matter of each witness’ testimony and a brief summary of the anticipated testimony. 7) A list of exhibits which each party intends to offer into evidence, marked as follows: (a) Joint exhibits marked with Roman numerals; (b) Plaintiff’s exhibits with Arabic numbers; (c) Defendant’s exhibits with letters; 8) Motions in limine or other pretrial motions pending or which are anticipated; 9) A list of all special damages being alleged; 10) Each party’s expectation of the trial time needed to present its side of the case; and 11) The status of settlement negotiations, including specific demands and/or offers. (Upon motion and leave, specific demands and/or offers may be excluded from filed documents but shall be included in the copy provided Judge to chambers as required, below).
Judge Greg S. StephensPage 8, section G. PRETRIAL STATEMENTSMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Expert report
An expert may not testify or offer an opinion on an issue that is not raised in the expert’s report.
An expert will not be permitted to testify or provide an opinion on any issue not raised in the report.
Judge Greg S. StephensPage 4, section C. DISCLOSURE OF EXPERTS AND THEIR REPORTSMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Notice of compliance
After completing mediation outside the court program, the parties must file a Notice of Compliance identifying the mediation date, mediator, and participating attorneys or parties.
If mediation is ordered but is completed via mediation other than through the Court’s mediation program, e.g., private mediation, an insurance company “settlement week”, etc., the parties shall file a “Notice of Compliance” following the mediation, verifying the date of the mediation, the name of the mediator(s) and the attorneys/parties participating.
Judge Greg S. StephensPage 7, section F. MEDIATIONMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Evidence objections
Each evidence or trial-material objection must state its grounds and include a brief citation of authority.
Objections shall include both the grounds for the objection and a brief citation of authority.
Judge Greg S. StephensPage 10, section K. TRIAL MATERIALS EXCHANGEMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Pretrial and settlement conference attendance
Locally based insurance representatives appearing for a party must attend in person.
Local insurance representatives (i.e., those physically located in Butler, Hamilton, Clermont, Warren, Preble or Montgomery County) must appear in person.
Judge Greg S. StephensPage 9, section H. ATTENDANCE AT PRETRIAL AND SETTLEMENT CONFERENCEMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Trial materials
Each party or its counsel must assemble all depositions, documents, photographs, and other items intended for use at trial.
Each party, or its counsel, shall assemble all depositions, documents, photographs and other items to be used at trial.
Judge Greg S. StephensPage 10, section K. TRIAL MATERIALS EXCHANGEMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Pretrial and settlement conference attendance
Trial counsel, all parties, and a person with settlement authority must personally attend the pretrial and settlement conference.
Trial counsel and all parties, including someone with settlement authority, shall be personally present at the pretrial and settlement conference.
Judge Greg S. StephensPage 9, section H. ATTENDANCE AT PRETRIAL AND SETTLEMENT CONFERENCEMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Pretrial statement
Pretrial statements must also identify expert witnesses, list and mark trial exhibits, identify pending motions in limine, list special damages, estimate trial time, report settlement status, and provide requested jury instructions and interrogatories.
(6) The names, addresses, and qualifications of the expert witnesses expected to testify at trial, together with a brief statement of the subject matter of each expert witness's testimony; (7) A list of exhibits which counsel intends to offer into evidence, marked as follows: (a) Joint exhibits with Roman numerals, (b) Plaintiffs exhibits with Arabic numerals. (c) Defendant's exhibits with letters; (8) Motions in limine not previously filed; (9) A list of all special damages being requested; (10) Counsel's expectation of the trial time needed to present his side of the case; (11) The status of settlement negotiations including specific demands and/or offers; (12) Requested jury instructions (other than boilerplate), and jury interrogatories.
Judge Jennifer Muench-McElfreshPage 2, section E. PRETRIAL STATEMENTSMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Exhibit or material objection
Objections to exhibits or other trial material must be written, filed by 4:00 p.m. on the indicated date, contemporaneously delivered to chambers, and briefly state the grounds with supporting authority.
Objections to the admission of exhibits or to the use of other material must be made in writing and filed before 4:00 p.m. on the date indicated and a copy of the objection shall be contemporaneously delivered to the court in chambers. Objections shall state briefly the grounds for the objection and a brief citation of authority.
Judge Jennifer Muench-McElfreshPage 2, section G. TRIAL MATERIALS EXCHANGEMandatoryCivil cases
- Applies to
- Pretrial statement
Pretrial statements must include the parties' claims and defenses, admitted and stipulated facts, disputed factual and legal issues, supporting authority, and witness information.
Counsel shall prepare pretrial statements which shall contain the following: (1) A concise statement of the claims and defenses of the parties; (2) Those facts established by admissions in the pleadings, admissions by discovery, and stipulations of counsel; (3) The contested issues of fact; (4) The contested issues of law, together with counsel's citations of authority for his position; (5) The names and addresses of witnesses, together with a brief statement of the subject matter of each witness's testimony and a brief summary of each witness's expected testimony;
Judge Jennifer Muench-McElfreshPage 1, section E. PRETRIAL STATEMENTSImportant
- Applies to
- Estimated taxes statement request
A request for the estimated-taxes statement must be submitted to the Butler County Treasurer using a Treasurer-approved form.
A written request for such statement of estimated taxes due shall be submitted to the Treasurer of Butler County upon a form approved by the Treasurer.
Important
- Applies to
- Notice of counsel substitution
Counsel may substitute without a hearing by submitting a notice signed by the withdrawing counsel, client, and substituting counsel.
(B) Substitution may be accomplished without hearing by the submission of a notice signed by the withdrawing counsel, the client, and the substituting counsel.
Important
- Applies to
- Subsequent filing
Documents submitted later for filing must contain the same information required on the Notice of Appearance.
Documents subsequently submitted to the Clerk for filing shall contain the same information as set forth above.
Important
- Applies to
- Proposed decree of foreclosure
When personal liability is discharged or no personal judgment will be entered, the proposed decree should state that fact and the caption should say “Judgment in Rem.”
If a homeowner’s personal liability has been discharged in bankruptcy, or there is otherwise no personal judgment to be rendered against any party, this should be explicitly stated in the decree of foreclosure, and the case caption should contain the phrase “Judgment in Rem”
ImportantCivil cases
The judge handling the original case must be notified of the refiling to permit a timely transfer if necessary.
notify the judge of the original case of the refiling so that a timely transfer of the case may occur if necessary
Court-level rulesOfficial source Page 1, section APPENDIX C (LOCAL RULE 5.02) — DOCKET STATEMENT — Refiling of CaseImportantCivil cases
- Applies to
- Memorandum
A party seeking to raise a particular legal or evidentiary issue is expected to submit a short memorandum with pertinent cases attached.
If there is a particular legal or evidentiary issue which any party wishes to bring to the court’s attention, a short memorandum with pertinent cases attached is expected.
Judge Daniel E. HaugheyPage 3, section E. JURY INSTRUCTIONSImportantCivil cases
- Applies to
- Pretrial briefing
Before trial, parties are expected to brief the court on all legal issues related to the trial.
The court expects the parties, before the trial, to have briefed the court on all legal issues related to the trial.
Judge Daniel E. HaugheyPage 3, section F. ISSUES TRIED TO THE COURTImportantCivil cases
- Applies to
- Motion or entry
A motion or entry signed or submitted by counsel who has not filed a notice of appearance may be stricken or not considered.
Motions or entries signed/submitted by counsel who have not filed a notice of appearance may be stricken or not considered.
Judge Greg S. StephensPage 1, section A. APPEARANCE BY COUNSEL – DUTY TO MONITOR THE DOCKETImportantCivil cases
- Applies to
- Pretrial and settlement conference attendance
With prior court approval, corporate parties, insured parties, and qualifying insured parties may appear through specified representatives instead of the persons otherwise required to attend.
However, with prior leave of court: (1) a corporate party may appear through an officer or employee having knowledge of the subject matter of the case; (2) a party who is insured concerning the claim may appear through a claim representative from his or her liability carrier; and (3) in those instances when trial counsel can assure the Court that an out-of-town representative of an insurance carrier is available for immediate contact by telephone, the trial counsel for an insured party may appear for the party and the insurance carrier.
Judge Greg S. StephensPage 9, section H. ATTENDANCE AT PRETRIAL AND SETTLEMENT CONFERENCEImportantCivil cases
- Applies to
- Pretrial legal issue briefing
Before trial, the parties are expected to have briefed the court on every legal issue related to the trial.
The Court expects the parties, before the trial, to have briefed the Court on all legal issues related to the trial.
Judge Greg S. StephensPage 10, section J. ISSUES TRIED TO THE COURTNoteCivil cases
- Applies to
- Issue memorandum
The Court appreciates but does not require a short memorandum with pertinent authorities when a party wishes to highlight a legal or evidentiary issue.
If there is a particular legal or evidentiary issue which any party wishes to bring to the Court’s attention, a short memorandum with pertinent cases attached is appreciated.
Judge Greg S. StephensPage 9, section I. JURY INSTRUCTIONSNoteCivil cases
- Applies to
- Notice of compliance
A notice of compliance with the expert-report exchange deadline is prima facie evidence that the report was provided.
A notice of compliance with the exchange deadline shall be deemed prima facie evidence that the report was provided.
Judge Greg S. StephensPage 4, section C. DISCLOSURE OF EXPERTS AND THEIR REPORTSNoteCivil cases
- Applies to
- Healthcare provider records
A healthcare-provider expert may testify and offer opinions about matters addressed in the provider’s relevant records.
An expert witness who has provided medical, dental, optometric, chiropractic, or mental health care may testify and offer opinions as to matters addressed in the healthcare provider’s records.
Judge Greg S. StephensPage 4, section C. DISCLOSURE OF EXPERTS AND THEIR REPORTSNoteCivil cases
- Applies to
- Healthcare provider records
Relevant healthcare-provider records may replace a formal expert report when the records contain an adequate statement of the expert’s opinion and a separate report would be redundant.
The healthcare providers’ records relevant to the case may be provided in lieu of a formal written report, provided that the expert’s opinion is contained within the records, the records adequately set forth the expert’s opinion, and a formal written report would be redundant.
Judge Greg S. StephensPage 4, section C. DISCLOSURE OF EXPERTS AND THEIR REPORTSNoteCivil cases
- Applies to
- Expert report
Expert reports do not need to be filed with the court.
Reports need not be filed.
Judge Greg S. StephensPage 4, section C. DISCLOSURE OF EXPERTS AND THEIR REPORTS