Court Rules

Fifth Judicial Circuit of Florida, Citrus, Hernando, Lake, Marion and Sumter Counties Chambers Communication Rules

212 rules from official source documents

Rules 151 to 200, page 4 of 5

Rules for contacting chambers: permitted methods, hours, and purposes.

WARNINGCivil cases

Hearing scheduling must be coordinated with opposing counsel and may not be done unilaterally.

Hearings must be coordinated with opposing counsel and may not be unilaterally set.

Judge Robert W. Hodges

WARNINGCivil cases

Contact
Email to chambers

Orders should not be sent via U.S. Mail and by email. Please use one or the other, but not both.

Orders should not be sent via U.S. Mail and by email. Please use one or the other, but not both.

Judge Robert W. Hodges

WARNING

Contact
Email

Hearing scheduling requests should be emailed to Judicial Assistant ToniAnn Papa.

To schedule hearings, please send an e-mail to ToniAnn Papa at tpapa@circuit5.org

Judge Shanae L. Pickens

WARNING

Contact
Email to chambers

Written communications to Judge Pickens’ office should be submitted by email.

All written communication with Judge Pickens’ office should be submitted via email.

Judge Shanae L. Pickens

WARNING

Contact
Phone to chambers
Phone
(352) 401-7820

Telephone communication with the judicial office is limited to self-represented litigants and attorneys excused from email service; text messages are not accepted.

Only self-represented litigants and attorneys who are excused from e-mail service may communicate with the judicial office by telephone call to (352) 401-7820. The judicial office does not accept text messages.

Judge Stacy M. Youmans

WARNING

Contact
Phone

After two business days without a coordination response, the requesting party may ask the court to set the hearing unilaterally and must document its email and telephone coordination attempts.

If a party does not respond to coordinating counsel within 2 business days, the party that requested the hearing may reach out to the Court, provide information as to the attempts made to coordinate, and request that the hearing be unilaterally set. Contact must be attempted at all emails provided as well as telephonic attempts at any phone number provided.

Judge Stacy M. Youmans

WARNING

Parties and witnesses must log in five minutes before the hearing begins.

Parties and witnesses must be logged in 5 minutes prior to the start of the hearing.

Judge Stacy M. Youmans

WARNING

Contact
Email to chambers

Other motions or matters may not be scheduled for the same time as an already scheduled motion or petition without prior email approval from the Judicial Assistant.

Once a motion or petition is scheduled, any other motions or matters may not be noticed for the same time without prior approval from the Judicial Assistant via email.

Judge Stacy M. Youmans

WARNING

Phone
352-401-7820

The public must not call the Court expecting to discuss a pending case with a judge, and communications not submitted through authorized courtroom argument or court filings cannot be forwarded to the judges.

*NOTICE TO THE PUBLIC:* The Code of Judicial Conduct governing behavior by judges forbids the Judges of the Fifth Judicial Circuit to discuss pending cases with the public. Please do not call the Court expecting to speak with a Judge about any case. The Court is only allowed to consider arguments made in the courtroom and in documents properly filed by actual parties in the case as authorized by law and the Rules of Court. The Court cannot ethically read or consider any other opinions or arguments about the case. Communications that do not meet these legal requirements cannot be forwarded to the Judges.

Judge Stacy M. Youmans

WARNING

Contact
Email

Requests for electronic appearances of expert witnesses must be submitted by email to the Judicial Assistant.

Electronic appearances of expert witnesses only can be requested via email to the Judicial Assistant.

Judge Stacy M. Youmans

WARNING

Do not call the Court expecting to discuss a pending case with a judge.

Please do not call the Court expecting to speak with a Judge about any case.

Judge Steven G. Rogers

WARNING

Hearings are held via Zoom, and an in-person hearing must be requested when the hearing is scheduled.

All hearings are held via zoom. If you want an in person hearing this must be requested at the time of scheduling your hearing.

Judge Thomas R. Eineman

WARNING

Contact
Email to chambers

If a hearing date and time cannot be identified within five days, the scheduling party should email the judicial assistant and copy opposing counsel and any self-represented litigant.

If parties are unable to identify a hearing date and time within 5 days, the scheduling party should e-mail the judicial assistant, copying opposing counsel and any self-represented litigant, to coordinate the scheduling of the hearing.

Judge Thomas R. Eineman

WARNING

Contact
Email to chambers

An email to the judicial office must identify the case number, case name, and relevant matter in its subject line.

The subject line must contain the case number, case name, and relevant matter (e.g., 2024 DR 001234 SC – Doe v. Doe - 2-Hour Hearing Requested.)

Judge Thomas R. Eineman

WARNING

The court will not consider unsolicited communications from non-parties.

Unsolicited communications from non-parties will not be considered by the court.

Judge Thomas R. Eineman

WARNING

Contact
Email to chambers

After the court finds a conference necessary, the requesting party may schedule it through the judicial assistant by email.

If the court agrees that a CMC or status conference is required, the moving party may schedule the CMC or status conference through the Judicial Assistant at mstevens@circuit5.org.

Judge Thomas R. Eineman

WARNING

Contact
Email

Requests for hearing or trial interpreters should be emailed to interpreters@circuit5.org.

Interpreter Requests: If an interpreter is needed for a hearing or trial, please send your request to: interpreters@circuit5.org

Judge Thomas R. Eineman

WARNING

Contact
Email to chambers

Use TREcalendarrequest@circuit5.org to request a hearing date.

Please use the following address to request a hearing date: TREcalendarrequest@circuit5.org

Judge Thomas R. Eineman

WARNING

Contact
Email to chambers

A hearing-cancellation request must be emailed to the hearing-request address and state the reason for cancellation.

If you wish to cancel a hearing that has been previously scheduled, you must email JudgeMcCourtHearingRequests@circuit5.org and state the reason for the cancellation.

Judge Timothy McCourt

WARNING

Contact
Email to chambers

Proposed orders must be emailed to JudgeMcCourtProposedOrders@circuit5.org.

Please send proposed orders to: JudgeMcCourtProposedOrders@circuit5.org.

Judge Timothy McCourt

WARNING

The Judicial Assistant may not provide legal advice.

The Judicial Assistant is not authorized to provide legal advice.

Judge Timothy McCourt

WARNING

Contact
Email to chambers

Hearing requests must be emailed to JudgeMcCourtHearingRequests@circuit5.org.

To schedule hearings, please send an e-mail to: JudgeMcCourtHearingRequests@circuit5.org.

Judge Timothy McCourt

WARNING

Contact
Email to chambers

All written communications to Judge McCourt’s office must be submitted by email with the parties’ names and case number in the subject line.

All written communication with Judge McCourt’s office should be submitted via email. The subject line of your email should include the names of parties and case number (e.g., State v. John Doe, 2025-CF-9876).

Judge Timothy McCourt

INFO

Contact
Email to chambers

Email is the preferred means of communicating with Judge Boylston’s office.

The best way to communicate with Judge Boylston’s Office is via email at tvinson@circuit5.org

Judge Benjamin M. Boylston

INFO

Contact
Email to chambers

Judge Toti’s office should be contacted by email at tmann@circuit5.org.

The best way to communicate with Judge Toti’s Office is via email at tmann@circuit5.org

Judge Brian M. Toti

INFO

The judicial assistant aims to respond to inquiries within one business day.

The Judicial Assistant strives to respond to all inquiries within one (1) business day.

Judge Brian M. Toti

INFO

Contact
Email to chambers

Proposed orders must be submitted to JudgeTotiProposedOrders@circuit5.org.

For Order submission, please email: JudgeTotiProposedOrders@circuit5.org

Judge Brian M. Toti

INFO

Contact
Phone

Members of the public must not call the Court seeking to discuss a pending case with a judge.

*NOTICE TO THE PUBLIC:* The Code of Judicial Conduct governing behavior by judges forbids the Judges of the Fifth Judicial Circuit to discuss pending cases with the public. Please do not call the Court expecting to speak with a Judge about any case.

Judge Carol Falvey

INFO

A pro se litigant may contact Ada Nieves Muller for assistance scheduling and setting a Zoom hearing.

A pro se litigant may obtain assistance with scheduling and setting of a Zoom hearing by contacting Ada Nieves Muller.

Judge Carol Falvey

INFO

Contact
Email

Case-law submissions under five pages may be emailed to anieves@circuit5.org, while submissions over five pages must be sent by U.S. Mail sufficiently early for pre-hearing review.

If you have case law for the Judge to consider and the submission is less than five (5) pages, you may email it to anieves@circuit5.org or send it by U.S. Mail (all submissions over 5 pages) giving the Court sufficient time to review it prior to the hearing date.

Judge Carol Falvey

INFO

Contact
Email

When all parties are represented, submitting proposed orders by email to anieves@circuit5.org is permitted.

If all parties are represented by counsel, proposed orders maybe submitted by email to anieves@circuit5.org.

Judge Carol Falvey

INFO

Contact
Phone to chambers
Phone
352-341-6717

Counsel and parties may request telephonic appearance for a hearing by contacting Ada Nieves Muller at the stated number.

Counsel and parties may appear telephonically for a hearing by contacting Ada Nieves Muller at 352-341-6717.

Judge Carol Falvey

INFO

Contact
Email to chambers

The court requests that communications allow 48 hours for a response and discourages repeated emails that may delay hearing or document processing.

Please allow 48 hours for a response. Numerous, repeat e-mails are unnecessary and will only slow the response and processing of your hearing request or document processing.

Judge Charles L.W. Helm

INFOCivil cases

Counsel should advise the Judicial Assistant how much time will be needed if establishing a reasonable expert fee may require an evidentiary hearing.

Be sure to advise the Judicial Assistant as to how much time will be needed.

Judge Dan R. Mosley

INFO

Contact
Email to chambers

Procedural questions may be emailed to Judicial Assistant Joyce Weeks.

For procedural questions contact Joyce Weeks, Judicial Assistant, at jweeks@circuit5.org.

Judge Daniel B. Merritt Jr.

INFO

Contact
Email to chambers

Emergency guardianship hearing dates may be obtained by email to the judicial assistant.

Emergency Guardianship Hearing dates can be obtained by contacting jweeks@circuit5.org or by calling our office at 352-754-4480.

Judge Daniel B. Merritt Jr.

INFO

A party may contact the judicial assistant to inquire about a motion if no ruling has issued after 45 days.

In the unlikely event that forty-five (45) days have passed without a ruling on your motion, please contact the judicial assistant to inquire.

Judge Don Barbee

INFO

Contact
Email to chambers

When a hearing is required or approved, available hearing time may be obtained by emailing the judicial assistant.

If a hearing is required or approved by the Court, hearing time may be obtained by contacting the judicial assistant at dcbcivil@circuit5.org.

Judge Don Barbee

INFO

Contact
Email

Questions about the standing order should be directed to Judicial Assistant Jamie Shreiber by email at hernandoprobate@circuit5.org.

If you have any questions about this standing order, please contact Jamie Shreiber, Judicial Assistant, at hernandoprobate@circuit5.org

Judge Don Barbee

INFO

Contact
Email

Hearing times for probate cases may be obtained by emailing hernandoprobate@circuit5.org with the case number, motion title, and estimated hearing duration.

10. HEARINGS: Hearing times for probate cases may be obtained by sending an email to hernandoprobate@circuit5.org. Please include the case number, title of motion, and an estimate of the time needed.

Judge Don Barbee

INFO

Contact
Email to chambers

Questions about the standing order may be sent to the judicial assistant by email at dcbcivil@circuit5.org.

If you have any questions about this standing order, please contact Jamie Shreiber, Judicial Assistant, at dcbcivil@circuit5.org or (352)540-6655.

Judge Don Barbee

INFOCivil cases

Contact
Email to chambers

After approximately 45 days without a ruling following compliance with the motion practice instructions, counsel may email the presiding judge's judicial assistant to confirm receipt.

If you have properly followed all of the instructions in this Motion Practice Order and have not heard from the court within approximately forty-five (45) days, it is appropriate to contact the Presiding Judge's judicial assistant via email and politely make sure the motion/request has been received.

Judge Donald E. Scaglione

INFO

Contact
Email to chambers

The courtesy-copy email address will not respond to messages.

Please note the above address will not respond.

Judge Donald E. Scaglione

INFO

The chambers fax number is (352) 754-4273.

FAX: (352) 754-4273

Judge Donald E. Scaglione

INFO

Contact
Email

The chambers email address is bhaimes@circuit5.org.

bhaimes@circuit5.org

Judge Donald E. Scaglione

INFO

Phone
(352) 754-4030

The judicial assistant's phone number is (352) 754-4030.

JUDICIAL ASSISTANT (352) 754-4030

Judge Donald E. Scaglione

INFO

Contact
Email

Questions about the Zoom standing order may be emailed to Paula Barto, Judicial Assistant, at pbarto@circuit5.org.

If you have any questions about this standing order, please contact Paula Barto, Judicial Assistant, at pbarto@circuit5.org or (352)569-6960 or see court website - Erin Daly - State of Florida Fifth Judicial Circuit - https://www.circuit5.org/courts-judges/sumter- county/judiciary/erin-daly/ - “zoom appearances”.

Judge Erin Daly

INFO

Contact
Email to chambers

Judge Singeltary’s office should be contacted by email at etorres@circuit5.org.

The best way to communicate with Judge Singeltary’s Office is via email at etorres@circuit5.org

Judge George L. Singeltary II

INFO

A hearing need not be coordinated with a pro se party when it can be scheduled with sufficient notice to that party.

If one party is pro se and the hearing can be scheduled with sufficient notice to the pro se party, the hearing will not need to be coordinated with the pro se party.

Judge Jennifer Bass

INFO

Contact
Email to chambers

Hearing requests should be emailed to Judicial Assistant Susan Jones with the case information, hearing or motion type, requested duration, and opposing party or counsel copied.

Hearing requests should be made via email to the Court's Judicial Assistant, Susan Jones, at sjones@circuit5.org, and shall include the case name and number, the type of hearing/motion to be heard, and the amount of time being requested. The opposing party/counsel should be copied on the email.

Judge Joel D. Fritton