Court Rules

Fifth Judicial Circuit of Florida, Citrus, Hernando, Lake, Marion and Sumter Counties Chambers Communication Rules

212 rules from official source documents

Rules 1 to 50, page 1 of 5

Rules for contacting chambers: permitted methods, hours, and purposes.

CRITICAL

A lawyer must avoid substantive ex-parte communications with the presiding judge in a pending case.

A lawyer must avoid substantive ex-parte communications in a pending case with a presiding judge.

Court-level rulesOfficial source

CRITICAL

A lawyer must notify opposing counsel of communications with the court or tribunal unless the communication concerns only scheduling or clerical matters.

The lawyer must notify opposing counsel of all communications with the court or other tribunal, except those involving only scheduling or clerical matters. (See R. Regulating Fla. Bar 4-3.5).

Court-level rulesOfficial source

CRITICAL

Contact
Email to chambers

When a hearing is to be cancelled, a notice of cancellation must be filed and this office must be immediately notified by email.

In addition to filing a notice of cancellation, immediately notify this office by e-mail, when a hearing is to be cancelled.

Judge Ann Melinda Craggs

CRITICAL

Contact
Email to chambers

A copy of the Notice of Cancellation must also be emailed to the Judge’s office.

3. You must also send a copy of the Notice of Cancellation to the Judge’s office to Tvinson@circuit5.org

Judge Benjamin M. Boylston

CRITICAL

Parties must not call the Court seeking direct judicial discussion of a case.

Please do not call the Court expecting to speak with a Judge about any case.

Judge Benjamin M. Boylston

CRITICAL

Every other party, or that party’s attorney if represented, must be copied on all correspondence to the Court.

All other parties to the case (or their attorneys, if they are represented) must be copied on all correspondence to the Court.

Judge Benjamin M. Boylston

CRITICAL

Contact
Email to chambers

A hearing or trial cancellation must be reported by email to the Judicial Assistant with a stated reason.

1. You must contact the Judicial Assistant at tvinson@circuit5.org to notify the Court of the cancellation and state the reason for cancellation.

Judge Benjamin M. Boylston

CRITICAL

Parties must not call or email the Court expecting to discuss a case directly with the Judge.

Please do not call or email the Court expecting to speak with a Judge about any case.

Judge Benjamin M. Boylston

CRITICAL

Any communication with the Judicial Assistant must include all parties or counsel.

Any communication to /with the Judicial Assistant shall include all parties or counsel.

Judge Benjamin M. Boylston

CRITICAL

Contact
Email to chambers

Scheduling requests must be emailed to Toni Mann at tmann@circuit5.org.

For scheduling requests, please email Toni Mann at tmann@circuit5.org.

Judge Brian M. Toti

CRITICAL

Contact
Email to chambers

Proposed orders must be submitted to the court only by email.

ALL PROPOSED ORDERS shall be submitted for entry by email ONLY.

Judge Brian M. Toti

CRITICAL

Contact
Email to chambers

A copy of the notice of cancellation must be emailed to the judge’s office.

You must also send a copy of the Notice of Cancellation to the Judge’s office to tmann@circuit5.org

Judge Brian M. Toti

CRITICAL

Contact
Email to chambers

Hearings longer than 15 minutes must be held in person, with the request sent to the judge’s office by email.

Hearings that exceed 15 minutes must be in-person. Please send your request to tmann@circuit5.org

Judge Brian M. Toti

CRITICAL

Contact
Email to chambers

To request a continuance, notify the judicial assistant by email.

You must contact the Judicial Assistant at tmann@circuit5.org to notify the Court of the request to continue.

Judge Brian M. Toti

CRITICAL

Contact
Email to chambers

To cancel a hearing or trial, contact the judicial assistant by email and state the reason for cancellation.

You must contact the Judicial Assistant at tmann@circuit5.org to notify the Court of the cancellation and state the reason for cancellation.

Judge Brian M. Toti

CRITICAL

After coordinating the new date, contact the judicial assistant to place the hearing or trial on the court calendar.

Once the date is coordinated, you must contact the Judicial Assistant to actually put it on the calendar.

Judge Brian M. Toti

CRITICAL

Any communication with the judicial assistant must include all parties or counsel.

Any communication to /with the Judicial Assistant shall include all parties or counsel.

Judge Brian M. Toti

CRITICAL

Contact
Phone to chambers

Members of the public may not call the court to discuss a pending case with a judge.

*NOTICE TO THE PUBLIC:* The Code of Judicial Conduct governing behavior by judges forbids the Judges of the Fifth Judicial Circuit to discuss pending cases with the public. Please do not call the Court expecting to speak with a Judge about any case.

Judge Brian Welke

CRITICAL

Additional motions may not be cross-noticed for an existing hearing without court approval and coordination through the judge's office.

Cross-notice of a hearing without the Court’s approval is not permitted. Before requesting the setting of an additional motion(s) at a previously scheduled hearing, the attorneys must contact our office so the Court can determine if sufficient time is available to have the additional motion(s) heard. Your motion will not be heard if the hearing is not coordinated through the judge’s office.

Judge Brian Welke

CRITICAL

Contact
Phone to chambers

After emailing a civil emergency motion, counsel must telephone the judge's office because the email is not continuously monitored.

YOU MUST ALSO CALL the Judge’s office to inform them of the emergency motion after submission via email, as the email is not constantly monitored.

Judge Brian Welke

CRITICAL

Contact
Phone to chambers

When a hearing will be cancelled, the filing party must immediately notify the judge's office by telephone or email after filing the cancellation notice.

In addition to filing your notice of cancellation, immediately notify the judge’s office by telephone and/or email when a hearing is to be cancelled.

Judge Brian Welke

CRITICAL

After coordinating a hearing with all counsel, counsel must confirm it remains available with the court office before preparing the Notice of Hearing because dates cannot be held.

Once a hearing date and time has been coordinated with all counsel, confirm the date with this office prior to preparing your Notice of Hearing to assure that date and time is still available as hearing dates cannot be “held.”

Judge Carol Falvey

CRITICAL

Contact
Phone to chambers

When cancelling a hearing, you must immediately notify the office by telephone or email, in addition to filing a notice of cancellation.

In addition to filing your notice of cancellation, immediately notify our office by telephone or email when a hearing is to be cancelled.

Judge Carol Falvey

CRITICAL

Opposing counsel must be included on every correspondence sent to the court’s office.

It is necessary that you include opposing counsel on ALL correspondence to this office.

Judge Charles L.W. Helm

CRITICAL

Contact
Email to chambers

A hearing request must be emailed to the judicial assistant and opposing counsel with the case number, motion to be heard, and requested duration.

Please e-mail Judge Helm’s Judicial Assistant at ngugliotta@circuit5.org and opposing counsel with the Case Number, Motion to be heard and amount of time requested.

Judge Charles L.W. Helm

CRITICAL

Contact
Email to chambers

A noticed hearing may be cancelled only with court approval, requested by email to the judicial assistant with a statement of the cancellation reason.

Noticed hearings may only be cancelled with the approval of the Court. If you wish to cancel a hearing that has been previously scheduled, you must e-mail Judge Helm’s Judicial Assistant at ngugliotta@circuit5.org and state the reason for the cancellation.

Judge Charles L.W. Helm

CRITICAL

Parties must not call the court expecting to discuss a pending case with the judge.

Please do not call the Court expecting to speak with a Judge about any case.

Judge Charles L.W. Helm

CRITICAL

Contact
Email to chambers

All hearing requests must be emailed to the judicial assistant at dcbcivil@circuit5.org.

SCHEDULING: All hearing requests must be sent to my Judicial Assistant at dcbcivil@circuit5.org.

Judge Don Barbee

CRITICAL

Contact
Phone to clerk
Phone
(352)540-6366

Hearing requests must be made through the Probate/Guardianship Division of the Clerk at the stated telephone number.

At the present time, all hearing requests shall be made through the Probate/Guardianship Division of the Hernando County Clerk of Circuit Court at (352)540-6366.

Judge Don Barbee

CRITICAL

Contact
Email to chambers

A movant who believes a reply is necessary must immediately notify the judicial assistant by email.

If the movant believes a Reply is necessary to the Response, he/she shall immediately notify the judicial assistant via email at dcbcivil@circuit5.org.

Judge Don Barbee

CRITICAL

A last-minute settlement must be communicated specifically and immediately to the court, court reporter, parties, and witnesses.

In the event a last-minute settlement is reached between the parties, the Court, court reporter, parties and witnesses must be specifically and immediately advised of same.

Judge Donald E. Scaglione

CRITICAL

Contact
Email

Counsel must notify the court's Judicial Assistant by email at bhaimes@circuit5.org when the case is dismissed or settled.

Counsel must make notification in writing via email to bhaimes@circuit5.org).

Judge Donald E. Scaglione

CRITICAL

A lawyer must avoid substantive ex parte communications with a presiding judge and notify opposing counsel of court or tribunal communications, except communications limited to scheduling or clerical matters.

5. A lawyer must avoid substantive ex-parte communications in a pending case with a presiding judge. The lawyer must notify opposing counsel of all communications with the court or other tribunal, except those involving only scheduling or clerical matters. (See R. Regulating Fla. Bar 4-3.5).

Judge Donald E. Scaglione

CRITICAL

Each attorney of record must immediately notify the court when the case settles.

Each attorney of record shall immediately notify the Court in the event of settlement of their case.

Judge Donald E. Scaglione

CRITICALCivil cases

Contact
Email

The moving party must set up the Zoom hearing and send invitations to all parties, including an email invitation to the Court.

It is the moving party's responsibility to set up the Zoom hearing and send invitations to all parties, including an invitation to the Court at DES-circuitcivil@circuit5.org

Judge Donald E. Scaglione

CRITICALCivil cases

Contact
Email to chambers

All hearings must be scheduled through the email link on the 5th Circuit website.

All hearings are scheduled via the email link on the 5th Circuit Website (www.circuit5.org)

Judge Donald E. Scaglione

CRITICAL

Contact
Email to chambers

A pro se party appearing by phone must set up CourtCall and email the court before the hearing to confirm the arrangement.

PRO-SE PARTIES MUST ALSO SET UP COURTCALL FOR PHONE APPEARANCE (See Courtcall.com or call 1-888-882-6878) AND CONTACT THE COURT PRIOR TO THE HEARING DATE AT bhaimes@circuit5.org TO CONFIRM WITH THE COURT YOU HAVE ARRANGED YOUR APPEARANCE.

Judge Donald E. Scaglione

CRITICALCivil cases

Scheduling requests may not be made by telephone.

No phone call scheduling request are allowed.

Judge Donald E. Scaglione

CRITICAL

Contact
Email to chambers

A party may confirm a hearing date and time by email only after all parties agree to that selection.

Only upon each party’s agreement to a specific date and time should you send an email to Erika Torres at etorres@circuit5.org confirming the selection of a date and time.

Judge George L. Singeltary II

CRITICAL

Contact
Email to chambers

Hearing requests must be submitted by email to Erika Torres because the chambers office does not schedule hearings by telephone.

Parties requesting a hearing shall send an email request to Erika Torres at etorres@circuit5.org as hearings are not scheduled by telephone.

Judge George L. Singeltary II

CRITICAL

Parties must not call or email the court expecting judicial discussion of a case.

Please do not call or email the court expecting to speak with a Judge about any case.

Judge George L. Singeltary II

CRITICAL

Contact
Email to chambers

A hearing or trial cancellation must be reported by email to the judicial assistant with the reason for cancellation.

You must contact the Judicial Assistant at etorres@circuit5.org to notify the Court of the cancellation and state the reason for cancellation.

Judge George L. Singeltary II

CRITICAL

Contact
Email to chambers

A copy of the Notice of Cancellation must also be emailed to the judge’s office.

You must also send a copy of the Notice of Cancellation to the Judge’s office to etorres@circuit5.org.

Judge George L. Singeltary II

CRITICAL

The public must not call the court expecting to discuss a case with a judge.

Please do not call the Court expecting to speak with a Judge about any case.

Judge George L. Singeltary II

CRITICAL

Contact
Email to chambers

Every email to the judicial assistant must copy all other parties or their attorneys.

All other parties to the case (or their attorneys, if they are represented) must be copied on all correspondence to the Judicial Assistant at etorres@circuit5.org.

Judge George L. Singeltary II

CRITICAL

Contact
Email to chambers

You must contact the Judicial Assistant at etorres@circuit5.org to notify the court of the request to continue.

You must contact the Judicial Assistant at etorres@circuit5.org to notify the court of the request to continue.

Judge George L. Singeltary II

CRITICAL

Contact
Email to chambers

Proposed orders must be emailed to JudgeSingeltaryProposedOrders@circuit5.org.

For Order submission, please email: JudgeSingeltaryProposedOrders@circuit5.org

Judge George L. Singeltary II

CRITICAL

The correspondence guidelines apply to every communication with the judicial assistant, including hearing scheduling and proposed-order submissions.

These guidelines apply to all communications with the Judicial Assistant, including scheduling hearings and submitting proposed orders.

Judge George L. Singeltary II

CRITICAL

Contact
Email

Parties must request hearings by email to Audrey Hatcher because hearings are not scheduled by telephone.

Parties requesting a hearing shall send an e-mail request to Audrey Hatcher as hearings are not scheduled by telephone.

Judge Jason J. Nimeth

CRITICAL

Contact
Email

The cross-noticing permission email must identify the motion, existing hearing date and time, and opposing counsel’s position.

The e-mail shall include the name of the desired motion to be cross-noticed, the currently scheduled date and time of the existing hearing, and opposing counsel’s position on the request.

Judge Jason J. Nimeth
Common questions about Fifth Judicial Circuit of Florida, Citrus, Hernando, Lake, Marion and Sumter Counties chambers communication rules

How may parties contact Fifth Judicial Circuit of Florida, Citrus, Hernando, Lake, Marion and Sumter Counties?

Fifth Judicial Circuit of Florida, Citrus, Hernando, Lake, Marion and Sumter Counties: A lawyer must avoid substantive ex-parte communications with the presiding judge in a pending case.

View ruleOfficial source Source: page 6, section IV. Adherence to a Fundamental Sense of Honor, Integrity, and Fair Play

Judge Stacy M. Youmans: An email to the judicial office must identify the case number, case name, and relevant matter in its subject line.

View ruleOfficial source Source: page 2, section A. Communications with the Judicial Office

Judge Donald E. Scaglione: A last-minute settlement must be communicated specifically and immediately to the court, court reporter, parties, and witnesses.

View ruleOfficial source Source: page 7, section Combined CMC/Pretrial Order Scheduling Cause for Pre-Trial Conference and Jury Trial

209 more rules answer this question.