Court Rules
All enforcement actions
SettlementMedium Risk

NY AG Fines Personal Touch $350K for Healthcare Data Breach

Personal Touch Holding CorporationOctober 18, 2023New York Attorney General

Penalty Amount

$350,000

Consumers Affected

316,845

Summary

New York Attorney General Letitia James secured a $350,000 settlement from Personal Touch Holding Corporation for failing to protect patient and employee data. A ransomware attack in January 2021 compromised the personal and medical information of approximately 316,845 New Yorkers due to inadequate security measures. As part of the agreement, Personal Touch must pay penalties, enhance its cybersecurity program, and provide free credit monitoring to affected individuals.

Remedy

Personal Touch must pay $350,000 in penalties, offer free credit monitoring and identity theft services to affected individuals, and implement a comprehensive information security program including encryption, access controls, employee training, and vendor management procedures.

Monetary PenaltyCompliance Program

Contract Impact

In-house legal teams should review all agreements involving the handling of sensitive personal or health information, particularly vendor contracts, business associate agreements (BAAs), and data processing addendums. Specific clauses to scrutinize include data security standards (requiring encryption, access controls, and MFA), incident response and breach notification obligations (including timelines and reporting requirements), audit rights for security compliance, and subprocessor management. Given the ransomware attack via a phishing email, contracts must also mandate security awareness training for the vendor's personnel. Changes may be needed to strengthen security obligations, require regular vulnerability assessments and penetration testing, mandate immediate notification of security incidents, and ensure contractual rights to audit or require certification of compliance with frameworks like HIPAA Security Rule. For healthcare data, all BAAs must explicitly incorporate HIPAA Security Rule requirements and hold vendors liable for failures leading to breaches.

Contract Search Terms

data encryption requirementincident response planHIPAA business associate agreementdata security schedulesubprocessor managementbreach notification timelinesecurity audit rightsdata retention and disposal policyphishing training provisionsmultifactor authentication clause

Laws Cited

HIPAA

Violation Types

Entity Details

Entity

Personal Touch Holding Corporation

Also known as: Personal Touch

Industry

Healthcare

Official Sources

Source Evidence

Entity Name
"Personal Touch Holding Corporation"
Fine Amount
"pay $350,000 in penalties"
Laws Cited
"Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA)"
Violation Description
"failing to protect vulnerable New Yorkers’ personal information and health care data"

Related Enforcement Actions

NY

BCMB1 Trust, First Age LLC, NS194 LLC, Second Start LLC, and Southern MBA Trust

$240K

The New York Attorney General investigated a group of debt buyers for filing foreclosure actions seeking payment of long-expired mortgage debts. The companies agreed to pay $240,000 in penalties and more than $242,000 in consumer restitution, stop seeking payment of time-barred debts, and amend claims in pending foreclosure cases.

NY

BCMB1 Trust; First Age, LLC; NS194, LLC; Second Start, LLC; Southern MBA Trust, and their affiliates

$240K

New York Attorney General Letitia James reached an agreement with debt buyers that allegedly filed foreclosure lawsuits seeking payment on expired mortgage debt. The companies must pay $240,000 in penalties and more than $242,000 in restitution, and stop seeking expired payments in ongoing and future cases.

NY

NovaTechFx and AWS Mining Pty Ltd.

$6.0M

The New York Attorney General secured disgorgement settlements totaling $5,975,861 from four promoters of NovaTech and AWS Mining over fraudulent investment claims and an illegal pyramid scheme. The promoters were permanently banned from the securities, commodities, and cryptocurrency industries; the Attorney General separately asked the court to order NovaTech’s founders to pay $1.3 billion, which was not yet an order.

NY

T-Mobile USA, Inc.

$98K

New York Attorney General Letitia James secured a settlement after T-Mobile raised prices on plans it had advertised with a promise that prices would never change. T-Mobile must offer affected customers refunds and other benefits, honor price guarantees through at least 2029 for customers who remain, clearly disclose limitations on future guarantees, and pay New York $98,000.

NY

Boston Children’s Health Physicians, LLP and XTIUM

$2.6M

New York and Connecticut reached a settlement with Boston Children’s Health Physicians and its IT security provider, XTIUM, after a 2024 breach exposed private information of approximately 825,000 New York residents and 62,871 Connecticut residents. The companies will pay $2.64 million and implement enhanced cybersecurity measures; additional penalties are conditional on violating the settlement.

NY

U.S. Department of Justice

New York Attorney General Letitia James joined 16 other attorneys general in urging Congress to pass proposed legislation addressing the federal government’s release of Jeffrey Epstein-related records. The press release says DOJ has not fully disclosed the records required by the original law and that personal information of at least 43 victims was exposed in released files; this is a legislative advocacy announcement, not an enforcement action imposing a penalty or remedy.