New York Supreme Court, Monroe County Document Filing Requirements
102 rules, 51 to 100 shown
Required elements, certificates, and structural requirements for court documents.
Rules 51 to 100
Mandatory
- Applies to
- Proof of receipt of child support standards chart
Where minor children are involved, proof must be provided that any unrepresented party received the Child Support Standards Chart.
17) Proof that any unrepresented party has received a copy of the Child Support Standards Chart (where there are minor child[ren]).
Judge Elena F. CariolaPage 27Mandatory
- Applies to
- Summons
A summons, or a summons with notice when service occurs without the complaint, must be time-stamped and must state the nature of the action, requested ancillary relief, grounds, and whether spousal maintenance is sought.
2) Summons or Summons with Notice (if served without complaint) (all cases). Summons with Notice must have: (must be time-stamped) □ a) nature of actions stated; Filed: □ b) list of all ancillary relief requested; □ c) grounds (DRL §170); DRL 170(7) □ d) statement that Plaintiff IS or IS NOT seeking spousal maintenance as payee OR prior written agreement addresses spousal maintenance;
Judge Elena F. CariolaPage 26, section General RulesMandatory
- Applies to
- Deposition designations
Failure to comply with the deposition-designation requirements may preclude nondesignated testimony and waive trial objections to proposed testimony.
The failure to comply with this Order shall waive any trial objections to the proposed testimony, and result in the preclusion of any non-designated testimony.
Judge Elena F. CariolaPage 22, section Deposition DesignationsMandatory
- Applies to
- Separation agreement or stipulation
An agreement or stipulation entered into after September 15, 1989 must advise the parties of the Child Support Standards Act and state that its basic child-support obligation would presumptively result in the correct award.
NOTE: If applicable, every agreement or stipulation entered into after September 15, 1989 must have a provision stating that the parties have been advised of the Child Support Standards Act and that the basic child support obligation provided for therein would presumptively result in the correct of child support to be awarded
Judge Elena F. CariolaPage 27Mandatory
- Applies to
- Video recorded testimony
Failure to timely object to proposed video testimony waives trial objections to that testimony.
The failure to comply with this Order shall waive any trial objections to the proposed video testimony.
Judge Elena F. CariolaPage 22, section Video-Recorded TestimonyMandatory
- Applies to
- Objection to deposition designation
Each objection to deposition testimony must identify the witness and page/line number and state a specific basis, with legal support if necessary.
All objections must delineate the name of the witness, page/line number of the proposed testimony, and provide a specific basis for the objection with legal support if necessary.
Judge Elena F. CariolaPage 22, section Deposition DesignationsMandatory
- Applies to
- Proposed judgment or decree
The proposed judgment or decree must provide detailed maintenance terms consistent with one of the stated alternatives and address the payor cap, the Maintenance Guidelines Law, and any adjustment; when child support is also awarded, it must include the quoted maintenance-termination adjustment language.
□ c) terms for maintenance: (i) the terms of maintenance are pursuant to a settlement agreement/stipulation (detailed); OR (ii) the guideline award for maintenance under the Maintenance Guidelines Law was zero OR neither party requested spousal maintenance; OR (iii) detailed maintenance terms, including addressing payor maintenance cap AND whether the award followed the application of the Maintenance Guidelines Law or the Court adjusted the award of maintenance under the Maintenance Guidelines Law as unjust and inappropriate; AND (A) If child support is also awarded, the statement that: “If maintenance is to be paid pursuant to this Judgment of Divorce, then, subject to the terms of DRL 240(1-b), upon termination of the maintenance award, the amount of child support payable shall be adjusted, without prejudice to either party’s right to seek a modification pursuant to DRL 236(B)(9)(2).”
Judge Elena F. CariolaPage 28Mandatory
- Applies to
- Proposed judgment or decree
The proposed judgment or decree must include terms dividing both separate and marital property.
□ b) terms for property division (both separate and marital)
Judge Elena F. CariolaPage 28Mandatory
- Applies to
- Proposed judgment or decree
The proposed judgment or decree must state whether the separation agreement or stipulation is incorporated and survives or is merged, order both parties to comply, and address the retaining jurisdiction language that continues onto the next page.
□ d) statement required by 22 NYCRR 202.50 as to whether separation agreement/stipulation is to be incorporated and surviving or merged, or a combination thereof, that both parties are ordered to comply with the terms of the separation agreement/stipulation, and that the court and Family Court retain
Judge Elena F. CariolaPage 28Mandatory
- Applies to
- Written communication
- Must include
- caption, case number
Written communications to chambers must include the short caption and index number.
All written communication with chambers shall include the short caption and index number.
Judge Elena F. CariolaPage 2, section I. Appearances and communication by CounselMandatory
- Applies to
- Counterclaim
A time-stamped verified counterclaim is required only in a dual divorce or a divorce in favor of the defendant and must contain the required complaint elements.
5) Verified Counterclaim (only for dual divorces or divorce in favor of defendant – must include items required for complaint - see above). (must be time-stamped)
Judge Elena F. CariolaPage 26, section General RulesMandatory
- Applies to
- Drl 253 sworn statement
Each party taking divorce must provide a DRL § 253 sworn statement, with proof of service on a defaulting party unless the ceremony was civil; the statement may be included in a complaint served on the defaulting defendant.
9) DRL § 253 sworn statement for each party taking divorce, and proof of service on defaulting party (unless ceremony was civil). (ex. if included in complaint and complaint served on Defendant)
Judge Elena F. CariolaPage 27Mandatory
- Applies to
- Proposed findings decision or referees report
For DRL § 170(7), the submission must include the quoted statement that all listed economic and custody/visitation issues were resolved by the parties or court and will be incorporated into the divorce judgment.
□ c) For DRL 170(7): a statement that “all economic issues of equitable distribution of marital property, the payment or waiver of spousal maintenance, the payment of child support, the payment of counsel and experts’ fees/expenses as well as custody/visitation with the minor children of the marriage have been resolved by the parties or determined herein by the Court and shall be incorporated into the judgment of divorce”.
Judge Elena F. CariolaPage 28Mandatory
- Applies to
- Proof of receipt of notice of guideline maintenance
Proof must be provided in all cases that any unrepresented party received the Notice of Guideline Maintenance.
18) Proof that any unrepresented party has received a copy of the Notice of Guideline Maintenance (all cases)
Judge Elena F. CariolaPage 27Mandatory
- Applies to
- Certified court order
Applicable certified Supreme Court or Family Court orders must be included when incorporated by reference.
14) Applicable Certified Supreme Court and/or Family Court Order(s) (if incorporated by reference).
Judge Elena F. CariolaPage 27Mandatory
- Applies to
- Attorney fee affidavit
When attorney fees are requested, an attorney-fee affidavit must describe the work, time expended, usual rates, compensation received, and the fee retainer agreement.
10) Attorney fee affidavit (if fees are requested), with description of work, time expended, usual rates for a those doing work, compensation already received, retainer agreement as to fees (22 NYCRR § 202.16).
Judge Elena F. CariolaPage 27Mandatory
- Applies to
- Proposed findings decision or referees report
The conclusions of law must state that DRL §§ 230, 236, 240, 253, and 255 have been satisfied and that the party is entitled to the specified divorce or separation judgment and incidental relief.
For conclusions of law include that the requirements of DRL §230, 236, 240, 253 and 255 have been met and that the plaintiff/defendant is entitled to a judgment of divorce/separation granting the incidental relief awarded in the judgment.
Judge Elena F. CariolaPage 28Mandatory
- Applies to
- Stipulation or notice of withdrawal
When a party has waived or withdrawn an appearance or pleading, the stipulation or notice of withdrawal must be signed and notarized.
6) Stipulation or notice of withdrawal (where one party has waived or withdrawn appearance and/or pleading) - signed and notarized
Judge Elena F. CariolaPage 27Mandatory
- Applies to
- Motion
Legal relief must be requested by formal motion rather than correspondence.
The Court will not accept correspondence requesting legal relief. A formal motion must be filed.
Judge Elena F. CariolaPage 2, section I. Appearances and communication by CounselMandatory
- Applies to
- Motion
Counsel must attach required pleadings and other documents needed for the court to make an informed decision, particularly on CPLR 3211 and 3212 motions.
Counsel must attached copies of all pleadings and other documents as required by the CPLR and as necessary for an informed decision on the motion, especially on motions pursuant to CPLR 3211 and 3212.
Judge Elena F. CariolaPage 5, section IV. Motion Practice — A. General ProceduresMandatory
- Applies to
- Deposition designations
Each deposition designation must identify the witness, provide page and line numbers, and include a transcript of the proposed testimony.
Said Deposition Designations shall provide the name of the witness, page/line numbers and a transcript of the proposed testimony.
Judge Elena F. CariolaPage 22, section Deposition DesignationsMandatory
- Applies to
- Proposed order
For an unopposed motion, the movant must provide a proposed order at least 14 days before the return date.
Where a motion is unopposed, the movant shall provide the Court with a proposed order at least 14 days prior to the return date.
Judge Erin S. SkinnerPage 3, section Motion PracticeMandatory
- Applies to
- Disclosure motion
- Must include
- proposed order
Disclosure motions and responses must include a proposed order specifying the relief requested and the exact amount of costs, disbursements, and attorneys’ fees for the prevailing party.
All motions relating to disclosure shall strictly comply with 22 NYCRR 202.7 (a) and (c), and all such motions and responses thereto shall be filed with a proposed order containing the specific relief requested and the exact amount of costs, disbursements, and attorneys’ fees to be awarded to the prevailing party.
Judge Erin S. SkinnerPage 3, section DiscoveryMandatory
- Applies to
- Trial submissions
The parties must provide proposed CPLR 3117 testimony, video-recorded testimony with a transcript, a list of proposed marked exhibits, and requests for courtroom technology and accommodations.
The parties will also be directed to provide the Court with any proposed testimony to be read pursuant to CPLR 3117, video-recorded testimony along with a transcript thereof, a list of all proposed marked exhibits, and requests for courtroom technology and accommodations.
Judge Erin S. SkinnerPage 3, section Trial PracticeMandatory
- Applies to
- Notice of motion
The notice of motion must be filed without a return date.
The notice of motion shall be filed without indicating a return date.
Judge Erin S. SkinnerPage 3, section Motion PracticeMandatory
- Applies to
- Motion
Counsel must attach the pleadings and other documents required by the CPLR and necessary for the Court to decide the motion.
Counsel must attach copies of all pleadings and other documents as required by the CPLR and as necessary for the Court to make an informed decision on the motion.
Judge Erin S. SkinnerPage 3, section Motion PracticeMandatory
- Applies to
- Proposed order
Counsel must obtain and attach the bench-decision transcript and reference it in the order.
Counsel will be directed to obtain and attach a copy of the transcript of the bench decision and reference the same in the order.
Judge Erin S. SkinnerPage 3, section Motion PracticeMandatory
- Applies to
- Written correspondence
- Must include
- caption, case number
Every written communication to chambers must include the case caption and index number.
All written communication with chambers shall include the case caption and index number.
Judge Erin S. SkinnerPage 1, section General Rules — Appearances and Communications by CounselMandatory
- Applies to
- Notice of motion
The movant must state the exact relief requested in the notice of motion or order to show cause.
The movant must specify in the notice of motion or order to show cause the exact relief requested.
Judge Erin S. SkinnerPage 3, section Motion PracticeImportantCivil cases
- Applies to
- Settlement position
By requesting a settlement conference, each party consents to the court receiving that party’s ex parte settlement position.
When requesting a settlement conference, the parties consent to the Court receiving an ex parte position on settlement from each party.
Judge Daniel J. DoylePage 4, section III. Settlement Conferences and Mediation OrdersImportantCivil cases
- Applies to
- Exhibit stipulation
All parties must consult and, to the extent possible, enter into a stipulation addressing the authenticity and admissibility of all exhibits.
All parties are herein ordered to consult with each other and, to the extent possible, enter into a stipulation governing the authenticity and admissibility of all exhibits.
Judge Daniel J. DoylePage 19, section General RulesImportantCivil cases
- Applies to
- Exhibit list
Exhibits not properly listed may be excluded at trial.
Exhibits not listed in accordance herewith may be excluded at trial
Judge Daniel J. DoylePage 19, section General RulesImportantCivil cases
- Applies to
- Defendant defenses and counterclaims section
Defendants completing this section should list any counterclaims and, if alleged in the answer, any laws or regulations.
Brief Description of Defendant’s Defenses and any Counterclaims: (to be completed by Defendant(s)- please include a list of any counterclaims. Should any laws or regulations be alleged in the answer, please list those as well.)
Judge Daniel J. DoylePage 13, section Brief Description of Defendant’s Defenses and any CounterclaimsImportantCivil cases
- Applies to
- Statement of material facts
A statement of material facts is optional, but if submitted it must cite the exhibits supporting the alleged facts.
Consistent with long-standing practice, such Statements are not mandated. Should counsel choose to submit a statement of material facts, citations to the exhibits supporting alleged facts are required.
Judge Daniel J. DoylePage 6, section IV. Local Commercial Rules — (f) Statement of Material FactsImportant
- Applies to
- Case information statement
The party requesting the preliminary conference must prepare and submit the Case Information Statement on notice to the opposing parties, concurrently with the RJI when applicable or within seven days after chambers notifies the parties that the case has been assigned and the conference scheduled.
This statement shall be prepared by the party requesting the preliminary conference and submitted – on notice to the opposing party or parties - concurrently with the RJI for cases already assigned to Justice Cariola, or within seven (7) days of notification from chambers that the case has been assigned to Justice Cariola and the conference has been scheduled.
Judge Elena F. CariolaPage 11, section Case Information StatementImportant
- Applies to
- Objections to requests to charge
- Must include
- legal argument
Objections to requested jury instructions must be written and submitted no later than seven calendar days before the pretrial conference or are waived.
Any objections thereto shall be made in writing no later than seven (7) calendar days prior to the Pretrial Conference scheduled herein, or will be deemed waived.
Judge Elena F. CariolaPage 21, section Pretrial Conference RequirementsImportant
- Applies to
- Motion
When only discrete portions of a voluminous referenced document are relevant, excerpts must be attached as exhibits.
If a document referenced in an affidavit or affirmation is voluminous and only discrete portions are relevant to the motion (such as with a deposition transcript), attach excerpts as exhibits and submit the fill exhibit separately.
Judge Elena F. CariolaPage 5, section IV. Motion Practice — A. General ProceduresImportant
- Applies to
- Memorandum of law
Each party must submit a memorandum of law addressing anticipated questions of law and unique evidentiary issues no later than fifteen calendar days before the pretrial conference.
No later than fifteen (15) calendar days prior to the Pretrial Conference scheduled herein each party shall submit a memorandum of law that addresses each question of law or unique evidentiary issue the party expects to arise at trial.
Judge Elena F. CariolaPage 21, section Motions in Limine and Memorandum of LawImportant
- Applies to
- Affidavit of regularity
A consent-based matter requires the defendant's affidavit or a stipulation, and the Affidavit of Regularity should be dated on or after that document.
(if the matter is upon consent, need Affidavit of Defendant or stipulation) (the Affidavit of Regularity should be dated on or after the Affidavit of Defendant or Stipulation).
Judge Elena F. CariolaPage 27Important
- Applies to
- Case information statement
The opposing parties must complete the relevant portions of the Case Information Statement and submit them at least two days before the scheduled preliminary conference.
The opposing party or parties shall complete the relevant information below not already completed and submit at least two (2) days in advance of the scheduled conference.
Judge Elena F. CariolaPage 11, section Case Information StatementImportant
- Applies to
- Requests to charge
- Must include
- legal argument
Each party must provide the Court and opposing counsel with paragraph-specific requests for Pattern Jury Instructions ten calendar days before the pretrial conference.
Ten (10) calendar days prior to the Pretrial Conference scheduled herein, each party shall provide the Court and opposing counsel with written paragraph-specific references to Pattern Jury Instructions that said party requests be provided by the Court to the jury.
Judge Elena F. CariolaPage 21, section Pretrial Conference RequirementsImportant
- Applies to
- Summary judgment motion
A statement of material facts is not required for summary judgment motions, is discouraged unless the Court directs its filing, and may be required by the Court under 22 NYCRR 202.8-g.
A Statement of Material Facts is not required; however, the Court may direct the filing thereof pursuant to 22 NYCRR 202.8-g. Statement of Material Facts are discouraged unless directed by the Court.
Judge Elena F. CariolaPage 7, section IV. Motion Practice — B. Summary Judgment MotionsImportant
- Applies to
- Trial order
After the note of issue is filed, the Court will schedule a conference and issue a Trial Order setting the trial date and deadlines for trial submissions and disclosures.
Upon the filing of the note of issue, the Court will schedule a conference at which the Court will issue a Trial Order setting forth a date certain for trial, as well as the schedule for submitting a proposed verdict sheet, requests to charge, motions in limine, expert witness disclosure, and witness lists.
Judge Erin S. SkinnerPage 3, section Trial PracticeImportant
- Applies to
- Notice of motion
A party seeking oral argument must request it in the notice of motion or responsive papers.
Parties seeking oral argument must note their request in the notice of motion or responsive papers.
Judge Erin S. SkinnerPage 3, section Motion PracticeImportant
- Applies to
- Motion
Motions are ordinarily decided on the submitted papers unless the Court indicates otherwise.
Motions will be heard on submission unless otherwise indicated by the Court.
Judge Erin S. SkinnerPage 3, section Motion PracticeNoteCivil cases
- Applies to
- Motion in limine
Any motion in limine submitted before the Pretrial Conference will be decided at that conference.
Any motions in limine submitted prior to the Pre-Trial Conference shall be decided at the conference.
Judge Daniel J. DoylePage 20, section General RulesNoteCivil cases
- Applies to
- Exhibit list
- Must include
- exhibit list
The Pretrial Conference is scheduled for January 12, 2027 at 10:00 a.m., and counsel must submit a list of all previously unprovided exhibits.
A Pre-trial Conference will be conducted on January 12, 2027 at 10:00 a.m., at which time counsel shall submit to the Court a list of all exhibits not previously provided.
Judge Daniel J. DoylePage 20, section General RulesNoteCivil cases
- Applies to
- Deposition objections
The deposition-objection rule does not apply to testimony and video recordings used solely for impeachment or credibility purposes.
This Rule does not apply to portions of deposition testimony and corresponding video recording to be used solely for impeachment or credibility purposes
Judge Daniel J. DoylePage 19, section General RulesNote
- Applies to
- Proposed verdict sheet
Supplemental proposed verdict sheets may be permitted when unanticipated developments or trial testimony warrant them.
Supplemental Proposed Verdict Sheets may be permitted based on unanticipated developments or testimony at trial.
Judge Elena F. CariolaPage 21, section Pretrial Conference RequirementsNote
- Applies to
- Requests to charge
Where possible, parties are encouraged to rely on Pattern Jury Instructions rather than drafting their own instructions.
To the extent possible, parties are encouraged to rely on Pattern Jury Instructions as opposed to writing their own instructions.
Judge Elena F. CariolaPage 21, section Pretrial Conference Requirements