Skip to main content
Court Rules

New York Supreme Court, Nassau County Pre-Motion Conference Requirements

91 rules, 1 to 50 shown

Pre-motion conference and letter requirements before filing motions, including sequential steps.

Filters
Severity
Case type

Common questions

Rules 1 to 50

  1. Mandatory

    Before filing a discovery motion, counsel or a party must email the part, identify the issue, and request a conference call for the Court's assistance.

    3. Discovery Motions: Prior to filing any discovery motion, counsel/parties must contact the part via email, setting forth the issue, and request a conference call for the Court’s assistance in resolving the issue.

    Judge Anna M. GrimaldiPage 4, section MOTIONS
  2. Mandatory

    No discovery motion may be filed or served without prior written permission from the court.

    Counsel and/or self-represented parties shall NOT FILE OR SERVE ANY DISCOVERY MOTION without obtaining prior written permission from this Court.

    Judge Catherine RizzoPage 3, section A. DISCOVERY MOTIONS
  3. Mandatory

    An order to show cause may be filed only for genuine urgency, when a stay is required, or when a statute mandates the proceeding; absent advance written permission, reply papers may not be submitted.

    Orders to Show Cause shall only be filed where there is a genuine urgency, a stay is required or a statute mandates so proceeding. Absent advance written permission by the court, reply papers shall not be submitted on orders to show cause.

    Judge Catherine RizzoPage 3, section B. ORDERS TO SHOW CAUSE, APPLICATIONS FOR A STAY OR TEMPORARY RESTRAINING ORDER, (TRO)
  4. Mandatory

    A request for permission to file a discovery motion may be submitted by a letter uploaded to NYSCEF and emailed to the judge, copied to all counsel and self-represented parties, or made in person at a scheduled conference; the letter must describe good-faith efforts and requested documents, address whether a Jackson Affidavit was requested and, if applicable, not provided, and may not exceed three pages.

    Permission to make a discovery motion may be made by way of letter uploaded to NYSCEF and emailed to JudgeRizzoRemote@nycourts.gov, copied to all counsel and/or self-represented parties. The letter shall succinctly set forth the good faith efforts made to resolve the issue, identify the document(s) sought with particularity and specific identification, that a “Jackson Affidavit” was requested, and if applicable, not provided. The letter shall not exceed three pages. Permission to make a discovery motion may also be requested in person at a scheduled conference before the Court.

    Judge Catherine RizzoPage 3, section A. DISCOVERY MOTIONS
  5. Mandatory

    A discovery motion may not be submitted without the required conference.

    There shall be no submitted discovery motions in the absence of a Conference (see Rule III(E) above).

    Judge Christopher T. McGrathPage 7, section IV. Motions/Orders to Show Cause/Temporary Restraining Orders
  6. Mandatory

    Parties must attempt to resolve a discovery dispute before filing any discovery motion, including a motion to vacate the Note of Issue.

    The parties are not to make any motion concerning discovery, including motions to vacate the Note of Issue, without having first attempted to resolve the issue.

    Judge Christopher T. McGrathPage 3, section III. Court Conferences
  7. Mandatory

    Before involving the court or filing a discovery motion, parties must meet and confer through a genuine exchange rather than a one-sided letter or threat.

    Regarding discovery disputes, parties are required to meet and confer before involving the court or making a motion (Rule 202.20-f). It is the policy of this Part to not accept letters as good faith efforts, unless a series of letters indicates an interaction among counsel, and not just a one-sided statement or threat.

    Judge Conrad D. SingerPage 6, section Discovery in General
  8. Mandatory

    A cross-motion set beyond the original motion's return date does not adjourn the original motion.

    Submission of a cross-motion with a stated return date that is beyond the return date of the original motion will not serve to adjourn the original motion.

    Judge Conrad D. SingerPage 5, section Cross-Motions
  9. Mandatory

    Sur-reply papers addressing a motion's merits are prohibited without advance permission, except for a letter identifying a relevant post-submission court decision without additional argument.

    Absent express permission in advance, sur-reply papers including correspondence, addressing the merits of a motion are not permitted, except that counsel may inform the court by letter of the citation of any post-submission court decision that is relevant to the pending issues, but there shall be no additional argument.

    Judge Conrad D. SingerPage 4, section MOTIONS: Submission of Motions
  10. Mandatory

    Discovery motions may not be filed without prior court approval.

    Such motions may not be filed without approval from the Court.

    Judge Conrad D. SingerPage 5, section Discovery Motions
  11. Mandatory

    Before filing a discovery motion, the moving party must make a genuine good-faith effort to resolve the dispute and, if unsuccessful, arrange a discovery conference among counsel for all parties and the court; one-sided letters alone will not suffice.

    Prior to making or filing any discovery motions, counsel for the moving party MUST make a good faith effort to resolve the issues at hand, pursuant to 22 NYCRR 202.7(c) and Section 202.20-f. It is the policy of this Part to not accept letters as good faith efforts, unless a series of letters indicates an interaction among counsel and not just a one-sided request or threat. If after a true good faith effort to resolve the discovery issues has been made without success, counsel for the moving party MUST arrange for a conference to be held among counsel for all parties and the Court to discuss the issues involved and the possible resolution of those issues. Requests for discovery related conferences must be submitted on the Pre-Motion Discovery Conference Request Form attached at the end of this document, and must be sent to chambers by email or fax.

    Judge Danielle M. PetersonPage 2, section Motions
  12. Mandatory

    Before filing a discovery motion in this part, the requesting attorney or party must submit the completed conference request form and confer with the court regarding the discovery dispute.

    NO DISCOVERY MOTIONS MAY BE FILED IN THIS PART WITHOUT FIRST SUBMITTING THIS FORM AND CONFERENCING THE MATTER WITH THE COURT.

    Judge Danielle M. PetersonPage 9, section Pre-Motion Discovery Conference Request Form - PART18
  13. Mandatory

    Before filing a discovery-related motion, a party must email the judge a completed conference request form summarizing the issues and attaching a good-faith affirmation detailing prior discovery efforts; conclusory or pro forma submissions do not suffice, and a motion without the conference request will not be scheduled.

    Prior to filing a discovery related motion, including motions to strike, restore, preclude, and compel, the parties must send an email to judgegugertyremote@nycourts.gov, attaching a completed conference request form that includes a summary of the discovery related issues, and an affirmation of good faith in compliance with the New Uniform Rules for the Supreme and the County Court (22 NYCRR) § 202.20-f, setting forth, in detail, the efforts made by the attorney/party requesting the conference to obtain discovery pri or to requesting judicial intervention. Conclusory statements, or pro forma letters or emails will not satisfy this requirement. Failure to request a conference prior to the filing of a discovery related motion will result in the motion not being scheduled.

    Judge David J. GugertyPage 4, section PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE
  14. Mandatory

    Before making or filing a discovery motion, counsel must first discuss the issue with opposing counsel and, if unresolved, must arrange a telephone conference with all counsel and the court, with knowledgeable counsel having settlement authority participating.

    Prior to the making or filing of any discovery-related motion, counsel for the prospective movant(s) shall first discuss the issue(s) in question with his or her adversary. If the issue(s) in question cannot be resolved, counsel for the prospective moving party MUST arrange for a telephone conference to be held with all counsel and the Court to address the issue(s) and any possible resolution thereof. Counsel fully familiar with the matter and with authority to bind their client MUST be available ===== PAGE 4 ===== to participate in the conference call.

    Judge Denise L. SherPage 3, section A. Pre-Motion Teleconferences
  15. Mandatory

    Before filing a discovery motion, counsel must make a good-faith effort to resolve the dispute, contact the court by letter describing the dispute and resolution efforts, obtain leave to file, and state that the procedure was followed; noncompliance may result in denial.

    If counsel cannot resolve the discovery issue between themselves after a good faith effort, then the counsel who believes that discovery is not being conducted in accordance with the Court’s Order is to contact the Court by letter (See Rule I[A]), supra.), to advise of the nature of the dispute and the efforts that have been made to attempt to resolve it. The court will either resolve the issue by letter or by scheduling a conference. After the Court conferences the matter and if the Court grants leave of Court to file a discovery motion, any discovery motion must state that this procedure has been complied with. Failure to comply with this Part’s rules as set forth above may result in the denial of the motion.

    Judge Donald X. Clavin Jr.Page 3, section III. Court Conferences
  16. Mandatory

    Before raising a discovery dispute, counsel and/or self-represented litigants must have actual, substantive telephonic or written communication about the dispute, without copying the Court unless requested.

    There must be actual, substantive communication between counsel and/or pro se (self-represented) litigant(s), either telephonically or in writing (not to be copied to the Court), regarding the claimed failure to engage in discovery, on the one hand, and the claimed compliance or reason for noncompliance, on the other.

    Judge Eileen C. Daly-SapraiconePage 5, section III. Court Conferences
  17. Mandatory

    The parties must first attempt to resolve a discovery issue before filing a motion concerning it.

    The parties are NOT to make any motion concerning discovery without having first attempted to resolve the issue.

    Judge Eileen C. Daly-SapraiconePage 5, section III. Court Conferences
  18. Mandatory

    No discovery motion may be filed without prior leave of court.

    NO DISCOVERY MOTIONS MAY BE FILED WITHOUT LEAVE OF COURT

    Judge Eileen C. Daly-SapraiconePage 5, section III. Court Conferences
  19. Mandatory

    If a good-faith effort fails, counsel must notify the court by letter of the dispute and resolution efforts, after which the court will respond by letter or schedule a conference.

    If counsel cannot resolve the discovery issue between themselves after a good faith effort, then the counsel who believes that discovery is not being conducted in accordance with the Court’s Order is to contact the Court by letter (see Rule I[B], supra), to advise of the nature of the dispute and the efforts that have been made to attempt to resolve it. The Court will either resolve the issue by letter or by scheduling a conference.

    Judge Eileen C. Daly-SapraiconePage 5, section III. Court Conferences
  20. Mandatory

    A discovery motion requires a prior pre-motion conference request and good-faith efforts to resolve the dispute, unless the Court directs otherwise.

    1. Parties wishing to file a motion concerning discovery must first request a pre- motion conference with the Court. No discovery motion may be filed in the absence of good-faith efforts to resolve the dispute and a pre-motion conference (unless the Court directs otherwise).

    Judge Ellen TobinPage 4, section Discovery Disputes; Pre-Motion Conferences Required
  21. Mandatory

    If parties cannot resolve a dispute, the requesting party must e-file a letter of no more than three pages describing the contemplated motion, its grounds, and resolution efforts, and the opposing party may respond within three business days with a letter of no more than three pages; the Court will decide whether to hold a conference.

    If the parties are unable to resolve the dispute, then the party wishing to make the motion is to e-file a letter, not to exceed 3 pages, succinctly describing the contemplated motion and the grounds for the same, and the efforts that have been made to resolve the issue. Any opposing party should then file a letter, not to exceed 3 pages, setting forth its position, within 3 business days after the request is filed. The Court will determine whether to hold a pre-motion conference.

    Judge Ellen TobinPage 5, section Discovery Disputes; Pre-Motion Conferences Required
  22. Mandatory

    Before raising a discovery dispute with the Court, a party must substantively meet and confer in good faith about the alleged deficiencies or noncompliance; a pro forma letter is insufficient.

    2. A party wishing to raise a discovery dispute with the Court must first meet and confer in good faith with the other side(s) about the issue(s) prior to raising it with the Court, in accordance with 22 NYCRR § 202.7. A pro forma letter does not meet the Rule’s requirements. There must be substantive communications between counsel and self-represented litigants regarding the alleged discovery deficiencies or noncompliance, on one hand, and the claimed compliance or reason(s) for noncompliance, on the other.

    Judge Ellen TobinPage 4, section Discovery Disputes; Pre-Motion Conferences Required
  23. Mandatory

    Before filing a motion, the moving party generally must serve written notice stating the intended motion and requested relief and offering a good-faith attempt to resolve the matter, subject to emergency and significant-prejudice exceptions.

    Except in an emergency situation or where an affirmation is presented demonstrating there will be significant prejudice to the moving party by giving prior notice, prior to making any motion, the moving party is required to serve a written notice to the opposing party of the intention to make the motion and the relief that will be sought in the motion, and offer to make a good faith attempt to resolve the matter.

    Judge Erica L. PragerPage 2, section II. MOTIONS — A. Pre-Motion — General Rules
  24. Mandatory

    Every discovery motion requires a conference on its return date unless the Court specifically waives the conference, and the movant must email the Court to schedule it.

    Notwithstanding [1] above, all motions relating to discovery require a conference on the return date of the motion or order to show cause, unless otherwise specifically waived by the Court. The movant shall email the Court to schedule same.

    Judge Erica L. PragerPage 3, section B. Pre-Motion – Discovery
  25. Mandatory

    The non-moving party must respond in writing within 48 business hours after receiving the pre-motion notice and identify any consent to or objection to the requested relief.

    The non-moving party is required to respond in writing to the moving party, setting forth consents and/or objections to the relief requested, within 48 business hours of receipt of the written notice from the moving party.

    Judge Erica L. PragerPage 2, section II. MOTIONS — A. Pre-Motion — General Rules
  26. Mandatory

    A discovery motion may not be marked submitted until the required conference has occurred and the Court determines that the matter cannot be resolved.

    No discovery motion shall be marked submitted prior to the holding of a conference with the Court in accordance with this rule, and prior to this Court’s determination that the matter cannot be resolved in conference.

    Judge Erica L. PragerPage 3, section B. Pre-Motion – Discovery
  27. Mandatory

    A request for a discovery-related conference must use the Pre-Motion Discovery Conference Request Form and be emailed to chambers.

    Requests for discovery related conferences must be submitted on the Pre-Motion Discovery Conference Request Form (you can find it here) and must be sent to chambers by email.

    Judge Francis RiciglianoPage 2, section III. Motions
  28. Mandatory

    Before making or filing a discovery motion, the moving party’s counsel must make a good-faith effort to resolve the dispute.

    Prior to making or filing any discovery motions, counsel for the moving party MUST make a good faith effort to resolve the issues at hand, pursuant to 22 NYCRR 202.7(c) and section 202.20-f.

    Judge Francis RiciglianoPage 2, section III. Motions
  29. Mandatory

    If a good-faith effort does not resolve discovery issues, moving counsel must arrange a conference among all parties’ counsel and the court before filing a discovery motion.

    If after a true good faith effort to resolve the discovery issues has been made without success, counsel for the moving party MUST arrange for a conference to be held among counsel for all parties and the Court to discuss the issues involved and the possible resolution of those issues.

    Judge Francis RiciglianoPage 2, section III. Motions
  30. Mandatory

    Before filing any discovery motion in this part, the requesting party must submit the pre-motion discovery conference form and confer with the court about the matter.

    NO DISCOVERY MOTIONS MAY BE FILED IN THIS PART WITHOUT FIRST SUBMITTING THIS FORM AND CONFERENCING THE MATTER WITH THE COURT.

    Judge Gary F. KnobelPage 7, section PRE-MOTION DISCOVERY CONFERENCE REQUEST
  31. Mandatory

    Before making or filing a discovery motion, moving counsel must undertake a genuine good-faith effort and, if the dispute remains unresolved, arrange and submit the required pre-discovery conference form for a conference involving all parties and the Court; one-sided letters alone do not suffice.

    Prior to making or filing any discovery motions, counsel for the moving party must make a good faith effort to resolve the present issues, pursuant to 22 NYCRR 202.7(c) and section 202.20-f. This Part will not accept letters as good faith efforts, unless a series of letters indicates an interaction among the parties and not one-sided requests. If after a true good faith effort to resolve the discovery issues there is no resolution, counsel for the moving party must arrange for a conference to be held among all parties and the Court to discuss the issues and possible resolution. Counsel must submit the attached pre- discovery conference form attached and email it to chamber and the Principal Law Clerk.

    Judge Gary F. KnobelPage 2, section III. Motions — a. Pre-Motion Discovery Conferences
  32. Mandatory

    Parties must follow the preliminary conference order's schedule, and any change requires prior court permission.

    The court expects parties to strictly adhere to the schedule contained within the preliminary conference order. That schedule cannot be changed without prior permission of the court.

    Judge Gregg RothPage 2, section Preliminary Conferences
  33. Mandatory

    Parties must meet and confer regarding discovery disputes before involving the court or filing a discovery motion.

    Regarding discovery disputes, parties are required to meet and confer before involving the court or making a motion (Rule 202.20-f).

    Judge Gregg RothPage 4, section Discovery in General
  34. Mandatory

    The compliance conference must be held no later than 60 days before the scheduled completion of discovery.

    The compliance conference date will be set down in the preliminary conference order and must be held no later than 60 days before the date scheduled for the completion of discovery (22 NYCRR §202.19[b][3]).

    Judge Gregg RothPage 2, section Compliance Conference
  35. Mandatory

    Attorneys at a compliance conference must have telephone access to their clients and be prepared for good-faith settlement discussions.

    Attorneys appearing at the compliance conference must have telephone access to their respective clients and shall be prepared to enter into good faith settlement discussions.

    Judge Gregg RothPage 2, section Compliance Conference
  36. Mandatory

    Preliminary conferences must comply with 22 NYCRR §202.19 and be held in the Supreme Court Building's Preliminary Conference Part.

    Preliminary conferences will be held according to the rules set forth in 22 NYCRR §202.19 and will be conducted in the Preliminary Conference Part of the Supreme Court Building.

    Judge Gregg RothPage 2, section Preliminary Conferences
  37. Mandatory

    The compliance conference may not be held later than the compliance requirement date stated in the DCM.

    In no event shall the compliance conference be held later than the compliance requirement date as set forth in the DCM

    Judge Gregg RothPage 2, section Compliance Conference
  38. Mandatory

    A reply to an Order to Show Cause is prohibited unless the court gives prior approval.

    replies are not allowed on the Order to Show Cause without prior approval of the Court.

    Judge Jerome C. MurphyPage 4, section Orders to Show Cause
  39. MandatoryCivil cases

    Absent an emergency, counsel must email Chambers a completed conference request form before making or filing a discovery-related motion, and the request tolls related filing deadlines pending the court's conference determination.

    D. Absent emergency, prior to making or filing any discovery-related motions, including a motion to vacate the note of issue, counsel for the moving party shall request a pre-motion conference by emailing to chambers a completed conference request form. The court will then determine whether a pre-motion conference will be held to discuss the issues involved and possible resolution. A request for a pre- motion conference tolls all related filing deadlines.

    Judge Leonard D. SteinmanPage 3, section III. DISCOVERY ADJOURNMENTS, DISPUTES AND PRE-MOTION PROCEDURES
  40. Mandatory

    A discovery motion may not be submitted unless the required conference has occurred.

    There shall be no submitted discovery motions in the absence of a Conference (see Rule III(C) above).

    Judge Lisa A. CairoPage 7, section IV.C. Discovery Motions
  41. Mandatory

    After a good-faith effort fails, the attorney must contact the court by letter describing the discovery dispute and the attempted resolution efforts.

    If counsel cannot resolve the discovery issue between themselves after a good faith effort, then the counsel who believes that discovery is not being conducted in accordance with the Court’s Order is to contact the Court by letter (see Rule I[A], supra), to advise of the nature of the dispute and the efforts that have been made to attempt to resolve it.

    Judge Lisa A. CairoPage 4, section D. Compliance with Preliminary Conference Orders
  42. Mandatory

    Unless extremely unusual circumstances causing detailed significant prejudice apply, the party presenting an Order to Show Cause requesting a Temporary Restraining Order or other emergency relief must notify opposing counsel or parties at least 24 hours before presentation and advise them of their right to be heard; in a true emergency, the Court may dispense with notice.

    Unless there are extremely unusual circumstances in which significant prejudice (set forth in detail in a supporting affidavit/affirmation) will result, opposing counsel or parties are to be advised at least 24 hours in advance of the date and time that any Order to Show Cause which includes a request for a Temporary Restraining Order or other emergency relief is being presented to the Court in accordance with 22 NYCRR 202.7(f) and is to be advised that he/she has the right to be heard on the application. In a true emergency, the Court, in its discretion may dispense with the 24-hour notice requirement.

    Judge Lisa A. CairoPage 7, section IV. Motions
  43. Mandatory

    A party may not file a discovery motion without first attempting to resolve the discovery dispute.

    The parties are not to make any motion concerning discovery without having first attempted to resolve the issue.

    Judge Lisa A. CairoPage 4, section D. Compliance with Preliminary Conference Orders
  44. Mandatory

    Discovery motions and discovery-related Orders to Show Cause generally require a conference before the return date unless the Court specifically waives it.

    All motions relating to discovery require a conference before the return date of the Motion or Order to Show Cause, unless otherwise specifically waived by the Court.

    Judge Nancy NicotraPage 4, section IV.A. PRE-MOTION DISCOVERY
  45. Mandatory

    A discovery motion may not be submitted unless the required conference has occurred.

    There shall be no submitted discovery motions in the absence of a Conference (see Rule III(E) above).

    Judge Paul KennyPage 7, section IV. Motions/Orders to Show Cause/Temporary Restraining Orders
  46. Mandatory

    Discovery motions, including motions to vacate a Note of Issue, require a good-faith attempt to resolve the dispute, possible notice to the court by letter, and leave of court before filing; the motion must state that the procedure was followed.

    The parties are not to make any motion concerning discovery, including motions to vacate the Note of Issue, without having first attempted to resolve the issue. If counsel cannot resolve the discovery issue between themselves after a good faith effort, then the counsel who believes that discovery is not being conducted in accordance with the Court’s Order is to contact the Court by letter (see Rule I[A], supra), to advise of the nature of the dispute and the efforts that have been made to attempt to resolve it. The Court will either resolve the issue by letter or by scheduling a conference. After the Court conferences the matter and if the Court grants leave of court to file a discovery motion, any discovery motion must state that this procedure has been complied with. Failure to comply with this Part’s rules as set forth above may result in denial of the motion.

    Judge Paul KennyPage 3, section E. Discovery Issues/Discovery Motions
  47. MandatoryCivil cases

    Before filing a discovery motion, the movant must make a good-faith disclosure conference with opposing counsel, and the court must hold a conference and grant permission before the motion may be submitted.

    Prior to filing a discovery motion or requesting a conference with the Court, the movant shall confer with counsel for the opposing party “in a good faith effort to resolve all disputes about disclosure” (22 NYCRR § 202.20-f[b]). If, after such effort, the parties are unable to resolve their dispute, they shall e-mail the Court to schedule a conference. There shall be no submitted discovery motions in the absence of a conference and permission from this court.

    Judge Philippe Solages Jr.Page 2, section 2. MOTIONS c. Discovery Motions
  48. Mandatory

    Before making or filing a discovery-related motion, counsel must first discuss the dispute with the adversary and, if unresolved, arrange a telephone conference with all counsel and the court.

    Prior to the making or filing of any discovery-related motion, counsel for the prospective movant(s) shall first discuss the issue(s) in question with his or her adversary. If the issue(s) in question cannot be resolved, counsel for the prospective moving party MUST arrange for a telephone conference to be held with all counsel and the Court to address the issue(s) and any possible resolution thereof.

    Judge Randy Sue MarberPage 3, section III.A. Pre-Motion Teleconferences
  49. Mandatory

    Counsel must make every effort to resolve discovery disputes with the opposing party before engaging in discovery motion practice.

    Counsel shall make every effort to resolve discovery disputes with their adversary before engaging in motion practice.

    Judge Rhonda E. FischerPage 5, section B. Discovery Motions
  50. Mandatory

    Every motion requires the Court's prior permission.

    ALL MOTIONS REQUIRE PRIOR PERMISSION OF THE COURT.

    Judge Rhonda E. FischerPage 4, section V. Motions / Orders to Show Cause / TROs

Back to top

Common questions about New York Supreme Court, Nassau County pre-motion conference requirements

Does New York Supreme Court, Nassau County require a pre-motion conference or letter before filing a motion?

Judge Ellen Tobin: A discovery motion requires a prior pre-motion conference request and good-faith efforts to resolve the dispute, unless the Court directs otherwise.

View ruleOfficial source Source: page 4, section Discovery Disputes; Pre-Motion Conferences Required

Judge Conrad D. Singer: Before involving the court or filing a discovery motion, parties must meet and confer through a genuine exchange rather than a one-sided letter or threat.

View ruleOfficial source Source: page 6, section Discovery in General

Judge Francis Ricigliano: A request for a discovery-related conference must use the Pre-Motion Discovery Conference Request Form and be emailed to chambers.

View ruleOfficial source Source: page 2, section III. Motions

88 more rules answer this question.