New York Supreme Court, Nassau County Pre-Motion Conference Requirements
91 rules, 51 to 91 shown
Pre-motion conference and letter requirements before filing motions, including sequential steps.
Rules 51 to 91
Mandatory
Except in exigent circumstances, counsel must first consult in good faith through an in-person or telephonic conference before contacting the court about a disclosure dispute.
Absent exigent circumstances, prior to contacting the court regarding a disclosure dispute, counsel must first consult with one another in a good faith effort to resolve all disputes about disclosure. Such consultation must take place by an in-person or telephonic conference.
Judge Rhonda E. FischerPage 5, section B. Discovery MotionsMandatory
A proposed discovery movant must send chambers and all counsel and self-represented parties a remote-email request with the required good-faith affidavit or affirmation, after which the court will notify whether permission or a conference is required.
The proposed moving party shall forward to chambers' remote email address, and all counsel and self-represented parties, any request to make a discovery motion with an affidavit or affirmation of good faith that substantially complies with the form described above. The Court will thereafter notify the moving party, all counsel, and self-represented parties, whether permission is granted, or whether a conference with counsel, self-represented parties and chambers concerning the matter is necessary.
Judge Rhonda E. FischerPage 5, section B. Discovery MotionsMandatory
An order to show cause may be filed only when there is a genuine emergency, a stay is required, or a statute requires the proceeding.
Orders to Show Cause shall only be filed where there is a genuine emergency, a stay is required or a statute mandates so proceeding.
Judge Rhonda E. FischerPage 5, section C. Orders to Show CauseMandatory
Absent extremely unusual circumstances causing significant prejudice, opponents must receive at least 24 hours' advance notice of an OSC seeking a TRO or other emergency relief and be told of the right to be heard.
Unless there are extremely unusual circumstances in which significant prejudice (set forth in detail in a supporting affidavit/affirmation) will result, opposing counsel or parties are to be advised at least 24 hours in advance of the date and time that any OSC which includes a request for a Temporary Restraining Order (TRO) or other emergency relief is being presented to the Court in accordance with 22 NYCRR 202.7(f) and is to be advised that he/she has the right to be heard on the application.
Judge Sarika KapoorPage 2, section III. MOTIONSMandatory
Motions and orders to show cause ordinarily are decided on the filed submissions without oral argument unless the court directs otherwise.
Unless otherwise directed, motions, including Orders to Show Cause, will be decided on SUBMISSIONS ONLY.
Judge Sarika KapoorPage 2, section III. MOTIONSMandatory
Counsel and self-represented litigants must confer in good faith before involving the Court or filing a discovery motion, and a one-sided letter alone will not establish a good-faith effort.
All counsel and pro se (self-represented) litigant(s) are required to meet and confer, in Disputes: good faith, before involving the Court or making any discovery motion, including a motion to vacate a note of issue (22 NYCRR 202.20-f). It is the policy of this Part to not accept letters as good faith efforts, unless a series of letters indicates an interaction among counsel, and not just a one-sided statement.
Judge Sarika KapoorPage 6, section VII. DISCOVERYMandatory
An order to show cause may be brought only for genuine urgency, when a stay is required, or when a statute mandates it.
Motions may be brought by Orders to Show Cause (OSC) only when there is a genuine urgency, a stay is required, or a statute so mandates (22 NYCRR 202.8-d).
Judge Sarika KapoorPage 2, section III. MOTIONSMandatory
Sur-replies are prohibited unless the Court expressly grants leave.
No Sur-Replies will be accepted or considered without express leave of the Court.
Judge Sarika KapoorPage 2, section III. MOTIONSMandatory
Before filing a discovery motion, the movant must first confer with the Court, schedule a conference, provide a summary of the discovery issues, and include an affirmative certification of good-faith compliance.
No discovery related motion may be filed until the issues are first conferred with Conferences: the Court. Prior to making or filing any discovery motions, the purported movant must schedule a conference so as to permit the parties and the Court to attempt to resolve the issue(s). Such request must include a summary of the discovery related issues, and an affirmation of good faith in compliance with 22 NYCRR 202.20-f.
Judge Sarika KapoorPage 6, section VII. DISCOVERYMandatory
Failure to appear on the TRO return date is deemed a waiver of the defaulting party's position on continuation or termination.
The failure to appear will be deemed a waiver of the defaulting party’s position with respect to the continuation or termination of the TRO.
Judge Thomas RademakerPage 4, section Temporary restraining ordersMandatory
A certification conference is required before filing a note of issue.
Pursuant to the rules of the Administrative Judge, a certification conference will be held prior to the filing of a note of issue.
Judge Thomas RademakerPage 3, section Certification ConferenceMandatory
Counsel must obtain court leave before filing a motion to compel discovery or strike a pleading.
Counsels must seek leave of the Court prior to filing a motion to compel discovery or strike a pleading.
Judge Thomas RademakerPage 4, section Discovery MotionsMandatory
Sur-reply papers are prohibited without prior court authorization and will be disregarded if filed without it.
The Court will not accept sur-reply papers unless prior authorization has been given by the Court. Sur-reply papers submitted in violation of this rule will be disregarded.
Judge Thomas RademakerPage 4, section Submission of papersMandatory
If the parties cannot agree whether to continue or terminate a temporary restraining order, all counsel and any pro se litigant must appear on the motion's return date.
If the parties or counsel cannot agree to the continuation or termination of a temporary restraining order, all counsel and any pro se litigant must appear on the return date of the motion.
Judge Thomas RademakerPage 4, section Temporary restraining ordersMandatory
Before making or filing any motion, moving counsel must arrange a conference call with the opposing party and the Court to discuss the issues and possible resolution.
Prior to making or filing any motions, counsel for the moving party MUST arrange for a conference call to be held with his/her adversary and the Court to discuss the issues involved and the possible resolution thereof.
Judge Vito M. DeStefanoPage 2, section II MOTIONS AND ORDERS TO SHOW CAUSEMandatory
An applicant seeking temporary injunctive relief must comply with 22 NYCRR 202.7(f) and, if practicable, provide the opposing side at least 24 hours' advance notice by telephone, facsimile, and/or email before presenting the Order to Show Cause.
Applications for temporary injunctive relief must be made in conformity with 22 NYCRR 202.7(f). In addition, the Court requires that the party seeking temporary injunctive relief give the opposing side 24 hours notice in advance of presentment of the Order to Show Cause to the court. Notice should be given by telephone, facsimile and/or e-mail, if practicable.
Judge Vito M. DeStefanoPage 3, section C. Interim Partial or Full SettlementMandatory
The moving attorney must attend the pre-motion conference with sufficient familiarity and settlement authority to bind the client.
Counsel fully familiar with the matter and with authority to bind their clients MUST be available to participate in the conference.
Judge Vito M. DeStefanoPage 2, section II MOTIONS AND ORDERS TO SHOW CAUSEImportant
Counsel are strongly encouraged, but not required, to use the same pre-filing email and conference-call practice for non-discovery motions.
Counsel are strongly encouraged to follow this practice for all non-discovery motions as well in order to reduce the need for motion practice.
Judge Anna M. GrimaldiPage 4, section MOTIONSImportantCivil cases
After an unsuccessful good-faith effort to resolve discovery issues, the moving party's counsel must arrange a conference among all counsel and the court, with the request sent to chambers by email.
If a true good faith effort has been made without success, counsel for the moving party must arrange for a conference to be held among counsel for all parties and the Court to discuss the issues involved and the possible resolution. Requests for discovery-related conferences must be sent to chambers by email.
Judge Carolyn M. GenovesiPage 2, section MotionsImportant
An oral-argument request is not automatically granted, and the Court may limit argument to 15 minutes per side.
A request for oral argument should not be construed as an automatic grant of same. The Court reserves the right to limit oral argument to fifteen (15) minutes to each side.
Important
Letters alone do not constitute an adequate good-faith effort unless they show an actual exchange among counsel rather than a unilateral request or threat.
It is the policy of this Part to not accept letters as good faith efforts, unless a series of letters indicates an interaction among counsel and not just a one-sided request or threat.
Judge Francis RiciglianoPage 2, section III. MotionsImportant
Even after the parties agree to resolve a discovery dispute, the Court may issue a sua sponte order with their consent or over their objections.
Regardless of an agreed resolution the Court may issue a sua sponte Order on its own motion on consent of the parties or over their objections.
Judge Gary F. KnobelPage 2, section III. Motions — a. Pre-Motion Discovery ConferencesImportant
Before a preliminary or compliance conference, counsel must consult about case resolution, discovery, alternate dispute resolution, and any mutually agreed informal information exchange.
“Counsel for all parties shall consult prior to a preliminary or compliance conference about (i) resolution of the case, in whole or in part; (ii) discovery, including discovery of electronically stored information, and any other issues to be discussed at the conference, (iii) the use of alternate dispute resolution to resolve all or some issues in the litigation; and (iv) any voluntary and informal exchange of information that the parties agree would help aid early settlement of the case.
Judge Gregg RothPage 2, section Preliminary ConferencesImportant
The opposing side may submit a specific response of equal length within five days after the original disclosure-dispute letter.
The other side may submit a specific response of equal length, within 5 days of the date of the original letter.
Judge Jerome C. MurphyPage 3, section Disclosure DisputesImportant
After the disclosure-dispute letters are submitted, the Part will schedule a conference if necessary to resolve or limit the disputed issues.
The Part will then schedule a conference, if necessary, with the goal of resolving or limiting the issues in dispute consistent with Rule 14.
Judge Jerome C. MurphyPage 3, section Disclosure DisputesImportant
Parties must use diligent good-faith efforts to resolve disclosure disputes before engaging in motion practice, and an unresolved dispute may support a request for a pre-submission conference.
C. Disclosure Motions: Parties are reminded that any dispute arising out of disclosure requires the parties to exercise diligent Good Faith efforts to resolve the issue prior to engaging in Motion practice. A failure to set forth such efforts may result in Summary Denial of the Motion. It is the policy of this Court to make itself available to resolve disputes related to Pre-Trial Disclosure. Therefore, if a dispute over Disclosure arises that cannot be resolved by the parties own diligent, Good Faith efforts, the aggrieved party may request that a Conference be scheduled prior to Submission.
Important
An unreasonable failure or refusal to participate in a requested discovery conference may excuse compliance with the conference requirement and may lead to sanctions under Part 130.
The unreasonable failure or refusal of counsel to participate in a conference requested by another party may relieve the requesting party of the obligation to comply with this paragraph and may be addressed by the imposition of sanctions pursuant to Part 130.
Judge Rhonda E. FischerPage 5, section B. Discovery MotionsImportant
Only the moving party may request oral argument, a non-movant needs a valid reason to be granted it, and the Court may request argument sua sponte.
Oral arguments may be requested only by the moving party. The non-movant may be granted oral argument provided they offer a valid reason and basis for orally arguing same. The Court may also request oral arguments on a motion.
Judge Sarika KapoorPage 2, section III. MOTIONSImportant
All motions must be made returnable to the Hon. Thomas Rademaker in Part 11.
All motions are made returnable to the Hon. Thomas Rademaker, Part 11.
Judge Thomas RademakerPage 3, section Motion Practice: Return date and adjournmentsImportant
The court reviews the papers before deciding whether to grant requested oral argument and then advises the parties of the argument date if granted.
If oral argument is requested, the Court will consider the request, after reviewing the papers, and will then inform the parties of the date of the oral argument if the request is granted.
Judge Thomas RademakerPage 3, section Motion Practice: Return date and adjournmentsImportant
Except for writs and contempt matters, motions are taken on submission unless the court directs otherwise.
With the exception of Writs and Contempts, motions are taken on submission part only unless otherwise directed by the Court.
Judge Thomas RademakerPage 3, section Motion Practice: Return date and adjournmentsImportant
The pre-motion conference requirement does not apply to counsel-relief applications, motions to dismiss, or motions for summary judgment.
This rule does not apply to applications for counsel to be relieved, motions to dismiss, and motions for summary judgment.
Judge Vito M. DeStefanoPage 2, section II MOTIONS AND ORDERS TO SHOW CAUSENote
Counsel should endeavor, where feasible or possible, to coordinate a motion's return date with an already scheduled Part conference or the return date of a previously filed motion.
In the event a case is already scheduled for a conference with this Part, counsel should endeavor to coincide the return date of a motion, where feasible, with the previously scheduled conference. Where a motion is previously filed, any subsequent movants shall endeavor to coincide the return date(s) of any such subsequently filed motions, where possible.
Judge Conrad D. SingerPage 5, section MotionsNote
The discovery pre-motion teleconference rule does not apply to counsel-relief applications, motions to vacate the Note of Issue, or dispositive motions.
This rule does not apply to applications for counsel to be relieved, motions to vacate the Note of Issue, or dispositive motions.
Judge Denise L. SherPage 4, section A. Pre-Motion TeleconferencesNote
If the discovery issue remains unresolved after the teleconference, the prospective movant may seek permission to file a discovery-related motion.
Where the matter cannot be resolved during the teleconference, the prospective movant may request permission to file a discovery-related motion.
Judge Denise L. SherPage 4, section A. Pre-Motion TeleconferencesNote
Movants are encouraged to schedule a virtual conference before making or filing a discovery motion to attempt to resolve the dispute.
Prior to making or filing any discovery motions, the movant is encouraged to schedule a virtual conference to permit the parties and the Court to attempt to resolve the issue(s).
Judge Erica L. PragerPage 3, section B. Pre-Motion – DiscoveryNote
Compliance conferences may be held in person or virtually.
Conferences will be held in-person and virtually.
Judge Gregg RothPage 2, section Compliance ConferenceNote
The discovery-motion pre-teleconference rule does not apply to applications to relieve counsel, motions to vacate the Note of Issue, or dispositive motions.
This rule does not apply to applications for counsel to be relieved, motions to vacate the Note of Issue, or dispositive motions.
Judge Randy Sue MarberPage 4, section III.A.ii. Pre-Motion TeleconferencesNote
After reviewing the submitted motion, the Court decides case by case whether to hold oral argument and will notify counsel when to appear.
Oral Argument: After a review of the submitted motion, the court will determine, on a case-by-case basis, whether oral argument will be heard and will advise counsel when they shall appear.
Judge Rhonda E. FischerPage 4, section V. Motions / Orders to Show Cause / TROsNote
Counsel and subsequent movants should, where possible, coordinate motion return dates with an existing Part conference or other related motion return dates.
In the event a case is already scheduled for a conference with this Part, counsel should endeavor to coincide the return date of a motion, where feasible, with the previously scheduled conference. Where a motion is previously filed, any subsequent movants shall endeavor to coincide the return date(s) of any such subsequently filed motions, where possible.
Judge Sarika KapoorPage 2, section III. MOTIONSNote
If the matter is resolved during the pre-motion conference, the court may issue an order consistent with the resolution.
If the matter can be resolved during the conference, an order consistent with such resolution may be issued.
Judge Vito M. DeStefanoPage 2, section II MOTIONS AND ORDERS TO SHOW CAUSE