Eastern District of Pennsylvania Local Rules and Judge Filing Requirements
Filing requirements from local rules, individual practices, standing orders, and published court policies for Eastern District of Pennsylvania
Federal court local rules are only the first layer. These filing requirements come from individual judges' practices, standing orders, and policies published by the Eastern District of Pennsylvania. They supplement the district local rules and the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure. Requirements vary significantly between judges in the same district, so always verify the specific rules for your assigned judge.
- Senior Judge Anita B. Brody
Proposed jury instructions must be emailed to law clerk in Microsoft Word format.
- Judge Mia Roberts Perez
ECF filings must be text-searchable; exhibits need descriptive file names; reference documents by docket number; don't use existing docketed documents as exhibits.
- Judge Gail A. Weilheimer
Sample certification language for meet-and-confer requirement.
- Senior Judge Timothy J. Savage
Government must file proposed findings and conclusions before suppression/Starks/Daubert hearings.
- Judge John Milton Younge
Pro hac vice applications must be submitted in writing using Court website forms with signed affidavit of good standing.
- Judge Mia Roberts Perez
Chambers communications limited to scheduling/non-substantive matters via phone/email; substantive matters require motion/filing; no ex parte communications on substantive matters.
- Senior Judge Anita B. Brody
Email permitted for urgent administrative matters; other matters must be motions or ECF-designated letters.
- Senior Judge Timothy J. Savage
Pretrial conferences held only in complex cases or with multiple attorneys.
- Judge John Milton Younge
Carbon copies of letters to opposing counsel are not accepted.
- Judge Gerald A. McHugh
Call chambers for immediate ruling on deposition disputes if judge is available.
- Judge Mia Roberts Perez
Replies and sur-replies must be filed within 7 days of the response.
- Senior Judge Anita B. Brody
Extension requests must include a specific revised deadline date.
- Senior Judge Timothy J. Savage
Suppression, Starks, and Daubert hearings held at least 2 weeks before trial.
- Judge John Milton Younge
Rule 26(f) meeting must occur at least 10 days before Rule 16 conference.
- Judge Gerald A. McHugh
Extension stipulations must be emailed to Chambers and require court approval.
- Judge Mia Roberts Perez
Sur-replies require court permission and limited to 5 pages.
- Senior Judge Anita B. Brody
Briefs and memoranda of law are limited to 35 pages unless court authorizes otherwise.
- Senior Judge Timothy J. Savage
Proposed jury instructions and interrogatories due 7 days before trial.
- Judge John Milton Younge
Reply and sur-reply briefs limited to 10 pages.
- Magistrate Judge José R. Arteaga
Case synopsis submitted for settlement conferences must not exceed five pages.
- Judge Mia Roberts Perez
Rule 16 conference scheduled after answer or during preliminary motions.
- Senior Judge Anita B. Brody
Replies automatically allowed for all motions; surreplies allowed for Rule 56 motions, discouraged for others.
- Judge Gail A. Weilheimer
Parties must conduct substantive verbal communications before filing certain motions, with certification required.
- Judge Gerald A. McHugh
Rule 16 conference required after answer; lead counsel must appear in person.
- Magistrate Judge José R. Arteaga
Good faith telephone/video conference required before judicial intervention for discovery disputes.
- Senior Judge Anita B. Brody
Two hard copies of all pretrial submissions required, single-sided, three-hole punched, unstapled.
- Judge Mia Roberts Perez
All writings to Chambers must use 12-point Times New Roman font with 1-inch margins.
- Senior Judge Timothy J. Savage
Each jury instruction/interrogatory must be on separate sheet with party name.
- Judge John Milton Younge
Correspondence limited to unopposed extensions/scheduling; max 5 pages by fax; no correspondence for opposed matters.
- Judge Gerald A. McHugh
Searchable briefs encouraged; scanned briefs should use OCR software.
- Magistrate Judge Elizabeth T. Hey
Hand delivery to chambers required for non-electronically filed documents.
- Judge John Milton Younge
Provide 2 copies of exhibits (1 at final pretrial, 1 at trial start) in binders.
- Senior Judge Anita B. Brody
Two hard copies of pretrial submissions required, single-sided, three-hole punched, unstapled.
- Judge Gerald A. McHugh
Physical courtesy copies required for ECF filings with more than 3 exhibits; must be three-hole punched with tabbed, labeled exhibits.
- Magistrate Judge José R. Arteaga
Judge Arteaga may require hard copies of lengthy materials.
- Magistrate Judge José R. Arteaga
Protective orders may not include language allowing parties to seal materials without prior specific court approval.
- Judge Joseph F. Leeson, Jr.
Confidentiality orders require detailed explanation of injury and specific categories of protected information.
- Judge Jeffrey L. Schmehl
Confidentiality/sealing orders require good cause.
- Judge Joshua D. Wolson
Parties filing material under seal must familiarize themselves with the sealing standard established in In re Avandia.
- Judge Gail A. Weilheimer
Confidentiality/sealing orders require good cause and specific language about Court's modification rights.
- Magistrate Judge José R. Arteaga
Plaintiffs must submit a written settlement demand at least three weeks before the scheduled settlement conference.
- Judge Joshua D. Wolson
Joint Rule 26(f) status reports must be filed at least seven days before the Rule 16 scheduling conference.
- Judge Chad F. Kenney
Rule 26(f) meeting report must be filed at least 3 business days before the pretrial conference.
- Judge Kelley Brisbon Hodge
Rule 26(f) reports must be filed and emailed to Chambers at least 7 calendar days before the Rule 16 conference.
- Magistrate Judge Katayoun M. Copeland
Counsel must file a joint Rule 16(f) report one week before the Rule 16 teleconference if not previously filed.
- Judge John Milton Younge
Joinder in substantive motions of other parties is strongly disfavored and normally not permitted.
- Judge Gerald A. McHugh
Supplemental, reply, and sur-reply briefs may be filed without leave, but consideration begins after initial opposition.
- Magistrate Judge José R. Arteaga
Exhibits must be provided as two tabbed loose-leaf books (one for judge, one for law clerk) with joint, plaintiff's, and defendant's exhibits.
- Judge Jeffrey L. Schmehl
No Rule 16 conference or scheduling order in arbitration track cases (except de novo appeals).
- Magistrate Judge Craig M. Straw
One set of pre-marked trial exhibits required; provide two copies to Judge.
- Magistrate Judge José R. Arteaga
Proposed jury instructions and verdict form must be filed on the Court’s docket.
- Judge Joshua D. Wolson
Exhibits filed via ECF must be separate documents with identifying names (not generic labels like “Exhibit A”); single “Exhibits” files will be struck.
- Judge Chad F. Kenney
Attorneys must file public documents via ECF and sealed documents via email to Clerk with motion to impound; all filings via ECF or Clerk’s Office.
- Judge Kelley Brisbon Hodge
All counseled parties must use ECF; proposed orders attached to motions; no Chambers submissions except via ECF; court won't act on non-docketed submissions.
- Senior Judge Anita B. Brody
Multiple attorneys allowed for different witnesses/legal points, but only one attorney per witness or point.
- Senior Judge Timothy J. Savage
Oral argument granted on motions at judge's discretion.
- Judge Jeffrey L. Schmehl
Multiple attorneys may examine different witnesses or argue different points, but only one per side may address the jury.
- Judge Gerald J. Pappert
Multiple attorneys may examine different witnesses or argue different points, but only one attorney per side may examine same witness or address jury.
- Judge Gail A. Weilheimer
Junior attorneys (associates) may argue with notice to chambers; supervising counsel can supplement their argument.
- Magistrate Judge José R. Arteaga
Parties must submit Rule 26(f) report via email to chambers at least 5 days before scheduling conference if not already on docket.
- Judge Joshua D. Wolson
Moving parties must serve the statement of undisputed material facts on all parties at least 28 days before the summary judgment motion deadline.
- Judge Chad F. Kenney
Service of documents must be executed at the time of filing.
- Judge Kelley Brisbon Hodge
Rule 56 moving parties must provide a Word document of the Statement of Undisputed Material Facts to opposing counsel.
- Magistrate Judge Katayoun M. Copeland
Counsel may send correspondence to the Court only if copies are simultaneously sent to all other counsel in the matter.